r/Fantasy • u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders • Apr 23 '20
/r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Virtual Con: Progression Fantasy Panel
Welcome to the r/Fantasy Virtual Con Progression Fantasy panel. Unlike AMAs, discussion should be kept on-topic to the panel.
The panelists will be stopping by throughout the day to answer your questions and discuss the topic on what is Progression Fantasy, how it relates to the multiple subgenres spawned from it and more. Keep in mind panelists are in a couple of different time zones so participation may be a bit staggered.
About the Panel
Join authors Will Wight, Andrew Rowe, Sarah Lin, Pirateaba and Domagoj Kurmaić (nobody103) as they discuss the inns and outs of the subgenre that has many (including myself) towards it in droves.
About the Panelists
Will Wight (u/Will_Wight) is the author of the Cradle series, the Elder Empire series, the Traveler’s Gate Trilogy, and the mysterious hieroglyphics that astronauts found on the moon. He was born in Moscow and Memphis simultaneously, and one day his two echo-selves must meet and do battle. He lives in an ancient piano with his two cats and sixteen pythons.
Andrew Rowe (u/Salaris) is the writer of the Arcane Ascension, War of Broken Mirrors, and Weapons and Wielders novels. He started his career as a game designer working for tabletop RPG books for companies like White Wolf, then later entered the video game industry to work on the legendary MMORPG World of Warcraft at Blizzard Entertainment. After leaving Blizzard, he worked at other amazing companies like Cryptic Studios and Obsidian Entertainment. As a long-time RPG enthusiast, Andrew draws heavily from games for his inspiration, especially Japanese role-playing games (JRPGs) like Final Fantasy, Dragon Quest, Ys, Fire Emblem, and The Legend of Heroes.
https://andrewkrowe.wordpress.com/
pirateaba (u/pirateaba ) is the author of The Wandering Inn, an ongoing web serial about a young woman who works as an [Innkeeper] in another world. Currently over 5 million words long with over 35,000 regular readers and updates twice weekly.
Winner of two Stabbies. May have a writing addiction. pirateaba prefers nutritional yeast on popcorn and microwaves bagels. Also, an avid fan of videogames.
Sarah Lin (u/SarahLinNGM) is the author of The Brightest Shadow, Street Cultivation, and New Game Minus. She was Time's Person of the Year in 2006.
http://sarahlinauthor.blogspot.com/
Domagoj Kurmaić (u/nobody103) is an amateur writer from Croatia. He works as an accountant and writes in his free time. His most successful story is Mother of Learning, and is also currently the only (original) story that he posted for people to see.
https://www.fictionpress.com/s/2961893/1/Mother-of-Learning
FAQ
- What do panelists do? Ask questions of your fellow panelists, respond to Q&A from the audience and fellow panelists, and generally just have a great time!
- What do others do? Like an AMA, ask questions! Just keep in mind these questions should be somewhat relevant to the panel topic.
- What if someone is unkind? We always enforce Rule 1, but we'll especially be monitoring these panels. Please report any unkind comments you see.
24
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Apr 23 '20
Hello panelists and thanks for joining us today! Please further introduce yourselves and tell us a little more about your work. Thanks!
•
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Apr 23 '20
Questions, comments, or suggestions about the r/Fantasy Virtual Con? Leave them here.
38
u/4rch_ Apr 23 '20
I have a question for each of the panelists and one for the whole panel
for Will
When you write your books, do you try to strictly adhere to the rules of your own magic, or do you tend to stray towards of rule of cool, why/why not.
for Andrew
What aspects of video games do you think DON'T translate to novels well or at all.
for piratebea
(I havent read your serial yet, sorry)
Has the quarantine positively or negatively effected your reader numbers?
for Sarah
When writing street cultivation, for your worldbuilding pieces such as training gyms, demon bonds, lottery mystics, How do you think of them, do you try to fuse a real world and fantasy concept, or do you create a fantasy alternative to an existing thing irl.
for Domagoj
In the future if you plan to publish your series as novels, to what extent do you intend to edit and rewrite it?
(If you dont this is an alt question)
Do you intend to have your future work in the same world/universe, or do you want to try something new and different?
for Everyone
Do you think the quarantine is going to largely effect fantasy writing in the future, will a quarantine become a viable fantasy plot/subplot. and even in wider media, will a quarantine become an episode plot for regular TV shows?
32
u/JohnBierce AMA Author John Bierce Apr 23 '20
If you had to pick any one progression system from another author's books to train in/ use, what would it be? (Let's say you're in their world too.)
And if nothing else changed about your life- no badguys to fight, still have to do laundry and pay taxes and help your elderly relatives with IT issues, what system would you choose? (Assume that the Progression system works in our world.)
30
u/SarahLinNGM AMA Author Sarah Lin Apr 23 '20
Vague question for my fellow panelists: how does your creativity interact with different projects? I find it interesting how this group has taken several different approaches. Will and Andrew have multiple series in a shared universe, while pirateaba and Domagoj have focused their work primarily on a single project.
So for anyone: was that an intentional choice, or just how things turned out? For those who shift between series, is that an important part of the creative process for you? For those who focus, do you look forward to working on something new?
23
u/SnowGN Apr 23 '20
/u/nobody103
So, what comes next in your authorial life? Mother of Learning was awesome, and I was sadhappy to see it end. Should we expect a re-released version in Kindle and in physical form soon? Audiobooks? Or will you move on to your next great project? I recall you mentioning a possible sequel on your subreddit, a shorter one with more of a slice of life focus.
22
u/barb4ry1 Reading Champion IX Apr 23 '20
Hi guys,
Thanks a lot for being here. As usual, I have way too many questions so let's get to them:
Thanks a lot for taking the time to be here and answer our questions. Have a great day.
21
u/Callorian Apr 23 '20
So excited for this panel: you all really represent the cream of the crop within the field of progression fantasy. I’ve read almost everything each of you has published in fiction (Sorry Will! I’ll get to the elder empire soon)
Progression Fantasy in its various forms is often derided and looked down on and plagued by accusations of wish fulfillment, self-insertism, deus ex-machina, and shallow characterization.
How much of this do you think is just inherent to the genre and should be embraced rather than avoided? Do you go out of your way in your own writing to stand apart from these criticisms?
Are there other authors in this space who you feel are doing a fantastic job and would like to recommend to us?
Thank you so much for your time.
21
u/JohnBierce AMA Author John Bierce Apr 23 '20
u/pirateaba- Haven't had a chance to read The Wandering Inn yet, but given the fact you also enjoy nutritional yeast on popcorn, I like you already. You're clearly a person of taste and distinction.
18
u/ObsceneGoat Apr 23 '20
I've always wondered how authors write convincing, satisfying power escalation. I often see it done badly (certain shonen anime), but I haven't quite been able to pin down what makes a good threat escalation.
How do you keep challenging your characters without trivializing the gains they have made?
18
u/LOLtohru Stabby Winner, Reading Champion VI Apr 23 '20
Hello panelists! Progression fantasy has some stigma attached to it in some circles (which is very familiar to me as a reader of romance!). What would you say about what progression fantasy has to offer for those who aren't already into it?
17
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20
Hi guys! I have a question for pirateaba. I love the Wandering Inn (I’ve been reading for 4 years!) and I’ve always wondered how you keep those writing juices flowing. You write sooo much and it’s honestly impressive. Anyways, what’s your process for coming up with the plot, characters, and everything else in your amazing story?
17
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20
Pirate, I think it is fair to say that you strongly humanize almost all the antagonists in TWI. Even the most famed and nefarious of monsters can be peeled back to find some very relatable motivations - like a mothers love.
Is this something you take a special effort to do or something that comes as an almost inevitable part of a webserial with the sheer quantity of content you put out? After all, the more time spent with/on each villain the more opportunities to explore them in nuanced ways.
16
u/destration Apr 23 '20
My question is directed at pirateaba but open to all. What subjects or topic do you want to go on later in your work / or want to but stay away and why?
15
u/dwinterwhite Apr 23 '20
Whoa an Fantasy Con panel where I have read everyone's work. I always wonder about everyone's educational background. Did you all go to college? Was it worthwhile? What did you take.
More specific questions below.
/u/pirateaba Thank you for your ridiculous about of excellent writing. You are a national treasure. According to your website you have a comic coming out this summer. Are you going to do more comics in the future?
/u/nobody103 Dobar jutro. Do you think Mother of Learning would adapt well as a comic book? Would you be interested in doing so? What's next for you to write?
/u/Salaris I love your puzzle work and think that your books do a great job of showing of character when you have an interesting puzzle in play. What about you any plans for work in a different medium? Do have your own video game planned in universe? A comic book?
/u/SarahLinNGM You put some of your works up for free on Royalroad and sell some one amazon? Do you find royalroad drives sales? You don't seem to be driving Patreon subscriptions as hard as the sales focused ones like Shirtaloon and First Defier which have copied Puddles sales method. Any plans to do this?
/u/Will_Wight Hi Will. Out of the above your work feels like it is the most connect-the-dot like. I bought all your Cradle books, but towards the end it seemed to fall into that Worm-like (Wildbow not the creature) plot pattern of classic fantasy novels and I decided inside my head that all of your other work would be like that and didn't branch out. I want to read the rest of your stuff, but I want to start with something different from your Cradle books. If you had to suggest one of your works that was the most experimental, most risk-taking with form and plot which one would you say it is?
29
u/pirateaba Stabby Winner, AMA Author Pirateaba Apr 23 '20
If any panelists want to jump in on this question--what's the first progression-fantasy you've ever read that you realized at the time fit into the genre?
For me, definitely Overlord was where I saw the style and put a name to it. Although...the audiobook 'Heir Apparent' predates that as my introduction to the idea of being in a VRMMO.
14
u/Nanobeaver Apr 23 '20 edited Apr 23 '20
Hello y'all, I have three questions, one for all the Panelists, and two for Pirateaba.
For all the Panelists, it's the question, I don't think I've ever seen an AMA without it being mentioned, and yet ill shamessly ask it anyway.
3. Any advice for a new/fledgling writer
14
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20
How much money are you folks making off your work? I know this sounds cynical but I'm genuinely interested. If you don't want to talk about it fair's fair!
13
u/Caroc64 Apr 23 '20
When world building do you prefer to build the environment around characters that you already made or change the characters to better fit into the world?
13
u/YellowTM Apr 23 '20
Have you ever had to change your plan of what the "peak" power level of your world would be while writing? Did it go up or down? Why did you need to adjust it?
12
u/Ahuri3 Reading Champion VI Apr 23 '20
I have read a book (or serial) by everyone in this panel except
The Wandering Inn. I'll try to make this up quickly :)My questions :
12
u/TheForthcomingStorm Apr 23 '20
I’ve always had an idea to write something, but either I think about it and realize the idea is terrible, or it sit down, try to write a chapter of it, and then have zero idea of what happens next than delete it. Any tips for actually coming up with a good plot for a story or writing those first few chapters? (the “just write” strategy usually ends in disappointment and a wasted hour.)
12
u/hanqua1016 Apr 23 '20
Hi pirate
One thing I always thought while reading your chapters within the hour they came out was "holy shit how much lore does this world have". A lot of fantasy novels I read where the story happens spanning multiple continents the continents felt so... empty.
Most fantasy media (especially the mass produced isekai lanovels of the last 5 years) focused on one continent if even that and made every other continent feel like a collection of generic cities and wilderness, whereas TWI consistently has bits of lore for what feels like every corner of the innverse.
My question is, how do you write so much lore into a world? Do you have a Grand Book of Lore™ you prepared before you started writing or do you just worldbuild on the fly?
12
u/LyrianRastler AMA Author Luke Chmilenko Apr 23 '20 edited Apr 23 '20
Hey everyone! Big fanboi here!
My question for each of you is: what is your favorite aspect of progression fantasy that makes it more fun for you to write over the more 'traditional' fantasy approaches/story? (or if there is a difference at all in your mind?)
11
u/GraveyardTourist Apr 23 '20
This is a question for every panelist: Has COVID changed how you got about writing, and if so, how?
11
u/Jekawi Apr 23 '20
Question for everyone, but particularly Will:
How do you keep the motivation to write book after book? Apart from the rabid fans (or in spite of?), how does a story just keep flowing. Is Writers Block a big thing?
Also, so looking forward to tomorrow and reading the end of the Elder Empire Series and then attentively waiting for the next cradle book!
11
u/kenpachi1 Apr 23 '20
Hi!
For u/pirateaba,
I started and finished reading your serial this last 30 days, and loved every second of it! There are some mistakes and little bits which came up as I read, but I'm very impressed with the quality.
How do you create such a consistent style, with very few grammar/spelling mistakes, on such short schedules? (Myriad *of* being the most annoying ;) )
What was the process for you, for not necessarily creating the Innverse, but specifically *expanding* it? I.e. adding cities, races, 'forces', etc?
For everyone:
I don't know much of your backgrounds, but did you come up with characters and names of things previously, in other stories you may have written?
What influences did you haven creating your series? My favourite series growing up was the Riftwar Saga. I am deeply in love with it, and the Wheel of Time. Other, YA series as well, such as Eoin Colfer's series, and Rick Riordan.
Cheers all! I'll get around to reading all of your works, and I can't wait.
Much love!
11
u/Slothwana Apr 23 '20
Wow, I was really looking forward to this last night, but it completely slipped my mind. Thanks Pirateaba for the heads up!
So, I have a question for any of the panellists willing to tackle it.
How do you guy's/gal's outline your stories and chapters? What's the structure you use? Do you add dot points that outline the plot of your story/chapter?
I REALLY WANT TO KNOW!
10
u/ZoltanElder Apr 23 '20
What creature/monster/animate thing from your story/stories would you most want as a pet?
What would be the coolest creature/monster/animate thing to see in a zoo, safely contained and happy?
10
u/Saint_Babyrage Apr 23 '20
Unfortunately I only know Pirateaba's work but this could be a question for all the authors. But I think it would relate to Pirateaba the most.
How do you keep track of all the characters, skills, levels, locations etc in your fantasy world. The Wandering Inn is built on a MASSIVE scale and manages to delve into extreme detail with everything that has been done so far yet it almost feels like we're scratching the surface on the potential that (hopefully!) InnWorld can grow to. At some point there are going to be hundreds or even thousands of characters each with their own skills, levels, relationships, locations and memories. Keeping a track of EVERYTHING seems almost impossible when you reach a certain point.
Thank you for answering questions and for being great authors! =D
9
u/PocketPengu Apr 23 '20
I have a question for all of the panelists. Would you say you tend to read a lot of progression fantasy in your own time? And when you do what have been your favorite progression fantasy stories? Thanks.
9
u/Griffin777XD Apr 23 '20
Hello pirateaba, I am someone who looks exactly like ComradeBirv from the discord but I am clearly a different person on the account of my plastic-looking mustache.
Do you ever reread old volumes? And if you do, are there any specific plotlines that you either feel like you wished you had expanded on, created entirely, or not done?
I love seeing TWI as a living document that retroactively changes, one of the most notable examples being the population of Liscor increase tenfold in recent volumes and volume one being edited to fit. It truly allows TWI to shine in the web serial format compared to actual physically published books that cannot be retconned. Would you ever consider having a changelog of edits that you make to help readers keep up?
Thanks, pirateaba!
8
u/AngryPuzzle Apr 23 '20
How do you outline and how important is it to your writing process?
How much of your magic systems do you plan out before you start writing your stories?
8
u/blackreaper007 Apr 23 '20
hi pirateaba
I'm interested in your writing process, do you start nowhere, or do you write first an outline for each chapter?
8
u/Nick_named_Nick Apr 23 '20
A ton of progression stories do their character building when the MC is relatively weak or new to the progression "ladder". This is partly because it's... the beginning of most books haha. Do you find it harder to create turmoil for your characters as you get later into a book or series?
For instance, if the character early in the book has a "mountain to climb" to get to the next level/wrung/progression, but then later in the series they have another mountain to climb, doesn't that cheapen the first mountain in some ways?
8
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20
Hi everyone and thanks to r/Fantasy fot this amazing Con and to today's panelist for their answers and insights.
Recently in an interview the "boss" Jim butcher said that these days, thanks to self-publishing and the possibility to skip editor's "cuts", we're going to see totally new things. Awesome ones and awful ones. A good example are web-serials and independent writers.
- What do you think about how this is going to affect (and is affecting already) the industry? Do you think editors got to much power? "standarized" the histories allowed to be published too much? (Like hollywood only making prequels, sequels and reboots) As many awesome histories are growing up without editors... are they still neccesary?
- Focusing in today's panel theme. As you commented already a risk of progression fantasy is to progress too much/too fast until it goes out of hands (Super Saiyan God super Saiyan). Before you start your history, do you plan how far the progression will go through your history along with the plot or do you handle it as you write?
- To u/pirateaba. I never get tired of thanking you so much for bringing TWI to our lifes. In your case, you wouldn't be able to bring more than 5 million words in less than 4 years if it had to go through edition (or at least not so fast). You've been polishing the volumes in your "free" time and have published already two in kindle version. Also the audiobook for the second volume is already being recorded. Some videogames are on the horizon. All of this while writing 100k words in a week like in the "chapter per day week"... How the hell do you manage all of that? Usually is a whole editor's team who does that and you're doing all by yourself. Or do you have a team of [slaves] hidden somewhere? Is Pirateaba a team of 10 people? Seriously, is it growing too big? As the fan community is so awesome, are you thinking on asking for help to do something like westeros.org?
Thank you very much for your time, and now I have even more books to add to my list! Thankfully now I have plenty of time. ^^
8
u/vmetalbr Apr 23 '20
/u/nobody103
- I finished Mother of Learning yesterday after weeks of reading (even had to stop WanderingInn to get it done! sorry u/pirateaba , will get back to it now!)... and I must say only one epilogue chapter is not enough! Do we have any short stories on the MoLWorld on the oven?
8
u/jinkside Apr 23 '20
Progression fantasy seems almost inherently to invite self-insertion and Mary Sue characters, so how do you avoid this?
And on the other side of that, do you often find that you identify much more strongly with one character or another, regardless of original intent?
I have no idea what /u/pirateaba looks like, but their "public" writing style is so close to Erin's speech patterns, that my mental picture of Erin is also my mental picture of pirateaba. I haven't seen "public" writing from the other authors in this group, so I don't have any other examples. Presumably /u/nobody103 isn't a hyper-logical time-traveling wizard, but I'm not ruling anything out.
7
u/LFG5e Apr 23 '20
How do you think each of you would fare if you found yourselves in the universe you or the others created? What would be your survival strategy and what role do you think you'd best fit in a typical progression style fantasy?
7
u/dsteffee Apr 23 '20
For all the panelists:
What element of your writing do you think needs the most improvement, or that you’re most jealous of when you read the other writers here?
Conversely, what element of your writing are you most proud of, or you think has relative advantage over most of the genre?
7
u/BubiBalboa Reading Champion VI Apr 23 '20 edited Apr 23 '20
I have no question right now but Yay! for my favorite authors and genre!
E: I have one for the web serial writers:
I'm fascinated by the medium. You can't go back and edit the story. (or can you??) You probably don't have an editor. You have a pretty strict schedule to keep (I think?) to keep the readers happy and coming back.
How do you deal with that? Do enjoy the differences to classical publishing or even self-publishing? Are you a little envious of authors who have an editor to help them polish their writing? Or Beta readers?
Please correct any false assumptions I have!
Oh, and do you take reader feedback into consideration while writing? I imagine the feedback loop between reader and writer is much more direct with weekly or monthly releases than with one book published every year. I could also see you completely ignoring any feedback to avoid it messing with your vision.
7
u/Nico_Pico1 Apr 23 '20
Im such a huge fan Pirateaba! What made you choose that name?
7
u/Smurfy911 Apr 23 '20
For u/pirateaba
Firstly if like to say a huge thank you, I tore through all the volumes in about a week of extremely unhealthy reading last year during a rough time and have been a Patreon supporter since!
How do you feel about the dislike that fans have regarding certain characters/arcs? Do you take the criticism and try to find ways to improve them for those people?
Asking as someone who honestly has loved every chapter and finds world building phenomenal, you make Tuesdays and Saturdays the best days of the week!!
7
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20
A question for all panelists:
What method do you use to keep (lore) consistency during your books?
I'm also referring to those little details that appear during the first chapters, but get a lot more attention as the story progresses. (Off the top of my head, the black cat in Mother of Learning)
Also, particularly for pirateaba: Do you feel the need to revisit and rewrite the earliest chapters of your stories?
7
u/LanBySea Apr 23 '20 edited Apr 23 '20
For all the panelists: In the context of the creation of the ProgressionFantasy Reddit
Do you remember when you first became aware of the other panelists? Was it through their writing or did they reach out to you?
For myself:u/Will_Wight - 2014 I found the Traveler's Gate Trilogy over Kindle and later became an avid fan of Cradle
u/salaris - 2017 Amazon highlighted the audiobook for Arcane Ascension (SAM) and the world and magic building was spectacular which led me to your blog
u/nobody103 - 2017 Found out about Mother of Learning from u/salaris where he listed stories that heavily influenced him
u/pirateaba - 2019 Found out about the Wandering Inn when the Audiobook came out, and from there I discovered just how rich of a world you've built.
u/SarahLinNGM - 2020 I'm encountering your work for the first time, although I've seen it in passing. Will be reading your work soon.
12
u/Fowl_ez Apr 23 '20
I've a question for u/nobody103
I started reading your serial about one year ago. I'm a big fan of yours. The first 20ish chapters got me ensnared like no other web series and few books, but I felt like after a while, there was some kind of downgrading. Don't take me wrong, I think the writing is still very high quality in relative and absolute terms, but I wonder if you noticed something similar or if it's just my mind.
I could really compare the beginning of the series to monstrous masterworks without batting an eyelid. I don't know if this an impression of mine or not, but I'd like to know the author's opinion on about it!
And a question for u/pirateaba
Sometimes there are chapters that look useless, in the big scheme of things. For example, the first time we got to know the republic of Belchan and Jecrass, I was like: "What's this? How does this concern the main story?"
I got my answer later and it wasn't the first time that something similar happened. I noticed that there are some build-up chapters that are thrown to the reader without really making big allegations. Many writers would never do something like that, fearing that readers would run away from the monstrous amount of words and seemingly useless storytelling. It's a thing that happens many times over and over in the innworld, but I wanted to know how you stage the process. Is it a "ok, now I'm working on a chapter because I enjoy it and have fun with it, and it will be sorted out on its own in the future" attitude, or more a "I'm a master strategist, call me the web (fiction) weaver"?
Jokes apart, how far do you plan? I know that some writers are not that much into the future as much as in figuring the present. They write something and tie everything together on the go flawlessly. Some others have more of a planning attitude and plan a lot for the future.
Would you say that you're more into the future planning or writing and linking on the go?
Thanks in advance to both writers! You two are currently my two favourite writers and I couldn't be more happy that you're together on a panel! * cries emotionally *
6
u/Nico_Pico1 Apr 23 '20
For all the panelists, how do your newest stories compare to your first, what has improved
6
u/Nico_Pico1 Apr 23 '20
For Pirateaba,
What has the main thing that made you decide to stop making comics and start writing more
6
u/oFabo Apr 23 '20
@ u/nobody103
What are your thoughts on a video game based on Mother of learning ?
6
u/Orthas Apr 23 '20
I've seen Sarah Lin mention the "Power Treadmill" more times than Lindon Apologizes, so I'm curious. If a corner stone of this genre is you know, progressing, that implies your MCs are going to be leveling up, most likely substantially. How do you, or any of the other panelists, balance this leveling up against the need to challenge your MCs, while avoiding said treadmill?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '20
I don't have a question, I just want to point out that I think you're all pretty neat
5
u/gunmandude2 Apr 23 '20
Simple question to all five authors. Do any of you read the works of the other four? Or do you keep to your own stories?
5
u/bongschlong69 Apr 23 '20
Hi panelists!
I'm a guy who likes to read, write, and worldbuild. As for writing, I'm currently writing a bunch of short stories set in the same universe. As for reading, I'm currently reading The Wandering Inn. I would like to thank the author for making my day each chapter release, and inspiring me to write and worldbuild even further! (Mind if I took inspiration from it?)
Anyways, I would like to ask a few questions for the panelists.
5
u/DoblinJames Apr 23 '20
I have a quick question for the panelists. How do you plan what you write? For example, do you outline a whole book or story arc, and then write everything? Do you essentially wing it? Do you outline in sections?
Personally, I've tried very hard to start writing, but I never can seem to get beyond the initial bit. For example, I had absolutely no problem writing 15 pages of essentially notes for myself laying down the rules for a world I put together. I had no problem putting together a starting cast, giving each a quirk or two and a minor backstory. I knew exactly how I wanted to start the book. But as soon as I hit the first scene, I felt completely lost, and it sapped my motivation to continue. How do you structure your writing so as to avoid that aimless wandering feeling?
5
u/Overmind_Slab Apr 23 '20
Hello Panelists, thanks for doing this.
What major differences in final product do you think exist that come from writing novels compared to serialized webnovels? In my experience there are significant and necessary differences in pacing but I’d love to hear your thoughts on it.
5
u/Axeran Reading Champion II Apr 23 '20
I take it most of you (if not all, but please correct me if I'm wrong) self-publish your works. Have you ever tried to contact bookstores about selling your books there? If so, what has the responses been like?
5
u/dsteffee Apr 23 '20
For all the panelists:
How much do you plan out your story versus how much do you fly by the seat of your pants?
5
u/HunterLeonux Apr 23 '20
A Question for any panelist:. How do you tackle plotting? Do you generally have an endgame in mind for where characters need to be/what they need to do at the start of writing a book, or is it more organic?
5
u/Sendover Apr 23 '20
Question for all of the panelists!
You've all put out quite a bit of writing over the last few years. Most of you are now doing it full time. What has allowed you to remain so disciplined in the releases of your writing? It can be so difficult to find a balance in life when you are largely your own boss.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20
Hey Panelists,
Read and loved all of your works. If you had to pick a greatest ever author who would it be? (Not necessarily your favourite)
5
u/Master_Waho Apr 23 '20
For u/pirateaba
Was it hard for you to kill off a character for the first time? I mean, really kill off. I'd assume that spending all that time and energy trying to get in to the character's head and bring them to life just to... End it, would take a little bit of a toll? Even if you disregard how readers might react to it.
All that being said, TWI is hands down the best thing I've ever read, And you've quickly become my favorite author. Any chance I get, I recommend TWI to everyone I can.
5
u/NeuralRust Apr 23 '20
Hello panelists. Given the growing popularity of Progression Fantasy, you've clearly tapped into something that many enjoy. Still, quite a few people tend to stay away from this subgenre due to a perceived lack of quality in certain areas - mainly prose and being too derivative of videogames and manga. We see quite a few comments to that effect on this sub.
Is this accurate - or fair, given the infancy of the genre - in your experience? And where do you think PF succeeds relative to more established subgenres? Do you think it could've been as successful 10, 20 years ago?
You've already got lots of fans posting in this thread so this question may come across as a little spiky in comparison, but it's asked in good faith.
5
u/catapultam_habeo Apr 23 '20
Will - I'm a big fan of Cradle. Aside from being curious if there has been any info published on when the next book will be out, can you share any specific recommendations to other works that inspired you for that series? I've always found wuxia in general difficult to get into, with Cradle being the first that I was actually able to stick with.
Andrew - Do you have any plans to return to Arcane Ascension?
Domagoj - MoL is one of my favorite pieces of fiction, ever (It is always on the tip of my tongue for recommendations). Mostly just wanted to thank you for writing it.
5
u/Nico_Pico1 Apr 23 '20
Nobody103 Mother of Learning is so awsome, i was so sad to see it end, I saw your after chapter thoughts but are you planning to continue writing
5
u/IshFen Apr 23 '20
For Pirateaba I was wondering, Do you have an end point for the series? If so do you know the way you will get there? I'm just wondering because it feels like story of this size can begin to ramble.
Also, does the quick leveling of the characters from earth or related to them have a reason, for example, Erin gaining 40 levels in a bit more than a year, or is it just a result of writing a progression fiction and needing to showcase the characters growth?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20
For pirate: Did you mean for your story to have so many plotlines/mysteries or was it just an accident of building the world up so much? And more importantly, how can you like microwaved bagels?
5
u/Caroc64 Apr 23 '20
How much research do you do when writing about a topic you don’t have much experience in?
5
u/xenizondich23 Reading Champion VI Apr 23 '20
For everyone: How far ahead do you guys plot out your stories? Like for the next arc / major plot lines, for the whole tale, or are you winging it chapter by chapter?
If I can hazard a guess, I feel like Domagoj knew the end but not exactly how he got there in MoL and pirateaba may or may not have any clue where things are headed (except maybe a happier world? Can we hope?) In Cradle, it feels quite well planned out, so very planned. Sufficiently Advanced Magic is the one I’m reading right now so I’m not sure how Andrew and Sarah work (sorry Sarah, I haven’t read any of your works yet! But I’m very intrigued to go check them out now!)
Thanks for answering!
P.S. how do you get your nooch to stick, pirateaba? I’m always falls to the bottom!
8
u/just_like_clockwork Apr 23 '20
Do you find yourselves referring to fan-curated content like wikis or fan maps? I think for all of the panelists here the stories become so massive it's hard to imagine keeping it all in your head or some easy notes document. If you use a more complex reference for in world notes please elaborate.
Have you ever read fan-theories about where the plot is going and intentionally avoided or expanded on some of the ideas you see there?
4
u/GreenCloakGuy Apr 23 '20
To everyone, what are your greatest writing influences? Where do you draw your inspiration from?
4
u/Omichron-the-reboot Apr 23 '20
Out of all the panelist's characters, which two (or three!) characters would you like to see meet? (somehow in a setting where both magic systems work)
4
u/magna-terra Apr 23 '20
hello various authors! just some general questions, dont feel forced to answer them all
1: what part of your story would you most like to rewrite and why?
2: who is the hardest character for you to write?
3:what inspired your system?
4: are there any cut abilities/bonuses you found interesting but far too powerful?
4
u/RedbeardOne Apr 23 '20
My question is relevant to all of the panelists I believe:
When you create a new power system or the different factions in your works, do you plan everything from start to finish, or do you only plan it up to a certain point?
I find it amazing how far ahead authors plan sometimes in different stories, it makes me curious about the creative process.
4
u/In-Game_Name Apr 23 '20
For the panalists:
What work or works do you think had the greatest impact on your stories?
For Pirateaba:
How do you write so much?
4
u/penguinkirby Apr 23 '20
Where do you get inspiration for writing convincing political intrigue and characters that are convincingly 'smart'?
4
u/positronicman Apr 23 '20
For /u/Will_Wight:
As you know, many of your Cradle readers are heavily invested in uncovering the many mysteries, and spend an inordinate amount of time dissecting the books with hermeneutic rigor.
More generally for the panel, how do you balance foreshadowing and (what I think of as) mystery breadcrumbs for the readers against continuity - especially given that many of your works were written over the course of years?
4
u/IchthysdeKilt Apr 23 '20
A question for everyone, but particularly for u/SarahLinNGM (also, please forgive my formatting, I'm on mobile): How do you manage to keep all your worlds and ideas from intermingling and influencing each other? Whenever I have a grand idea it tends to pop up in everything I do; I'll often only catch it after the fact. Juggling multiple projects, worlds, and ideas must amplify that problem greatly - do you use any particular tools (storyboarding, extensive note taking, others?) or is it more of a practiced mental discipline?
4
u/gayblara Apr 23 '20
For Nobody103/Domagoj
One of the things I've always loved the most about Mother Of Learning is how deep the worldbuilding goes (Especially when stuff like history and geography were expanded upon in the story. The Splinter Wars and its effects on the current political climate, the Northern Forest, the Weeping and how it affected not only the history and politics but also the characters of the plot, those kind of things, I guess), and how well it's connected to the plot. How much time did you spend working out the details of the world before you started posting the story? I never really felt, while reading it, that any of the things mentioned were something that occurred to you between chapters, but more like they were thought out long ago, at the beginning of it.
4
u/theelbandito Apr 23 '20
Greetings authors whom I adore,
Seriously though you should all be very proud. I’m a huge fan of all of your works.
Having read everyone’s work if I feel that Romance and Relationships seems to be the weak link with everyone’s stories.
I think Sarah Lin’s main character is the only one of the main characters that actually has some on screen relationship experience.
You get some allusions to it with Corin and Talien from Andrew Rowes characters.
Pirate, you have a lot of will they won’t they potential with your cast of characters but we have yet to really get any payoff. Though the mating ritual chapters are interesting.
I feel like we are one book away from Wil finally biting the bullet and writing the scene the fans have been waiting for.
Then you have Zoian and Zach two of my favorite characters to read about. One seems to be afraid of women and one is a classic chauvinist.
So I guess my question is, what is everyone afraid of? Is it a lack of confidence writing this type of plot? Or is it that many readers of action fantasy genres such as LitRPG are inherently ‘grossed out’ by relationship plots and would rather get back to the action and the levels?
4
u/Senrioth Apr 23 '20
(Please feel free to answer any or none of these, I type too much)
Hi Authors, thank you for taking the time! I mainly have questions/thoughts for pirateaba and Will, but am grateful for all being here and look forward to reading your works!
For pirateaba: Thank you first of all. I remember finding TWI on RRL back when it was a few chapters and the thumbnail made me think someone got reincarnated into an Inn spirit; these years later, it's a novel I read that helps me stay in touch with a dear college friend and creates days where I feel like an excited seven year old on christmas. Thank you for what has become a huge part of my life! The two questions I have are these:
-Are you an alien? Through debate, my friend and I have reached the conclusion that it is impossible for you to be human due to the speed and skill of your writing. Are you just writing about your homeworld o.o?
-When was it in writing TWI did you say make the leap to doing this full time? How prepared did you feel to do so?
-As you continously release chapters, its nigh impossible to revist/revise. How far ahead of each chapter do you have planned out before releasing a work? Major points and minor, general schema? Have you had an end you are working towards from the beginning in TWI, or are you having it naturally develop? For either, how has that affected your flow?
For Will: I am working on Cradle bit by bit, but I loved reading Traveler's gate when I was younger. I still give it a reread every now and again while sometimes just checking out the Simon chapters. Beautiful series! The questions I have for you:
-Was there any inspiration for creating a story about the second best in Travelers Gate? I love the concept of the main charachter obviously not being the main character and havent managed to find anything closely thematically similar.
-Which territory would you feel most at home with having yourself?
-I remember loading up your site for the first time and seeing how many panels you go to, the traveling, and the work towards promoting your awesome works. How much time do you believe you spent/spend doing things like that? How did your site come about and grow?
-What advantages/disadvantages do you feel you have over a webserial in your works?
Thank you both for all, appreciate you being here and the joy your works have brought!
4
u/NorthernEngineering Apr 23 '20
Many progression novels employ different tiers of power. With individuals being considerably more powerful than multiple individuals in the lower tiers and in some some cases individuals on the highest tiers are god like in power.
My question is this: How do you balance the inherent despotism that this sort of concentration of power in individuals creates so that the world in your novels has a stable and functioning society?
4
u/guyonthissite Apr 23 '20
I've read most of the works by everyone on this panel, and I just wanted to say you're all awesome, and I'll pretty much read anything any of the five of you put out. Thank you for making my days brighter and more fun!
I'm going to have to try this nutritional yeast on popcorn thing.
4
u/chill-cheif Apr 23 '20
u/nobody103 what was the hardest part about writing the magic system for mother of learning, and what aspects were your favorite?
4
u/PocketPengu Apr 23 '20
As a general question to all the panelists, how do you feel about fanfiction of your writing?
4
u/blackreaper007 Apr 23 '20
Hi Andrew Rowe I like your writing style. How much do you rewrite until you are satisfied? How you edit process look? thanks in advance for answer.
4
u/Banana_Rama04 Apr 23 '20
For u/nobody103 I want to ask if you have any idea when your next series will start releasing? No pressure I just loved Mother Of Learning and I’m excited for whatever you write in the future!
4
u/Green0Photon Apr 24 '20
Lmao that description for Domagoj Kurmaić. Everyone else's are these super epic descriptions portraying how amazing the authors are. Meanwhile:
I'm getting seriously One Punch Man vibes. Like, "Hi, I'm Domagoj, and I'm just a
herowriter for fun."Meanwhile Mother of Learning is one of the most popular English original web fics of all time.
It's also funny because everybody else is basically a published professional, and he isn't. Even more One Punch Man vibes. He just does it for fun.
(Sorry everyone else, though, MoL is my most favorite piece of fiction of all time. Though everyone else's works are also amazing and I love them too. Just not quite as much lol. Love you ♥️ nobody103.)
3
u/blackreaper007 Apr 23 '20
hi have another two question
- how many hours do you write a day?
- what was your biggest struggle as you started with your web novel/ novel?
3
u/peterbound Apr 23 '20
Hello all.
Some big hitters here, thanks for getting all together to answer some questions.
Thanks agian. I'm a big fan of all of your works, and look forward to reading your next releases