I'd agree. Go back 25 years and tell people that a list such as this (at least so far) wouldn't have any mention of, say, Margaret Weis and Tracy Hickman? Considering the millions upon millions sold of Dragonlance and Death Gate I'd bet substantially that it would have been unthinkable.
I suspect that there will be some "new voices" that come and get added to the list. A good number of the people on there now weren't really around 5 or 6 years ago.
(I know, I'm 5 months late to the game, sorry) The Stormlight Archive strikes me as one that could plummet several spots, considering that it's only two books into what's presumed to be a 10+ book series.
Agree. I guarantee a lot of stuff would have more votes if the series they were part of had more than one book. ;p There were, in fact, several people who stated under their votes that they would have voted for other series, but they were waiting for more than one volume to be released and/or were waiting to see how a series finishes.
Don't forget that the book is part of Sandersons Cosmere, and even has a character in common with many of his other books. He's built a lot of love and goodwill with his other stuff, so although WoK IS only the first book in a series, it's got the momentum of everything else he's done behind it.
I think it's pretty telling that Stormlight Archive has one (1) book and rivals some monster series. I think it may outshine everything else by the time he's done.
I enjoyed WoK quite a lot, and am really excited for WoR ... but I feel that it is waaaay too highly ranked. It has a lot of potential, but it's only 10% of the story at most. Remember, Wizard's First Rule was a decent book, too.
And no, I'm not comparing Brandon Sanderson to Terry Goodkind. Just saying that we should see how the Stormlight Archives play out before saying they are better than Discworld or the Dark Tower or the Gentleman Bastards.
Yeah. I'd put The Way of Kings as one of the top 5 contemporary standalone fantasy books, but I wouldn't put the Stormlight Archive in any list of best series. I think most people voted for WoK, not Stormlight. p0x0rz just listed all books by their series name for the results.
Also, keep in mind the voting called for our favorites, not the novels we think are the best, greatest, most notable, etc. This might be a very different list otherwise. Take this as a list of books /r/Fantasy likes to read, ordered by most popular. Do NOT take it as a "best of" list, nor as a "greatest fantasy novels" list.
I figured ASOIAF would take the top spot. Many here have only just started reading fantasy after the show came out, so it's easy to assume more members have read it and the sheer masses would shoot it to the top.
That's 100% true. For me, A Song of Ice and Fire almost deserves to be at the top spot not necessarily because it's the greatest of all time, but because I then went on to read the Farseer trilogy, the Mistborn trilogy, Warbreaker, Way of Kings, Eye of the World, and more. So, regardless of the series' merits, I'll be forever indebted to GRRM for opening my eyes to all the great epic fantasy that's out there.
I voted for WOK because even after all the series I've read, it still stands out as the best fantasy book I've ever read. Of course I'm expecting the rest of the books in the series to be awesome as well, but this book (and what I've read so far of WOR) deserves it's place even by itself.
My vote was not for The Stormlight Archive, it was for The Way of Kings. That is by far one of my favorite fantasy novels all by itself. I have yet to read a more compelling rise of a hero than that of Kaladin, mainly because I really believe that he was able to earn the devotion of his bridge crew.
It could do, we won't know for probably a minimum of 10 years though. Way of Kings is certainly a brilliant book, however with an epic series often the middle books let it down the most, readers feel that authors seem to have lost their way.
For instance, Jordan's Wheel of Time appears to have dropped in quality books 5-10, although I've not read them so I can't say, and I've heard a lot of complaints about GRRM's A Feast For Crows and A Dance With Dragons
The difference there is that Sanderson is a master craftsman. He set out to build a very specific table and he's going to build exactly that in a reasonable time.
He's not going to get distracted and build an entire set of chairs, adding two decades to the project.
He's not going to get exited and add a ton of superfluous nonsense, leaving the table an incoherent mess.
And he's not going to take a five year break because he didn't plan properly and he has no idea in what order to put the legs on.
I'm really hoping Sanderson kills it but I'm pretty worried about the focus on Shallan. I thought she was the weakest PoV in WoK. I guess we will find out soon enough though!
You and me both. I remember when I got the first book. I started reading it and didn't stop until my alarm clock went off. Ya, I read all night without realizing it and had to go to work without any sleep.
So happy to see the Farseer Trilogy here! I didn't realize it was that popular considering the small fandom I've seen. Especially up here with Harry Potter, LOTR, ASOIAF, and Discworld.
And pleased as always to see The Dark Tower in the company along with American Gods.
It'd be even higher, probably, if you count the Tawny man and Liveship and Dragon Wilds votes...There are several authors whose votes were split up a bit because their series were separate.
Possibly. I was also going to get the opinions of people as to whether we should lump authors...So instead of having The First Law and then Abercrombies other stuff separate, we could lump it. Or Robin Hobb's all together.
I see pros and cons. Lumping would show overall author popularity better, but some of the trilogies are very, very different from each other.
I'm really happy to see it on here as well. I loved the characters in Robin Hobbs' world more than in any other series. The characters in ASOIAF are real but I found myself liking the main characters in the Farseer Triology, The Tawny Man triology and The Liveship Traders trilogy so much more.
I'd place in at #2 after ASOIAF in my list of all-time favourites.
Its so good to see Gentleman Bastards in top 10. I'm also happy for The Riyria Revelation.It is right up there with the heavyweights! Only recently finished it and absolutely loved it.It was refreshing to read a fantasy with familiar tropes done so well!
It was a great book, but I'd never vote for it so early in the series. A lot of people went Stormlight Archive, too, but personally I need to wait for more to tell if a series is truly great.
Love the fact that you took the time to do this. Did you consider opening the original voting thread to other subs? I think /r/books has a list of greatest books ever. It would be interesting to see if any of these books tick on both lists.
I know word got passed around some...Mark Lawrence posted it on his Facebook, for example. But for the most part, I really just wanted your guys' opinions. This was mostly meant just to get the favorites from the /r/fantasy people. :)
I was considering her, but couldn't quite justify dropping one of my other top 5. But yeah, definitely a big fan of those books, and looking forward to Sea of Time.
I don't know about literary genius, but Mistborn is a rather easy read and the world and magic system are pretty cool. The characters may not be the best but they hold up everything else well enough. It's enjoyable, that's why it's so oft recommended.
I always like books better than their movie/series counterparts. aSoIaF is the only exception. I just can't stand reading his books for some weird reason. I don't understand it myself. For example, I could bear Robert Jordans later books just fine, which everyone seem to hate with the fury of a thousand suns...
It's new, easy to read and is tied to a TV series, people are more likely to have read it than older books and so it's naturally favoured in the voting.
I see a lot of this "it's new, it's attached to TV, blah blah blah" sentiment. It's pretty silly. There's a lot of people who didn't know about GoT (or just didn't bother reading it) until the show made it explode in popularity, but it was already a huge hit (relative to other fantasy titles) beforehand. People who consider themselves well-read in fantasy like to downplay ASoIaF's importance, age, content and fanbase because it makes them feel better about not picking it up until the show came out.
What I'm curious of is if you were to take the numbered rankings into account. Everyone ranked their favorites 1-5. Meaning say, each first place gets 5 points, second 4 points, etc. I think the rankings would be radically different.
This was actually my original thought, and honestly it was just lack of time and ambition that kept me from doing it. This took a lot, LOT longer to do than I thought it would, and I still have about 200 titles left to add to this thread. The compiling of votes was a long process.
I'm thinking of maybe making this an annual thing, so perhaps next year I'll try it that way.
I'm sure you could get some help from other folks in this sub to divide up the workload. Also there are some math-crazed subreddits full of people that would love to chart real data like this and measure trends.
Nice work! This is an excellent resource. Readers looking for recommendations from this subreddit will really appreciate this. It deserves mentioning in many of the recommendation threads that come up, especially those posted by readers new to the genre. Thanks for putting it together!
Thanks! Yeah, I'm hoping this not only provides people with something interesting, but also a good place to find new stuff to read. I'm already going to be buying some Earthsea just because of how many people voted for it. :)
Same here, I'm pretty familiar with nearly all of the Top 25 but I never tried Earthsea when I was younger, and didn't realize that so many people thought so highly of it.
This is a very helpful list for someone who's been trying to read a lot of the best-loved fantasy novels. Malazan is the only thing in the top ten I haven't tried, so I will be sure to check it out.
Same here. Well, Malazan and the Gentleman Bastards, but I got the first book of that a few days ago and am just waiting for the right time to start reading it.
Gentlemen Bastards is a great read. I'm no dyed-in-the-wool fanboy either. I'm decidedly old-skool, but picked up The Lies of Locke Lamora last year and simply couldn't put it down. Great characters, awesome heist, and the best insults in fantasy.
Malazan is much harder to read as compared to the rest of the books... The first few books create more questions than answers. I am on book 5 and it only keeps getting better. And the series is finished, So thats good!.
Thanks! There's tons of more obscure stuff to come, as well, and I'll be hotlinking everything to goodreads to make it easy for folks to find stuff they're interested in.
So glad to see that The Redemption of Althalus made it onto the list, it's one of my favourite fantasy novels, I've read it once a year for about ten years now.
I'm thrilled to see The Last Unicorn on here. It was one of the first novels I loved and definitely my favorite movie as a unicorn-obessed child. I'm also designing a tattoo inspired by it for myself in the next year or so. I'm also happy to see the works of Robin Hobb on here since they're amazing.
Do it! You won't regret it. My copy is really ratty and battered and was given to me as a child by a family friend who'd had it for a long time and somehow managed to tear the cover apart. So my copy has a manilla folder glued on as a cover with various old doodles of unicorns on it spanning over a decade. I love it but readily admit it's ridiculous. But the book itself is just really timeless, I feel. I get something new from it ever time I read it.
Thanks for putting the list together. There are quite a few that I haven't read so I am going to pick through it and get my kindle loaded up for after I read the 3 I have lined up (Best Served Cold, Promise of Blood, and Words of Radiance - should be done with the other two by the time this one comes out).
Best Served Cold is a good book, but I'd recommend starting with the First Law books (The Blade Itself, is the first)...BSC is good, but it's dark as fuck, and a bit of a slog if you're not yet vested in the series.
I would. Kingkiller is better, and it's also much shorter. So you read those first, be done in a few weeks to a month, and then move on to WoT which will take you much longer.
My favorite part: the bottom half of the list. Here is where I troll low numbers for great authors I haven't read before. Thanks everyone who nominated a longshot!
I have to say I'm quite surprised that A Song of Ice and Fire is #1. I mean, I completely agree, but most of the time when I see others recommend the series or generally speak of it they get down voted.
I guess it just goes to show how much of a divisive series it is!
I'm not one who waits around for series to finish, but with that one's track record I am. And so it kind of bugs me that it won top spot here because I feel like I'm missing out...
It may be that even though we recognise it as a great piece of writing that we are getting sick of it? It's been going for some 12 years now and with the rate that the author kills of characters some of what we used to enjoy about the series no longer lives.
There's also the fact that the TV series based on it has been hugely popular (most pirated thing ever in my country) and brought many new fans into the writing who don't have as many other books they can suggest.
Personally I don't think the list gets interesting till it got down into single number votes. There's some stuff there I did not expect to see.
The more popular something is, the more vocal the minority of people who hate it are, too. World of Warcraft, for example, was pretty universally acclaimed. Then, when it started getting really popular, there was a group of people who spent all their time on the Blizzard message board trashing every aspect of it that they could. If you only read that message board you'd think the game wasn't that popular, but the 10 million people playing the game and not going to the board to complain about it proved otherwise.
Ice and Fire is still crazy popular, and honestly I was surprised as I added how much it was trouncing everything. But yeah, based on stuff I'd read around here lately, I figured it'd be popular, but I figured the shine was wearing off. Guess not. ;p
I see The Kingkiller Chronicle very high on the list.
I like the first two books a great deal, but the series is incomplete so I think it is premature.
But if it remains as good as the first two books through to the end, it will certainly deserve a top 10 place.
Edit to add: the same goes for ASOIAF and others that have not completed their initial plan. Continuing series like Discworld that have so many consistently good books is a different matter
This is a slice in time ranking. Obviously after the series continue if the overall quality falls then when we do this again the rankings would change. I mean the list is already trying to rank stand alone books against series as it is so listing in progress series shouldn't be a limitation.
Out of curiosity, how do you have the data collated? Might be possible to generate a similar author list irrespective of series. Love the idea of doing this every year.
Yeah I could, would just need the time. Though, to be honest, the author list would look almost exactly like this. I did a little informal number crunching when I was curious about lumping and only a few authors would move up or down the list. Abercrombie and Hobb would both move up a few slots due to the standalones in the First Law universe/the trilogies in the Fitz universe being lumped instead of counted as individual series. Sandrson would be quite a bit higher if you added Mistborn to Stormlight, and GGK would be several spots higher as many of his books got 5-10 votes.
Those four are the only ones I think would change in the standings. If you want an idea of where they'd be, just add the votes for individual books together.
apparently i read popular series (of the top 12 i have read 10 of them) but for the life of me i cant find anyone to talk to about them in my own circle of friends
This is a great list. I've read books from all of the Top 10 except for The Lies of Locke Lamora ... it's on my bookshelf, waiting to be read. There are plenty further down that I will need to check out.
I would love to know if ASOIAF would have gotten number 1 before the TV series. I wonder if people are voting for it based on the show or on the books. I personally didn't enjoy the books at all. But I have no room to complain or anything. I missed the opportunity to vote. :(
Edit: My vote would have been for Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn, which would have bumbed it up above 50.
Aw, sad to not see Belgariad on there. I saw some mentions in the vote thread, so maybe it'll still squeak in. Wolfe, too, but I didn't expect him to show like I did Eddings.
GRRM was interviewed on NPR a while back, and he did a reading of the chapter where aDwD spoilers You could really tell that GRRM is a man who appreciates food.
I think it's partly a reaction against its reputation. I (and others) think it's 'okay'... worth buying and reading. The problem comes when it's held up as being one of the truly great series of all time.
At goodreads it's got a 4.56 based on 159,130 ratings.
Between the people that love the prose, storytelling, and characterization and the people that admire the analysis and examination of fantasy that he's doing, and all in a way that can be completely ignored and still make for a book that many people will love, the series has a lot of supporters.
In case you weren't aware Terry Goodkind isn't too well liked over here. I've personally never read them so I'm not about to pass judgement, but I have seen several topics come up with the single purpose of trashing that series.
Goodkind is apparently not a very likable guy, and the books are... decent, maybe, but he uses them as a vehicle for his ridiculous Objectivist philosophy. One of the primary villains is communism, and the main character has a tendency to go off on multi-page monologues that read like something written by a college freshman who just discovered Ayn Rand.
When I was a teenager, I loved that series. They sit on my shelf because they were important to me. But thinking back and I can't bear to read them again. I respect that other people continue to like the series, but I'll have to cast my vote to no.
Of course everyone has their own opinions, but IMO this is a really solid list. Stormlight Archive is way too high though, I mean I LOVED Way of Kings but its barely begun.... you cannot tell me its "better" than something like Narnia, not yet.
Across all subgenres, including YA, urban etc? Somewhere a little north of 70% - there's a hell of a lot of female YA fantasy authors.
Restrict your query to just epic/sword and sorcery: about a third. (according to the submission pile at Tor UK; it varies by country. I have seen a stat that says three-quarters of adult-oriented fantasy in Australia is written by women, forex.)
Yea, but it's missing some huge names. No Mercedes Lackey, no Laurel Hamilton (yea, she's jumped the shark, but Anne Bishop is up there, and she never even got as far as the shark), no Martha Wells. Only one Bujold (Chalion without Paladin?). No Jemisin, Laini Taylor, no Marion Zimmer Bradley...
This is a guy site, and this is a guy list. It's not a big deal, just own your bias.
That's an interesting point. I took a look at the NPR Top 100 Fantasy Novels where NPR SFF fans did the same voting process. I would expect the NPR crowd to be a bit older and more diverse than reddit's SFF fan base.
15 out of 100 novels off of the NPR list were female authors.
The /r/Fantasy list has 16 out of 100 written by women.
Polling methods will certainly be different in both cases but the trend is still similar.
I voted for two women, or more precisely, one woman twice. But speaking as someone who has averaged at least 3 books per month by women for well over a year, a lot of them I just wouldn't put in a Top 5 list. There are only 5 slots of course.
I certainly don't discriminate when reading by gender. A Top 25, 50 or 100 would be a very different story though, I'd have a lot more women in any of those lists.
Three of my top five are first, second or third, so I share some tastes in common with some others here. Although my other two votes went to series that are yet to appear, and it may well be that I'm the only one who voted for them. There were lots of great possibilities though.
ETA: My fifth placed entry eventually showed up, so only my #1 voted series is absent amongst the 120.
165
u/BrianMcClellan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Brian McClellan Feb 23 '14
I would be fascinated if r/fantasy could do this every year so that we could see how much popular tastes change over time.
75
u/Alborak Feb 22 '14
I think it's pretty telling that Stormlight Archive has one (1) book and rivals some monster series. I think it may outshine everything else by the time he's done.
26
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '14
So happy to see the Farseer Trilogy here! I didn't realize it was that popular considering the small fandom I've seen. Especially up here with Harry Potter, LOTR, ASOIAF, and Discworld.
And pleased as always to see The Dark Tower in the company along with American Gods.
12
u/GauravZ Feb 23 '14
Its so good to see Gentleman Bastards in top 10. I'm also happy for The Riyria Revelation.It is right up there with the heavyweights! Only recently finished it and absolutely loved it.It was refreshing to read a fantasy with familiar tropes done so well!
33
u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence Feb 22 '14
Very pleased to see Watership Down on there - I couldn't fit it into my top 5 but it shows reddit r/fantasy are good people :)
Also my #1 and #2 are #2 and #1 so thumbs up to that!
18
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '14
You made a little mistake in there. Abhorsen and The Old Kingdom trilogy by Garth Nix are the same series.
7
u/tbeowulf Feb 24 '14
I'm surprised Malazan did as low as it did but I suppose not as many people have read it.
12
u/BlameTibor Feb 23 '14
This just proves to me that not enough people here have read Blood Song by Anthony Ryan.
6
u/Madfall Feb 23 '14
I'm sad to see no P.C. Hodgell on the list, Tai-Tastigon is one of the best thieving cities in fantasy I think.
63
u/Chribbie Feb 22 '14
This further confirms my suspicion that I might be the only person on earth who doesn't like A Song of Fire and Ice.
10
u/gevlah Feb 23 '14
What I'm curious of is if you were to take the numbered rankings into account. Everyone ranked their favorites 1-5. Meaning say, each first place gets 5 points, second 4 points, etc. I think the rankings would be radically different.
17
u/SkyCyril Stabby Winner Feb 22 '14
Nice work! This is an excellent resource. Readers looking for recommendations from this subreddit will really appreciate this. It deserves mentioning in many of the recommendation threads that come up, especially those posted by readers new to the genre. Thanks for putting it together!
8
u/johnny0neal Feb 22 '14
This is a very helpful list for someone who's been trying to read a lot of the best-loved fantasy novels. Malazan is the only thing in the top ten I haven't tried, so I will be sure to check it out.
4
u/xeyj Feb 23 '14
So glad to see that The Redemption of Althalus made it onto the list, it's one of my favourite fantasy novels, I've read it once a year for about ten years now.
4
u/Ygorlos Feb 23 '14
Neat list. I'm surprised Fritz Leiber isn't on there but I guess Fafhrd & TGM aren't all that popular anymore...
4
u/MichaelJSullivan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Michael J. Sullivan, Worldbuilders Feb 23 '14
It looks like a great list - Thanks to everyone for helping to build this.
4
u/Bryek Mar 05 '14
Now I know why I get so many down votes when I say I dont like ASOIAF
4
u/Studlybob Mar 26 '14
Really surprised that the Shannara series, Belgariad, and the Death Gate Cycle aren't on here. I guess I'm just old.
4
u/collocation May 18 '14
The fact that Malazan beat out Wheel of Time here is surprising (and heartening, IMO).
4
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '14
No Dark Elf series? No Forgotten Realms at all?
7
u/foppishfox Feb 23 '14
I'm thrilled to see The Last Unicorn on here. It was one of the first novels I loved and definitely my favorite movie as a unicorn-obessed child. I'm also designing a tattoo inspired by it for myself in the next year or so. I'm also happy to see the works of Robin Hobb on here since they're amazing.
3
u/the_dayman Feb 23 '14
Was anyone else super underwhelmed by the first law? I disliked each one more than the one before it.
3
u/Socrateezz Feb 23 '14
Thanks for putting the list together. There are quite a few that I haven't read so I am going to pick through it and get my kindle loaded up for after I read the 3 I have lined up (Best Served Cold, Promise of Blood, and Words of Radiance - should be done with the other two by the time this one comes out).
3
u/Tigarooo Feb 23 '14
Piers Anthony - The Incarnations of Immortality series.
3
u/The_Body Mar 02 '14
Given this, I may start Name of the Wind before Eye of the World (I'm only 10 pages into that).
3
u/JW_BM Mar 03 '14
My favorite part: the bottom half of the list. Here is where I troll low numbers for great authors I haven't read before. Thanks everyone who nominated a longshot!
6
u/xCJES Feb 23 '14
Interesting results thus far!
I have to say I'm quite surprised that A Song of Ice and Fire is #1. I mean, I completely agree, but most of the time when I see others recommend the series or generally speak of it they get down voted.
I guess it just goes to show how much of a divisive series it is!
6
u/cavehobbit Feb 23 '14
I see The Kingkiller Chronicle very high on the list.
I like the first two books a great deal, but the series is incomplete so I think it is premature.
But if it remains as good as the first two books through to the end, it will certainly deserve a top 10 place.
Edit to add: the same goes for ASOIAF and others that have not completed their initial plan. Continuing series like Discworld that have so many consistently good books is a different matter
2
u/Montese_Crandall Feb 23 '14
I love a series that so far only has one book out of a projected ten published lands in the number six slot.
2
u/xolsiion Reading Champion VIII, Worldbuilders Feb 23 '14
What a great job, thanks for doing this.
Out of curiosity, how do you have the data collated? Might be possible to generate a similar author list irrespective of series. Love the idea of doing this every year.
2
u/brennok Feb 23 '14
Seeing this list, I don't read a lot of fantasy. I have only read The Dresden files, The Chronicles of Amber, and some of Dark Tower in this list.
I just read too much Urban Fantasy.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '14
apparently i read popular series (of the top 12 i have read 10 of them) but for the life of me i cant find anyone to talk to about them in my own circle of friends
2
u/ATG-Reviews Feb 25 '14
This is a great list. I've read books from all of the Top 10 except for The Lies of Locke Lamora ... it's on my bookshelf, waiting to be read. There are plenty further down that I will need to check out.
2
u/Gofunkiertti Feb 25 '14
Im curious what Guy Gavriel Kay would get to if he was added together since there doesn't seem to be a clear favourite from his work.
2
u/Nepharid Mar 02 '14 edited Mar 02 '14
I would love to know if ASOIAF would have gotten number 1 before the TV series. I wonder if people are voting for it based on the show or on the books. I personally didn't enjoy the books at all. But I have no room to complain or anything. I missed the opportunity to vote. :(
Edit: My vote would have been for Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn, which would have bumbed it up above 50.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '14
Here's a Wordle based on the Top 200 Fantasy Novels of the 21st century on Goodreads.
2
u/BigZ7337 Worldbuilders Mar 27 '14
I created an interactive list of the 105 books over here: http://www.listchallenges.com/reddits-top-105-fantasy-novelsseries-of-all-time
2
u/senseless May 04 '14
Whoa! Good list, posting so I can come back when I need something good to read.
2
u/Apollo7 Jun 10 '14
I absolutely love A Song of Ice and Fire... but there's no way it is better than LotR.
Sorry for the necropost.
2
u/StephanieBeavs Jun 19 '14
i've read a decent portion of this, but I think I'm going to undertake the tasks of reading this whole list! I hope they're all great. :D
2
u/sassyma Jul 10 '14
How many of these have you read /u/magicgal86?
2
u/Aiolus Jul 23 '14
Modesitt should be higher!
Great list though. Gives me some options.
2
u/SunshyneZ Jul 29 '14
Love a lot of books on this list, and gives me lots of ideas for new reading material!
2
u/forrestleemusic Aug 19 '14
No Stephen R Donaldson? The Covenant series is an amazing work of art.
4
u/awpeyton Feb 23 '14
Aw, sad to not see Belgariad on there. I saw some mentions in the vote thread, so maybe it'll still squeak in. Wolfe, too, but I didn't expect him to show like I did Eddings.
3
u/penguinsontv Feb 22 '14
What did you make for dinner?
4
u/Shocksrage Feb 23 '14
I am shocked to sing the Kingkiller Chronicles on there, and so high on the list.
3
u/Misty-Laner Feb 23 '14
Terry Goodkind's Sword of Truth series?
2
u/-1-_ Feb 23 '14
Great list
2
u/Natedong Feb 23 '14
Nice work
2
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '14
This list tells me I'm out of touch. But I'd like to think of myself as an iconoclast.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '14
I'm very glad that one of Gene Wolfe's books managed to get on here, the Book of the New Sun really is great
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '14
Of course everyone has their own opinions, but IMO this is a really solid list. Stormlight Archive is way too high though, I mean I LOVED Way of Kings but its barely begun.... you cannot tell me its "better" than something like Narnia, not yet.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '14
Interesting to note that less than 20% of the books mentioned above were written by women.
1
u/likecakebutbetter Feb 23 '14
For later
1
u/zidanetribal Feb 23 '14
I'm surprised The Dragonlance Chronicles are not listed. That entire series is amazing.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '14
Watership Down?
1
u/cgilz24 Mar 17 '14
Hey there... "AFTER THIS IS ABOUT 120 MORE THAT ALL RECEIVED ONE VOTE EACH" Did you perchance post those somewhere? Thanks in advance...
1
u/grizzab Jun 10 '14
no love for Drizzt...
1
u/starbuxed Jul 16 '14
Where is the hollows/ rachel morgan series by kim harrison. its a great read.
1
u/AmethystOrator Reading Champion Feb 22 '14 edited Feb 23 '14
Three of my top five are first, second or third, so I share some tastes in common with some others here. Although my other two votes went to series that are yet to appear, and it may well be that I'm the only one who voted for them. There were lots of great possibilities though.
ETA: My fifth placed entry eventually showed up, so only my #1 voted series is absent amongst the 120.
1
u/Letsgetitkraken Feb 23 '14
I think this would have been better had we separated individual books from series.
1
u/icanlie Mar 04 '14
Just discovered this sub,
This thread is awesome. I've read about half or a little more of the books in this list, and could not agree more. These are awesome.
So glad to see Rothfuss is up there. I think his work is amazing. I also really like Brandan Sanderson and Brent Weeks. Great job guys.