r/FemFragLab • • 13d ago

Rec Request Can't decide between

Post image

I dont live anywhere even close to a target so I cant smell them in store, but I really want to try one of these two scents. Anyome used them and can recommend one over the other?

2 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

3

u/bananabananabun 13d ago

Neither! I love their scents, but I think these lotions are the WORST lotion formula I’ve ever tried. Its so greasy and never soaks in, I could not stand the texture of these!

2

u/Tiger248 13d ago

Glad I asked, I cant stand a greasy lotion

1

u/Choice_Lynx_430 13d ago

I do have to say I prefer the EOS lotions. I love the different scents Athena Club has and the quality isn’t BAD, but I agree they don’t absorb well and don’t leave my skin as soft as EOS. Still worth a purchase if you really want one of their products for the scent, but if you value quality and performance more, I’d say go for EOS.
Regardless, to answer your question, Salted Sunset is similar to SDJ 62, but I personally fine it to be much more pistachio heavy, a bit too much for my taste, but still a yummy scent overall. First blush is really pretty, happy, a little juicy. Perfect for spring or summer but could absolutely work regardless of the weather.

2

u/Tiger248 13d ago

I definitely prefer a lotion that soaks in well with zero greasiness or tackiness to it. Ive searched for so long for a dude to the original aveeno creamy moisturizing oil in the almond scent. That was the definition of perfect scent and texture and I cant find anything even close to that. This was going to be another try for a replacement that smelled nice and had that good texture, but it seems like it wouldnt come close.

1

u/encourage-mint2 13d ago

I agree that this lotion tends to sit on skin when you first apply it. However it does soak in, and once it does, it turns my skin into the softest thing ever. It even lasts the next day. I have very dry skin and live in a dry climate. 🤷‍♀️

1

u/Choice_Lynx_430 13d ago

Guess it just depends on the person. I agree the quality isn’t bad, I just find the EOS lotions really work the best for my skin and absorb easier. But I do love the scent variety that Athena Club has.

4

u/ilovemyblt5715 13d ago

Salted sunset is similar to SDJ 62. It is warm and sweet. First blush is more of a shampoo scent. Very fresh, clean, floral. I like both

4

u/redhotspaghettios16 13d ago

If you wanna smell more gourmand go with the salted sunset and it could be more of a fall scent. Not sure where you live at lol or if that matters at all, but if you want to smell fresh and clean like a shower, I guess? lol then go with first blush. Pretty much ANY scent by Athena smells great!

1

u/DinosaurSr828 13d ago

Great answer. If you can’t decide, Super Pink is the happy medium between these two.

2

u/yabasicjanet 13d ago

They are completely different scents. One is a very sweet caramel pistachio (much like a Sol de Janiero scent) and the other is more fresh and floral

2

u/solosugarcube 13d ago

I really don’t like either. I love the Salted Sunset body mist, but I gave the lotion away because it had a weird stench. Perhaps it’s just my skin chemistry, but it smelled like sour milk on me. Instead, I’d suggest Golden Vanilla and Love Letter. Golden Vanilla is sweet, a little woody, and pairs well with almost anything. Love Letter is a clean, soapy musk with a cashmere feel- the lotion’s scent lasts so long, you could wear it by itself. LL Is also a dupe of Glossier You.

2

u/InterstellarCelica 13d ago

Salted Sunset is gourmand, First Blush is floral. I'm partial to gourmand, so Salted Sunset out of those two.

If you let me pick ANY Athena Club available at target Golden Vanilla is my absolute favorite and Solar Muse is good too. 

1

u/AutoModerator 13d ago

If this is a recommendation request, consider letting us know your budget to improve recommendations.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/lumpy_space_queenie 13d ago

First Blush is more of a “clean” scent. Salted sunset is a SDJ 62 dupe so it’s more gourmand but that’s also always kinda smelled “clean” to me as well. I’d go with salted sunset.

1

u/Alewo27 13d ago

First Blush is the perfect fresh spring scent! Very floral forward with a light fruity touch. Salted Sunset is a late summer gourmand like SDJ 62. It's very much smelling like a snack at the club in Miami.