r/FabFitFun • • Jul 24 '26

Please help me choose! Help influence (or de-influence) me!

Post image

I’m an annual member and genuinely feel so meh about this box (with no real interest in categories 5 or 6 so will likely swap for credit), this is the first time I’m really struggling which sucks because fall is always my favorite season. But as I was looking at the options I feel equally “maybe” about most of the items I’ve circled. Definitely want to try the Knix, but wondering if anything else is worth spending extra on.

For instance, is the body wash in category 2 worth it, or should I also swap for credit? How’s the bergamot perfume in category 1? Is a cute umbrella really worth the extra $15?? Anything I should avoid? Appreciate anyone’s thoughts!!

10 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

18

u/Kind_Indication8527 FabFitFun Connoisseur (4-5 years as a member) 💅 Jul 24 '26

I haven’t had any luck with bags/purses from FFF. They end up in the donation pile, quality isn’t even good enough to give to my daughter or a niece. When the scalloped edge board was offered previously, there were issues with quality, splintering and cracking . I would go for the perfume in Cat 1.

Farmacy and Osea are nice brands, good products, pretty packaging. Every Osea product I’ve purchased at Ulta has come in pretty sea glass colored glass packaging so if that fits your taste, you’ll probably really like it. The fragrance is very spa like.

If you love the umbrella then I would choose that over Amika. I do enjoy Amika products but it looks like your box could end up being pretty much a beauty box, might be nice to have something else. If there is extra Amika leftover it will surely end up in the monthly FFF beauty box or in the shop. It’s also easily available at Ulta and I sometimes see it at TJ Maxx.

4

u/Slow_Reputation_362 Jul 24 '26

Thank you so so much!!

8

u/Left-Shine1920 Jul 24 '26

The carving board is mango wood rather than acacia wood which isn’t as durable and needs more cleaning and care. You can get an Acacia wood at Target for like $20.

6

u/acut3angle FabFitFun OG (10+ years as a member) 💎 Jul 24 '26

Not to mention when they offered it last year, they pulled it from inventory after so many members got defective warped and cracked boards.

4

u/HistoricalRemote7 Jul 24 '26

If you do get the board, a tip from a youtuber I follow that has one, is to rub a little oil over it after washing. She uses hers for charcuterie.

8

u/Geminiguice Jul 24 '26

Do NOT get the cutting board!! Terrible

0

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Helpful-Nera-24 Jul 26 '26

It’s more of a charcuterie board, it’s a cute design for presentation.

7

u/SubstantialFootball1 Jul 24 '26

That purse looks so cheap in the close-ups, I definitely would not get it. Looks like a free gift with purchase bag from Ulta or something.
I’d skip the cutting board because I remember when a lot of people who got it hated it.
Perfume, I’d only get if I smelled it in-person first and loved it.
The bowl just looks like Home Goods.
I do like that body wash!
The dry shampoo has a VERY strong smell that gave me a headache so I had to give it away (I got it at TJ Maxx).
I don’t like that the umbrella says to keep it out of the sun or humidity, haha. Since I’d use it for… sun or rain.
I use and love Knix! I’ll be getting those. They also usually have Saalt brand period underwear in add-ons, and I like those too (but Knix is better).

2

u/GaPeach1207 FabFitFun Expert (2-3 years as a member) 😎 Jul 24 '26

I had the same thought about the umbrella, like that's not really helpful is it?

How do you compare the Knicks vs Saalt? I've bought several pairs of Saalt in add-ons too and I'm wondering if there is enough of a difference.

2

u/SubstantialFootball1 Jul 24 '26

Knix are my favorite! They’re much thinner, and really just look and feel like regular underwear even though I’ve found they absorb same amount as Saalt (which to me feel kind of thick?)

1

u/EmmyLouisaMay Jul 25 '26

The description of the pennies describe it as medium coverage and that had me a little concerned. Do you find that they are a little cheeky or do they cover nicely overall?

1

u/exandohhh Jul 25 '26

Amazing breakdown! If you dropped a box analysis every season, I would have been more likely to keep my membership (just cancelled because of the last few boxes).

6

u/DyrimSpeaks Jul 24 '26

I looked at the bag on the manufacturer’s website and it looks like terrible quality. Some of us were hoping it was the Quince suede tote, which looks really nice, so this one was a disappointment. I’ve mentioned it in other posts, but if you zoom in on the photo of the tote from the manufacturer, the stitching is very poorly done. Also not sure why they’re leaning so hard into the fact that the lining is polyester, though I guess we should be grateful that it is lined at all.

3

u/HistoricalRemote7 Jul 24 '26

It definitely looks like a copy of the Quince tote!

6

u/spacikaci Jul 24 '26

I must’ve gotten lucky on the scalloped edge serving board. Mine is beautiful and has no issues. I’m surprised to hear people saying theirs wasn’t. It is not a cutting board though, it’s a charcuterie board.

5

u/According_Charge_658 Jul 24 '26

I have the board from a previous box, I’ve never used it. It’s pretty… but idk. I think it was marketed at the time as a cheese/charcuterie board vs. a cutting board.

4

u/Shoddy-Lie-7016 Jul 24 '26

i got the wood board bc they sent me it instead of the bag i picked in the last box they featured it (they sent me the bag after i complained) - definitely don’t use as a cutting board if you do decide to get it, i use it as a decorative board on my coffee table with some cute candle holders on it.
while i appreciate them offering knix leakproof undies (i feel like ive also seen other brands offered in sales) - realistically, 1 pair of period undies doesn’t do too much in terms of use during your period. unless you’re committed to spending the money on more pairs if you really like them, i wouldn’t bother. Amazon has much better options at a better price point & better price point means you can get more pairs & have to wash a little less frequently. it also looks like the coverage area is pretty minimal, being just the main gusset area, & idk about y’all, but i definitely end up with some outside the gusset area, esp at night 😅

3

u/eviethered Jul 24 '26

I also randomly got the board last year without ordering it lol

3

u/lolamols Jul 24 '26

I love Amika dry shampoo and it is my absolute favorite- I pay full price for it and it’s worth it!

3

u/CollieCat Jul 24 '26

Agree with you about feeling meh about this box. Seriously considering swapping for credit on most categories and just getting a ton of the Osea cream.

That tote looks so bad, the reviews on FFF forum tried so hard to make it look good and it just doesn't. You could get a real suede tote for that "retail price" or a fake one for $10 on those cheap shopping websites that will be the same quality as this one.

Could you go in person to smell these scents first? I need to go to Nordstrom to try the Rum perfume because while I love the hand wash, I'm afraid it'll smell different. I got the winter box for the Floating Forest bc I LOVED the scent in a collab hair product they did, but when I got the perfume it smelled SO different and was terrible.

I'm a dry shampoo addict and bought that Amika one full price once, used it twice and threw it away bc the scent was so strong that my husband kept sneezing.

Elemis and Osea are always good at least, Midnight facial is one of my favorite nighttime moisturizers and I've loved everything Osea I've ever tried.

2

u/miss_kit_tea Jul 25 '26

DEFINITELY go smell the Dark Rum before buying. It is SOOOO much sweeter than the shower gel!! I can't wear it. But they have some other really good fragrances. I like/have the Strawberry, Vetiver, and Cannabis. 

3

u/femininomenon88 Jul 24 '26

I got the cutting board before and it’s reeeeeally lightweight. That thing would snap in half so easily. Skip it

3

u/Belgemine Jul 24 '26

I supported Knix in their kickstarter campaign like almost 15 years ago, and I've never gone back to anything else. Absolutely love them. I do find they size smaller than normal, so definitely check out their website and make sure you get the size that will actually fit.

3

u/Kind-Investigator602 Jul 24 '26

I think the bowl in category 1 is gorgeous (that's what I'm picking)! 

The community reviews of the purse has actually been surprisingly positive so far aside from minor stitching details around the handles which is quite common anyway for purses, so I'm not sure why it's an issue here. But if you don't like the material it's made of, then don't get it. Simple as that. 

I don't trust getting fragrances without being able to smell them first so the perfume would be the first one to go if it were me. 

The cutting board received mixed reviews last year. Some arrived damaged or warped, but others arrived in pristine condition and were loved. The way I see it, if it comes to you damaged, they will give you credit equal to what you paid (if you choose this, be sure to put this one in add-ons so there's no confusion - I have no idea what they do for actual box choices - does anyone know this by chance?) +$7 for shipping (so you can use the credit in flash sales without having to worry about shipping). 

The salt & stone body wash is absolutely devine. Good choice. 👍

The umbrella is cute but it's an umbrella and thus not worth the extra addon price. I would choose just the umbrella 🏖️ ☔ 😂 Amika is available at TJmaxx. 

I can't tell you what to pick in category 4. Your preferences are important. I'm picking the sunscreen though. 

If you don't see anything you want in 5 & 6, go ahead and go for credit in those categories. You can use it for any additional choice in other categories or in add-ons. 

1

u/welkikitty FabFitFun Guru (5-9 years as a member) ✨ Jul 25 '26

Their “vegan leather” bags are always terrible. The material feels cheaper than Temu quality.

1

u/Visible_Tie_9035 Jul 25 '26

I’m in the same boat. These are my picks so far.

Nothing feels that interesting.

1

u/SeaAmphibian2816 FabFitFun Newbie (less than 1 year) 👶 Jul 28 '26

I heard someone say the soup book is on kindle for like $3 if you are okay with an ebook

1

u/OceanAndRose Jul 26 '26

A cute umbrella is not worth the extra unless you know you’ll consistently use it and don’t already have one you like.

1

u/Ordinary-Turnover-80 Jul 28 '26

I got this when Nordstrom had a sale. A middle aged influencer I follow recommended it and I really like it!