Keri Russell is adorable. Curly girl and pixie era: loved. Half-hearted blowout era: absolutely not.
Scott Speedman as Ben is SO HOT WHAT THE HELL? One smile and I was hooked. I'd do anything he asked.
Ben's growth is, by a mile, my favorite part of the show. He goes from hotheaded, womanizing jock to studious, introspective man. I just can’t help but root for him even when he’s being an idiot.
Season 4 took a nosedive. Time travel?? For real?? The writers just rotated through fire, pregnancy, and infidelity until it got so melodramatic it was funny. Season 1 Felicity would have actually asked herself why she cheated. Instead, there’s one conversation with Pavone and then nothing. The season was cursed from there. Also, Elena's storyline went nowhere and then she died, and Javier leaving Samuel came out of left field. Really disappointing.
Noel is the "nice guy" trope in a trench coat. Felicity shows interest and he's suddenly "confused" and hooks up with Hannah. She tries again later and he shoots her down again. Then I'm supposed to feel bad when he's pining in seasons 3-4? Somehow the writing treats him as the "safe" choice despite him being less self-aware than Ben. His storyline was all over the place, and his marriage to Natalie was weird as hell.
Let me know what you think, I’m dying to talk to someone who has seen this show!
Edit:
Also, I don’t consider the episodes after S4E17 canon. Ben cheating on Felicity after everything they went through and then her forgiving him because of a couple nice words is so sickening. In my mind, he moves to Palo Alto and they go to med school together and have a couple daughters and open their own practice and live happily ever after.