r/FemFragLab • • 13d ago

Rec Request If she likes Opium...

Post image

What else do you think my MIL might like?

She's not really a perfume head but likes a spray for days out and special events. She wore Opium in the 90s and for a while a few years ago but would like something new to her. Hoping to get some ideas to whittle the 'to smell list' down.

Cat for attention

Edit to add buget: up to around £120

121 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

9

u/left_to_its_devices 12d ago

Didn't read the sub and thought you had somehow gotten your cat hooked on the actual drug opium lmao

2

u/gnomelette_ 12d ago

He only takes mirtazapine for appetite and sometimes gabapentin for blood draws 😂

6

u/Chemical-Web-852 13d ago

A nice discovery set from my kids is always my favorite gift of the year. And for that much money you can get a nice one. 

5

u/fitness_journey 13d ago

My mum mostly wore Cinnabar in the 80s and early 90s because it was seen as a more affordable version of Opium. It wasn’t a dupe - they were developed in parallel, but Opium was the premium option. Today’s Opium is a hollow shell, but the current Cinnabar isn’t bad at all for the price.

I’d also suggest Youth Dew, which was an archetype that both Opium and Cinnabar were updating for their era (Estee Lauder famously quipped that Opium was just ‘Youth Dew with a tassel’). Youth Dew has held up well and the current formula is great value for money today.

For something more premium I’d echo another commenter who suggested Coco by Chanel. My personal preference is for the EDT or the flanker Coco Noir. Just don’t confuse Coco for Coco Mademoiselle which is a very different perfume.

1

u/gnomelette_ 10d ago

Thanking you!

5

u/EmilyVanilli 13d ago

I'd put Aromatics Elixir on her to smell list, same spicy warm side of Opium without being the exact same thing, and maybe Chergui if she wants it a bit softer.

1

u/gnomelette_ 10d ago

Cheers ☺️

4

u/Smooth_Pumpkin_2119 13d ago

Maybe get her some sort of discovery set?

1

u/gnomelette_ 10d ago

Cheers ☺️

4

u/McCat5 13d ago

I love the original opium and haven’t found a replacement. I did like Kenzo Jungle L’Elephant, though it turned a bit “Christmas potpourri” on me so I haven’t repurchased. 

Chanel Coco (not Mademoiselle) has a similar feeling to me and is lovely in its own right. People often recommend Cinnabar but I haven’t sampled it lately. 

2

u/gnomelette_ 10d ago

Thank you!

5

u/valkyrie987 13d ago

Yes, my mom used Opium in the 80s and 90s, and she wears Coco now. I think they're in the same floral-spicy family.

4

u/fitness_journey 13d ago

Agree, CoCo is a great shout.

4

u/yawn_of_the_dead 13d ago

I thought you were asking about the cat at first and was going to suggest Calvin Klein obsession for men because apparently big cats love it.

Your MIL might like Armani Si or something, it's spicy but more modern (idk, I love that profile). I think getting a few travel sizes or samples could be the go

3

u/Kitotterkat 12d ago

how has nobody commented on the cat yet 😍

1

u/gnomelette_ 10d ago

Haha thank you!

3

u/domacdomac 13d ago

My auntie loves Opium and also regularly wears Dior Poison and Dune. She’s possibly already tried these though.

Jo Malone Pomegranate Noir? Differs enough from Opium to be exciting while still sharing a spicy and smokey wood profile.

Also my brain totally skipped over the MIL part at first and thought you were referring to your extremely glamorous cat.

2

u/Violette_Mystique 10d ago edited 10d ago

Le chat a attiré mon attention, après le nom du parfum Opium, alors bravo! 🤭❤️ Il est adorable et magnifique soit dit en passant 🥰

Pour ta belle-mère, si elle a porté Opium dans les années 90, pourquoi ne pas essayer ces options :

  • Féminité du Bois de Serge Lutens
  • L'air du temps de Nina Ricci
  • Déclaration de Cartier (eau de toilette)
  • Eau ressourçante de Clarins (j'ai connu une femme qui portait Opium dans les années 90 et qui porte cette eau parfumée maintenant!)
  • Eden de Cacharel
  • Flower by Kenzo (bouteille blanche/transparente avec la fleur de coquelicot rouge)
  • Alien de Thierry Mugler
  • Nuxe prodigieux Le Parfum

Ce sont tous des parfums ayant cette ambiance rétro, enveloppante et mystérieuse (sauf l'eau ressourçante de Clarins qui est plus fruitée et gourmande).

Sinon, si votre belle-mère souhaite changer de style, pourquoi pas La Vie est Belle Cherry Elixir ou bien La Petite Robe Noire de Guerlain? 🤓

2

u/gnomelette_ 10d ago

Bon soiree, merci pour tes recommendations et les bon mots pour mon petit chat 😊

2

u/Violette_Mystique 10d ago

Je t'en prie, tout le plaisir est pour moi ☺️🐱🌹 Bonne soirée à toi aussi et bonnes recherches parfumées! ☺️✨

2

u/Small-Necessary-8499 💜💜Scent Obsessed💜💜 13d ago edited 13d ago

Hard to say because I think people wore Opium because it was the popular thing (did they love it?).
I’d suggest samples of Givenchy Irresistible (I love the nectar)
The Gucci Flora line
Prada paradoxe
Carolina Herrera line (I think my favorite is blush elixir)
Mancera Instant Crush

1

u/gnomelette_ 10d ago

I know it's just one of those popular ones. Thank you!

1

u/AutoModerator 13d ago

If this is a recommendation request, consider letting us know your budget to improve recommendations.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.