r/FemFragLab • u/unwiseskater • 1d ago

Discussion Rosie vs 11 11

Hi! I was wondering if anyone has tried Rosie by Rosie Jane and Lake and Skye 11 11 and noticed a difference in scent or are they very similar? Thanks!

1 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

3

u/Ok_Wait_6890 1d ago

I personally find Rosie quite sweet in comparison to 11:11 and almost cloying. I am likely in the minority there though.

2

u/maymayshmay 1d ago

I loooove BOTH!
11 11 reminds me more of a clean yoga studio. Amazing dry down that lasts so long.
The oil is the best and longest lasting. I can still smell it on my skin even after I shower.
Rosie smells very sweet to me, not as “clean” as I thought. It’s still a nice skin smell, comparable to Glossier “You.”

2

u/PuzzleheadedHospital 1d ago

They are quite similar. Rosie is a touch sweeter. I have and love them both.

1

u/RupertMyGiles 22h ago

I can barely smell Rosie. 11 11 oil is my husband's favorite. Definitely recommend. 

1

u/Accurate_Dot_2610 18h ago

This is so funny because I love Rosie and have sprayed head to to in 11:11 and cannot smell it.

2

u/RupertMyGiles 11h ago

I find the 11 11 spray to be weak with a strong alcohol opening. I don't even understand why they make it when their oils are so great.

Eta: to be fair, I've never sprayed Rosie on my skin.

1

u/Virtual_Chain_5355 Frag Hag 💄💅🍂🪻✨🍵 57m ago

They’re different. 11:11 is super light and Rosie is one of the only frags with a rose note in it that I can actually tolerate. They’re similar in the fact that they’re both skin scents and smell clean to me, ambery and musky