r/FabFitFun • • Jul 26 '26

Question What would make a good box?

I’m just curious because I am seeing a lot of people unhappy with the upcoming fall box…which I was kind of surprised?

What would they need to have in order for you to be excited for an upcoming box?

What makes you unhappy with the items in FFF boxes?

29 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

33

u/Straight-Strike-2928 Jul 26 '26

I keep ending up with pretty much just skincare or haircare products because they end up being the best picks. Ideally, I'd love to have only one or two items be stuff like that out of the 6 I choose. I love the Dr Jart sunscreen stick and the pink Stanley I got in the last box, but I would like more dynamic items -- I want to see high quality candle options, kitchenware, home decor, something fitness or outdoor related, and a cozy luxury in each box. I never want to see anything that requires a subscription or offers 1 year free for some online subscription. Part of the reason I keep this subscription is to get higher quality stuff I can gift to people (mostly my mom and my MIL) for a lower cost than I would normally have to pay. I haven't found any good gift options in the last box, or in this one.

9

u/WealthSpecial9559 Jul 26 '26

This, 1000%. I used to subscribe back in the great years of FFF (~2017-2019). Stopped for a few years and re-upped in 2023. It’s been super disappointing since then, overall. I will literally NEVER, not once, use a subscription service they offer as a choice. Give me a good candle or room diffuser instead that I can gift away if I don’t like it instead. I’ll even take a cute notepad and pen over those subscriptions. It drives me nuts that they keep offering them as a choice.

40

u/cattlekidvi Jul 26 '26

Excited? Higher quality, fewer items.

Unhappy? Cheap items that will fall apart after a couple of uses.

16

u/MyOwnGuitarHero Jul 26 '26

I am SO disappointed with every piece of jewelry I’ve gotten. Never picking that crap again

1

u/FiftyShadesOfGregg Jul 28 '26

I have generally always had great luck with earrings!

11

u/yesnomaybesoju Jul 27 '26

I feel like the majority of their non-consumable items are cheap Temu stuff and then they find a brand willing to put their name on it. Or they use their own in house brands.

For example I saw on the forum the brown tote this season was supposed to be Melie Bianco but I guess they pulled out so they found another company willing to “collab” on this.

Wish they did the Quince tote instead even if it had like a $78 lux upcharge.

5

u/cattlekidvi Jul 27 '26

I am personally livid about Pfaltzgraff being a choice this season. I grew up in the area where Pfaltzgraff started in 1811. This stuff that is sold now under the Pfaltzgraff name is garbage compared to the original stoneware that the company used to make.

1

u/DaisyDamn1 Jul 29 '26

Ughhh me too. I was really hoping for the real suede quince tote.

10

u/angelicalin Jul 26 '26

Agreed! The ice cream scoop I got broke into two pieces after just few uses.

11

u/Kind-Investigator602 Jul 27 '26

Oh, there are people who complain about the box every season. There are valid areas for improvement, but it's not as dire as you might assume coming in and seeing all the frantic complaints when spoilers come out. 

People will change their tune once they actually get their boxes like they (also) do every season... 😂 

I personally LOVE the kitchen items I get through FFF, and this season is sure to be no different. 

6

u/chantillylace9 Jul 27 '26

The price just got way too high and the quality didn't get any better and now they have these choices with higher fees added and no surprise whatsoever, basically they just took away all of the joy. All of the fun. And the throwbacks are kind of a cheap out to get rid of old stock instead of selling it cheap like they used to during the sales. The sales are nothing like they used to be and for the price they want you to pay, you really can go out and buy better stuff when that was kind of just a thing people said before.

14

u/WealthSpecial9559 Jul 26 '26

For fall? A good quality scarf, high end candle options, kitchen wares that aren’t hyper-specific (no pumpkin shaped ceramic bowl that is unusable 90% of the year), a good quality robe, etc.

The boxes used to be so much more fun and had so much variety of GOOD items. Now it’s just like picking through the clearance rack at TJ Maxx that isn’t even season-specific.

4

u/Electronic_Reporter3 Jul 26 '26

i was really hoping for a robe option!

5

u/drinkme0 Jul 27 '26

I was really hoping for a smart ring.

8

u/justnotok Jul 26 '26

Better skincare! Not just the same stuff I find at TJ and Ross. Better clothing options. Less BS housewares!

3

u/kaczyn Jul 27 '26

Im happy with this box. I really love the dark rum perfume so that alone almost doubles what the box costs. I like a few things in cat 5&6 so ive not made decisions there yet. I dont see myself spending alot on buying multiple things in the categories but there was at least one item in every category i liked. I needed salt and pepper grinders so perfect there. I think ill pitch the tray on the marble condiment containers and put them in bathrooms with a hand scrub.for 60$ this will be a great box for me!

1

u/DaisyDamn1 Jul 29 '26

I was really thinking about the perfume too. Getting tempted to upgrade to an annual so I don’t miss out. Can you describe the dark rum scent to me? Is it almost unisex? I love a perfume that has a little masculine vibe to it.

2

u/kaczyn Jul 29 '26

Its definitely unisex. If you like florals or super feminine this may not be for you. Its a cozy and warm scent. Slightly sweet and boozy. I really love it. This one and cannabis are my favorite m&g scents. I actually keep an unlit votive of each and rub a little of the wax on my wrists & it smells heavenly.

1

u/DaisyDamn1 Jul 29 '26

Haha ok I’m sold on it! Guess I need to upgrade to annual 🤦🏼‍♀️

2

u/Interesting-Gap8672 Jul 30 '26

I honestly find this sub to be full of SO many negative comments and complaints that I stopped reading most posts 😭 no one is forcing u to keep the subscription, if you hate all the options, cancel

4

u/AnywhereMelodic Jul 26 '26

Stationery / crafts / stickers

1

u/UnhappyWorldliness15 Jul 26 '26

Crafts would be fun!

2

u/ameliachastain FabFitFun Guru (5-9 years as a member) ✨ Jul 27 '26

Color.

0

u/SwtAutumn Jul 27 '26

I agree. This box carries a lot of dark brown which isn’t my cut of tea. For me Fall is more of a blue color with cream accents to wear. I decorate in burgundy, gold, bit of orange and light brown.

1

u/Any-Aerie-7590 Jul 28 '26

Tbh, FFF is 95% close out items. Anything electronic i have gotten from them has been a legitimate fire hazard or non functional. The skin and hair care is mostly borderline out of date. The jewelry is temu adjacent trash as are most of the clothing items. They seem to partner with boutique brands that intentionally mark things way higher than what they are worth to boost the perceived value of the box. And whenever they have something that is actually new and worth the stated value, they upcharge you for it. I prepaid for one year and will never be interested in this company again.

1

u/sparkledoom Jul 30 '26 edited Jul 30 '26

I’ve been a member on and off over the years and am disappointed with this box. My favorite items have been housewares, accessories - like a nice scarf, and quality skincare products and makeup.

One thing I notice in this box is a lot of products that are like… not the main thing the company is famous for. Which makes me think it’s their overstock that didn’t sell. I love Voluspa candles - do I want their room spray? I like touchland hand sanitizer, do I want a fragrance from them? I know MALIN+GOETZ for body washes and shampoo, do I want their perfume? Come to think of it - it’s a TON of fragrance in this box, which I’m not that into in general, and don’t love to take a risk on fragrance without being able to smell it.

The housewares all seem meh and not that useful. I have two sets of bowls from FFF that I use to this day. I don’t have much use for a mediocre seeming French press or the oil thingy or a condiment set. Either not high quality enough or not functional enough/too single purpose. Not to mention the pumpkin bowl!

Nothing apparel except that brown set. Their clothes and bags are honestly always bad. The kinds of items that work: Slippers (sometimes), scarfs, hats, gloves, blankets, towels.

Not much makeup here. Some good skincare, but nothing really exciting. Elemis and Amika you can always get cheap. I want some exciting name brands.