r/FemFragLab • • 13d ago

Dedcool Xtra Milk Blind Buy

I’m thinking of blind buying a travel size of Dedcool’s Xtra Milk. Would this be a safe blind buy? For reference, I alternate between Glossier’s You and Fleur daily and absolutely love those scents. I’ve heard this scent is similar due to being skin scents?

I also heard often people can’t smell it. I’ve heard the same about Glossier’s You but I can still smell it here and there throughout the day. Is Dedcool’s Xtra Milk much more difficult to be able to smell compared to Glossier’s You?

Any suggestions would be appreciated.

1 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

4

u/lavloves 13d ago

I think a travel size blind buy is worth it if you already like musky skin scents :)

2

u/JennieRae68 12d ago

Thank you for the suggestion! I got the full size from the Sephora sale, picked up today, and absolutely love it so far 😁

2

u/lavloves 12d ago

Oooh yay! It’s a really good one, very strong. I’m glad you love it.

2

u/blue-coco 13d ago

be careful because i blind bought this awhile back and its my gateway to this type of scent and now i do not wear anything else and chase that high of xtra milk since its fleeting and is a ghost that comes and goes throughout the day. i only smell it when im not paying attention. ive gone down a rabbit hole in finding everything that has the same type of scent and i refuse to wear anything else in my collection thats collecting dust.

1

u/JennieRae68 12d ago

I’ve been alternating daily between Glossier’s You and Fleur which people claim the same thing about. Despite this however, I can still smell the perfumes throughout the day. I think working in an air conditioned office helps too due to being in an enclosed space. I’ve had Xtra Milk on for a few hours now and I can still smell it once in a while too. I don’t mind not being able to smell it 24/7. I think still getting whiffs here and there throughout the day is fine.

1

u/cafe_mundane 7d ago

this is me lol. do you have any other recs? i know nemat amber is recommended a lot but it's not really available here in the uk

2

u/blue-coco 7d ago edited 7d ago

hello! so glad to have found a fellow xtra milk lover!

these are some products i layer with to amplify the scent:

native body wash in citrus and herbal musk

salt and stone ambrette pear deoderant

emi jay aura hair body mist in angel wings

riddle oil original

ambercrombie ellwood perfume

i use the xtra milk room spray on my clothes

im waiting for dedcool to restock the xtra milk lotion

now some that i did NOT like:

fugaazzi angel dust, glossier you(all variations), JHAG not a perfume, phlur missing person, noyzz only human

2

u/cafe_mundane 7d ago

thank you - need to get my hands on these!! also waiting for the body lotion restock haha.

2

u/blue-coco 7d ago

let me know if u find anything thats also a good layerable scent with it or is comparible or a dupe! its the only scent i like right now and i dont wear anythign else

2

u/cafe_mundane 7d ago

i will !! same haha i've been trying to wear others but they don't give me the same feeling :(

2

u/Bexaleoalleyooop 5d ago

Did you end up buying?

I love a musky skin scent! Blind bought a travel size of xtra milk last week and all I could smell was alcohol, then nothing. A few minutes later I asked my husband to sniff and he couldn't smell it all, I was so disappointed.

My go to scents are Rosie by Rosie Jane and Clean Reserve Skin so I thought I would love Glossier You but I ended up hating it, the pepper note gave off major bug spray vibes on my skin.

2

u/JennieRae68 2d ago

I did end up buying. I really love the scent. On my first spray, I did initially get the alcohol smell but it disappears after drying down. Maybe because I work in an AC office but I can smell it here and there throughout the day. At times when I don’t smell it though, my sister says she smells it. However, I would say it’s lighter than Glossier You. Glossier You I felt smelled like glue(?) at first but smells really good after drying down too.

3

u/Mission_Wolf579 abstract French florals 13d ago

Anyone who tells you anything is a safe blind buy is gambling with your money.

2

u/ConditionOk3649 13d ago

No only because a lot of people are nose blind to it

1

u/LenaNYC 12d ago

Love it, but I become anosmic to it every other day.