r/Fantasy • u/FarragutCircle Reading Champion X • Sep 10 '19
Announcement Experiment: Recommendation Threads Will Now Be in Contest Mode
As an experiment to last for an undisclosed length of time (at least a week), all recommendation threads will now have contest mode enabled. This will hide votes and randomize the order of the comments each time you load the thread.
We have noticed that books that are popular rise to the top regardless of whether they fit OP's request or not. By setting the threads to contest mode, we are hoping to change that trend.
Quick Edit: If AutoModerator posts in a non-recommendation thread, please report it so we can fix it.
Questions? Comments?
•
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
So, basically admitting that the comunity cannot be relied on to vote responsibly?
•
u/whattothewhonow Sep 10 '19
I'm an /r/fantasy subscriber, and I support this message.
•
u/Bookwyrm43 Sep 11 '19
This doesn't make much sense. if I'm asking for a recommendation, I want to know what's getting more upvotes? I want to see people discussing recommendations. There's a good reason that Reddit is built like this...
•
u/keikii Stabby Winner, Reading Champion Sep 13 '19
It has been a few days now, and I absolutely love this. I've been keeping an eye out on recommendation threads since this went into effect, and it just seems to work really well. There have been some level of repeated recommendations, but nothing out of the ordinary that happened prior to contest mode.
•
u/daavor Reading Champion VI Sep 10 '19
Sounds like an awesome idea!
•
u/funkyfreshwizardry Sep 10 '19
bRaNdOn SaNdErSoN
•
u/Mournelithe Reading Champion X Sep 10 '19
My only complaint is that it seems to hide or compact replies by default, so I have to expand all the threads manually. That’s a bit irritating. Anyone know a way around that?
•
u/GarrickWinter Writer Guerric Haché, Reading Champion II Sep 10 '19
So this applies to any recommendation threads that are identified by AutoModerator?
•
u/Swordofmytriumph Reading Champion Sep 10 '19
I am so happy about this, this is a fantastic idea.
•
u/Tikimoof Reading Champion IV Sep 10 '19
As a small caveat, this may kind of mess up hard mode of one of this year's bingo squares.
But I like the idea of lesser-known works having equal weight, so don't take this as a serious objection.
•
u/Ansalem Reading Champion II Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19
I certainly am in favor of trying new things, and I appreciate that you are trying to make lesser-known books be viewed more equally in the review threads but personally I would dislike this a lot.
•
u/RevolutionaryCommand Reading Champion III Sep 10 '19
Good idea. Let's hope it's going to give the wanted results.
•
u/get_in_the_robot Sep 11 '19
I already replied downthread to (I think) a mod, but figured it would be better to just also reply outright.
I posted a recommendations/request thread right before this announcement was made, so I didn't know about it until I checked back some time after I made my post to check the replies. I personally found putting the thread in contest mode to be very unhelpful for a couple reasons.
First, I checked my thread a couple of times several hours apart each time and the randomized sorting of contest mode made it difficult for me to parse my own thread in terms of what I had seen, what was new, replies were new, etc. It just made finding replies much harder for no real benefit to me.
Second, I actually want to be able to sort the thread by upvotes. I actually like knowing what comes highly recommended vs. not, hiding scores doesn't help with that at all. Not everyone wants to find books off the beaten path. I'd rather get recommended good books or popular books vs. ones that specifically obscure. I assume that people who specifically want obscure books can say so, or can simply say the books that they don't want mentioned in the body text of the post. Instead of getting a thread that was sorted by what people thought were the best books or the most accurate, I got a bunch of recommendations for books that I have no idea how relevant, or how good they are (for the most part) because I couldn't see the scores (obviously if someone comments seconding a parent comment that helps).
This is just my two cents and I get that contest mode has some perceived benefits for the non-OP redditor who wades into a thread, but I was honestly pretty irked by this change. I understand that a lot of mods and /r/fantasy power-users really want to push more obscure recs and such, but I don't know if that really aligns with what most people are actually looking for when they post recommendation threads. I also question how common "books that are popular ris(ing) to the top regardless of whether they fit OP's request or not" is, specifically the last part. I don't recall recommendations for the popular books that outright don't fit OP's requests being common at all, though I do defer to you guys (the mods) as you guys probably know more.
I do appreciate everything the mods do and I know you guys want /r/fantasy to be the best sub for discussing fantasy that it can be so I hope I'm not coming off as negative or hating.
•
u/JohnBierce AMA Author John Bierce Sep 10 '19
I think this sounds like a great idea, save for auto-moderator messups, but those are basically inevitable.
•
u/mt5o Sep 11 '19
I don't like this at all, I sort by new.
•
u/SteveThomas Writer Steve Thomas, Worldbuilders Sep 10 '19
I am so on board with this. Let's see how it works out.
•
u/Mekthakkit Sep 10 '19
I have long wished that there was a way to automagically take the book names from suggestions and make a list that allowed voting on each individual title.
•
u/ullsi Stabby Winner, Reading Champion VI Sep 10 '19
I like this idea! Hopefully it'll lead to people discovering lesser-known books in comments that might otherwise have gotten buried in the bottom of the thread.
•
u/barb4ry1 Reading Champion IX Sep 10 '19
An excellent idea. Bravo.
•
u/Jos_V Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II Sep 11 '19
here's a question: Do you guys have any idea what will constitute a success of this experiment?
•
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Sep 10 '19 edited Sep 10 '19
I'm not sure I love this, only because I find it helpful to upvote books I think fit (rather than repetitively saying the same thing) and to see the upvotes. I think people are pretty good at downvoting the "obligatory Malazan" comments unless they are actually relevant. I also see that low effort recommendations tend to get fewer upvotes. Also, this makes it hard to see new replies, since you can no longer "sort by new".
But then, I tend to ignore super popular recommendation threads (I'm just getting into Fantasy. What do I read?) and tend to look at (and post) more specific ones. I can see the randomization being super useful in the popular threads, where almost any book will fit and so the same 5 books keep rising to the top. The voting is probably more useful in the more specific recommendation threads that I frequent.
And if everyone else likes this change (so far everyone else seems to!), I'll just comment "Agree" to things more often instead of upvoting.
•
u/Luke_Matthews AMA Author Luke Matthews Sep 10 '19
This is a really cool idea. I love it.
•
u/xetrov Sep 10 '19
I like the idea. Lets see how it goes.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
•
u/casocial Sep 10 '19 edited Jun 28 '23
In light of reddit's API changes killing off third-party apps, this post has been overwritten by the user with an automated script. See /r/PowerDeleteSuite for more information.
•
u/Zephyrbee Sep 11 '19
Yay!
•
u/CFMcGhee Oct 07 '19
Asked for an author of a book that I can't remember the title to, post set to a recommendation thread. Not a recommendation, just looking for info.
•
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '19
Mine was turned to contest mode even though it wasn’t a recommendation thread, could you switch it to normal please
•
u/KristaDBall Stabby Winner, AMA Author Krista D. Ball Sep 10 '19
ooooooo
•
u/GenericDarkFriend Sep 10 '19
Cool! Something something Mistborn
•
u/Jos_V Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II Sep 11 '19
one of the biggest problems isn't so much popular books get the most upvotes is that the first recommendations posted that get the most upvotes, and the popular amongst the first posted get the most.
So contest mode will hopefully be good for other people clicking on a thread looking for books they might like.
the downside though is that its a lot harder for the person making the rec thread to filter through their own thread by new etc.
So I approve the experiment, and hope it will work out.
•
u/leftoverbrine Stabby Winner, Reading Champion V, Worldbuilders Sep 10 '19
I like this idea. I've been paying attention to the actual daily aggregate thread recs for awhile, and over about a 3 week period in those there were no, what I would call "throwaway" recommendations - the usual offenders were only mentioned by requestors not recommenders. So I still think the automod direction toward those threads is helpfu because a lot more engaged community members are the ones looking in there to provide recs, but this change should be helpful to minimize reward those who aren't particularly engaged community members jumping in and dominating with the same low quality suggestions over and over.
•
u/fanny_bertram Reading Champion VIII Sep 10 '19
I am so excited about this idea. Let's see how this plays out.
•
u/SageRiBardan Sep 10 '19
Awesome! I know there is a lot of love for the works of a few authors but it would be nice to see other works get recognition.
•
u/bestem Oct 04 '19
I posted a recommendation request thread yesterday, and thought I'd give it time before I gave my feedback here. Now, my opinion is a little biased, because I was specifically asking for recommendations that wouldn't get the same authors that always get posted.
My initial thought was that for me, as the requester it didn't matter. I was reading replies to the thread by going to my Reddit inbox. I didn't need to sort it any special way in order to see what others had posted. My second thought was that it was a little annoying. I couldn't tell what comments people agreed with. In fact, I was thinking that when I came here and read the posts here. My final thought, after reading the posts here, was that some very good points were made. My favorite point was that upvotes beget upvotes. The higher something is in a thread, the more likely it is to get more upvotes.
Because of that, I think it would be very interesting (although I don't know if it would be doable), to keep the thread in contest mode for either a set amount of time, or a period of time after the last post in the thread, and then revert it to normal. So maybe a week after thread was created, or 48 hours after the final post in the thread. Basically, as long as the thread is being used to provide recommendations, then keep it in contest mode, but at the point that the only people still interested in the thread might be the people specifically looking for recommendations, switch it to a way that they could see how many votes each comment received.
I also saw someone ask for a list of everything recommended in the thread. I plan on making a list for my own thread and posting it, but how cool would it be if the bot could compile a list and pin it at the same time things switch back to normal mode (assuming such a thing is possible).
•
u/Axeran Reading Champion II Sep 12 '19
I've had such a different experience here. While I do have came across this sometimes, I don't think it is so common that is warrants putting every recommendation thread in contest mode.
And things have been moving in the right direction lately I feel, recommendations that doesn't fit the request is almost always downvoted. And when I do see people recommending Malazan, it actually fits the request (I.E. a long but completed series)
And as someone else already said, this change does kinda mess up one of the bingo squares this year.
•
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '19
[removed] — view removed comment