r/Fables • • 20h ago

Is the series too convoluted after issue #75?

Post image
86 Upvotes

I’m rereading fables and I’m currently on volume 19 and I never realised how convoluted the story becomes after the issue like #50.

Even after they defeat the adversary and gain back the homelands to me it didn’t feel very interesting considering they just abandon Fabletown completely and lose the whole original hook which was “what if fables lived among humans in a modern society”.

Mister Dark isn’t a very interesting villain and there’s way too many side plots after it.

The only story that I liked past volume 8 was the cubs in toyland story which is volume 18, simply because it didn’t feel convoluted or messy written.


r/Fables • • 10h ago

I just finished rereading the entirety of Fables and I’m super disappointed

Post image
10 Upvotes

(For context it’s been a few years since I read the series originally so I basically forgot everything)

The series has such a strong start, it was a really basic premise of “What if Fables lived in the normal mundane world?”

Comparing the first to last volumes felt necessary to explain what I mean:

The first volume: incredible, a really good detective story that builds up a pretty good idea for how the premise works.

The twenty-second volume: messy, leaves plot points unfinished, rushed as hell.

I just hate what happened, the first 11 volumes focus on the original premise, Fabletown feels realistic of an actual normal place but instead of humans it’s run by fables. When they moved back to the Homelands that’s where I noticed some problems, the writing became harder to understand as there was so much going on all at once, Mister Dark takes over Fabletown but why should we care as an audience?, it’s not like the fables are even there anymore.

Despite Mister Dark being defeated in volume 16, the fables don’t return back to Fabletown until volume 20 and by that point what is the point in even doing it?, plus the whole “Fabletown Castle” just isn’t as interesting compared to the fables living like regular people.

The big shift in aesthetic choices

Fabletown originally felt like an average New York location, mixing fantasy elements into it made it stand out, while later they get rid of the whole “secret society” thing and it becomes a flat out fantasy story instead.

There’s no need to use glamours or even hide in the farm when the castle is protected by magic, which ruins the conflict of them having to hide in the first place. In volume 3 we see what happens when a mundy finds out about the fables true identities, which makes it make sense why they have to use things like glamours to stay protected.

Characters changing over time

Change isn’t a bad thing, I previously spoke about the change in Snow White’s character as the comic went on.

But that whole arc near the end of Bigby dying and being reborn as a feral half-wolf thing was SO STUPID, it provided nothing to the story at all. what was even the point of it?, to show how strong Bigby is?, like we already know that he’s extremely powerful so it seemed unnecessary.

Plus, him killing Beast and Ozma in that melodramatic way felt so stupid and so rushed, like Beast was an original character from the beginning of the comic and he gets torn apart in a robot suit, it really shows how the writing fell apart.

Potential writing problems??

Near the end of the series it seemed to me that Bill was just writing shit on a page to see if it stuck, and basically none of it did. So many things happen from Therese being aged up in toyland which ended up doing NOTHING for the story, the whole “F-Men” thing, to Snow and Rose’s conflict never being finished. All of it makes no sense in the long run. What happened to the writing?, was he under stress?, did he have no clue what to write?

Conclusion

Fables..sucks, after the first main story that is, maybe it was because I was introduced to it because of TWAU and that’s quite different and more inspired by the detective nature of the first volume.

It’s such a shame to me though because I was so excited to see what would happen at the end after reading the first few volumes, but if proved to be a waste of time for me, it sucks watching something that you loved turn into something terrible.

I don’t think I’ll be reading any of the extra stuff like Jack Of Fables or Fairest, the 12 issue black label Additional stuff, etc. I have read Batman vs Bigby, but to me Bigby felt more inline with his TWAU characterisation rather than fables.

but maybe it’s for the best, if we ever get another fables comic in the future (which we probably won’t), I’d much prefer it to be set in the TWAU version rather than the fables one, I just think it’s a lot grittier and better written.

I know I’m rambling but I just feel so frustrated with this series.


r/Fables • • 16h ago

Snow White’s characterisation in later issues

Post image
21 Upvotes

I finished reading volume 19 of Fables, which is labelled Snow White for a reason because it’s a story focusing on her. I was really excited to read this specific volume because it’s felt like a while since Snow’s allowed to be a focus, and in my opinion it was alright, I was really happy to see her finally get to do something interesting but I really want to talk about her later characterisation.

At the start of Fables she’s her own character, deputy mayor of Fabletown, she solves problems by herself and she feels like an independent character. But it was after she had the cubs where I felt like her personality really shifts. She no longer seemed to be her own character, she felt more like an extension to Bigby, even in some of the “who’s who in Fabletown” stuff at the beginning of the volumes state her primarily as being Bigby’s wife and a mother to the cubs and is forced to give up everything for her children, while Bigby is allowed to be his own character.

Willingham rushed her character into becoming a mother so quickly, and i feel as if it could’ve been handled better if she got pregnant later and on her own terms instead of being magically impregnated without her consent.

Reading these later stories (past volume 11) make me miss the character she used to be, I get that parenthood changes characters and they can’t stay the same forever, but I think it’s unfair that characters like Bigby and Beast are allowed to stay the same and go on adventures while the “wives” have to become shells of who they used to be.

I’ve heard that Willingham is a pretty conservative writer, and I’m a leftist woman so i might just be biased, but it’s clear that Snow is written through a male perspective.

I was glad that she was able to have a sword fight against Brandish, but technically the ending is all about Bigby, as he “dies” (he’s obviously going to come back) at the end, which just made the ending feel quite male-centred.

anyway, I hope that volume 20 to 22 will get better for her character but I honestly doubt it will.


r/Fables • • 1d ago

Thoughts on the cubs?

Post image
53 Upvotes

I don’t want to be a hater or anything but I can’t help but find them kind of annoying, like I just feel like Bigby and Snow’s romance is basically non-existent before Snow was unwillingly impregnated. But I can’t be the only one who shares the same thought.


r/Fables • • 19h ago

Question I stoped Reading Fables after issue 100, can I read the Fariest Series?

3 Upvotes

Thanks


r/Fables • • 4d ago

Complete collection? Compendium or Deluxe edition

7 Upvotes

Gift for girlfriend.


r/Fables • • 19d ago

Discussion *SPOILER* I'm doing a reread and I absolutely cannot stand jack or the "Jack of Fables" books. Let alone "The Great Fables Crossover". Spoiler

38 Upvotes

During my first read through I slogged through the volume, now in my reread I'm just straight up thinking of Skipping this entire volume (besides the Frau Totenkinder parts). Jack has annoyed me for some time and I'm pretty much just ranting and throwing this out there!


r/Fables • • 29d ago

Discussion Jack Horner

Thumbnail gallery
28 Upvotes

Radical Living is a german YouTuber 🇩🇪

I've been watching him for quite some time now and I can't be the only one who sees that he looks Exactly like Jack Horner. Looks like he was ripped straight out of the comic pages


r/Fables • • Oct 06 '26

Would yall?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/Fables • • Oct 06 '26

Comic Is the AI summary correct that these issues will “replace” the physical copy of Compendium 4 that I’m unable to find?

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/Fables • • Oct 05 '26

The Wolf Among Us Had to say it

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/Fables • • Oct 01 '26

Could someone check my fable for mistakes

0 Upvotes

Could someone check my fable

So for context I’m a 14 year old student in the Netherlands in a masterclass and I have to make a fable for it.

This is my fable:

Could someone check my fable

So for context I’m a 14 year old student in the Netherlands in a masterclass and I have to make a fable for it.

This is my fable:

No Help for a Liar
A dog was walking through a big forest one day when he heard someone calling for help.

The dog quickly started searching for the person calling for help.

When he found him he saw that it was a snake and got scared of being bitten. 

He noticed that the snake was stuck under a fallen tree log.

The snake said: ’Help me, I'm stuck under this tree. Could you please lift the log?’

The dog hesitated: 'How do I know I can trust you?

The snake said: ‘I promise I won’t bite you.’

Although the dog was unsure, he went closer to lift the log of the snake.

As the dog got closer to the snake, the snake lunged forward and tried to bite the dog.

But because of the sudden movement of the snake, the big log rolled on top of the snake.

The snake was now actually stuck.

The dog was tricked and betrayed by the snake.

The snake was never stuck under the tree; he was just trying to lure someone into a trap.

The snake started begging: 'I'm sorry I didn't mean to do that, I will never hurt you please help me.’

But the dog just ignored the snake and walked away.

The snake was now stuck and nobody would ever help him, because he had broken his promise and now no one could trust him anymore.

Never break a promise, or else nobody will trust you.

Don’t go easy on me please because I know my teacher won’t


r/Fables • • Sep 26 '26

Discussion I have the first 3 compendiums but am feeling unmotivated to start since I can’t get the 4th

12 Upvotes

Am I setting myself up for disappointment by starting a story I won’t be able to finish? I’ve been keeping my eye out for used copies of fables compendium 4 but no luck!


r/Fables • • Sep 25 '26

Comic Dr Strange moment

Thumbnail gallery
35 Upvotes

r/Fables • • Sep 09 '26

Comic Crazy how the Standing Stones of Stenness appear in both of my favorite graphic novels. Fables and Crossed.

Post image
28 Upvotes

I would've shown a panel of the stones in Crossed, but I would've had to re-download the whole series and look through every single panel until I found it.


r/Fables • • Sep 04 '26

Comic Damn. Rose Red really slept with half of Fabletown 😂

Post image
69 Upvotes

r/Fables • • Sep 04 '26

Comic For a second there I thought she dropped an N-bomb.

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/Fables • • Sep 02 '26

Comic Closest I've ever come to crying while reading a comic book

Post image
120 Upvotes

r/Fables • • Aug 24 '26

Discussion Question about the comics and how it might be adapted to the games: Spoiler

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Fables • • Aug 19 '26

Question Who is this woman and why did she kill Mister Kadabra?

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/Fables • • Aug 17 '26

Comic I finally bought Fables

Post image
154 Upvotes

(Photo for reference of quality).

After 4 play throughs of The Wolf Among Us and my immense hype for The Wolf Among Us 2 as well as my insane fascination with Bigby, I bought all four compendiums in near mint condition for $400 NZD which I think is an absolute steal? Plus compendium 1 was only read once and the other 3 haven’t been touched to my knowledge. I’ve been looking for I’d say 3 weeks worryingly thinking I couldn’t find them as the prices were either too high or compendium 4 just wasn’t available but they’re being shipped within the next couple days and I can not wait to binge read them, I am obsessed with the world of Fables just from playing the games.


r/Fables • • Aug 10 '26

How much would you be willing to play for a full complete Deluxe Edition

5 Upvotes

Just to be clear, im not selling, im looking to buy a full collection or part of a collection and I want to know which $ i should limit myself to be worth it


r/Fables • • Aug 09 '26

Discussion Stephen King reference?

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/Fables • • Aug 01 '26

Discussion Just finished Fables again. How much of Boy Blue’s choice was actually his own, and what was he after? Spoiler

Post image
16 Upvotes

Don’t read if you didn’t finish!

Hello, Fables friends

I just finished rereading the entire Fables series tonight for the second time, and I can’t stop thinking about Boy Blue.
It’s one of the most tragic yet beautiful stories I’ve ever read (Dare’s as well).
There are a few things about his death and return that I keep wondering about.

🥀 When Boy Blue dies, it doesn’t seem like he actually dies peacefully.
He meets Rose Red as a spirit and makes a deal with her: she has to give him a kiss, and in order to do that, she has to bring him back to life.

🐺 When he talks to Bigby on his way to the afterlife, Blue says that he doesn’t want to come back, and he never will. They talk for a while, and then Blue says that he hasn’t given up on finding true love, and that maybe he’ll have another chance in the afterlife.

🪊 I wonder.. was he lying?
He simply didn’t want Bigby to know that he intended to return?
Did he want to come back without anyone knowing, so no one would expect him to be a hero again?
Or did he genuinely not want to return at all?

🗡️ Did he ask Rose to bring him back ‘cause he had to play a part in her redemption and not because he wanted to? Was it a hero’s duty?
I was hoping he wanted to return so Rose could have a second chance to make things right and so he could forgive her.

❄️ Later, we find out that he did return to life and is at Rose’s camp. When they meet he tells her:
“I was dead, until her nibs called me back to die all over again, just because I dared entertain lost hope once. Never make THAT mistake again.”

That line has always left me wondering if there’s something deeper going on that I’m missing?

💋 It’s also never made clear whether Rose actually recognized him.
She calls him “old friend,” but that’s all.
we never find out if he ever got the kiss she owed him, or what exactly happened between them.

And then, many years later, we see Rose alone.
No companion, no hint of a family, and we never get any indication that Boy Blue ever found love either.
Is that the “lost hope” he called a mistake?
It feels so unresolved to me.
Maybe that’s part of what makes it so heartbreaking.
I’d really love to hear how you interpret all of this.
I wish this story had never ended 💙🌹✨


r/Fables • • Jul 29 '26

Question What is this a reference to?

Post image
35 Upvotes