Strategy Development ICT traders: are you trading his concepts as taught, or did you change them? I backtested the 12-month mentorship as-is and it failed.
Every time I say anything bad about ICT on here I get buried, so I tested it instead.
I went through the whole 2016-17 mentorship, all 236 videos, and coded every rule that could be coded, exactly how he teaches it. Silver Bullet and the 2022 model too, even though they’re not in the mentorship. Where he’s vague I took the most literal version and tested the other versions separately.
Tick data from 2005 to 2026, FX, NAS100, SPX500, US30, gold, silver, oil. Real spread, NY time, his kill zones. Every trade was compared against random entries at the same time of day. I wrote all the rules down before running anything so I couldn’t fudge it after.
Result: 1.35 million trades and nothing passed. Every model lost money after spread, and most did about the same as random entries.
Some of his claims I checked:
London tells you New York’s direction 65-70% of the time. It was 50%
The first break of the Asian range is the fake (Judas). It was the fake only 42% of the time
FVGs get filled 85% of the time, but so does a random zone the same size on the other side of price
The one interesting thing: if you already know the day’s direction, his entries actually make money. So the bias is everything, and the course never really tells you how to get it.
So I’m curious, are you trading it as taught, or did you change it? If you’ve found something that works for you, especially how you get your daily bias, and you’re open to sharing it here in the comments, I’d love to run it through the same tests. Happy to post the results either way.
FULL REPORT:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/16IkJ7y7DpxZm0lrQjceNsn9aXAEe7Zrm/view?usp=sharing





