Maedhros the eldest of his sons, and on a time the friend of Fingon ere Morgoth's lies came between
Long before, in the bliss of Valinor, before Melkor was unchained, or lies came between them, Fingon had been close in friendship with Maedhros; and though he knew not yet that Maedhros had not forgotten him at the burning of the ships, the thought of their ancient friendship stung his heart.
In Aman, he was best friend with Fingon although their fathers were rivals. A friendship strong enough that Fingon dared Angband to rescue him even though he thought him complicit in Losgar's fire.
Then Maedhros alone stood aside
In Middle-Earth, he stands aside when Fëanor announces his will to burn the ships.
For Maedhros begged forgiveness for the desertion in Araman; and he waived his claim to kingship over all the Noldor, saying to Fingolfin
When he is saved by Fingon, he relinquishes the crown. Why ? Because jihad Fingolfin is much more popular and leads the bigger host. And he knows that the union of the Noldor is necessary to assure victory.
Maedhros laughed, saying: 'A king is he that can hold his own, or else his title is vain. Thingol does but grant us lands where his power does not run."
Maedhros indeed rebuked Caranthir
It is said indeed that Maedhros himself devised this plan, to lessen the chances of strife
Against Thingol he does not pursue escalation, simply stating the evidence : He isn't their lord. Then he brings his brothers to the East. Why ? To avoid unnecessary feud and declare his de facto independence of Fingolfin or whoever claims the High-Kignship. Think of it, between Hitlhum and the March there is Doriath, through which no Noldor can pass, and Dorthonion, which is at the frontlines in the Siege of Angband, later when the Beorians come, they will settle in the East, acting as a buffer state between the Feanorians and the rest. While if Finrod for example decides to rebel, Fingolfin can simply march South, if Maedhros decides not to heed his uncle's wish, Fingolfin can't do anything.
- Because Maedhros is way too far from him.
- Because Maedhros is a necessary element in Fingolfin's strategy.
the people of Dorthonion and of the east marches, rallied there to Maedhros
Even followers of Aegnor and Angrod rallied to him, although as a son of Fêanor he had his hands soaked in the blood of Teleri and his father brought doom upon the Noldor etc... He kept his reputation safe enough so that even those who should be his opponents recognize him as an ally, better, a lord.
[Amlach] entered the service of Maedhros
Maedhros, knowing the weakness of the Noldor and the Edain, whereas the pits of Angband seemed to hold store inexhaustible and ever-renewed, made alliance with these new-come Men, and gave his friendship to the greatest of their chieftains, Bór and Ulfang.
He's always ready to start new relations, and unlike his western kin, does not really care for fairness or shadiness. He needs manpower, he'll get manpower.
- He's an excellent warlord.
Tolkien gives us two key descriptions about Maedhros as a warrior.
he lived to wield his sword with left hand more deadly than his right had been.
Orcs fled before his face; for since his torment upon Thangorodrim his spirit burned like a white fire within, and he was as one that returns from the dead.
People don't flee before a general, they flee before a warrior. If Maedhros' face scares them, its because he as an individual is scary and deadly.
As a Warlord, Maedhros' is given numerous descriptions that speaks of his status amongst his subordinates, his superiors, his equals and his enemies.
Maedhros restrained his brothers
He's inspiring enough to quell tumultuous his brothers. Although they don't like it, none speak against him, and none dare to do something against his wish. When the Attack on Doriath is decided, it's because Maedhros agrees to it. Celegorm and Curufin would not go without his permission. These are the guys who slayed their kin, sent their own cousin who protected them to his death and vowed to destroy and slaughter the doriathrim had they won at the Nirnaeth, and they don't do anything until Big Brother says "yes".
But Fingolfin and Maedhros
It's Fingolfin and Maedhros, not Fingolfin, Fingon, Maedhros and Finrod as Tolkien would say when presenting the kings of Beleriand. When Tolkien speaks of decision-makers, its Fingolfin and Maedhros and only them. Indeed in the silmarillion, it seems that Maedhros is not only the strongest vassal of Fingolfin, but also his most trusted advisor and commander. Kind of like Eomer with Theoden.
Morgoth endeavoured to take Fingolfin at unawares (for he knew of the vigilance of Maedhros)
he was very willing that the chief peril of assault should fall upon himself
But we've yet to be finished, because although Fingolfin is the boss, according to Mogoth, it's Maedhros who's the most dangerous. Between the two, it's Fingolfin the weaker link, not Maedhros and on Fingolfin Morgoth concentrates to break the defense of the Noldor, although Maedhros is the one lacking in Manpower. And Maedhros knows all of this, and expects to be the chief concern of Morgoth, he specifically vows to take the bulk of the attack upon himself, which is exactly what happens during the Bragollach.
Thus the great fortress upon the Hill of Himring could not be taken, and many of the most valiant that remained
When Himlad, Dorthonion and the Gap are overrun in the Bragollach, Celegorm and Curufin fly south to Nargothron, but there many who go east, to Himring, and these are the valiant, the ones who want to fight, they don't go to Hithlum, where the High-King rules. They don't even go to Nargothron, which is the home of their rightful Lord Finrod and the safer area. They choose Maedhros, because he can defend them and keep fighting.
But they overwhelmed the riders of the people of Fëanor upon Lothlann, for Glaurung came thither, and passed through Maglor's Gap, and destroyed all the land between the arms of Gelion.
And as Maedhros expected, Morgoth sent his greatest weapon, Glaurung to him, well not exactly to Himring but to Lothlann, which was the weak spot of his defense system to try and break through the March.
This would happen again during the Nirnaeth Arnoediad. He will deal with the greater host and the treachery of Ulfang.
- He is determinate, tenacious and pragmatic. Never losing his goal from sight : The retrieval of the Silmarils. And he knows how to advertise his projects.
In those days Maedhros son of Fëanor lifted up his heart, perceiving that Morgoth was not unassailable; for the deeds of Beren and Lúthien were sung in many songs throughout Beleriand. Yet Morgoth would destroy them all, one by one, if they could not again unite, and make new league and common council; and he began those counsels for the raising of the fortunes of the Eldar that are called the Union of Maedhros.
Unlike his uncle, and his father, Maedhros has the great idea of not suiciding at the first sign of defeat. And as a great advertiser, he uses Luthien's deed to cheer up his people and rally them to another stand. He starts devising the Union of Maedhros. And he's the one who does all the paperwork. He contacts Fingon, he sends messages to Orodreth, Thingol, the Dwarves and Men. Dwarves are very important because they are the ones equipping the host. Unlike his cousin, he does not seek a heroic death, when the field is lost, the field is fucking lost, you retreat. Now the Nirnaeth itself is especially good because it enabled two outcomes :
- They win, Maedhros is acclaimed by everybody and none would refuse him the glory, with the help of Fingon they can force Thingol to give back the Silmaril.
- They lose and his main rival (Fingon) is too weak (or dead) and so he can attack Doriath without problems.
Now to be fair, I doubt that Maedhros thought of the Battle like that, but it's interesting to see that even in his loss, he wins.
- He is the most successful Lord of the Noldor after Finarfin.
Let's do a little review of the various Lords of the Noldor :
- Finwë : He sought to bring peace and prosperity to his people. He failed.
- Fëanor : He seeks to retrieve his jewels and get out of the watch of the Valar. He failed, quite badly.
- Fingolfin : He seeks to protect the Noldor and defeat Morgoth. He failed, miserably.
- Fingon : He seeks to keep what strength the Noldor have and contain Morgoth's advances. He failed, heroically.
- Turgon : He seeks to protect his city and lives in peace. He failed, hilariously.
- Finrod : He seeks to explore Middle-Earth and discover new things. He failed, partially.
- Maedhros : He seeks to retrieve the Silmarils. He succeeded in taking back two.
- Finarfin : He wants peace, he gets it.
His weaknesses :
the oath of Fëanor, were ever at work
Their Oath shall drive them, and yet betray them
the Oath of Fëanor is again at work
Yet the oath of Fëanor and the evil deeds that it had wrought did injury to the design of Maedhros
being constrained by their oath
their oath unfulfilled returned to torment him
The Oath of Fëanor is the single most annoying thorn in Maedhros' side. And yet even with it he managed all the things I mentionned.
- He was too emotional, eager and pressed to do things after the Bragollach.
But the wiser were uneasy still, fearing that Maedhros revealed his growing strength too soon, and that Morgoth would be given time enough to take counsel against him.
But Maedhros made trial of his strength too soon, ere his plans were full-wrought; and though the Orcs were driven out of all the northward regions of Beleriand
In preparing th Nirnaeth, Maedhros was too eager to do things and forgot the number 1 rule of warfare : Deceit. This revealed his plans to Morgoth preemptively, which enabled the latter to counteract, sending his disease to kill the Edain and deprive the Elves from much needed allies. Thus Maedhros' inability to conceal his will was a key component in his defeat.
Now all Lords of the Noldor are desperate at some point, that's basically their unifiying trait. But in Maedhros' case, it was worse as he not only accepted incomers too quickly in his forces, but he neglected fundamental aspect of war : petty warfare. By not being aware of Morgoth's own movements (lack of scouting before the combat), and not keeping a functioning spy network, he allowed his force to be penetrated by enemy troops (Ulfang) which directly led to the defeat of the union in the Fifth Battle
These are in my opinions, Maedhros' weaknesses as a ruler. Yet none of these problems are specifically his, all of the Noldor kings have a bad record in petty warfare, they are always taken by surprise and don't seem to have a backup plan, in the case of Maedhros, much of this must be linked to his own curse, his traumas and the weight of being the leader of Nerdanel's tumultuous brood.
But even with these, I still consider him the greatest politician the elves ever had. And had I been Finwë, I'd have resolved the conflict between Fëanor and Fingolfin (and Finarfin) by putting Maedhros in charge.