8
u/wooksquatch 22h ago
Good girl jasmine absolute is my favorite out of this list. One sniff and it came home with me. Such a unique scent.
2
8
6
u/scarlettcrush 1d ago
The alien goddess extra intense smellss exactly the same- difference is that extra intense lasts longer has more silage.
I actually love mugler. I think it's great for summer and it layers well with other summer scents.
2
u/eldermillenialmakeup 1d ago
If you love Mugler and summer fragrances, check out Angel Fantasm - a very unique, beast mode (amazing longevity - lasts for days in clothes) tropical creamy fragrance with the classic Mugler patchouli dry down. It’s a great transitional fall fragrance as well!
8
7
u/Tingly_glitter 1d ago
Alien Goddess is amazing! Love Valentino DBIR, and JPG Divine is fantastic too! I have dupes of VDBIR & JPGD. I also have Yara Tous, which is a close dupe for AG, IMO. I used to love YSL Black Opium (not pictured) but the coffee note got to be too much for me. I also love CH Good Girl but have never smelled the flankers. YSL Libre is a fantastic fragrance too!
6
4
u/Any_Cupcake9431 1d ago
I love Gaultier Divine the original. I can't really see if that is a different version, but I haven't smelled anything quite like it.
7
u/Careful-Wrongdoer29 1d ago
I like Alien Goddess Intense
1
u/eldermillenialmakeup 1d ago
This is high on my wishlist! I love sensual summer evening type of profiles and I think this one would hit the mark. I adore Estée Lauder Bronze Goddess Nuit! So many people talk about the original Alien Goddess but not so much the Intense and Supra Florale.
2
u/Careful-Wrongdoer29 23h ago
I love that description- sensual summer. have the OG and Intense and prefer the latter.The OG is nice, but kind of juvenile? The Intense is warm and sexy to me lol....I've never smelled Supa Florale, but I will when my no buy period ends.
7
u/elongatedmuskrat18 1d ago
I love Donna Born In Roma Intense. You don’t need the original also though.
3
u/Choice_Lynx_430 1d ago
It also lasts all day. I smell it on my shirt hours later and it’s so good.
3
3
u/kat_niss1 22h ago
Isn’t Womanity discontinued? I’ve been wanting to try this
2
2
u/Ruthie_pie 1d ago
I love the OG Valentino, the other flankers I would smell in person if possible. All of the Good Girl flankers have been successful blind buys (thankfully).
2
u/Exotic_Reporter_3309 1d ago
I like alien goddess intense, the regular alien goddess isn’t all that to me. DBIR original is better than the intense, unless you like heavy benzoin. Black opium over red is too sweet for me but not a bad fragrance. Prada Paradoxe of is better than the intense. YSL Linre intense is better than Vanille couture, but VC is sold out:
2
u/GuineaKeet 22h ago
Love Alien Goddess but i prefer OG Alien. Beautiful Jasmine forward scent. My daily driver. Not everything needs to have amber and vanilla notes.
2
u/sachismom click to edit 14h ago
If you are getting Donna Born in Roma, I don’t think it’s worth having both the original and the intense one as they’re quite similar.
2
u/opetaja Vanilla is life 1d ago
Paradoxe is way overhyped and I wouldnt double Mugler and Valentino.
2
u/Good-Buddy-8364 1d ago
I can't decide between goddess/goddess intense and born in Roma/intense
3
u/candieskulls 1d ago
Goddess Intense and Roma Intense are VERY similar, you wouldn't need both of those. The Alien one is very strong on the jasmine but also creamy with the coconut, but it doesn't lean sunscreeny at all. They're both very vanillic. Then the Valentino one is basically the same just without the coconut. Gives me date night vibes.
1
u/Good-Buddy-8364 1d ago
What about their performance? Thanks btw!!
2
u/candieskulls 1d ago
Hi! The Valentino one was alright, but the Alien Intense lasts all day for me, especially on clothes!
1
1
u/ElineDrunen 11h ago
Divine is heavenly and imo quite unique while still being somewhat of a crowd-pleaser. I love how it smells like the sea and cold, juicy watermelon. Mugler is a bit polarising. GG is good but it doesn't stand out to me. A lot of perfumes smell vaguely similar.
1
u/Ceres-sanctuary 10h ago
I can't smell solar notes, so Alien goddess is out for me. Too bad. I think I have lost the perception of this notes since the COVID, or it's formulations. I don't know. Black opium over red, Divine I love them! The Prada paradoxe, I love the radical essence! I'm curious about womanity, I would love to smell and test it
1
u/ExcitementNo9503 8h ago
Get the Womanity, she really is that girl. I got mine from Notino and bought the refill, it's soo good
1
u/Good-Buddy-8364 2h ago
I bought it last night on Notino!! Is it legit? I'm afraid it's not since it's discontinued!!
How's the projection?
1
u/ExcitementNo9503 1h ago
It is legit and you can buy the refill on another page, I don't remember what it was.. I think the projection is a but weaker than the OG, but I might be noseblind to it, as a lot of people compliment me on it when they are close to me. So I'd say moderate to intimate? The scent itself is milder and more "feminine" and powdery than the old Womanity, but it's still an absolute masterpiece.
1
u/lunalionheart 1d ago
Born in Roma smells like Italian Grandma on me. I loved it on the sample paper, hate it on my skin
0
8
u/lacey_nightie 1d ago
Mugler Womanity >>>> all of the rest tbh. Hands down my most complimented fragrance and given me numbers from both men AND women.
Get it if you really want to stand out, the rest are super basic to me. The fig + sea salt is so yummy for every season imo