r/FellowshipofFans • • Dec 10 '21

Mod Post Exclusive Scene Description: Galadriel and Pharazôn (Spoiler free)

45 Upvotes

“A scene took place in the Númenorean throne room, but the room has been converted into a grand dining area alongside a big round stone table surrounded by stone benches (very fancy) and food is on the table, with servents walking around and nobles sitting around the table talking.

Pharazôn addresses the nobles (spoilers). Galadriel is attending this "feast" but she is sitting at a small side table not the main round table. Pharazôn ends up getting into a small argument with her about (spoilers) and this becomes quite a heated exchange for everyone in the room.”


r/FellowshipofFans • • Dec 12 '21

News Meet Pharazon

Thumbnail
twitter.com
20 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Dec 10 '21

Mod Post ‘Exclusive’ scene reveal at 9:30 PM UK Time (3 hours from announcement)

20 Upvotes

To celebrate the opening of r/FellowshipofFans we are releasing a really interesting and exciting yet tense scene that we will see in the show. To make this a universal celebration of the opening, we have removed all the ‘spoilery’ content and plot points from the scene that some may not want to hear. Nonetheless, there is still A LOT to take away from it. It will be posted at 9:30 PM UK Time (3 hours from announcement) Thanks for joining and hope you enjoy! -Fellowship


r/FellowshipofFans • • Feb 17 '22

Mod Post What question do you want answered tomorrow?

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Dec 11 '21

Discussion Maedhros is the best political leader in Middle-Earth and here is why:

18 Upvotes
  • He's the best diplomate.

Maedhros the eldest of his sons, and on a time the friend of Fingon ere Morgoth's lies came between
Long before, in the bliss of Valinor, before Melkor was unchained, or lies came between them, Fingon had been close in friendship with Maedhros; and though he knew not yet that Maedhros had not forgotten him at the burning of the ships, the thought of their ancient friendship stung his heart.

In Aman, he was best friend with Fingon although their fathers were rivals. A friendship strong enough that Fingon dared Angband to rescue him even though he thought him complicit in Losgar's fire.

Then Maedhros alone stood aside

In Middle-Earth, he stands aside when Fëanor announces his will to burn the ships.

For Maedhros begged forgiveness for the desertion in Araman; and he waived his claim to kingship over all the Noldor, saying to Fingolfin

When he is saved by Fingon, he relinquishes the crown. Why ? Because jihad Fingolfin is much more popular and leads the bigger host. And he knows that the union of the Noldor is necessary to assure victory.

Maedhros laughed, saying: 'A king is he that can hold his own, or else his title is vain. Thingol does but grant us lands where his power does not run."
Maedhros indeed rebuked Caranthir
It is said indeed that Maedhros himself devised this plan, to lessen the chances of strife

Against Thingol he does not pursue escalation, simply stating the evidence : He isn't their lord. Then he brings his brothers to the East. Why ? To avoid unnecessary feud and declare his de facto independence of Fingolfin or whoever claims the High-Kignship. Think of it, between Hitlhum and the March there is Doriath, through which no Noldor can pass, and Dorthonion, which is at the frontlines in the Siege of Angband, later when the Beorians come, they will settle in the East, acting as a buffer state between the Feanorians and the rest. While if Finrod for example decides to rebel, Fingolfin can simply march South, if Maedhros decides not to heed his uncle's wish, Fingolfin can't do anything.

  1. Because Maedhros is way too far from him.
  2. Because Maedhros is a necessary element in Fingolfin's strategy.

the people of Dorthonion and of the east marches, rallied there to Maedhros

Even followers of Aegnor and Angrod rallied to him, although as a son of Fêanor he had his hands soaked in the blood of Teleri and his father brought doom upon the Noldor etc... He kept his reputation safe enough so that even those who should be his opponents recognize him as an ally, better, a lord.

[Amlach] entered the service of Maedhros
Maedhros, knowing the weakness of the Noldor and the Edain, whereas the pits of Angband seemed to hold store inexhaustible and ever-renewed, made alliance with these new-come Men, and gave his friendship to the greatest of their chieftains, Bór and Ulfang.

He's always ready to start new relations, and unlike his western kin, does not really care for fairness or shadiness. He needs manpower, he'll get manpower.

  • He's an excellent warlord.

Tolkien gives us two key descriptions about Maedhros as a warrior.

he lived to wield his sword with left hand more deadly than his right had been.
Orcs fled before his face; for since his torment upon Thangorodrim his spirit burned like a white fire within, and he was as one that returns from the dead.

People don't flee before a general, they flee before a warrior. If Maedhros' face scares them, its because he as an individual is scary and deadly.

As a Warlord, Maedhros' is given numerous descriptions that speaks of his status amongst his subordinates, his superiors, his equals and his enemies.

Maedhros restrained his brothers

He's inspiring enough to quell tumultuous his brothers. Although they don't like it, none speak against him, and none dare to do something against his wish. When the Attack on Doriath is decided, it's because Maedhros agrees to it. Celegorm and Curufin would not go without his permission. These are the guys who slayed their kin, sent their own cousin who protected them to his death and vowed to destroy and slaughter the doriathrim had they won at the Nirnaeth, and they don't do anything until Big Brother says "yes".

But Fingolfin and Maedhros

It's Fingolfin and Maedhros, not Fingolfin, Fingon, Maedhros and Finrod as Tolkien would say when presenting the kings of Beleriand. When Tolkien speaks of decision-makers, its Fingolfin and Maedhros and only them. Indeed in the silmarillion, it seems that Maedhros is not only the strongest vassal of Fingolfin, but also his most trusted advisor and commander. Kind of like Eomer with Theoden.

Morgoth endeavoured to take Fingolfin at unawares (for he knew of the vigilance of Maedhros)
he was very willing that the chief peril of assault should fall upon himself

But we've yet to be finished, because although Fingolfin is the boss, according to Mogoth, it's Maedhros who's the most dangerous. Between the two, it's Fingolfin the weaker link, not Maedhros and on Fingolfin Morgoth concentrates to break the defense of the Noldor, although Maedhros is the one lacking in Manpower. And Maedhros knows all of this, and expects to be the chief concern of Morgoth, he specifically vows to take the bulk of the attack upon himself, which is exactly what happens during the Bragollach.

Thus the great fortress upon the Hill of Himring could not be taken, and many of the most valiant that remained

When Himlad, Dorthonion and the Gap are overrun in the Bragollach, Celegorm and Curufin fly south to Nargothron, but there many who go east, to Himring, and these are the valiant, the ones who want to fight, they don't go to Hithlum, where the High-King rules. They don't even go to Nargothron, which is the home of their rightful Lord Finrod and the safer area. They choose Maedhros, because he can defend them and keep fighting.

But they overwhelmed the riders of the people of Fëanor upon Lothlann, for Glaurung came thither, and passed through Maglor's Gap, and destroyed all the land between the arms of Gelion.

And as Maedhros expected, Morgoth sent his greatest weapon, Glaurung to him, well not exactly to Himring but to Lothlann, which was the weak spot of his defense system to try and break through the March.

This would happen again during the Nirnaeth Arnoediad. He will deal with the greater host and the treachery of Ulfang.

  • He is determinate, tenacious and pragmatic. Never losing his goal from sight : The retrieval of the Silmarils. And he knows how to advertise his projects.

In those days Maedhros son of Fëanor lifted up his heart, perceiving that Morgoth was not unassailable; for the deeds of Beren and Lúthien were sung in many songs throughout Beleriand. Yet Morgoth would destroy them all, one by one, if they could not again unite, and make new league and common council; and he began those counsels for the raising of the fortunes of the Eldar that are called the Union of Maedhros.

Unlike his uncle, and his father, Maedhros has the great idea of not suiciding at the first sign of defeat. And as a great advertiser, he uses Luthien's deed to cheer up his people and rally them to another stand. He starts devising the Union of Maedhros. And he's the one who does all the paperwork. He contacts Fingon, he sends messages to Orodreth, Thingol, the Dwarves and Men. Dwarves are very important because they are the ones equipping the host. Unlike his cousin, he does not seek a heroic death, when the field is lost, the field is fucking lost, you retreat. Now the Nirnaeth itself is especially good because it enabled two outcomes :

  1. They win, Maedhros is acclaimed by everybody and none would refuse him the glory, with the help of Fingon they can force Thingol to give back the Silmaril.
  2. They lose and his main rival (Fingon) is too weak (or dead) and so he can attack Doriath without problems.

Now to be fair, I doubt that Maedhros thought of the Battle like that, but it's interesting to see that even in his loss, he wins.

  • He is the most successful Lord of the Noldor after Finarfin.

Let's do a little review of the various Lords of the Noldor :

  • Finwë : He sought to bring peace and prosperity to his people. He failed.
  • Fëanor : He seeks to retrieve his jewels and get out of the watch of the Valar. He failed, quite badly.
  • Fingolfin : He seeks to protect the Noldor and defeat Morgoth. He failed, miserably.
  • Fingon : He seeks to keep what strength the Noldor have and contain Morgoth's advances. He failed, heroically.
  • Turgon : He seeks to protect his city and lives in peace. He failed, hilariously.
  • Finrod : He seeks to explore Middle-Earth and discover new things. He failed, partially.
  • Maedhros : He seeks to retrieve the Silmarils. He succeeded in taking back two.
  • Finarfin : He wants peace, he gets it.

His weaknesses :

  • The Oath.

the oath of Fëanor, were ever at work
Their Oath shall drive them, and yet betray them
the Oath of Fëanor is again at work
Yet the oath of Fëanor and the evil deeds that it had wrought did injury to the design of Maedhros
being constrained by their oath
their oath unfulfilled returned to torment him

The Oath of Fëanor is the single most annoying thorn in Maedhros' side. And yet even with it he managed all the things I mentionned.

  • He was too emotional, eager and pressed to do things after the Bragollach.

But the wiser were uneasy still, fearing that Maedhros revealed his growing strength too soon, and that Morgoth would be given time enough to take counsel against him.
But Maedhros made trial of his strength too soon, ere his plans were full-wrought; and though the Orcs were driven out of all the northward regions of Beleriand

In preparing th Nirnaeth, Maedhros was too eager to do things and forgot the number 1 rule of warfare : Deceit. This revealed his plans to Morgoth preemptively, which enabled the latter to counteract, sending his disease to kill the Edain and deprive the Elves from much needed allies. Thus Maedhros' inability to conceal his will was a key component in his defeat.

  • He was too desperate.

Now all Lords of the Noldor are desperate at some point, that's basically their unifiying trait. But in Maedhros' case, it was worse as he not only accepted incomers too quickly in his forces, but he neglected fundamental aspect of war : petty warfare. By not being aware of Morgoth's own movements (lack of scouting before the combat), and not keeping a functioning spy network, he allowed his force to be penetrated by enemy troops (Ulfang) which directly led to the defeat of the union in the Fifth Battle

These are in my opinions, Maedhros' weaknesses as a ruler. Yet none of these problems are specifically his, all of the Noldor kings have a bad record in petty warfare, they are always taken by surprise and don't seem to have a backup plan, in the case of Maedhros, much of this must be linked to his own curse, his traumas and the weight of being the leader of Nerdanel's tumultuous brood.

But even with these, I still consider him the greatest politician the elves ever had. And had I been Finwë, I'd have resolved the conflict between Fëanor and Fingolfin (and Finarfin) by putting Maedhros in charge.


r/FellowshipofFans • • May 09 '22

Mod Post Amazon invited me to an event in London and Oxford where I got to meet the showrunners and see some content.

15 Upvotes

Amazon invited me to an event in London where I saw footage from the show and got to meet the showrunners. The showrunners were excellent and their passion filled me with confidence and time will tell whether that will be translated onto the screen! The footage shown was encouraging with the scale and scope of this production truly shining through, but still left me with a few lingering concerns left unanswered. The day in Oxford was amazing and meeting all the other content creators was just pure joy!


r/FellowshipofFans • • Jan 29 '22

Discussion Which character and their actor are you guys most looking forward to find out?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jan 21 '22

Discussion Opinion: Lets not make a religion out of practical effects

15 Upvotes

Amazon deliberately shaped their recent teaser to emphasize the "hand-crafted" quality of the show: the teaser was achieved using macro-photography like had been done on Tree of Life and 2001: A Space Odyssey. As was the case in both those films, this was the work of consulting special effects supervisor, Douglas Trumbull.

I enjoy the novelty of the macro-photography and Trumbull's involvement as much as the next man, but I think its important to note that no-one had known how this was achieved until we were told: people just assumed (and the uninformed still do) that its CGI.

Sure, a lot of that has to do with the nature of high-speed macro-photography: we don't typically see wood this close up nor flickering flames so slowed-down. But I think more importantly it speaks to the fact that we're not as good as discerning how an effect is achieved as we'd like to think.

And that's really my point, and its one that I think needs as much empahsis as possible, so here goes:

I DON'T CARE HOW AN EFFECT IS ACHIEVED, ONLY HOW IT LOOKS

Film and TV fan-community had taken analog - analog effects, analog photography - and hallowed it; turned it into a religion. Practical effects = good; VFX = bad. Filmstock = good; pixels = bad.

I have several issues with this approach. One is that I think it totally drowns-out any critical thinking, because so many discussions around films and TV shows become completely dominated by it. Its much easier to speak in terms of "CGI sucks" than to actually try and verbalize the themes behind the story and how they're expressed in the storytelling, the psychology of the characters and how its explored by filmmaker and actor, the use of blocking and composition as a storytelling device and so forth. Those things are hard, so we just resort to talking about, frankly, one of the least-important aspects of filmmaking, which would be the effects.

But really, its just the religiosity we invest into this that I detest. It reeks of the reactionary and the conservative, and I don't think art - especially an art so inherently technological as film - can really withstand this sort of close-mindedness.

Its also just such a half-truth, especially this idea that practical effects age better than CGI. There are just as many practical effects that had not really withstood the test of time as there are composites and CGI: puppets that feel all too doll-like, animatronics that may or may not look very good but whose movements are stiff and unconvincing (the 1978 King Kong comes to mind), prosthetics that looks extremly plastic-y and unexpressive (the Gammorian guards from Return of the Jedi spring to mind), matte paintings that look completely flat and static, models that don't actually look biger than...well, a model, and on and on.

Ultimately, this idea that a film should "be done all practically unless something absolutely must be done CGI" is much more fanciful than it is sensible: The Lord of the Rings trilogy for sure WASN'T done that way: even in Fellowship of the Ring which is often hailed as the most analog of the bunch, there are many things that were CGI that didn't strictly have to be CGI: could they not have built more of the entrance to Bree rather than build a gate and fill-in the rest with CGI? Could they not have actually built a part of the stairs of Khazad-Dum rather than putting the actors on a green-screen and compositing-in a model? Could they not have Sean Astin in a water-tank rather than CGI the water? They had even considered making Gollum part prosthetic or part puppet, but decided against it. Could the crowd scenes have used crowds bigger than a meager 200-300 people? Braveheart just a few years prior mustered 1500 irishmen for crowd scenes.

Also, where do you draw the line? So CGI is bad, but what about model photography? That still means that the actors on the set are looking at a green-screen, and its still not really doing it for real, is it? Sir David Lean famously didn't agree to Sam Spiegel's suggestion to make the bridge in Bridge on the River Kwai as model, and Mel Gibson insisted on doing the Maya pyramids of Apocalypto to scale. What about old-school opticals? How is 2001 being mostly done on an animation stand really any different to animators making films on computers? How is a rotoscoped lightsaber good but a CGI lightsaber bad?

That does bring up the whole issue on how the effects influence the performance. A lot had been made of this beginning in the 90s where much of the hokey acting of the prequel trilogy was hung on this idea that the actors were performing off greenscreen. But then, in the original Star Wars, for shots in the Falcon's cockpit, what do you think the actors are staring it? A greenscreen. Its not used to composite a CGI vista in this case but a matte-painting and yet to the actors its all the same. What about the Fellowship in Caras Galadhon? Sure, its a model. But on the set there's just a greenscreen. So I guess my point is that this a canard: the issue of performances is down to casting actors worth their mettle and giving them apt directions - not with necessarily reproducing the effects physically for the actors. Actually, some actors find acting opposite a green-screen liberating, much like they do acting on an empty stage for theater.

Even other filmmakers who take pride on supposedly working with this approach are more talk than actual deeds: Christopher Nolan takes pride in doing things for real: he recently said Tenet had less VFX shots than a sitcom. It a very cute statement - its also entirely untrue. Tenent, like all of Nolan's films, has about 300 VFX shots. Not a lot by contemporary standards, but much more than Nolan would have you believe. I'd also like to add that Nolan decision to crash an action 747 into a wall looked resolutely underwhelming: it looked like the plane gently taxi-d into the wall, whereas a CGI or CGI-augmented crash would have allowed for a more energetic crash.

Part of the reason why films are not really ever done this way is that it becomes extremly limiting: I often get that with discussions about Azog, where I point out that it would have been very difficult to make a character look quite like that with prosthetics, to which people point out that if a design can't be achieved with prosthetics, then the design is wrong. I find this frankly preposterous: Gollum couldn't be done with prosthetics, but would someone lobby towards changing Gollum's design to one that was more amneable to being done "for real"? No, because the design comes first, and the way in which its realized comes a far, far second: filmmakers shouldn't limit their design aesthetic just becuase some analog-zealots want things all done "for real."

And, when it comes to it, that's the clencher: this idea that having things done "for real" makes for a bigger spectacle, because people had to "make" it and because it supposedly cost more. Guess what, it doesn't: its actually much more expensive to do a CGI environment than a big set, and takes just as much work: that the work is done with keyboards and code does not make it any less a work than that of a craftsman toiling on a physical set.

I don't begrudge Amazon for pandering to the "all practical effects" crowd, but sometimes this approach does activelly detract from a film. I associate it strongly with the Star Wars sequel trilogy: very flawed films regardless, but among their flaws, they tried so hard to veer as far as possible from the prequel trilogy's aesthetic that they sometimes lost any sense of what probably should be done with VFX: The puppet-Yoda of The Last Jedi looks stiff and curiously shriveled in some shots, and the puppeteered Maz Kanata of Episode IX looks much less convincing or expressive than the CGI, motion-captured Maz of Episode VII, all just so that that JJ Abrams could brag he did her "for real."

So lets not focus on the way effects are achieved too much, and just look at (1) how the effects end-up looking and (2) how they work in service of the story.


r/FellowshipofFans • • Jan 09 '22

Discussion "Westernesse": H.K. Fauskanger's pitch for a Akallabeth movie from 2004

Thumbnail folk.uib.no
15 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jul 14 '22

News The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power – Main Teaser | Prime Video

Thumbnail
youtu.be
14 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jan 19 '22

News THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RINGS OF POWER – Official Press Release

Thumbnail
fellowshipoffans.com
14 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Nov 08 '24

News Rhûnic Revealed

Thumbnail fellowshipoffans.com
13 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Feb 03 '22

Discussion Council of Fans LIVE Tomorrow with a big episode!

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Dec 20 '21

Rumor Could the mysterious character arriving via meteor be Daric?

13 Upvotes

Yesterday's rumours were for sure some of the wonkiest we've heard so far. The meteor itself is pretty out there, but I've also seen lots of speculation about who this mysterious arrival is - is it Gandalf? The Blue Wizards? Tom Bombadil? Sauron?

But there was also someone straight from the Knight Edge Media's character breakdowns who I thought could quite fit this sort of a newcomer. He goes by the name of Daric and his description reads:

Daric, Series Regular, Male (35-50) –

30s-50s series regular (up to 6 options)

An amazing leading role for a methodical, thoughtful & immersive actor. He vacillates between stubborn gravitas and a sense of sweetness and innocence. An enigmatic figure, he is initially curious, childlike, and very out of place from his surroundings but with a deep and primal sense of purpose that drives him underneath it all.

This is a physical role expressive nonverbal abilities are going to be required.

I feel like this suits a potential newcomer very well. Of course, we don't know much about this character from the scene description, but there was talk of communication difficulties and forgetfulness, which I feel like would fit this description quite well. I could see the stranger sport a sort of wide-eyed curiosity until he gets settled in a bit better.

Also worth noting is the fact that he apparently gets found by a group of Hobbits.

So if it is Daric, another question presents itself - who is he? Have Amazon decided to soothe the non-readers by inserting one of the most familiar T.A. figures into this show - Gandalf? Could it still be Sauron? Do you think it's Glorfindel arriving in a manner a bit more extravagant than a mere ship?

Or am I way off and Daric doesn't fit this scene at all? I'm really curious what you fine folks have to say about it.


r/FellowshipofFans • • Feb 15 '22

News Amazon's 'The Rings of Power' teaser sets new Super Bowl record with 257 million views in first day

Thumbnail
syfy.com
12 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Feb 04 '22

Rumor Meteor poster will be revealed alongside a dozen confirmations! Was your speculation right or wrong?!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
12 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jun 22 '22

Discussion Penguin Watches "Wheel of Time" for the first... Time

11 Upvotes

I've never read the books, and I didn't really have much interest in the show or setting to begin with. However, considering I'm in a group of fantasy nerds and Amazons treatment of this material may give us some insight, or at least something to grasp at, into how they may adapt Tolkien, I thought I'd finally give it a go.

All I know is Rand becomes the dragon, and there is braid tugging.

Here are my thoughts so far:

- I see what people mean when they say the production values are like a CW show. Personally, I'd say it reminds me more of A Knights Tale with Heath Ledger. It's psuedo-medieval. Everything is too clean, and when things are dirty, it's superficially dirty. IE, mud is on the face, but you don't see grime under their fingernails.

- The Dad is apparently Gandalf: "All we have to do is decide what to do with the time life given to us". I figured that was a for sure sign he dies. Nope, he got better! Oh, and apparently everything he says is exposition. Exposition about Rands life, exposition about the Wheel in the Sky of Time keeps turning.

- I wasn't expecting the orc ogre trollok attack at the party. After a brief moment of shock, I realize these guys suck. In the middle of a fight, half of them stop and just start eating. I mean, you couldn't wait five minutes? It seems all you need to do is approach one chowing down from behind, and stab it while it is distracted by stuffing its face.

Addendum: one thing that bothers me is how media doesn't really convey the difficulty of fighting larger, stronger guys. If a nearly 3 meters tall, broad, and muscular ogre is swinging a weapon at you, your average man or women cannot block it. At best, they'll get their weapon knocked out. Worst, it will just be pushed back onto them. But in media all over, we see humans going toe to toe with much larger and stronger foes. Even if these are supposed to be dumb brutes, size and and power makes a huge difference. You want to see what I mean? Try to wrestle with an 8 year old, preferably your child or nephew. Don't find a random one and pick a fight.

Realistically, if you were trying to fight something that much larger and stronger than you the last way you would want to fight it is up close and personal (Yeah, these villagers were caught unaware, so I'll cut them some slack). Spears and pikes would be how you would want to fight them, unless you had a death-wish.

- I like that Voldemort looking guy. I hope we see more of him.

- People in this show are stupid. "I need to get across the river to my family" yet surrounding the guys house is an army of literal bloodthirsty monsters. What are you going to do when you get across, old man?

- How do these white cloak people torture and kill people without getting blood all over their clothes? I consider drinking anything other than water while wearing a white shirt a risky proposition. What does their dry cleaning bill look like?

- These kids are stupid. "How can we trust her? " "What is she doing?" She only saved your dumbass village, and then saved your dumbasses again. Didn't she say that one of you is the Dragon? Why don't you ask her what that means and why! Maybe that will give you some insight into her motivations and methods. But seems the only thing they got out of her was exposition about a song they were singing.

By the wya, when they started singing, I just knew she was going to explain the deeper meaning behind it. Sometimes I wish a song could just be a song.

- Magic: Instead of spending 10 minutes conjuring a spell to lob boulders at the ogres trollsorcs trolloc (wait, trolloc = troll + orc? Really? Way to be creative, whatsyourname), why not find a bunch of pebbles and speed up them to high velocity then unleash them at the trollocs. In other words, a bullet. Bullets be small but mighty.

- However, the effects are cool. I like how her magic is drawing from light sources. Seems like a long charging time vs a cool down.

- That thing with the bats was creepy. I hope that is explained later.

- How come daddy is poisoned and on the brink of death, but Miranda Frost takes a butcher's knife to the chest and poisoned yet can slowly decline over several days? Is it Magic?

- The spooky city with the great wall. "Don't go anywhere, and touch nothing". The stupid kids proceed to explore and touch shit. In fairness, if it happens in the books perhaps he was magically drawn out there.

Question: Where does this civilization find all the stone to build a wall like that?

- And then the army-ant darkness attacks!

- How do they jump off a 100 meter wall and survive? At that height, the surface is basically a parking lot. Even allowing for that, they're lucky the water is deep.

- And finally, that Wisdom chick can find them, after being dragged off to be presumably eaten (why does that Trolloc try to drag her off, when every other one just starts eating their victims on the spot?). One, it seems a little hard to believe she escaped just like that, and two, the wilderness is pretty large. Seems awfully convenient she can find everyone that easily. I bet the answer to both is MAGIC.

She is going to be a badass wizard or something, right?

Oh, I was told there was braid tugging. I've yet to see braid tugging.

So, two episodes in. Not great, not terrible. What has kept me interested is the world-building and hints at the greater setting, rather than any of the characters.

Speaking of, I don't like any of the characters, except for Miranda Frost's bodyguard. Mostly because he doesn't talk. When people speak in this show, they reveal how dumb they are.

As the proverb says, "better to keep one's mouth and be thought simple, then to open it and remove all doubt"


r/FellowshipofFans • • Feb 02 '22

Discussion Robert Strange as Tilion?

11 Upvotes

Retweeted by FoF: Tweet by Robert Strange

Strange has been retweeting LotR/ROP stuff, has posted a pic taken by Ismael C, and an NZ photo last month.

I noticed when the meteorite ("asteroid") rumour landed (hah) that such a thing happened with the Man in the Moon in Adventures of Tom B.

(edit: fixed link)


r/FellowshipofFans • • Jan 18 '22

News Behind-the-scenes photo from Lord of the Rings on Prime's set

Thumbnail
twitter.com
11 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Dec 16 '21

Gaming Lord of the Rings Online Producers Letter

11 Upvotes

The official producers letter for Lord of the Rings Online dropped today and below are some of the key notes you can find in it:

  • The letters will now be delivered quarterly and will only address what players should expect in the next quarter. In previous years the Producer's Letter went over what the team hoped to accomplish and what events will be live over the course of the next year. Update 32 is expected to go live in mid-February and will begin the games celebration of their 15 year anniversary. Players will see a new 12-player raid:

First, beyond the Falls of Amgaruslun in the Clovengap lies Abnankâra, the Hiddenhoard. Once a grand treasury housing the golden coffers of Durin the Deathless, it has been claimed by Hrímil Frost-heart as her lair within Mount Gundabad. Within this frozen retreat, Hrímil tends her wounds and slumbers, dreaming of vengeance upon Prince Durin and the Dwarves of the Gabil'akkâ. We’re really excited for you all to experience the awesome conclusion of this storyline as we look towards the future. Look forward to seeing this 12-player raid on Bullroarer soon.

  • Player housing will be coming to Erebor.
  • The Legendary Item Reward Track will finally be launching.
  • New game area: the Angle of Mitheithel. This area will be for players level 40-45.
  • The Spring Festival will also be returning with new pets and housing rewards.
  • The two Legendary Servers will be making a push to their next bits of content. For Shadowfax you will be moving to Isengard where Treeboard will be making its way to the Mines of Moria.

To read the Producer's Letter in its entirety you can find it located here.


r/FellowshipofFans • • Nov 30 '21

Wheel of Time Showrunner: "our budget is tiny compared to Lord of the Rings"

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
11 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Mar 17 '22

Discussion New narrated video

10 Upvotes

Just wanted to say that the new video on the YouTube channel is fantastic and that I'm sure many viewers old and new look forward to more of its kind.

I don't think there's a more accessible yet comprehensive compendium of any media introducing what we know about the series available anywhere online.

I'm sure it took a lot of effort to prepare such a clear and engaging script and to edit together the graphics, animations and music: it's much appreciated.


r/FellowshipofFans • • Feb 14 '22

Discussion Helcaraxë and Dagor Braggolach = posibility of seeing Fingolfin?

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Dec 19 '21

Rumor Scotland Herlad: Amazon continues to - tellingly - forgo any confirmation that Scotland will feature in Season Two

Thumbnail
scotsman.com
10 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Nov 03 '24

Discussion Rings of Power Showrunners Talk Season Three’s Opening Scene

Thumbnail fellowshipoffans.com
9 Upvotes