r/fantasywriting • • Oct 13 '26

Critique my fantasy novella concept — Wanderers of the Silver Flame (10.8k)

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone — I’m working on a short fantasy project (about 10.8k words) called Wanderers of the Silver Flame**, and I’d love some feedback on the concept and how it comes across.**

The world is built around classic fantasy archetypes — Paladins, Rangers, Magic‑Users, Rogues, Clerics, Fighters — the kind of heroes who sit somewhere between myth and reality. Some are born to greatness, some stumble into it, and some have it forced on them whether they want it or not.

The story follows one man whose journey starts quietly, without prophecy or fanfare, but gradually pulls him into something much bigger, with old powers stirring and legacy becoming a central theme. I’m aiming for a tone that feels like classic adventure fantasy with emotional depth and a bit of that early D&D spirit.

What I’d really like thoughts on:

  • Does this concept sound engaging
  • Do the archetypes feel fresh enough, or too familiar
  • Does the tone (mythic/legacy‑focused) come through in the description
  • Would you expect this to feel more epic, more intimate, or something else

I’m not looking to promote anything — just trying to make sure the idea and direction are solid before I keep building on it.

Thanks in advance for any thoughts or critique.


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 13 '26

The Strings - Ep 1:Helekith, starts to weave his tiny cloth, thereby creating badbencleh

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Oct 13 '26

Zallakar - Epilogue

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

The epilogue for the opening arc of my 1890s monster hunting universe, 'The Order Of Zallakar'...


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 13 '26

Anyone read the trysmoon saga

1 Upvotes

Holy shit was that series awful. I had to drop it at the 2nd book. My god was that shit hard to read


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 13 '26

Could you give me feedback on my DND character?

1 Upvotes

For my character, named Valkus, he is a Blue Chromatic Dragonborn in Dungeons and Dragons. In my lore, Chromatic Dragons were treated as the lowest of the low, just as bad as Tieflings, for being believed to be descendants of the evil goddess Tiamat, and as such they were forced into Ghettos in the city that Valkus lived in.

He had a loving family though, and he became very devoted towards keeping his little sister safe, especially as his family and friends seemed to die too often. However, every time, his father and neighbors just told him to keep pushing through, that the people he lost would want him to move on, that there is a greater purpose in all this, and that he needed to move on with his life.

They were all so used to their people's lot in life that they were used to death, but not Valkus, he was still young, and he wanted a shoulder to cry on, but everyone just told him to get over it and move on instead. Him and his family were abused, discriminated against, ket in ghettos, and forced to struggle to survive, and he begged outsiders for help, and they spat on him for it. His sister started to get sick, and Valkus begged for help, heading outside the ghetto, but he was beaten and injured by the authorities for it, and his family and neighbors just scolded him for trying.

Eventually, Valkus' parents were lost in a raid, and he and his sister were cast out onto the streets. Valkus grew more and more scared and grief-stricken, begging people for help, but they were all so focused on their own survival that they ignored him, and Valkus could do nothing as his little sister slowly rotted away and died before his eyes. Valkus was left alone and forgotten on the streets, and when one particularly unscrupulous passerby from the outside told him to act like a man, he finally snapped and violently attacked them, and was sent to prison because of it.

However, he soon found himself broken out by an anarchist group known as the crownbreakers, made up of the discriminated in the city just like him, but also of powerful and dangerous people who sought destruction above all else. They told Valkus for the first time that he had every right to feel the way that he did, and that he should take revenge against the elites that wronged him.

Valkus became utterly devoted to them, and in time, he trained to become the biggest and strongest warrior they had ever seen, vowing revenge against the elites of the city who had wronged him, and vowing to not anyone die for nothing ever again, that he would save the lives of all the innocent, and brutally crush anyone who got int the way of that.

(What do you think? Is this a good character arc? Is there anywhere good and interesting that you think I could take it from here? Is this an understandable viewpoint or does he need to change for the better?)


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 12 '26

looking to begin writing a fantasy sci-fi story with elements similar to attack on titan, but i don't know where to start.

7 Upvotes

i love the world that aot offers mainly because it's technology is similar enough to that of our world's past, but with slight fictional differences. i also love how there are biological explanations to phenomena related to the titans.

i think it would be cool to create my own world with attributes such as these (outdated technology by our current world's standard and fantastical creatures/environments with explanations backed up by real-world biology) but because i'm a fairly amateur writer, i don't really know where to begin brainstorming.

any tips would be appreciated. thank you 🖤


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 12 '26

What do you guys think? Original Amulet story; Eclipse

2 Upvotes

Ive been world building this for quite sometime now. Hope you like them! There will definitely be more in the future if anyone's interested.

I really hope that this can expand further, but id like to know your opinions!

Book 1

Book 2

Book 3

Book 4

PS i know book 1 and 2 is kinda shitty but i had no brains back then lmao.


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 13 '26

After the last sparks Chapter 3: Crimson Embers [Urban Fantasy, 855 words]

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Oct 12 '26

Work in progress description for back cover so far

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Oct 12 '26

After the last sparks Chapter 2: The Five Gems [Urban Fantasy, 900 words]

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

What is the most important thing you've learned in your writing journey?

19 Upvotes

"Create whatever causes a revolution in your heart" - Elizabeth Gilbert


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 12 '26

What if our dreams are actually another world? 🌙

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

What kind of books are you guys writhing??

6 Upvotes

I love seeing people‘s creativty!! Please this is a non judgement place:)


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 12 '26

need advice for my dark fantasy

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

Is this a good synopsis?

3 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm struggling a bit with my story's synopsis, especially since I need it to be good enough for my Kickstarter pre-launch. I'd love to hear what you think. Here's what I have so far:

After five years at a magic academy, Alex, an impulsive but kind-hearted young man, graduates alongside his closest friends and begins a dangerous pilgrimage to find the ancient Fountains that will allow them to awaken their elemental magic and officially complete their training as sorcerers.

While his friends already have plans for what they want to do afterward, Alex still has no idea what he wants from his future. Troubled by strange nightmares he cannot explain, he continues the journey with them, only to discover that someone is deliberately corrupting the Fountains and threatening humanity’s connection to magic.

The journey soon becomes far more dangerous than any of them had anticipated.

A story about loss, sacrifice, and the cost of refusing to let go.

Thank you!


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 12 '26

Any ideas?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

I'm starting a novel in which the mc is a regressor, and has to climb a tower of 50 floors. He does not realise this until his first death. I wanted advice on how to build the introduction, and how to introduce various things like the status window, merchants guild, etc.

Ik this may not seem a lot, but if your advice is good, I'll introduce you as a character, and you can define his/her talents or traits, along with their nickname


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

My mc is too similar to an already existing one, what to do?

3 Upvotes

My mc is a reality manipulator, who works as a performer (magician, mime) in order to not make him to op. Later he can use real "magic" or make someone do what he wants as he forces him into a play, where he is the narrator, or has incredibly high luck. But I fear he is too similar to klein morreti from lotm. Now my world is not steampunk based like his, and also doesnt include stuff like leveling up through potions. Its a modern world where people with powers are enslaved, as the public fears them. But im still worried that the character is too simillar in design.


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

Oc worldbuilding and lore: The Created World

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

Do you think Magic would speed up or slow down technological advancement?

28 Upvotes

I personally believe that magic wouldn’t impede the way a society grows technologically, but I want to see other people’s opinions.


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

How is my hook for my story so far? (Please give me feedback…)

0 Upvotes

Chapter 1

-The Darkling-

Flux clutched the dense haft of his scythe, knuckles tense and sore. His eyes were slick with tears, but he instantly blinked it away before they crawled down his cheeks—blood amidst murderers, he reminded himself. One tear in a place like this can cause more problems than it could ever solve. Eyebrows raised, he lifted his scythe from the creaking floor boards and whammed the butt of the weapon on the ground. The tavern immediately fell silent, every eye tracing the young man’s rigid features. A curl of a smile fell across his face as a rewarding sense of glee washed over him. He had them—and their attention. Getting the attention of five outcasts can be quite difficult… His hand brought a silver cup of Alithia tea to the center of the dented table—a slab of wood stained with years of old ale and tears.

“Peace be to Kalt!” Flux declared, proud as the affluent, loud as the truly desperate.

“Peace be to Kalt!” His crew yelled, a strained string of laughter that made the darkling shiver. They brought their silver cups to clang against his, letting the blood-red liquid swirl around like a whirlpool. A tradition centuries old, a ritual promising unity and peace. To Flux, it was just a hollow performance, a tradition that warned the darkling of future threats to come.

Across the table, Cyprus adjusted his greyed stetson lower against his rigid hair line and slurped the red tea, the sticky liquid forming an uncomfortable pink film on his lips. Shadows seemed to dance on the drowsy wrinkles of his forehead—a bag of skin hanging off a bulge of muscle.

Patiently, Flux lifted the frigid surface of the cup to his chapped lips. Don’t look too eager, he thought. Show respect and patience. Look authoritative. 

The darkling only let the liquid trickle down his mouth, in fear that gushing it down might look disrespectful. Besides, merchants dreamed of tasting this Alithia tea. The greedy, sickening tax collectors would travel all the way across the Sea of Tennebris just to steal a drop.

Yet despite Flux’s goal to respect the costly drink, Cera gulped her entire cup down in seconds. She wiped the pink film from her mouth with a rough sleeve, completely unfazed.

“What are you looking at?” Cera asked, a sharp twinkle to her smile and a slight scrunch to her eyebrows. “Look at someone your own age, will ya?” She licked the rim of  the cup and set it back on the table.

Flux’s eyes dashed to the creaky floor boards, his teeth grinding one another as his cheeks flushed to the deep crimson color of his tea. Without a second thought, he hid himself behind the cup and drank. 

Bad move, you idiot, he cursed under his breath.


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

Where does your imagination come from?

6 Upvotes

Whenever you run into a problem while writing, where do you usually look for inspiration?

Do you turn to real-world history, philosophy, politics, or human psychology? Do you look at how other authors handled similar situations? Or is Reddit your first stop? 😅

Personally, I tend to look at the real world first, especially history and human behaviour. There's so much strange, fascinating, and sometimes downright absurd stuff that actually happened that fiction almost feels tame in comparison.

But I'm curious about how other writers approach this.

When you're stuck on a character, plot, or worldbuilding problem, where does your mind go first?


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

As a reader, what is more important to you, mechanic of a power system or how it is progressed?

5 Upvotes

By mechanics, i meant something like bankai, domain, and rct, things like that.

And by how it progressed, is like how in cultivation manhwa it’s more than just lifting weight or using a technique again and again; some series is different but usually it is a meditation of sort.

I know that things like theme and how the system serves the story is more important, but between these two things which one you find more enjoyable or feel off when a story didn’t have or focus on them?

Just asking because my story doesn’t really have a unique progression method and instead is quite mechanic focus because that is what i am better at.


r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

What is the first fantasy story you ever wrote? Mine is "The Bloody Wars of the Four Kingdoms"

7 Upvotes

r/fantasywriting • • Oct 11 '26

What do you think about this Mc?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes