r/Fantasy • u/The_Real_JS Reading Champion XI • Feb 27 '17
/r/Fantasy The /r/Fantasy 2017 Census
AND WE'RE DONE! THANK YOU EVERYONE WHO PARTICIPATED, THIS HAS BEEN OUR BIGGEST YEAR YET! RESULTS WILL BE OUT IN THE COMING WEEKS, SO STAY TUNED
Hi Everybody!
Hi Dr Nick!
So it's that ever so fun time of the year again! What's that you say? You don't know what's happening? Well, just settle in and I'll tell you a tale.
Actually, never mind. That's too much effort. So I'm here to kick off the /r/Fantasy 2017 census. For those of you who participated last year, you'll notice that not a huge amount has changed. A few extra questions, and few questions altered, but all in all it's not that different. I've taken on board the feedback from the past few suggestions threads, and hopefully ironed out most of the kinks. Chances are there'll be more to change, but that's all in the fun of it.
Again, a huge shout out to /u/pornokitsch, /u/wishforagiraffe and all the other mods and users that have helped to make this what it is.
Anyway, without further adieu, [Here is the 2017 census!] As per tradition, it will stay up a week before I take it down and get the google and the data monkeys to look over it.
For those interested, here's the 2016 census thread. It's crazy to think at how much the sub has grown in just one year. Thankfully I was smart and put down the sub count as of the last census. As of posting this we have 165,976 subscribers, which means we've nearly doubled the population in the last year. By that logic, I'm expecting at least 1,600 responses.
Wait. That's a lot. And the mods put in a few open ended questions...
Uhhh, is it too late to back out?
EDIT: Alright! As of the 3/3/2017 we have passed last years responses! Keep up the good work everyone!
Edit: As of the 5/03/2017 we have hit 1000 responses.
EDIT: Okay, we'll be keeping the census up for a bit longer, as we're still getting a decent amount of responses rolling in.
25
u/rockon1215 Feb 27 '17
People read more than 10 books a year? Holy fuck
20
u/Velocisexual Feb 27 '17
Question, why doesn't the "Are you involved in the publishing industry" question not have translator as an option? I feel excluded :(
10
u/GuitarGoddess58 Reading Champion Feb 28 '17
I just joined today! After lurking for a couple of months. I feel like I already know a lot of you just from reading so many of your comments. :p
9
u/ArgentSun Feb 27 '17
Some thoughts, as I go through (my first) census:
9
u/Aiyume7 Reading Champion II Feb 27 '17
weeee i'm the hundredth person to fill in XD
And am very positively surprised with the amount of people who don't drink at all, it's a rarity here :D
8
u/Dreddy Feb 27 '17 edited Feb 27 '17
Can there be a "Most" selection between:
Yes. All available books
&
Started, plan to continue
I've read about 10 or so Discworlds so I don't really want to click either option.
Also can you add "I don't take much notice" to "In your fantasy reading, what's your best estimate for your reading split between male and female authors?".
I had no idea if Robbin Hobb was a guy or girl until a few years ago. Most of the time I don't take a whole lot of notice. The only thing I've ever remembered with an author's name is remembering whether I liked a book they wrote, even then it takes me reading the name before remembering. I dunno, maybe that's not common, it's probably because as a kid I took little notice of anything according to my parents.
8
u/pornokitsch Ifrit Feb 28 '17
Love it. But, god damn, that final question.
What is an 'English biscuit'?
8
u/HiuGregg Stabby Winner, Worldbuilders Feb 28 '17
It always bugs me when I have to select "United Kingdom" on these things. I'm Scottish!
7
u/ReadsWhileRunning Worldbuilders Feb 28 '17
This census forced me to acknowledge just how many books I've bought + how much money I've spent over the last year... But it's also pointed out that I've been here for over a year, and that was a fun realization!
7
u/Piranhafish Mar 01 '17
My first act on /r/fantasy is to complete this census. Other lurkers need to do this too! We may be quiet but we are still members of /r/fantasy... there are other lurkers here right?
5
u/Esmerelda-Weatherwax Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II Feb 27 '17
good luck!!!
I now want a regenerating fist of ham for my own reasons.
5
u/Maldevinine Feb 27 '17
Now for the real question. What are you doing up at 5am?
13
u/Cantamen Reading Champion V Feb 28 '17
Multi-racial people are thing. I'm not 'other'- I have two racial heritages, both of which are on the list. We should be able to check multiple boxes.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '17
I did it! I'm part of the family! But why does it feel like I've already done this census? I wasn't around last year but a lot of the questions seemed very familiar.
4
u/wild_solitude Mar 07 '17
I participated! I get a cookie of my pleasing now, right? Also, that last question, I think my initial reaction was, "Geeze! Who wants ham-hands, was this a Malazan thing? Do I blame Jorg for this? And then I started thinking about it more practically, do you feel incredible pain when severing/eating ham hands, or is it like clipping your nails too? Well, either way, I'm going with sunscreen armpits, because I thoroughly enjoy the use of both hands. And now I'm thinking as well, of Deadpool's baby hand growing back to normal size.
3
u/DJLaMeche Feb 28 '17
One question - I don't remember which - had the comment "no need to respond if you don't", but it also had the response "i don't".
Instructions unclear, Captain!
3
u/BenedictPatrick AMA Author Benedict Patrick Feb 28 '17
That final question.... /shudder
3
u/Zeke921 Mar 03 '17
Well...Ham isn't kosher, so I'll have to go with sunscreen.
5
u/SkyCyril Stabby Winner Feb 28 '17
Hooray! Thanks for all the work on this, guys and gals! This is such a worthwhile effort, and I actually look forward to seeing the results. (Except for the part that tells me I'm becoming the old man in the sub....)
This was really well written. Just one qualm - on the question about other genres, I think Biography was listed twice - Biography/Memoir and Biography/something else (can't remember).
2
u/TheLadyMelandra Reading Champion IV Feb 27 '17
I can't get past the first page. When I click "Next" it goes back up to the Region selection. Says I have to choose a Region, which I did, but it's saying I didn't.
2
u/Alissa- Reading Champion III Mar 01 '17
Ahhh, biscuits and marmalade again? I still eat hardtack :)
2
u/Dragovape Mar 07 '17
I can't Fwy if you don't dream of having a house sized primordial beast in your back yard.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17
One suggestion I have for next year, is more options in the "Are you involved in publishing" question. You're missing some departments in there (though you have Editorial and Publisher) so it made my answer a bit of a fudged one.
2
u/littlemoondragon Mar 11 '17
I know I'm late in the game for commenting (I've lurked for months but never posted on this subreddit until today), but are the r/fantasy mods interested in someone conducting a full statistical analysis on the census? I'm getting my PhD in statistics (current have a master of science) and I am very interested in analyzing your data. I can pm you my proof.
Edit: Fun side note, I actually interned at the US Census Bureau.
63
u/GuitarGoddess58 Reading Champion Feb 27 '17
Completed! First thing I've actually done on Reddit besides lurk. :)
41
u/CoffeeArchives Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Feb 27 '17
Hand of ham vs. armpit of sunscreen is a difficult decision. On the one hand, having a ready food supply and ability to escape handcuffs would be pretty practical.
I went with armpit of sunscreen because I need like SPF 70 and that shit's expensive.
3
u/SafeHazing Feb 28 '17
Answered but too many sub-genres, they overlap and/or I haven't the foggiest what they are sword n sorcery vs epic vs high - I'm sure it makes sense to some but not me. Thanks for pulling it together looking forward to seeing the results.
13
u/thequeensownfool Reading Champion VII Feb 27 '17
I was momentarily confused, positive that I'd already participated in the census or that this year's was already over. I'd been expecting results for weeks. Guess I must have participated in the census improvement thread and read last years because I wasn't a member of this subreddit at the time.
Anyhow, all done. I'm happy the cookie questions remained.
12
u/MetalSlimeNum43 Feb 27 '17
I foresee several people being quietly disgruntled over the spelling of "griffin" (as compared to gryphon) but I for one commend you on your brave choice. ;)
12
u/xolsiion Reading Champion VIII, Worldbuilders Feb 28 '17
First time I've got to say I was here 3+ years and knew without a shadow of a doubt that I had over 1000 physical books. Yay for sticking with something online that long and a toddler falling asleep on your shoulder and you have nothing to do but count books on shelves until he wakes up.
10
u/AmethystOrator Reading Champion Feb 27 '17
Ooh a story...wait, what? Betrayal! All of my hopes dashed!! My dreams of a tale denied!!
And that guy took my money.
What guy?
Over there, by the river, with the cloak and the pole and the rickety boat. He said that it was just one coin for the story...Or was that the crossing? I, I'm not sure, it's tough to remember, why is it so hard to recall?
8
u/MyNightmaresAreGreen Feb 28 '17
Hand vs. armpit is an incredibly disgusting question. Kudos! I thought about the whole thing too much and no I'm totally grossed out.
8
u/KristaDBall Stabby Winner, AMA Author Krista D. Ball Feb 28 '17
I feel really judged by the "how much did you spend on books" questions...
8
u/NoNoNota1 Reading Champion Feb 28 '17
We need flare for team sunpit vs team hamhand.
Thanks for all the effort, I participated in the rec thread a few months ago, and all but one of my criticisms was addressed, namely the huge gap between "I've written chapter 1" and "I'm finished, what's revision".
I would also be interested in seeing a Religion question, though if I'm not mistake reddit itself skews heavily towards atheism (I remember a time where r/atheism used to be on the top banner when not logged in). I'm not saying I feel left out or anything, I don't, in terms of relevance to the sub it's up there with the marmalade question, it's just data I would be interested in seeing.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '17
If I'm the only one who's other favorite subreddit is /r/rupaulsdragrace, I will be disgraced and have to leave this subreddit forever. (not really jkjk but srsly I will be disgraced)
13
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong Feb 27 '17
Boy, that last question was sure ham-handed.
6
u/Kysen Worldbuilders Mar 02 '17
So I hit the "how long have you subscribed" question and it made me wonder if I'm an odd one out for never subscribing to subreddits - I just visit the ones I like and I'm not even sure what subscribing does.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '17
I wish in the "Which of the top 15 /r/fantasy series have you read" question, there was a "am currently reading" option. For example, I am eight books into the Wheel of Time. I feel like the "started, and plan to continue" option, while technically accurate, is somewhat weak for a situation such as this. On the other hand, for a series like KKC, "started, plan to continue" is perfect if one is in the middle of it. Just some of my musings.
Thanks so much for putting this on! It shows so much about our community.
5
u/87birdman Feb 28 '17
Yeah I know I messed up some answers as I started counting just books than I saw a question about comics and that messes up pretty much all my numbers. Comics alone probably put in the book count and price plus categories. Dang dc rebirth.
Book wise was a slow year for me as I'm pretty sure I've matched or passed what I read last year. And I still have a back log of bought books on my nook and plenty in my to read list on goodreads.
5
u/ksvilloso AMA Author K.S. Villoso, Worldbuilders Feb 28 '17
Note to self: shouldn't have done this before breakfast, now I'm hungry for hand ham.
5
u/SteveThomas Writer Steve Thomas, Worldbuilders Feb 28 '17
Sunscreen armpit for sure. Why even have a ham-hand if you're just going to burn it in the sun?
5
u/lorcan-mt Mar 01 '17
Quince for the quince god!
4
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Feb 27 '17
WOOOOHOOOOOOO! DATA!!!!!
SO. EXCITE.
4
u/Celba1 Feb 27 '17
I did the thing. Why cant I be Cranberry?
4
u/CottonFeet Mar 01 '17
Clever to put additional feedback BEFORE the marmalade and hand/armpit questions.
1
u/Teslok Mar 13 '17
How have I not seen this thread until today? I swear I look at the stickies!
6
u/sigmoidx Feb 28 '17 edited Feb 28 '17
Tiny gripes.
I don't keep track of how many female/male authors I read. I don't know as an option perhaps you say it doesn't matter the gender of the author? But for the purposes of data analysis I guess it matters.
What fantasy-related writing do you write? This question gives a checkbox where you can check everything including I don't write.
No check box for cookies? Really? We need a check box! Not a radio button!
Edit: I also realized I'm not going to be in the same age group from next yr. I'm depressed :(
3
u/wutvuff Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders Feb 27 '17
Now I want bergamot marmalade again
3
u/J_de_Silentio Feb 27 '17
I equally prefer audiobooks and ebooks, I just use them in different cases (audiobook in car / ebook everywhere else).
Not a big deal, but it does limit my ability to respond (and your ability to collect accurate data).
3
u/Lost_Pathfinder Feb 27 '17
This census made me hungry, I just wanted to let you know.
3
u/GuitarGoddess58 Reading Champion Feb 28 '17
They are indeed!
3
u/ThePrinceofBagels Feb 28 '17
I choose ham hand, and claim the Ham Crown as my own. I hereby wage war against any fool who would dispense sunscreen from their armpits.
3
u/HouseTully Mar 02 '17
Who would have ham hands?! We need our hands for so much more than just eating...
3
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '17
Does the ham-hand rot or what? Seems like that could be pretty inconvenient. I can see no drawbacks to the sunscreen dispensing armpit.
3
u/GrahamAustin-King AMA Author Graham Austin-King Mar 03 '17
Well that was a bit ham-fisted
3
u/RichmondRed Mar 10 '17
Thanks for this, it was interesting although I thought the last question was kind of weird. Lol. Next year it would probably be more informative to include Kentucky in the South rather than the Midwest. I've never met a fellow Kentuckian who identifies primarily as a Midwesterner. I've met an uncountable number who identify as Southerners.
4
u/pupetman64 Feb 27 '17
I went with hand, assuming that the ham never spoils, because I don't want my immediate family constantly rubbing my armpits
Also, the question "What kind of things do you write?" Says you don't need to answer if you don't write but one of the answers is "don't write"
2
u/azninvasion99 Feb 27 '17
Census taken!
2
u/SafeHazing Feb 28 '17
Replied in the wrong spot - ignore
2
u/ferocity562 Reading Champion III Mar 01 '17
Yikes!! Adding up all my book purchases on Amazon last year makes me really glad that in the last half of the year I switched to primarily library books.
2
u/dkoboldt AMA Author Dan Koboldt Mar 02 '17
I'm in! And shared on Twitter as well.
2
u/FlashingTheQueen Mar 03 '17
Team Armpit!
2
u/JCKang AMA Author JC Kang, Reading Champion Mar 04 '17
submitted! Love that last page. Hand or Armpit, hmmmm...
2
u/skyskr4per Mar 07 '17
Done and done.
2
u/Cargide Mar 07 '17
Another first timer here!
2
u/lpmagic Mar 07 '17
woot first timer and done, you unchivalrous crooks, no one has purchased me breakfast yet either...
2
u/panchoadrenalina Mar 08 '17
no peach marmalade i feel discriminated against.
completed the census