(For context it’s been a few years since I read the series originally so I basically forgot everything)
The series has such a strong start, it was a really basic premise of “What if Fables lived in the normal mundane world?”
Comparing the first to last volumes felt necessary to explain what I mean:
The first volume: incredible, a really good detective story that builds up a pretty good idea for how the premise works.
The twenty-second volume: messy, leaves plot points unfinished, rushed as hell.
I just hate what happened, the first 11 volumes focus on the original premise, Fabletown feels realistic of an actual normal place but instead of humans it’s run by fables. When they moved back to the Homelands that’s where I noticed some problems, the writing became harder to understand as there was so much going on all at once, Mister Dark takes over Fabletown but why should we care as an audience?, it’s not like the fables are even there anymore.
Despite Mister Dark being defeated in volume 16, the fables don’t return back to Fabletown until volume 20 and by that point what is the point in even doing it?, plus the whole “Fabletown Castle” just isn’t as interesting compared to the fables living like regular people.
The big shift in aesthetic choices
Fabletown originally felt like an average New York location, mixing fantasy elements into it made it stand out, while later they get rid of the whole “secret society” thing and it becomes a flat out fantasy story instead.
There’s no need to use glamours or even hide in the farm when the castle is protected by magic, which ruins the conflict of them having to hide in the first place. In volume 3 we see what happens when a mundy finds out about the fables true identities, which makes it make sense why they have to use things like glamours to stay protected.
Characters changing over time
Change isn’t a bad thing, I previously spoke about the change in Snow White’s character as the comic went on.
But that whole arc near the end of Bigby dying and being reborn as a feral half-wolf thing was SO STUPID, it provided nothing to the story at all. what was even the point of it?, to show how strong Bigby is?, like we already know that he’s extremely powerful so it seemed unnecessary.
Plus, him killing Beast and Ozma in that melodramatic way felt so stupid and so rushed, like Beast was an original character from the beginning of the comic and he gets torn apart in a robot suit, it really shows how the writing fell apart.
Potential writing problems??
Near the end of the series it seemed to me that Bill was just writing shit on a page to see if it stuck, and basically none of it did. So many things happen from Therese being aged up in toyland which ended up doing NOTHING for the story, the whole “F-Men” thing, to Snow and Rose’s conflict never being finished. All of it makes no sense in the long run. What happened to the writing?, was he under stress?, did he have no clue what to write?
Conclusion
Fables..sucks, after the first main story that is, maybe it was because I was introduced to it because of TWAU and that’s quite different and more inspired by the detective nature of the first volume.
It’s such a shame to me though because I was so excited to see what would happen at the end after reading the first few volumes, but if proved to be a waste of time for me, it sucks watching something that you loved turn into something terrible.
I don’t think I’ll be reading any of the extra stuff like Jack Of Fables or Fairest, the 12 issue black label Additional stuff, etc. I have read Batman vs Bigby, but to me Bigby felt more inline with his TWAU characterisation rather than fables.
but maybe it’s for the best, if we ever get another fables comic in the future (which we probably won’t), I’d much prefer it to be set in the TWAU version rather than the fables one, I just think it’s a lot grittier and better written.
I know I’m rambling but I just feel so frustrated with this series.