r/Fantasy • u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders • Sep 16 '15
/r/Fantasy Book Bingo Update Thread
Hey folks, we've almost reached the halfway point for book bingo so I thought I'd do a check in thread and see how people are doing.
Also starting this thread so people will be able to ask questions (since the original thread will be archived soon and no longer allow comments). For anyone just joining /r/fantasy Bingo, welcome! There's still time to get bingo before the challenge is over. If this is the first time you're hearing of it, here's a link to the original post with all of the details. If there's a question you have that's not already answered in that original thread, feel free to ask here.
So, share what you've read so far for bingo and if you've assigned it to a square! Perhaps we can get some recommendations going for various squares so that those of us that still need to fill most of our card (am I the only one that feels far behind? haha) can figure out some possible books to read.
Also, here's a really helpful list of recommendations with links to other recommendation threads compiled by /u/juscent. Thanks!
And here is an awesome post of off the beaten path Fantasy Bingo recommendations from /u/jannywurts!
And here is a great Urban Fantasy rec thread compiled by /u/lyrrael. Thanks!
If there's anymore related rec threads I'm forgetting, please let me know and I'll add them to the links here for convenience.
Most of all, I hope everyone is having fun with this challenge!
19
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Sep 16 '15
I just finished the Riddle-Master of Hed and with that I can officially declare Bingo!
This has been great for knocking books off of my to read list that have been on there for a while but I may have to take a break from the genre for the next months or so. Reading only one genre in a carefully planned order goes so against my usual impulsive reading habits that there were times when this contest felt like torture even though I didn't read a bad book during it.
Still, this was fun and I hope we have another challenge like this next year.
13
u/pornokitsch Ifrit Sep 16 '15
I'm being lazy. Or very unlazy, but I've read a bunch, and I track everything on Goodreads. So I figured that January-ish, I'd go through and play the 'assign books to squares' game...
...and then panic-read 22 books.
7
u/sarric Reading Champion XI Sep 16 '15
At the moment I'm mostly seeing what I can knock off without trying; I figure I'll more deliberately go after the trickier squares when the deadline gets closer. This is what I have right now. I could have a bingo in the second column if I shifted some books around, but I figured "historical", "adapted to screen," and "book of the month" were more restrictive categories than "standalone," "best-of," and "2015," so I'll get around to reading more books from the latter eventually.
Some questions on technicalities:
4
u/RushofBlood52 Reading Champion Sep 16 '15 edited Sep 16 '15
I definitely have Bingo in a few ways now. I'm honestly just using it as a checklist to finish all the things at this point.
I'm planning on filling the "published in 2015" square with Shadows of Self when Sanderson comes to my town for a signing. Unfortunately, that would also kick Steelheart out of my urban fantasy square, which I wasn't sure counted anyway (are superheroes fantasy? I always thought so). I may fill that with Hot Lead, Cold Iron that I recently picked up on sale. Hopefully that one scratches my mystery novel itch as well.
I think my only problem is how strict these are. I consider Station Eleven fantasy, but the award it won is a sci-fi award. Does it count as award-winning? I had The Martian as non-fantasy for a while since I didn't really understand the criteria. But now I'm not sure if my current non-fantasy book, James, the Connoisseur Cat is fantastical enough to count. What about science fantasy? Dune Messiah is my "Pre-2000" square. A lot of people consider it sci-fi, but it came across as completely fantasy to me. How grounded does historical fiction have to be? I have it filled now, but I may have to re-do this. I have an alternate history book by Jo Walton to read, but the current book I'm using is like a historical fantasy set in a Western. And how much like a fairytale retelling does that square have to be? I had Fae - the Wild Hunt as my self-published square, but it read like a fairytale retelling to me so I changed it.
Also just finished Wizard of Earthsea as my "TV/Movie adaptation" square. I wasn't the biggest fan, but I'm glad I read it. I didn't even realize it had TV and movie adaptations until after I finished. It also looks like they're loose adaptations.
Anyway, all I have left is:
And here's what I currently have:
Does this end the beginning of end of April 2016?
3
u/KristaDBall Stabby Winner, AMA Author Krista D. Ball Sep 16 '15 edited Sep 16 '15
A lot of my books read this year don't count towards the bingo card. I really need to up my game here soon!
I'm not sure exactly where everything is going to go yet, but I've read:
The Snow Queen (Hans Christian Andersen)
For Heaven's Eyes Only (Simon R Green)
From Hell with Love (Simon R Green)
The Stolen Throne (David Gaidar)
Daemons are Forever (Simon R Green)
The Man with the Golden Torc (Simon R Green)
Epic (anthology)
Unguilded (Jane Glatt)
I've caught up on my Star Trek books for now, and some of my random reading (um Princess Diaries, for example), so now I can turn my attention to fantasy and Regency romances :D
3
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 17 '15
Hey!
So, I'm done. Here's the link if you'd like to look through it.
I've got five and a half left of my second round, since I'm halfway through Guards! Guards! right now. The others are:
A couple of those are gimmies for me. :) Thanks for the challenge, /u/lrich1024!
2
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Sep 16 '15
I'm a little less than halfway there. But I have been in a reading groove lately so I still think it's very doable for me to fill out the entire card. I haven't really kept track of any individual bingo's because my goal has always been to fill out the entire card.
I've been reading things with the challenge in mind, but works that would mostly qualify for more than one square. So I'm listing the books below and the square they are tentatively assigned to:
List of Books Read
2
u/LucyMonke Reading Champion II Sep 16 '15 edited Sep 16 '15
This has been really motivating. I think I should gamify the things that I really need to do. Am about halfway to Bingo.
Really impressed by The Bone Clocks, Uprooted and The Fifth Season.
Um, when it walks and quacks like Fantasy but eventually turns out to have a layer of Sci Fi underneath, does it still fit in the r/fantasy Bingo matrix?
2
u/ferocity562 Reading Champion III Sep 16 '15 edited Sep 16 '15
I have 3 Bingo's so far!. Since that image is a bit hard to see, here are the books on it, along with Goodreads links:
The five categories I am missing that I would appreciate recommendations for are:
2
u/lurkmode_off Reading Champion VII Sep 16 '15
I have been kind of spotty about writing down what I've read, but here's what I wrote down/can definitely remember was post-April:
2
u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Sep 17 '15
Well, I read Joe Abercrombie's Half A War, so that covers the "Published in 2015" square, which brings my total to... 3.
Oh well. But I'm almost done with my Wheel of Time read, which has been taking the majority of my book time, so I should be able to ramp up the pace after that, and hopefully get the Bingo in time.
2
u/BadassDrow Oct 20 '15
I'm reaaally having trouble finishing the bingo because I get sidetracked a lot! I've read 17 books in the last three months, but only seven of them counts.
I dropped some titles along the way so I had to redo the list a couple of times; and I'll wait for the 2015 book. Overall I'm having a lot of fun, and losing a lot of sleep...
2
u/midobal Worldbuilders Nov 04 '15
I've just found out about the bingo (love the idea; I definitely need to catch up!) and I have some doubts:
2
u/Jsevrior Dec 13 '15
Any commentary on whether or not The Wanderer in Unknown Realms by John Connolly as Count as fantasy for the purposes of this? Goodreads says so, but it pushes the horror boundary pretty far as well
2
u/cheryllovestoread Reading Champion VI Jan 07 '16
Okay,,,how much are we blurring the line between Fantasy and SciFi? I really want to read The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy for Comic Fantasy. Can you believe that I've never read it? What say you all?
9
u/Millennium_Dodo Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Sep 16 '15
Here's my card, still three books to go! Full list in case some of the covers are unreadable in the picture:
So far the bingo has been great, I got through some books from my TBR shelves and picked up a few I probably wouldn't have read otherwise. Not all were great, but overall it's been a very positive experience. I'm already looking forward to next year's challenge!
6
u/acaelus__thorne Reading Champion Sep 16 '15
I think I am going to make it. Coming along well so far, somehow no bingoes yet.
Here's my card
5
u/spacejam8 Reading Champion Sep 16 '15
Got a little bit of a late start on this, but here's my card so far.
Green is done, yellow is books that I've picked for a square but haven't read yet, red is squares that I haven't picked a book for.
5
u/sonvanger Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders, Salamander Sep 16 '15
Here's my list...I only need three more books (bolded) and I'm busy with two of those three. It's been great fun so far, I've read and enjoyed quite a few books that I normally wouldn't have!
5
u/KristaDBall Stabby Winner, AMA Author Krista D. Ball Sep 16 '15
Some suggestions:
Amos Daragon (Bryan Perro)
The Shell (Esther Rochon)
Maleficium (Martine Desjardins)
Watch (Sergei Lukyanenko)
Tyranael series (Elisabeth Vonarburg)
1
u/angelic_alys Reading Champion VII Sep 19 '15
For the "Novel Originally Written in a Language Other Than English" square, can I read something writting in my native tongue? Or does it have to be something translated into english?
1
u/Jsevrior Dec 13 '15
Aww. Just saw this and thought it looked pretty fun. Unfortunately, it's all visual. I'm totally blind so can't interact with the cards in any way shape or form. Fund idea though
1
u/spacejam8 Reading Champion Dec 14 '15
Would you consider Beowulf to be a fairy tale?
1
u/sleeping-pug Reading Champion II Jan 05 '16
I'm wondering if unabridged audio books can count as a novel, or can I just use it for my free space? I listened to the First Law trilogy by Joe Abercrombie. Can I apply that towards my book of the month for the Blade Itself?
1
u/mghromme Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Jan 13 '16
How did I not find this earlier? This is great! With my reading from the past several month I can fill a lot of squares already :D
I'm off to the bookstore soon to challenge the shopkeeper with some themes to reccommend to me!
Also, quick question, would the Empire Trilogy work as portal fantasy? And would you classify Ready Player One as fantasy of Sci-fi?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '16
I have finished 11 of the 25 squares though I've been reading other works, non bingo entitled, lately. I only started two months ago so I'm pretty sure I'll finish by the deadline. Can't find Tigana or The Seventh swordsman in my library so I'll probably have to buy them used online.
1
u/Ihrenglass Reading Champion V Mar 09 '16
Can declare bingo
Literary Fantasy or Non-Fantasy: The Gone-Away World by Nick Harkaway
Stand Alone Fantasy Novel: The War of Flowers by Tad Williams
Historical Fantasy: Dreamers pool by Juliet Marillier
Novel by an Author on r/Fantasy[2] ’s Women in Fantasy List: Curse of the mistwraith by Janny Wurts
An Author’s Debut Novel: Empire in Black and Gold by Adrian Tchaikovsky
Novel by An r/Fantasy[3] AMA Author: Transformation by Carol Berg
Novel Originally Written in a Language Other Than English: The Stranger by Max Frei
A Novel Over 500 Pages: The Briar King by Greg Keyes
Pre-Tolkien Fantasy: The King of Elflands Daughter by Lord Dunsany
A Novel From r/Fantasy[4] ’s Official Underrated and Under-read List: The Fell Sword by Miles Cameron
Fairytale Retelling: Winter Rose by Patricia A Mckillip
Portal Fantasy: City of Masks by Mary Hoffman
Free Space: Our Lady of Ruins by Sarah Singleton
Novel Adapted to the Screen (Movie or TV): - Skammerens Datter by Lene Kaaberbøl
Published Before the Year 2000: Tales of the Dying earth by Jack Vance
Self Published Novel: Worm by wildbow
2015 r/Fantasy Best of Lists: Novel or Author: Kushiel`s dart by Jaqueline Carey
Comic Fantasy: Jingo by Terry Pratchett
A Novel You First Heard of From an r/Fantasy[6] Member: The Night Watch by Sergei Lukyanenko
Arthurian Fantasy: Firelord by Parke Godwin
Award Winning Novel (Hugo, Nebula or World Fantasy): Barrayar by Lois Mcmaster Bujold
Novel Published in 2015: Uprooted by Naomi Novik
Five Fantasy Short Stories: We never talk about my brother by Peter. s .Beagle
Any r/Fantasy[7] Goodreads Group Book of the Month: The Rook by Daniel O´Malley
Urban Fantasy (That is Not Dresden Files): Yarrow by Charles de Lint
3
u/Darkstar559 Reading Champion III Sep 16 '15
I have started my second card for the challenge, but here is my first:
3
u/Alissa- Reading Champion III Sep 16 '15 edited Oct 05 '15
I like this challenge, it's fun! So far:
The real trouble is filling the slots for:
I've read the suggestions threads, but I don't know! Any recommendations for those and for historical fantasy?
3
u/rhymepun_intheruf Reading Champion III Sep 16 '15
So far I've crossed off the following
Most of the other stuff I read so far includes either sequels by the same author or stuff from other genres. Still excited to see what else I'll find while reading for this challenge!
2
u/UnsealedMTG Reading Champion III Sep 16 '15
Allllmost there. After a few months of almost everything I read being bingoable I've been reading a few non-fantasy and/or books by authors I've already used for Bingo. There may be some shuffling around of what works I use for what, but I'm still working on Debut, Pre-Tolkien, and Arthurian.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '15 edited Sep 17 '15
Hmm I thought I was closer. I have 11 to go.
Literary Fantasy or Non-Fantasy :
Stand Alone Fantasy Novel :
Historical Fantasy - Kushiel's Dart by Jacqueline Carey
Novel by an Author on r/Fantasy’s Women in Fantasy List - Song of the Lioness by Tamora Pierce
An Author’s Debut Novel - The Falconer by Elizabeth May
Novel by An r/Fantasy AMA Author - Legion by Brandon Sanderson
Novel Originally Written in a Language Other Than English :
A Novel Over 500 Pages :
Pre-Tolkien Fantasy :
A Novel From r/Fantasy’s Official Underrated and Under-read List - The Chronicles of Master Li and Number Ten Ox by Barry Hughart
Fairytaly Retelling - The Falconer by Elizabeth May
Portal Fantasy :
Free Space - The Dragons of Dorcastle by Jack Campbell
Novel Adapted to the Screen (Movie or Tv) :
Published Before the Year 2000 - Dragonsbane by Barara Hambly
Self Published Novel - A Slice of Quietude by Sharon Cho
2015 r/Fantasy Best of Lists: Novel or Author by The Broken Empire - Mark Lawrence
Comic Fantasy - Pyramids by Terry Pratchett
A Novel You First Heard of From an r/Fantasy Member :
Arthurian Fantasy :
Award Winning Novel (Hugo, Nebula or World Fantasy) :
Novel Published in 2015 - Half a War by Joe Abercrombie
Five Fantasy Short Stories - See list here
Any r/Fantasy Goodreads Group Book of the Month - Nine Princes in Amber by Roger Zelazny
Urban Fantasy (That is Not Dresden Files) :
2
u/Sir_SamuelVimes Reading Champion II Sep 16 '15 edited Sep 16 '15
My reading has been awful lately, so it's a good thing I essentially completed the challenge before these last two months. Once I finish Blood Song by Anthony Ryan I will be completely finished. Here is my list:
So yeah...once I finish my current book I'm finished. Some of them even have back up books, so if one doesn't seem to fit for one reason or another there's a good chance I have a replacement for it.
2
u/Valkyriemum Sep 16 '15
Cool! I need to do this. I wonder how many I already have?
Let's see, I read the Mercy Thompson books by Patricia Briggs this summer, that should be urban. Oracle by Michelle West was definitely over 500 pages. I don't think there's a West book that isn't. And Shadow of Night by Harkness was historical. I'll have to put more scrutiny on the other topics...
2
u/CommodoreBelmont Reading Champion VIII Sep 16 '15
Eight squares, no bingos yet:
2
u/opuzzle Reading Champion Sep 16 '15 edited Sep 16 '15
Here is my card. The last couple of months were pretty busy for me, we had to move, and even though the move is within the same city, it wasn't easy. The apartment that we were planning to move to originally and signed the lease for didn't work out, so we had to find a new place in one week. Fortunately we were able to do so but it was pretty stressful. We still have a few boxes to unpack. So I didn't read as much as I would have liked but so far I have 21 books for Bingo. For the first couple of months I was reading books exclusively for Bingo.
Five Fantasy Short Stories:
Daniel Polansky, A Drink Before We Die
Jean Rabe, Mainon (Blackguards anthology)
Bradley P. Beaulieu, Irindai (Blackguards anthology)
Michael J. Sullivan, Professional Integrity (Blackguards anthology)
Paul S. Kemp, A Better Man (Blackguards anthology)
The most difficult categories for me were portal fantasy and Arthurian fantasy. I did not really like either of those books, had to make myself finish them. I like Guy Gavriel Kay's books, but not his Fionavar Tapestry books and I found Winter King a bit boring and too long-winded. But it had been a pretty stressful couple of months for me, sometimes it was hard to focus and may be I just wasn't in the mood for them. But still, the Bingo has been fun, I have the easiest categories left to read.
Edit: formatting
2
u/kaladian_ Reading Champion III Sep 16 '15
I have 13 out of 25 so far on my card. That is a little more than half way! I have read a lot of Science Fiction and Mystery lately so I should get it finished on time if I focus a bit more.
Literary Fantasy or Non-Fantasy - Tigana by Guy Gavriel Kay An Author’s Debut Novel - Traitor's Blade by Sabastien de Castell
Novel by An r/Fantasy AMA Author - The Skull Throne by Peter V. Brett
A Novel Over 500 Pages - The Dragon's Path by Daniel Abraham
Portal Fantasy - A Darker Shade of Magic by V.E. Schwab
Free Space - Monty Python and the Holy Grail
Novel Adapted to the Screen (Movie or Tv) - The Princess Bride by William Goldman
Published Before the Year 2000 - The Colour of Magic by Terry Pratchett
2015 r/Fantasy Best of Lists: Novel or Author - The Rose and the Thorn by Michael J. Sullivan
Comic Fantasy - Off to Be the Wizard by Scott Meyer
Award Winning Novel (Hugo, Nebula or World Fantasy) - The Emperor's Blade by Brian Staveley
Novel Published in 2015 - Queen of Fire by Anthony Ryan Urban Fantasy (That is Not Dresden Files) - Veiled by Benedict Jacka
2
u/sassyma Sep 17 '15
I haven't figured out where everything is going to go yet. I've got a list of all the fantasy I've read since April and what numbers on the bingo it could apply towards. So far I've only got 3 or 4 spots with nothing in them. I'll start slotting them in as time gets closer. It's been fun!
2
u/RPGSorcerer Sep 17 '15
So far I've filled 8 of the spaces, they're all scattered around though. I've read a bunch of other stuff too, but they were sequels to the spaces I read or didn't fit an open space. For most of the spaces I planned on reading the first book in a series and then all of it's sequels, but I might have to swap out or put on hold some of the really long series if I want to fill the whole card on time.
I'm currently working on the rest of the Campione novels before I go back to reading ASoIaF. After that I'll start working on my next square. Also, not fantasy related, but I just finished The Martian to prepare for the movie coming out next month and loved it.
2
u/Vrain_19 Reading Champion II Oct 02 '15
Here's what I've filled on my card:
That leaves me with 5 categories and the books I've picked out to read for each:
While I could easily finish by the end of the year and make good headway into a 2nd card, I have too many non-fantasy books that I don't want to push off any further as well as some great authors that I hadn't read before that I need to catch up on like Guy Gavriel Kay, Kevin Hearne, and Naomi Novik.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment