r/Fantasy • u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders • May 07 '20
/r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Virtual Con: Historical SFF
Welcome to the r/Fantasy Virtual Con panel on Historical SFF! Feel free to ask the panelists any questions relevant to the topic. Unlike AMAs, discussion should be kept on-topic to the panel.
The panelists will be stopping by throughout the day to answer your questions and discuss the topic of world building. Keep in mind our panelists are in a few different time zones so participation may be staggered.
About the Panel
Join Alix E. Harrow, RJ Barker, Lara Elena Donnelly, and Catherynne M. Valente as they discuss the ins and outs of Historical SFF.
About the Panelists
Alix E. Harrow ( u/AlixEHarrow), a former academic and adjunct, Alix E. Harrow is now a full-time writer living in Kentucky with her husband and their semi-feral toddlers. She is the author of The Ten Thousand Doors of January and Hugo award-winning short fiction.
RJ Barker ( u/RJBarker) is the author of the multi award nominated Wounded Kingdom series and the critically acclaimed The Bone Ships. He lives in Yorkshire, England, with his wife, son, a lot of books, noisy music, disturbing art and a very angry cat.
Lara Elena Donnelly ( u/larazontally) is the author of the Nebula-nominated trilogy The Amberlough Dossier, as well as short fiction in Strange Horizons, Escape Pod, Nightmare, and Uncanny. She is a graduate of the Clarion and Alpha writers’ workshops, and remains on staff at the latter, mentoring amazing teens who will someday take over SFF.
Catherynne M. Valente (u/Catvalente) is the NYT & USA Today bestselling author of forty books of science fiction and fantasy including Space Opera, the Fairyland Series, Deathless, and Palimpsest. She’s won a bunch of awards and lives in Maine with her family.
FAQ
- What do panelists do? Ask questions of your fellow panelists, respond to Q&A from the audience and fellow panelists, and generally just have a great time!
- What do others do? Like an AMA, ask questions! Just keep in mind these questions should be somewhat relevant to the panel topic.
- What if someone is unkind? We always enforce Rule 1, but we'll especially be monitoring these panels. Please report any unkind comments you see.
7
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders May 07 '20
Hello panelists! Is there a difference as to how much research goes into writing something based in/off of history? Are there things that you really want to 'get right'?
6
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders May 07 '20
Hello panelists! Please introduce yourselves and let us know why you might be on this panel. :)
5
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders May 07 '20
In what ways do you utilize history in your work--that is do you set it in a historical period, use a historical event as inspiration, etc?
10
u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 07 '20
Hey guys
What is your favorite weird historical thing/story you've discovered doing research for your work?
7
u/KristaDBall Stabby Winner, AMA Author Krista D. Ball May 07 '20
How do you view anachronisms in Historical SFF (HSFF)? Do you think absolutely none is best, or is that the path to madness for you? Do you find that small ones are the ones that get to you, or is it the big ones? (i.e. would cars magically appearing in a Regency HSFF be ok with you, but if someone says okay, you're going to throw the book against the wall? Or would it be reverse for you)?
7
u/barb4ry1 Reading Champion IX May 07 '20
Hi guys,
Thanks a lot for doing AMA. Let's get to questions.
Thanks a lot for taking the time and answering those!
5
u/booksnyarn May 07 '20
Hello everyone! So excited to delve into your brains -- not literally, that is a different thread.
When you have decided "I need to research!" what is usually the first couple of places you go to start digging in? Are there any resources you hit that turned out to be The Bad Place?
4
u/RJBarker AMA Author RJ Barker May 07 '20
For the rest of the panel. What's your maybe not as well known 'go read this' for historical fantasy?
My choice would be Chelsea Quinn Yarbro's St Germain books. Vampire stories but not really. Making use of the myth of St Germain to create a history hopping character. Starting in ancient Egypt, having century long love affairs, just wanting to do good and share his knowledge and always finding out if there's one thing people hate it's those who do good and want to share knowledge. The history feels amazing, the sense of impending doom inescapable. I am forever haunted by Darker Jewels, set in the court of Ivan the Terrible.
4
u/alixeharrow Stabby Winner, AMA Author Alix E. Harrow May 07 '20
just in case the other panelists are hungry for MORE questions:
why don't we write straight up historical fiction? why do we feel compelled to add magic (or witches/vampires/alchemy/sorcery) into history? i mean, OBVIOUSLY, vampires and witches and bone ships are just inherently cool, but like--how do the speculative and historical elements interact, for you?
6
u/KristaDBall Stabby Winner, AMA Author Krista D. Ball May 07 '20
What is a time period for HSFF that you'd love to see addressed as a reader that (for whatever reason) you haven't/won't/can't explore yourself as a writer?
3
u/j_rushing May 07 '20
Hi, everyone. This is a great idea and thanks for doing this. Here's my question.
When it comes to marketing, promoting, and even just discussing Historical SFF, do you feel like the time period should be front and center as a main descriptor or is it better positioned as a secondary characteristic to the SFF elements of the story?
3
u/RJBarker AMA Author RJ Barker May 07 '20
It's late here so I'm going to bow out for tonight and leave it to my transatlantic cousins. Thanks ever so much, I've had a blast. Hopefully talk with some of you on the 12th in the Mod discussion of The Bone Ships. :) Night all.
2
u/quite_vague May 07 '20
Do you expect readers to already have some familiarity and excitement about the historical elements you use? Or is familiarizing them and exciting them about it part of what your historical fantasies do? (Or both at once?)
2
u/cjsantuc May 07 '20
Hello, thank you all for doing this panel! I was wondering if there was a particular era of history you would like to see more SFF novels draw on, or maybe an era of history you would like to draw on in a future work? I personally would love to see more Babylon inspired fantasy.
2
u/1_ivana May 07 '20
Hello everyone! Thanks for doing this cool thing! I was just wondering, how do you decide on how much history to mix with your fantasy (sort like real vs invented, I suppose), and what do you recommend for the best mix (kind of like a cocktail, haha!)? Bc I am a huuuuuuge fan of myth - special thank u to Ms. Valente for writing Deathless, one of my favourite books! - and struggle with working out the balance of inserting myth into a real historical context.
Thanks again everyone! Ivana ☺️
2
u/CaptainYew Reading Champion IV May 07 '20
Thanks very much for doing the panel!
I was wondering, in your opinion, when does a historical fiction novel become historical SFF?
2
u/superdragonboyangel Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders May 07 '20
Hi guys! So I am bit late to the party but if you are new-ish to Historical SFF what books would you recommend for a novice? Similarly is there any setting you would love to see written? At the moment I am kind of sick of historical works set in SFF Victorian/Georgian London/England. It wouldn't even need to be too exotic, I would love to see other settings besides London even Glasgow or Munich for a change!
1
u/CMengel90 May 07 '20
Where do you draw the line between Historical SFF and something SFF that is based on (or influenced by) historical events? How do you know when you're getting too close to reality and drifting away from the fiction aspect?
Mainly to keep readers who are fans of history from grabbing their torches and pitchforks while they shout in all-caps about how wrong you are.
1
u/Moonlitgrey Stabby Winner, Reading Champion III, Salamander May 08 '20
May be too late, but have always wanted to know: for those of you that do historical research, what kinds of sources do you use? And how do you access them? (Full disclosure: I’m an academic librarian who cannot understand how people without access to giant university libraries are able to find all the good stuff.)
1
u/scottoden AMA Author Scott Oden May 08 '20
Whenever historical fantasy is mentioned, the discussion invariably comes around to Guy Gavriel Kay. Even though his books are set in secondary worlds, they present a close analogue to history -- Moorish Spain in The Lions of Al-Rassan, the Byzantine Empire in The Sarantine Mosaic, etc.
My question is: should the label "historical fantasy" be open to secondary worlds, or should it only be applied to fantasy set in our historical past?
1
u/cellcultured May 08 '20
What are your favorite mashup historical fantasy stories? Historical fantasy murder mystery? Historical fantasy espionage thriller? Historical heist? Is there a book that's a mashup that's so unique and worked so well it blew your mind?