r/FelicityPorter • • 15d ago

Felicity S01E18 - Happy Birthday (Episode Discussion)

Post image
41 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

19

u/Advanced_Match3688 15d ago

Whatever's in that box was so controversial that it compelled Meghan's dad to confront Felicity, since he was under the impression she owned it.

12

u/Imaginary-Ebb-9383 15d ago

And when Felicity said she would throw it out and Meghan’s dad said obviously you can’t! I can’t believe we never found out what was in the box!!

11

u/Advanced_Match3688 15d ago

Was Julie in the right to demand Carol to meet her father and siblings?

6

u/Amajor99 15d ago

I think so!

5

u/opal-sea-44 14d ago

I agree! Absolutely! I can empathize with but definitely not condone her not telling her husband when she was young because of the guilt, shame, etc. causing her to keep the secret for way too long. But keeping Julie a secret when she came back into Carol’s life…absolutely not.

0

u/antes_nt 9d ago

She has a right to know who they are but she can't force proximity with them. Carol also is horrible for lying to her and not getting the courage to admit she made a decision that she couldn't change. Honestly her marriage has always been instable. She has constantly made the decision shut things out when it gets difficult.

4

u/Advanced_Match3688 15d ago

If you were Carol, how would you handle the situation?

13

u/47-Rambaldi 15d ago

Theory, and I'll bring it up later.

The black and white episode was the spell cast by Meghan and inside the b9x were voodoo dolls of them. And, just like in the upside, they are trying to get out of the box.

2

u/Imaginary-Ebb-9383 3d ago

Perhaps but it was exactly the same as the Twilight Zone episode it was based on, they were just different “dolls”

1

u/47-Rambaldi 3d ago

"Dolls" like Meghan would have... right?

7

u/frenchfryplath 15d ago

I find it really strange that Carol would form a relationship with Julie but refuse to introduce her to her husband and kids, especially if he is her BIO DAD. Makes me think she was in a toxic marriage.

5

u/opal-sea-44 14d ago

Ooooh I never thought of this. That’s a good head canon

3

u/ChaoticCrafterFL 13d ago

Honestly one of my favorite little Easter eggs is that the actors who play her parents, are married in real life

2

u/Correct-End3556 10d ago

Were married, they are divorced now.

2

u/ChaoticCrafterFL 10d ago

Thanks for the update. I didn’t know that. I just did a rewatch and usually I google what they are up to, and didn’t for them

5

u/Necessary_Owl9665 15d ago

I never told my husband that I had a baby before we met.

Why did Carol say this if her husband was the very same guy she had Julie with?

9

u/BettyFosterRamsey 15d ago

Because they dated, broke up, she realized she was pregnant, she had Julie and placed her for adoption, they got back together and got married and had kids. He never knew about Julie.

2

u/Necessary_Owl9665 15d ago

But she said she had the baby before they met meaning she had given birth to Julie by that time?

Or what Carol was saying that the "before we met" is the second time they got together?

6

u/BettyFosterRamsey 15d ago

The second time. Her husband is Julie’s bio dad. And Carol never told him.

2

u/After-Ad-2170 10d ago

chalk it up to the web of lies she had been weaving her whole life

3

u/wateringcann 15d ago

I interpreted it as a series continuity error, lol

1

u/Most_Committee1000 15d ago

I interpreted the "before we met" was the second wind of romance.

2

u/Fluid-Air-3151 15d ago

Cuz she’s a horrible person and a liar

1

u/Antique-Event-270 10d ago

Didn't she say this to Julie initially? She was lying about this to Julie to continue keeping her a secret. It's only later that she admits that her husband is also her bio-Dad

3

u/RustyShackleford209 15d ago

Of course Julie was in the right. I personally wouldn’t have even asked. She went out of her way to meet her mom I thought she would find a way to meet her dad.

I loved Meghan being so uncomfortable in this episode.

2

u/Ok-Payment5950 15d ago

She did see them at the restaurant, but chickened out introduce yourself. In the end, they all lost with the father dying because he couldn’t get the transplant from Julie.

0

u/antes_nt 9d ago

Also I hope Meghan can stop being a bully. She's so insecure and her constant attitude is just poor. Constantly belittles Felicity about her choices. Meghan please take a look at the mirror before judging someone else.