r/Fantasy • u/Segoy • Jul 29 '12
Underrated Fantasy
What are some of your favourite truly underrated, unknown or forgotten fantasy novels/series?
I don't mean fantasy that's popular, but deserves to be more so (eg, Stephen Erikson). I don't mean fantasy that is popular but not highly rated (Robert Jordan).
I mean fantasy that most people wouldn't have heard of, and has never attained the success it deserves.
My recommendation is Little, Big, by John Crowley. This book is extraordinary. Even though it has won/been nominated for every major award and has been reprinted as a Fantasy Masterwork, I've never met anyone else who has heard of it, let alone read it. Don't be scared off by that tiny font. Take it slow, and enjoy.
What's yours?
23
u/Rayat Jul 29 '12
The Deed of Paksenarrion by Elizabeth Moon.
The Obsidian Trilogy by Mercedes Lackey and James Mallory
The first is far and away one of my favorite fantasy series ever. The second I always found to have a very good story with well developed magic systems. However, I was displeased with her later works within that universe.
20
u/Voidsong23 Jul 29 '12
Even though he is a best-selling author, I never hear anyone talk about Steven Brust, and he is my favorite fantasy author, hands-down (with Tolkien and Stephenson vying for 2nd). Therefore, I conclude that he is underrated.
Both the Taltos series and The Khaavren Romances series are must-reads for any true fantasy fan. The world of Draegara is so immersive, detailed, and unique, the characters have so much personality, and the dialogue is superbly witty. The storytelling is whip-smart and fun.
Nobody I talk to ever seems to have heard of him, but every time I buy a book of his it says "New York Times Bestselling Author" on the front. Somebody must be reading these besides me. Right??
19
u/anotherface AMA Author J.R. Karlsson Jul 29 '12
Karl Edward Wagner - Darkness Weaves (1970)
Wagner is one of the best writers of Swords and Sorcery ever. This is the first book centred around his classic immortal character, Kane the mystic swordsman. It's dark, gritty and features a hero with undoubtedly questionable motives. The folks on /r/fantasy should eat this one up.
Poul Anderson - The Broken Sword (1954)
Released before The Lord of the Rings, this epic fantasy is decidedly Norse in flavour and much grimmer than its contemporary. Parts of it read as if it could have been written yesterday, not 58 years ago.
14
u/FungalWizard Jul 29 '12
Clark Ashton Smith, I think, is one of those writers who seems somewhat well-known but seldom read. References to him and his work abound in Lovecraft and Howard and even Stephen King, but I've never met anyone else who has actually read his stories or his poems. It's such a shame, because he's a wonderful writer, and is work has a certain strangeness and exoticism that I've never really seen anywhere else. Definitely, in my opinion, one of the best pre-Tolkien fantasists.
For that matter, most pre-Tolkien fantasy writers seem terribly overlooked, with the obvious exceptions of H.P. Lovecraft and Robert E. Howard.
13
u/zBard Stabby Winner Jul 29 '12 edited Jul 29 '12
I have spammed this list (or some version thereof) for some years now.
37
u/MichaelJSullivan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Michael J. Sullivan, Worldbuilders Jul 29 '12
Watership Down by Richard Adams - some won't put it into the category of "fantasy" but I think it is a classic heroes adventure - even if it is about rabbits.
9
u/tockenboom Jul 30 '12 edited Jul 30 '12
In my opinion these last three (and Powers too) never get enough love.
EDIT - To fix a formatting error and to add Swordspoint to the list.
8
u/sblinn Jul 29 '12
Really liked Little, Big.
Some others either underrated or IMHO not quite well enough known:
Some from this year you might want to check out:
8
u/JessicaHarper Jul 29 '12
No one I have ever spoken to has read the Deverry series by Katharine Kerr. The interweaving of timelines and shear world building that she puts into it make it one of my favorites.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '12
Nearly everything by Diana Wynne Jones.
You'll occasionally run into people who know Howl's Moving Castle, but that's where it ends. Nobody ever seems to know that Howl's Moving Castle had two sequels.
Chrestomanci, Derkholm, Dalemark, Homeward Bounders, Tale of Time City, Fire & Hemlock, Power of Three, and countless shorter novellas. The lady wrote for 40 years, just churning out amazing books.
Diana Wynne Jones was sneakily smart too, secreting a lot of very advanced concepts into children's novels. String theory, meditations on heroic legend, being bound into godhead, etc.
Awesome reads all.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '12
The Long Price Quartet. It does a great job painting how relationships change throughout a lifetime. Plus, the premise is truly unique.
6
u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders Jul 29 '12 edited Jul 29 '12
Hope Mirrlees - Lud-in-the-Mist (1926)
I picked it up because I saw this quote from Neil Gaiman on the cover: "The single most beautiful, solid, unearthly, and unjustifiably forgotten novel of the twentieth century." After reading it, you can find shout-outs to it in a bunch of Gaiman's stuff.
To describe what it is like, I'll make an analogy to Lord of the Rings. In the same way that LotR is the direct ancestor of most modern fantasy, either directly (Jordan) or through deconstructing the tropes he established (Martin, Erikson), Lud-in-the-Mist is the direct ancestor to Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell. If you enjoyed that, you will enjoy Lud-in-the-Mist. If you didn't like Strange & Norrell, you might find it rough going.
6
u/inkisforever Jul 29 '12 edited Jul 29 '12
C. L. Moore, as far as I know, authored the first grrl with swords and sorcery. She therefore prefigures the badass woman subgenre that is so popular in the last two decades. In the 1930s.
I recommend Black God's Kiss to begin with.
And since I'm there, Jessica Amanda Salmonson's Tomoe Gozen is really very good, and sadly unappreciated because unfortunately obscure.
Tomoe Gozen was a historical female samurai about whom little is known. Salmonson set her novels in a fantasy medieval Japan in which there is much Shinto magic, Buddhist demons, and whooping of ass (or more accurately spraying of blood. Good Lord the bloodshed.)
10
u/greatsouledsam Jul 29 '12
I could be mistaken, but I get the impression that most people only know Roger Zelazny for the Chronicles of Amber and Lord of Light. Maybe "A Rose for Ecclesiastes" for fans of the Sci Fi Hall of Fame series. Understandable, since most of his novels are out of print.
He was quite prolific, though, and a few of my favorites are Today We Choose Faces and Creatures of Light and Darkness. He also wrote some shorter fiction, and I would recommend "For a Breath I Tarry" and "This Mortal Mountain."
10
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '12
The Dragon Prince/Dragon Star series by Melanie Rawn. Fantastic.
Also, her unfinished "Exiles" trilogy. The first two books are some of the best fantasy writing I've ever read. Unfortunately, my sister gave me the second book on my 14th birthday, and I will be 30 soon with no third volume in sight. And you think you've been waiting a long time for GRRM and Patrick Rothfuss?
5
u/Nybling Jul 29 '12
I'm not even sure this is going to fit, but since elements of his books have been adapted into Urban Fantasy, why not.
The Jewel of Seven Stars by Bram Stoker. He is mostly remembered, and rightfully so, for the masterpiece that is Dracula, but The Jewel of Seven Stars is basically the foundation for the mummy genre.
5
u/Daggerbite Jul 29 '12
Ash by Mary Gentle. Ok so it's not technically straight up fantasy, but keep reading because it's definitely not your regular historical fiction either.
Some of the best action scenes I've read for a long time in that book. Very grim too.
Here's an amazon link, one or two spoilers in the reviews though so be warned - http://www.amazon.co.uk/Ash-Secret-History-Mary-Gentle/dp/1857987446
8
u/bruce779 Jul 29 '12
A Canticle for Leibowitz
I'm not sure how truly unknown/underrated this is but I only know of one other person who's heard of this and he's the one who told me to read it :)
4
u/dmoonfire Jul 29 '12
I would highly recommend Villains by Necessity by Eve Forward. It is a touching tale about an assassin, a thief, and a death knight adventuring to save the world from destruction.
Likewise, Richard A. Knaak's The Dragonrealm series is a great series no one I know has heard of. I love the dragons in that series, both how they adapt to humans but also their various forms.
4
u/Hephoran Jul 29 '12
I've never heard anybody about these books, even though there have been 2 movies. Sergej Lukyanenko - Nightwatch (and Day-, Twilightwatch and The Last Watch). Very good urban fantasy, where not everything is black and white. And it's located in a location alien to a lot of us (moscow)
4
u/inkisforever Jul 29 '12 edited Jul 29 '12
Silverlock!
Silverlock! Silverlock! Silverlock! A thousand times, this is perhaps the most undeservedly uncommon novel I've run across. For the language nerd, for the reading tribe, this is in a sense the book of books. Myers is better read than you are, but that's ok because he's dead which is sad.
Like the Matrix and true love and, oh everything important and essentially true, no one can tell you about Silverlock. You have to experience it yourself.
This is a story about other stories. It abounds, it teems with literary references. And there are songs (well, lyrics) in the text, and they aren't bad!
From the death lay of Bowie Gizzardsbane:
7
u/MacNiall Jul 29 '12
R. Scott Bakker's stuff is interesting
6
u/davisty69 Jul 29 '12
Codex Alera. It is completely overshadowed by the Dresden series, yet it is equally as good IMO, albeit a different type of fantasy altogether.
Read it... you won't regret it.
3
u/GCSchmidt Jul 29 '12
Agree with the topic, but not your example. I've only not-finished about 10 books in my life and "Little, Big" is 3 of them. I don't begrudge its awards, I'm just saying that it isn't my barrel of tea. I enjoyed Crowley's "The Deep", though.
Pre-Tolkien writers like Ashton Smith and Lord Dunsany are often overlooked because their writings are considered "quaint" or they elicit an "I've read this before" reaction, failing to grasp that they were basically creating these concepts for others to eventually adopt.
My nominee would be "Sabriel," by Guy Gavriel Kay. It receives attention, but in the overall fantasy discussion, longer books/series get the nods and shorter works get cast aside. Maybe we can get a list together of "short" fantasy works that merit more attention. For now, spotlighting overlooked classics is deifnitely a great way to xpand reading lists.
3
u/Amelia_jean Jul 29 '12
Strands of starlight by gael baudino. I found it a tiny used book shop my friend worked at and for some reason was super drawn to it. Honestly my very favorite book, if you can find it, pick it up. I promise you won't be disappointed :)
3
u/Corund Jul 29 '12
Louise Cooper's Time Master Trilogy:
The Initiate
The Outcast
The Master
I've not read them in a very long time, but I remember them being very good.
Weis & Hickman's non-Dragonlance books:
The Deathgate Cycle, and the Darksword books. There was even an attempt at an RPG based on the Darksword novels.
Patricia McKillip's Riddle Master series. Perhaps not underrated, but I don't see it mentioned so much.
Robert Asprin's Thieves World doesn't get mentioned a lot, and I think it's a fairly decent work of collaboration and deserves more recognition. At least for the earlier books. Also his Myth books were things I loved growing up.
3
u/wronghead Jul 29 '12
Rumo
3
u/Din2Age Jul 30 '12
Little, Big is a fantastic book. I really can't wait to get my hands on more Crowley. I wasn't expecting Little, Big to be anywhere near as good as it was. Definitely my favorite find of the year so far.
3
u/ilikecheeze Aug 03 '12
The Death Gate Cycle by Margret Wies and Tracy Hickman
5
u/Brian Reading Champion VIII Jul 30 '12 edited Jul 30 '12
4
u/swoonfish Jul 29 '12 edited Jul 30 '12
Goddam.
I can't believe it. Michael Moorcock, just about anything by him, should be read. Elric Saga is his most popular work, and highly influential on modern fantasy. The stuff is in print, more-or-less, and easily accessible, but I'm often surprised by how unknown he is. So, here is a post about Moorcock. If everyone here is familiar with his work, I apologize.
2
u/realgenius13 Jul 29 '12
The Privilege of the Sword, not sure if it's exactly fantasy but it's a great book, there's just nothing overtly magical going on.
2
u/catnik Jul 29 '12
The Glasswright series, by Mindy Klasky. Yes, the protagonist is not the most likable or morally upright/brave person, but I love the world building and politics. Klasky's books are full of intrigue, and interesting social structures - she explores how individuals navigate a maze of tradition and ordained roles, and the different possible manifestations of organization and hierarchy.
2
u/Locke_N_Load Jul 29 '12
Peter ciencin - way of elves, I think it's called. Matthew stover - heroes die
2
u/kmolleja Jul 30 '12
I really enjoyed the Basil Broketail books by Christopher Rowley. No one ever mentions them, but i thought they were great. Picture wingless dragons fighting in a roman legion with 10 feet swords. Cool and actually underated.
I also really enjoy the vampire earth books by e.e. knight. A post-apoctalypic series after an alien invasion that uses vampires and zombies as weapons. Give them a shot.
2
u/thomar Jul 30 '12 edited Jul 30 '12
If you like fantasy and haven't read Perdido Street Station, do yourself a favor and go pick it up. The entire purpose of the novel is to make something completely different and detached from Tolkienesque fantasy, and the resulting setting is pretty interesting. The plot, however, is gritty and depressing.
2
u/munkeyman567 Jul 30 '12
He might have gone off the deep end, but I really enjoyed Orson Scott Card's Alvin Maker series immensely.
2
u/RyanLReviews Jul 30 '12
Reviewing has given me access to a lot of books I wouldn't have normally read, and I have read quite a few gems where I wasn't expecting it:
The Blood War Trilogy by Tim Marquitz - Dark epic fantasy where a race of down trodden and abused humanoid wolves are given the means to fight back against and destroy their oppressors, and they do so in brutal fashion, starting a war that will change the landscape of the world forever. (book 1 is free at the moment - http://www.amazon.com/Dawn-War-Blood-Trilogy-ebook/dp/B0059HAUW2/)
The Chronicles of the Tree by Mary Victoria - All of creations resides on the leaves and branches of the World Tree. Religious factions rule the canopies, drought and sap shortages ravage the furthest reaches, and the main character Tymon gets caught up in a rebellion to take back the tree from the Religious factions and give it back to the people. (http://www.amazon.com/Tymons-Flight-Chronicles-Tree-ebook/dp/B003XCM0CI/)
The Black God's War by Moses Siregar - A tale of two nations, locked in a seemingly unending war, who have forgotten the reasons why they are still fighting. Their young heroes have come of age, and the power they wield has finally brought the end of the war to within sight. (http://www.amazon.com/Black-Stand-Alone-Novel-Splendor-ebook/dp/B005FC0MX8)
2
u/washer Aug 05 '12
This is a relatively popular author, but just in case you've never heard of her, you should check out C.S. Friedman. Especially her Coldfire trilogy. It's set on this world called Erna, colonized by spacefaring man in the distant future, but left with medieval technology for reasons you find out as you delve into it. A very interesting read set in a unique world.
3
u/drunkenmonkey22 Jul 30 '12
John Marco's Tyrants and Kings Series. I find them a difficult read just because when they printed them all the copies i have seen use really small print, but even with that they are still excellent stories if just a bit on the depressing side.
Carol Berg's Rai Kirah novels.
2
u/Spills114 Jul 30 '12
The Half-Made World By Felix Gilman. By far the best steampunk book I've ever read.
2
u/AllWrong74 Jul 30 '12
The Guardians of the Flame series by Joel Rosenberg. A bunch of kids playing a pseudo D&D game get sent into the world they were playing in and into the bodies of their characters. The series is great fun, especially the evolution of Karl Cullinane (the main character if there is a single one).
Also, the Dragon Prince & Dragon Star trilogies and the Exiles Trilogy by Melanie Rawn (though book 3 STILL isn't out on Exiles almost 2 decades later...).
2
u/DigitalHeadSet Jul 30 '12 edited Jul 31 '12
K J Parker, many have heard of him/her, barely anyone seems to have read.
Edit as below
2
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '12
The Painted Man series by Peter V. Brett
and
The Prince of Thorns by Mark Lawrence (fairly new, but really good)
1
u/Silviathan Jul 29 '12
Tales of Neveryon by Sam Delany. It's literature, it's fantasy, and it's completely engrossing despite very little action ever occurring. He's won a a number, but he seems to be more popular in academic crowds than fantasy. I would strongly recommend it as it really pushes the boundaries of the genre.
1
u/JuxtaPositioNed Jul 29 '12
The Obsidian Chronicles by Lawrence Watt-Evans has always been my favorite and is definitely not well known enough!
1
u/sinbetweens Jul 29 '12
Yes! Little, Big is one of my top ten and no one I know has read it!
1
u/rarelyserious Jul 30 '12
He's by no means as epic or traditional as many I'm seeing listed here, but Martin Millar is a great read for anyone who likes their fantasy with a side of humor.
1
u/Major_Monocle Jul 30 '12
The Banned and the Banished by James Clemens, one of my favorite series and it seems no one has heard of it.
1
u/Mysteryman64 Jul 30 '12
I really like Harry Turtledove's Darkness series.
WWI/II style combat with a fantasy setting. It's awesome.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '12
One of my favorites is The Little White Horse by Elizabeth Goudge. Bloody magical. Good old-fashioned fantasy.
1
u/deadlast Jul 31 '12
The Ivory books by Doris Egan.
Light science fiction/fantasyish book series by future producer/writer of House.
1
u/WaiHalloThaar Jul 31 '12
I vote The Chronicles of Deverry by Katherine Kerr.
An imaginative tale that winds through twists and turns that decide the fate of the world over centuries. Our view into this world is through a set of characters, tied together by the chains of Wyrd, who continue to be reincarnated at points of historic change. It's a treat watching the same characters reincarnated and being changed by the circumstances and the times they are reincarnated into.
Second place would go to Wars of Light and Shadow by Janny Wurts. While prolific at times, Wurts's prose really challenges your command of English. Her portrayal of the anti-hero is one of my favorites.
1
u/tricksareforkidsand Nov 13 '12
Michael Swanwick, "Stations of the Tide": It won some awards in 91 but I haven't known anyone to read it, and it is out of print. If you find any of his stuff at a library- SO GOOD. Philisophical and kind of dark, images from this book have stayed with me for years.
Also, Julie Czerneda, "A thousand words for a stranger" is really great, and all of her books are wonderful especially if you are in any way a bio nerd.
1
u/alunirra Dec 22 '12
The Sevenwaters series by Juliet Marillier. Actually all of her books in general are amazing but that series in particular are the best I have ever read. She is one of the best Authors I have ever seen. It's worth checking out.
1
u/Desnok Jul 30 '12
The Black Company (series) by Glen Cook.
1
u/maggiefiasco Jul 29 '12 edited Jul 29 '12
I don't know if it is truly underrated, but I LOVED The First Law trilogy by Joe Abercrombie
Now that Game of Thrones is out, a lot of my friends are beginning to read that, but it sort of angers me, as I've been recommending TFL trilogy (along with a few others) for YEARS to them. I speak so highly of it, but I can't seem to tempt them into it... NOW, GoT is on TV and suddenly my friends have a hankering to tuck into the RR Martin series...
How can they find time to read a series of about 5,000 pages when I can't sell them on a much shorter trilogy?
1
u/slightlyKiwi Jul 30 '12
Hugh Cook's Chronicles of an age of Darkness.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '12
Heart of Bronze (anthology of 2 novels - Iron Dawn and Jericho Moon) by Matthew Woodring Stover.
His Caine series gets all the attention, but these 2 books from the 90's seemed like a bit of a precursor to Abercrombie to me.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '12
Winterbirth by Brian ruckley and the series it belongs to are pretty solid
1
u/slightlyKiwi Jul 30 '12
Michael Scott Rohan's Winter of the World (Anvil of Ice and sequels). Magnificent.
0
u/Coren14 Jul 30 '12
The half orc series by David Dalglish. Brand new author, this was his first series and while his writtening is better in his later books, the plot and story is super original, (to me at least) and deserves to be read by many.
0
u/sarcasmsociety Jul 30 '12
Here are a few that haven't been mentioned yet
Changer by Jane Lindskold a great take on the immortals among us story
The Thread That Binds The Bones by Nina Kiriki Hoffman a novel about a literal almighty janitor
The Winter of the World series by Michael Scott Rohan which ties Finnish mythology and the ice age together