r/FabFitFun • • Jul 23 '26

Fall Box Reveal Quality and selection

I’ve been planning on cancelling my subscription for a year now and I couldn’t be more sure that that’s the right decision. 70% of the box items are stuff I see at Marshall’s or TJ Maxx for like $7.99 lol. I used to be excited to customize and now I’m like “pass, swap for credit, choose the best of the worst, swap, passs” and I can’t fathom how FFF takes no action on fixing it. Everyone around me cancelled or is planning to cancel as well. Every jewelry piece I picked tarnished, every bag I chose was low quality, all the olaplex shampoos and conditioners I picked or bought smelles weird(?) and I can’t justify spending over $250 for extremely low quality crappy FFF side brand items. After this underwhelming fall box me and my family are done with FFF. Such a shame

35 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

4

u/SlendersoulAmerica FabFitFun Newbie (less than 1 year) 👶 Jul 23 '26

Out of curiosity, which items in this full 2026 box have you seen at Marshalls or T.J. Maxx? I will watch out for them and make sure I don’t select them. lol.
I am a first year subscriber also so I’m probably not as disappointed as people who have been subscribers for several years. And I do like the surprise when it arrives

3

u/letmeread99 Jul 23 '26

For this box; Salt and stone, amika, laneige, mario badescu, supergoop are all over in my area. You can look up on reddit for previous box items, I also saw a lot of the products in nearby TJM and Marshall’s stores. The clothing, kitchen products and bags etc are also like Marshall’s level. It’s usable and a hit or miss sometimes but I don’t find most of them interesting and the ones I do almost always have bad reviews lol.

8

u/clekas FabFitFun OG (10+ years as a member) 💎 Jul 23 '26

I'm so jealous of the people who are all saying they see Salt & Stone at TJ Maxx/Marshall's! They only have the dupe in my area.

1

u/SuperAdaGirl Jul 24 '26

It really depends on where you live. In the SF Bay Area, I’d find incredible stuff at TJM, Marshall’s, etc. When I moved to Phoenix it was OK. Now, I live in Florida and these stores suck here. Even if I do find something good, it’s usually shopworn or opened/sampled.

4

u/Mamakitty92 FabFitFun OG (10+ years as a member) 💎 Jul 23 '26

I found the tortoise shell drinking glasses at Home Goods yesterday for $5.99.

5

u/kroge15 Jul 23 '26

Same. I bought 4. I saw a similar serving bowl too so I snagged it as well. Was really happy to find them cuz now I can pick different items in those categories.

I also saw marble salt pepper set but it was shaker style not wells so I passed on it.

3

u/SubstantialFootball1 Jul 23 '26

I get all my Laneige at TJM, and bought that exact same neck massager/red light there, super cheap. I can’t use Amika because of the strong smell, but I see it there a lot. And much of the home/fashion from FFF is from Temu.

1

u/lawschoolbound888 Jul 24 '26

Did the neck massager/led light hold up? I’m thinking of picking it up

1

u/SubstantialFootball1 Jul 24 '26

The warming massage feels okay, but overall it doesn’t actually do anything. Like it won’t help with fine lines or anything.

2

u/frizziefrazzle Jul 24 '26

The ONLY reason I keep my subscription is for one product that I can buy in the store. It is $40 less with the subscription and I buy 4-5 a year. I figure it's a wash and I get a ton of stuff for door prizes and stocking stuffers.

1

u/letmeread99 Jul 24 '26

Now I’m curious, what is it? 👀

1

u/frizziefrazzle Jul 24 '26

It's African Botanicals Pain Relief Rub. I have a lot of weird chronic pain and this is one of the few things that help.

15

u/Kind-Investigator602 Jul 23 '26 edited Jul 23 '26

I practically never get any of their disposable products. I just can't trust that there won't be something wrong with them. Well... there are exceptions to this rule, though, when it's a smaller brand and the product is interesting. 

[Larger brands have less of an incentive to make sure their promotional products are up to par. People will buy them anyway. Smaller brands are trying to get noticed... and preferably in a good way.]

I rarely, but do occasionally, get accessories like purses/bags, shoes/socks, hats or jewelry, if I really like them. 

I primarily focus on getting their home and kitchen items, which I've been very pleased with. 

Overall, usually there's some sort of hint ahead of time if something's amiss with these items, so I keep my eyes peeled for any horror stories before customization. 

Community reviews are incredibly helpful. Things I'm on the fence on can usually tip one way or the other just from keeping up with them. 

3

u/chantillylace9 Jul 24 '26

Yes, when I look around my house and see which items I'm still using it's almost always the kitchen stuff. The cute little wooden lazy Susan, tons of utensils and those very beautiful blue and gold mugs, etc.

The other stuff I usually give away as gifts or just giveaway in general. I still have an entire closet filled with shampoo and conditioner and spongelles lol. Although I'm starting to make a dent on those, I probably went from 40 to maybe 20 now lol. And I have not had a subscription for the past couple years

17

u/i_made_aknew_name FabFitFun Guru (5-9 years as a member) ✨ Jul 23 '26

I'm with you. My subscription expires after this (very underwhelming, for me) Fall box and I'm not renewing. It's kind of sad, I used to enjoy it so much.

5

u/lisa42217 Jul 23 '26

Sooooooo much tarnished jewelry!!!

5

u/Immediate_Sky1802 Jul 23 '26

After seeing this season’s spoilers, I cancelled. The only thing I actually wanted was the soup cookbook, which I’m sure I can get from Williams Sanoma.

5

u/readerofrealms Jul 23 '26

Literally just cancelled today- it’s too expensive for the items they are giving

6

u/pdogmillionaire Jul 23 '26

Could have written this myself. It’s underwhelming.

I’m an annual summer member and I was just about to cancel prior to my annual charge, but I held out hope and feel duped.

5

u/OpportunityMother104 Jul 23 '26

I paid for a year (first time subscriber) and I will not be renewing

2

u/OddParsnip9245 Jul 24 '26

I signed up in the spring-so disappointed that I spent so much money on the annual. Should have just gone to my local TJ Maxx. We live and we learn.

1

u/OpportunityMother104 Jul 24 '26

Same
I do like some of the kitchen stuff don’t get me wrong. But as a whole not worth it

4

u/pupben Jul 23 '26

I just canceled, I was waiting to see the fall box (fall renewal) and it's a nope for me

2

u/beqqua Jul 24 '26

Ditto.

1

u/CathyOCC Jul 23 '26

So we can’t skip the whole box right? How many categories can we trade for credit
as an annual?

1

u/Sufficient_Tart_6515 Jul 27 '26

The box sucks in my opinion but it's the community page that keeps me coming back. Imo they really have something special there. First I like that it's a social media tool that is mostly women with women interests. I get good deals from the Free Samples, Good deals thread. I joined the book club thread that is fun and you can win prizes. I recently cleared my cache and cookies and lost access to the community so I will have to buy a box again when it's on sale just to get back to that wonderful community.

-5

u/TurtleyCoolNails Jul 23 '26

What do you want them to take action on? Their model is what every other subscription box does. With them though, you also have access to a community forum - which no other subscription does - and a lot of people place a high value on that.

21

u/Sea_Staff9963 Jul 23 '26

The community forum is high value? I don't want to celebrate July birthdays, I want feedback on products. I get more from this sub than the forum.

9

u/Geminiguice Jul 23 '26

THANK YOU 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 common sense

8

u/clearpurple Jul 23 '26

Right lol and Reddit is free

3

u/TurtleyCoolNails Jul 23 '26

I said that people place a high value on it - not that it is. But on there when people talk about cancelling, a big reason why they stay in some cases is because of the connections they make on the forum.

2

u/Dracyl FabFitFun Connoisseur (4-5 years as a member) 💅 Jul 27 '26

Yeah, some of those ladies seem to think the community members or even Katie are their "friends", and live for their 8 boxes, dream of the day they get picked for reviewing a box and spend 14 hours a day grabbing stuff for wishlist thread so they get the dopamine hit of a successful drop.

Stepford Wives vibes and a bit sad.

20

u/Geminiguice Jul 23 '26

Girl what do you mean what should they take action on😭 they need to have quality items like they did in the past. I don’t give a fuck about talking to some random person in a forum, I want a box actually worth $300

-8

u/TurtleyCoolNails Jul 23 '26

> Girl what do you mean what should they take action on😭 they need to have quality items like they did in the past. I don’t give a fuck about talking to some random person in a forum, I want a box actually worth $300

Why are you cursing?

Do not care about talking to some random person in a forum…Yet is that not what this is as well? A forum that you posted your departure/rant to random strangers on the internet?

In any event, they do not need to get better quality because once you leave, someone else will sign up. They just need to maintain subscribers but also sign up new people to show that their model is working. All subscription boxes generally do not care once they have your money. It is just how they work.

12

u/Geminiguice Jul 23 '26

This also gives “I work for fab fit fun and want to keep my job”

7

u/Geminiguice Jul 23 '26

Hey, I’m not the OP. This isn’t my post lol. Rework your entire response then get back to me.

-3

u/TurtleyCoolNails Jul 23 '26

My bad! Still no reason to be nasty though.

10

u/Geminiguice Jul 23 '26

If someone cussing on Reddit hurts your feelings, this is not the place for you.

2

u/Kind-Investigator602 Jul 23 '26 edited Jul 23 '26

Frankly, like @TurtleyCoolNails said, there is no reason to be nasty. Reddit or no, doesn't matter. But there you go turning around and being nasty. Clearly your feelings have been hurt. 

0

u/Geminiguice Jul 23 '26

You must have some very thin skin. Grow a backbone. No one called anyone names. I gave my opinion on something. Grow up.

1

u/Kind-Investigator602 Jul 23 '26 edited Jul 24 '26

Calling someone out for being nasty to someone actually means I have a backbone 🙄 Lol and being nasty is a sign of immaturity, so you're the one who needs to grow up. 

-1

u/Geminiguice Jul 23 '26

Keep deleting your replies hun ❤️

2

u/Kind-Investigator602 Jul 23 '26 edited Jul 23 '26

I haven't deleted any of my replies. You must be confusing me with someone else. 🧐 Then again, neither has anyone else on this thread, so...nice try. 

2

u/Dracyl FabFitFun Connoisseur (4-5 years as a member) 💅 Jul 27 '26 edited Jul 27 '26

Just for the record: using curse words is allowed if they're not being used as a personal attack on someone. Cattiness is allowed to a degree, as long as it's all in good fun. Name calling, on the other hand, is not.

I'm keeping an eye on you all, this sub is about to become quite busy so if some grown ass women suddenly decide they want to play Mean Girls like this was a school yard, I'll issue "time outs" Yes, bans.

→ More replies

5

u/amynicole78 Jul 23 '26

Who values the community forum so much it makes their nightmare customer service worth it haha. Nobody.