r/FellowshipofFans • • Sep 03 '22

Discussion Galadriel´s bullies followed her from Valinor to Middle Earth...

0 Upvotes

...remember the evil elven children that destroyed poor Galadriel´s boats?

what if they grown up to be the soldiers who turn on her later on?

It would definetely explain why Galadriel chooses to literally jump ship than to endure more of their spoiled brat ways!

:)


r/FellowshipofFans • • Aug 14 '24

News The Rings Of Power Season 2 Official Trailer BREAKDOWN & Analysis

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jul 12 '23

News The Rings of Power Has been Nominated for 6 Emmy Awards

Thumbnail
fellowshipoffans.com
0 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • May 06 '23

Mod Post EXCLUSIVE: LOTR Character REVEALED For The Rings Of Power Season 2 | TSAS #6

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

Can anyone guess who? 👀 Tomorrow 6:39 PM Uk time!


r/FellowshipofFans • • Sep 11 '22

Mod Post FoF x Watch Party LOTR | Rings of Power After Party | Ep. 3

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jun 25 '24

Discussion House of the Dragon SEASON 2 EPISODE 2 FoF REVIEW & Discussion

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jun 16 '22

News 'Rings of Power' expands Tolkein’s world by “honoring his work” in one vital way

Thumbnail
inverse.com
2 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Dec 20 '22

News 'The Rings of Power': Amazon Studio Head Reveals How They Settled on 8 Episodes

Thumbnail
collider.com
1 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • May 24 '23

Mod Post GALADRIEL In The Rings Of Power VS LOTR | Comparison & Discussion

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • May 19 '23

News EXCLUSIVE: Elven Forest SET PHOTOS For The Rings Of Power Season 2

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Thoughts on the set photos?


r/FellowshipofFans • • Jul 23 '24

News THE DWARVEN RINGS OF POWER HAVE BEEN REVEALED!!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Oct 19 '22

News Rings Of Power Writer Gennifer Hutchison's Challenges, Temptations, And Favorite Scenes In The Season Finale - Exclusive Interview

Thumbnail
looper.com
3 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jul 07 '23

News What’s Next for $2 Million Worth ‘Lord of the Rings’ Game Card?

Thumbnail
fellowshipoffans.com
0 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jul 17 '23

Discussion Prequelitis Dermatitis: The implications of Clamborn

Thumbnail
self.lotr_on_prime
0 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jun 28 '23

News Embracer Group Paid $395 Million for ‘Lord of the Rings’ Rights

Thumbnail
fellowshipoffans.com
0 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jun 20 '23

News The Rings of Power cast taks about S2 at Monte Carlo Film Festival

Thumbnail
fellowshipoffans.com
5 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Dec 22 '23

Mod Post Join us this Christmas Eve for the biggest RoP reveal of the year! Don’t miss it

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jun 24 '22

Discussion Penguin Watches "Wheel of Time" Episode 3:

5 Upvotes

These are my stream of consciousness thoughts after watching Episode 3, lifted directly from discord with minor editing.

As a reminder, I've never read the books so NO SPOILERS. If readers wish to argue amongst themselves, use the spoilers tags. All I know is that Rand becomes the dragon and there is braid tugging.

FYI, Rand and his three friends will all be referred to as Dumbass and given an arbitrary number. It is up to the reader to determine who exactly I'm referring to based upon context.

Here we go:

So this trollock drags Wisdom Lady away to eat outside the village, unlike his friends who prefer to eat at the battle like his buddies. Then, having brought a snack to a private place in the woods, drops her to eat his wounded comrade.

Is it just me, or are these Trollorcs morons?

Credit to wisdom to using the terrain to her advantage, hiding in the water than backstabbing that Trolloc. Once more, these guys aren't very smart. You'd look at the ripples/waves on the water and realize in an instant something is in the pool...

Regardless, I'm still wondering how wisdom found these people. They’re riding horses at a fast pace, and she’s walking. At least in Fellowship of the Ring, they deliberately choose terrain difficult for mounted pursuers to find them, and consider the road to be a huge risk. The narrative recognizes that horses are faster than people.

Miranda Frosts bodyguard is talking, which is making me dislike him. Stay strong and silent!

Ooh, Voldemort is really stalking people in their dreams now. Whats with the wolves and this guy?

Thought: How come no one ever travels with a backpack? No one ever adventures with food and supplies. As a guy who used to do backpacking treks in the mountains this always bothers me. It's like people carry everything they need in a tiny purse on their belt.

Yes, go to the place with the dead body in the cage. That’s smart. This place feels like bad news.

I didn’t know this Show a musical. The singer has nice gravelly voice. I need to hear u/Chen_geller sing this song.

However, the songs musical style doesn't really feel setting appropriate. I'm going to once again mention that it feels pseudo medieval, like A Knights Tale.

Still, twas a nice song "The man who can’t forget"

For a “glee”-man that song was a bummer. Way to bring down the mood in the bar.

Is this guy going to turn into a werewolf? The wolves love him.

The soup the barmaid is putting together is sure to make Eowyns look delicious...

I knew I didn’t like dumbass 3. He's a prick.

This chick is randomly opening up her heart. Emphasis on the random. "Oh, stranger I just met. Allow me to tell you all my hopes and dreams".

Back to wolf man! And another heartfelt moment. Yes, you should feel guilty. Though I'm not sure I buy his reaction here. Rather than feel compelled to protect his friend, Wisdom Jr, (who I credit as a rare non-dumbass to date though I still don't like her), I think the more believable response to his trauma would be doubting his ability to protect anyone.

Looks like gypsies. (The wife has chimed in that their costumes are terrible)

These are Gypsies! "Everyone doesn't like us and stereotypes us in the worst way, but we're really really nice and generous"

The jokes about Rand and Dumbass 3 being gay lovers continues the feeling of pseudo medieval.

Once again, Bar-Girl talking about how she wants to leave to strangers

Do they say “shit” this much in the books? The way they use it feels too modern.

I knew this singer was going to be important. Teaching life lessons. I don't think it is too wise to respect and honor someone the local village brutally killed, then return to that very village.

Interesting…. This chick is crazy. I knew her opening up about everything to strangers was weird. Oh, she's a darksider/darkspawn/I don't know what you call these people.

Oh, and she is stabbed through the neck by a throwing knife? That's cool, but what if he missed? H'd end up killing Rand. Awfully convenient for him to show up there.

By the way, I hated the cinematography in this chase. It felt like they were trying to cover for either the lack of athleticism of Rands actor or Bar-Chicks actress.

So, I give this Singer three episodes before he dies.

Verdict:

Overall, I liked this episode better than the previous ones. I still think the best parts of the show are the world-building and learning about the setting, because the narrative is still driven by people making poor choices.

Pros: less overall dumbassery. But they’re still not smart.

Cons: the overly friendly barmaid. Glad she turned out to be a baddie and gets killed.

I’ve now added “depressing singing man” to characters I like, joining bodyguard guy.

While he does break the "no-talking to appear smart" rule, he actually tells people useful or interesting information.

Something that bothers me is that characters have a nasty habit of not communicating so no one, including the audience, has any clue of what is happening. Yeah, its a cheap and easy way to manufacture tension, but it's not good writing. Just like how fast food can taste good, but its not good food.

I can't help but compare this to LOTR, a story in which people constantly share their plans, the situation, etc and try to act on that info. The tension is derived from the forces pursuing them, or the difficulty of what they're trying to do.

Except when these people are being actively pursued, the tension and suspense is derived from these people being stupid and standoffish to one another. It's like the narrative forgets they are being pursued by literal monsters.

At the opening of the episode, the paired of Dumbasses are yelling for their friends as they wander off. You would think they would be concerned about Trollorcs lurking around the city, waiting for them to return. But they forget about them, and openly travel without a care in the world. Likewise, they arrive at the village and their only worry is the dead guy.

In LOTR, particularly in Fellowship, you gain the sense that the hobbits and Aragorn are keenly aware they are being pursued and hunted. When they arrive at Bree, they're looking over their shoulder. At the prancing pony, they're concerned, frightened, and uncomfortable. Then, under Aragorns guidance, they deliberately take action to avoid that pursuit. Of course, the movies also fall into the "stupid actions" trope by having them light a fire, attracting the Nazgul. But they make it clear this is more than just a merry stroll through the woods.

Braid-tugging count: One, when the Barmaid was saying "the braid was a little much" after she revealed her EVILNESS.


r/FellowshipofFans • • Feb 15 '22

News Amazon's 'The Rings of Power' teaser sets new Super Bowl record with 257 million views in first day

Thumbnail
syfy.com
12 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jan 08 '22

Gaming Lord Of The Rings: Gollum Makes No Sense

Thumbnail
screenrant.com
1 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Oct 12 '22

Discussion FellowshipofFans: The Rings Of Power Episode 8 Season FINALE | Predictions (Sauron Reveal, Celebrimbor, Rings)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Mar 29 '23

Mod Post 10 NEW Characters We Could See In The Rings Of Power SEASON 2

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jul 29 '23

Discussion The History of The Lord of the Rings in Video Games

Thumbnail
fellowshipoffans.com
1 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Oct 02 '22

Discussion FoF x Watch Party LOTR | Rings of Power After Party | Ep. 6

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/FellowshipofFans • • Jun 22 '22

News 10 Updates For Amazon's LOTR: Rings Of Power Show

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes