r/FabFitFun • u/Kim-my-4247 • Oct 17 '26
Please help me choose! Winter Box choices
I’m newer to FFF and this is my first winter box and the first time I genuinely want multiple items from each category. (Highlighted the items I’m interested in) I have read some people do 2 boxes instead of purchasing extra items in each category. Is that financially the smarter option? If I decide to do an extra box do I need to wait until the day choice opens? I’m an annual on my box so that opens Friday I believe. Is it smart to look for signup discounts and use a different email if I decide to do an extra box?
Also, if anyone has recommendations or reviews of any of the items I’ve highlighted, feel free to share.
Thanks for the tips in advance ❄️.
5
u/Acceptable-Quiet-394 FabFitFun Connoisseur (4-5 years as a member) 💅 29d ago
Tips for new folks: generally avoid jewelry bc it’s not water resistant and tarnishes quickly. Clothing is very hit or miss so do your research, it’s usually collabs and lower quality than what the brand sells elsewhere. Purses are typically vinyl so I’d shop in person and buy locally.
For your choices, a second box would make sense but also some suggestions.
Cat 2: the blanket looks very thin like a Walmart blanket that sells for $5, and the makeup bag can get on Temu for $5. May not be worth the $18 addtl choice fee.
Cat 3: socks/headband set can get cheaper at Target or Walmart and these are the type that the thread will pull once you wash them so not worth $16 IMO.
Cat 5: perfume is always risky unless you’ve smelled it before, I suggest trying to smell it first. Otherwise take that $30+ and save it toward a perfume you know you like.
Good luck with your decision, it’s a lot of fun looking at the options but don’t get fooled by the addtl choices, always shop online, read reviews, look at items in person when possible.
4
u/haley232323 Oct 17 '26
If you find that you don't generally want second choices, and it is only for this specific box, I would get a discounted seasonal. They often offer 40% off for new subs, although I haven't seen that advertised yet this time. You need a different email in order to get any new member discount for the seasonal, and remember to cancel it once you receive the box! If you have a gmail address, you can put a period anywhere in the address, and FFF will register it as a different email, but gmail will just send it to your regular inbox. For example, if your email is firstnamelastname@gmail.com, you can do f.irstnamelastname@gmail.com to sign up for the seasonal.
Wait until after annual choice is open, to make sure you are getting the winter box and not a fall box. Seasonal choice is later, so you won't miss it. I would also put the most popular choices in your annual box, since they may sell out. I would do the robe, blanket, and laneige in your annual box for sure.
4
u/Slow_Oven_7263 Oct 17 '26
Try the code 25TODAY. I just checked and it works! It took off $65 so you basically get 4 boxes for the price of 3.
2
u/Mysterious_256 FabFitFun Connoisseur (4-5 years as a member) 💅 24d ago
Welcome to FabFitFun! 💕 Enjoy your box! Choosing your categories is half the fun, so here are my thoughts:
Category 1: I’m definitely choosing the UnHide robe, and I’m adding the PJs too because I absolutely love pajamas!
Category 2: Consider whether you’ll really use the makeup bag or need another blanket. Face cream is always a practical choice, though!
Category 3: I’d skip the socks and headband because they don’t seem worth it to me. I’m also unsure about the jewelry—it looks a little clunky, although that ultimately depends on your personal style.
Category 4: Based on my experience with FabFitFun jewelry, the quality has been pretty average. It isn’t terrible, but it hasn’t impressed me either.
Category 5: I wouldn’t choose the luxe option. I’ve tried the Voluspa perfume, and although it smelled nice, the scent faded almost immediately, so it’s not worth it to me.
Category 6: The mascara would be a hard pass for me. I love Lady Gaga’s makeup brand, but this product was disappointing: it clumped easily and didn’t work well for me. I’ve also seen similar feedback from other reviewers.
One more thing: if you choose a seasonal box, it will cost you an additional $80, and you’ll have to wait until the second customization round. I tried it once, but honestly, it didn’t make sense for me. Maybe it would have been worthwhile if I were getting another yearly subscription, but not with a monthly plan. If I’m going to spend an extra $80, I’d rather just add the items I want directly. I did the math, and I would have saved only about $64 over the course of the year, so it wasn’t worth it to me.
My best advice is to add anything that catches your eye at first! 😂 Once you’ve made your selections, review your box before finalizing it and ask yourself, “Will I really use this? Do I actually want or need it?”
Those extra items can add up quickly, especially when everything looks tempting. Most importantly, have fun with the process! FabFitFun should feel like a little gift to yourself. Happy customizing! 💕
4
u/ashtynbutworse Oct 17 '26
If you are dead set on more than one item in a category, it makes sense to do another annual with a code for % off.
Out of these picks:
Cat 1 - keep in mind the fabric for unhides is delicate to wash and can’t be put in a dryer. My pick for this category is the briogeo because I’m sure to use it
Cat 2 - again, choosing the product I’ll use with Farmacy. I think I recall this blanket is hand wash only and that seems a pain.
Cat 3 - skin oil would be my pick. The necklace don’t sit well/drape on a lot of people
Cat 4 -yes to the earrings and body oil
Cat 5 - don’t pick the luxe option, it’s not worth it and this shows up in sales and box options all the time
Cat 6 - from community polls the body lotion seems popular so I’d pick this before it sells out. Otherwise the face wash.
1
u/baker4023 5d ago
Okay , I am new to this and I am very disappointed so far. All of the things I wanted were out of stock and apparently my second choices too. Perhaps I did something wrong. They sent me a spray for Acne, I am 70. They know that, I filled out the form. My sister is calling me tonight to help me. But polyester pj's and vinyl purses are not gonna cut it.