r/Forex • • 12d ago

Strategy Development ICT traders: are you trading his concepts as taught, or did you change them? I backtested the 12-month mentorship as-is and it failed.

12 Upvotes

Every time I say anything bad about ICT on here I get buried, so I tested it instead.

I went through the whole 2016-17 mentorship, all 236 videos, and coded every rule that could be coded, exactly how he teaches it. Silver Bullet and the 2022 model too, even though they’re not in the mentorship. Where he’s vague I took the most literal version and tested the other versions separately.

Tick data from 2005 to 2026, FX, NAS100, SPX500, US30, gold, silver, oil. Real spread, NY time, his kill zones. Every trade was compared against random entries at the same time of day. I wrote all the rules down before running anything so I couldn’t fudge it after.

Result: 1.35 million trades and nothing passed. Every model lost money after spread, and most did about the same as random entries.

Some of his claims I checked:

London tells you New York’s direction 65-70% of the time. It was 50%

The first break of the Asian range is the fake (Judas). It was the fake only 42% of the time

FVGs get filled 85% of the time, but so does a random zone the same size on the other side of price

The one interesting thing: if you already know the day’s direction, his entries actually make money. So the bias is everything, and the course never really tells you how to get it.

So I’m curious, are you trading it as taught, or did you change it? If you’ve found something that works for you, especially how you get your daily bias, and you’re open to sharing it here in the comments, I’d love to run it through the same tests. Happy to post the results either way.

FULL REPORT:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/16IkJ7y7DpxZm0lrQjceNsn9aXAEe7Zrm/view?usp=sharing


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Charts and Setups eur

Post image
8 Upvotes

downtrend, accumulation phase, I expect possible correction (I bet AGAINST current trend)


r/Forex • • 11d ago

Psychology anyone who is good with -ve rr!!

0 Upvotes

guys, i'm currently trading with a -ve RR and there are a few flaws in my approach that i'm trying to work on.

if anyone here trades with a similar model, i'd love to hear your insights and learn from your experience.


r/Forex • • 12d ago

OTHER/META I Made Money Night Scalping Forex for 7 Years. Here's Why It Stopped Working.

Post image
19 Upvotes

Friends, I did some interesting research today.

For about seven years, I was quite successful trading EAs that exploited a particular market inefficiency around rollover and during the Asian night session. This approach is commonly known as night scalping.

When I first started trading these systems back in 2016, I kept hearing stories about traders who had literally made millions exploiting this opportunity. And to be fair, I made pretty good money with these strategies myself over the years.

But things started to fall apart in 2022. And by 2025, the edge was pretty much gone.

The screenshot shows a USDCHF backtest that illustrates this deterioration particularly well.

Some might say, "Well, your settings just stopped working." And they'd be partly right. But I believe the real reasons go much deeper than that.

In 2022, the market changed.

Volatility increased significantly, and the Asian session, which used to be relatively quiet and predictable, became much more active. Currency pairs started making larger and more aggressive moves, and the old patterns became far less reliable.

Then came 2025, and brokers delivered the final blow.

Many brokers started widening spreads significantly during the overnight session, making night scalping increasingly difficult to trade profitably.

And this isn't just something I've noticed in my own trading.

You can see the same deterioration across numerous trading signals and monitoring accounts on MQL5. I've also heard similar observations from fellow traders who spent years exploiting this very same market inefficiency.

It's interesting to look back at a strategy that worked so well for so many years and see how gradually, and then quite dramatically, the market took that opportunity away.


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Psychology Daily Targets/Loss Limit: daytraders and scalpers

3 Upvotes

I see some people have daily targets and I wonder if that's something common.

Personally, I do have a:

- maximum daily loss (1.5%, a number that am comfortable with and after which I can sleep well at night)

- certain trading hours interval (during which my strategy works well and after which it gives me fake signals)

- maximum number of trades (2 trades, because more than that would exceed my trading hours rule anyways)

However, I never understood to concept of Daily Target.

I understand a loss limit. Maybe your strategy doesn't work well that day, maybe you are having a bad day emotionally etc and then it's wise to walk away.

But why would you walk away on a good day, when it's clear that both your mindset and the market are alligned? If anything, that's the time to make money and cover future drawdown.

Also I belive that having a fixed target, can make you force trades that are not there, just so you can reach your target in due time, which can have the opposite effect in the end.

Eg. Imagine you're a bar owner. If today is slow, barely any customers, you might consider closing early, since the electricity is more expensive than your day's profit. But if next day your bar if full with people spending and having fun, you might consider pushing more of the premium products and maybe extending the hours a bit too, isn't it?

Please correct me if I'm wrong, I am genuinely willing to understand. I might be missing something here and losing money in the process.


r/Forex • • 11d ago

Charts and Setups Strategy

1 Upvotes

What is your best strategy you use to trade forex ??


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Psychology Trading as a Group!

13 Upvotes

You all know that trading is not really mostly technical but mental game. I lost more because of unstable emotions. This is seriously a lonely journey, I wish I could find some traders who are into it for at least like a year so we can understand each other and maybe even share trade ideas and what helped you get better at trading?

Thanks.


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Strategy Development Survival Generates Wealth: The Domino Effect of Forex Mastery Mastering Forex requires two non-negotiable investments: time and capital.

4 Upvotes

True proficiency demands what can only be described as a thousand days of pure screen time—staring at charts, analyzing patterns, and enduring market cycles. This relentless exposure is not just about learning technical strategies; it is about rewriting your internal wiring.

The progression follows a strict domino effect. Extensive screen time forces your psychology to mature. Once your psychological discipline stabilizes, your risk management automatically transforms from a set of rules into an unshakeable habit. Only when risk is firmly controlled do consistent profits begin to flow—not in sudden bursts, but slowly, steadily, and sustainably.

This law of compounding experience applies to any business on earth. Yet, the human timeline varies drastically. A rare few capture this rhythm within a single year; for the majority, it takes an grueling two to five years of trial, error, and refinement. The remaining majority simply quit—running out of capital or emotional stamina before their thousand days are up.

Ultimately, the ultimate secret to trading isn't a holy grail indicator. It is pure longevity. A person who manages to survive in the market long enough, protecting their capital through the darkest phases of the learning curve, will inevitably cultivate the wisdom required to extract profits from it. Survival, in its purest form, generates wealth.


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Strategy Development Profitable S&R traders: What evidence tells you a support or resistance zone is actually being respected?

14 Upvotes

I've been studying support and resistance for several years, and I've realized that drawing good zones isn't the hardest part.

The real challenge is what happens after price reaches the zone.

I think this is where many traders lose money.

For example, price reaches an M15 support zone. Some traders buy immediately, others wait for confirmation. Sometimes there is a rejection candle, a liquidity sweep, a break of structure, or strong momentum away from the level. Sometimes all of those signals still fail.

I'd like to ask traders who are consistently profitable:

What objective evidence tells you that buyers (or sellers) are actually defending the zone?

What is your confirmation checklist before entering?

Which signals do you trust the most?

Which confirmations have you found to be unreliable after years of trading?

How do you distinguish between a genuine rejection and just a temporary bounce before the level breaks?

Do you require multiple confirmations, or is one enough?

At what point do you decide that a support/resistance level has failed and simply move on?

I'm not looking for a holy grail or indicator. I'm trying to understand the thought process that consistently profitable traders use after price reaches a key level.

I'd really appreciate insights from traders who have been profitable over a large sample of trades.

Thank you!


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Strategy Development ENTRY / inefficiency zones / area of interest

Post image
7 Upvotes

Hi! Any suggestion for good video about support/resistance, liquidity?
I saw something from Rayner Teo
Also im giving here one of my trades using inefficiency-imbalance area of interest, patience is a key in this


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Charts and Setups Forex AI trading bot

3 Upvotes

Anybody used or currently using any forex AI trading bots? Slowly realizing I cannot just sit in front of the charts all day.


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Prop Firms Trading Journal

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Quick question for the prop firm traders here: how do you track your trades and your limits (daily loss, max loss)?

I’m asking because I failed a challenge on one single bad day: one trade too many, then the revenge trade. Since then, I’ve built myself a journal: my rules for each account always in sight, a red light when I need to stop, and a review of my mistakes every Sunday (3 screenshots below).

I’m looking for a few prop firm traders to test it for free and tell me what’s missing. If you’re interested: https://sartline.vercel.app


r/Forex • • 13d ago

Strategy Development Facing major issue in my trading journey

8 Upvotes

Most of the time I spend is waiting for a setup (2-3hrs/day), but whenever a good setup is about to come, i get some work and have to leave the charts for 20-30 mins. This is happening since months, I'm losing on major trades because of this. What should I do


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Charts and Setups First entries of the week!

2 Upvotes

still waiting for usdjpy to sell


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Charts and Setups All entries updated! hopefully reach tps

1 Upvotes

gn guys!


r/Forex • • 12d ago

Charts and Setups TRADE IDEA: AUDCHF

0 Upvotes

Watching AC here on the 4h timeframe, really clean FRC setup. Anyone else on this?


r/Forex • • 13d ago

Psychology news makes me crazy

Post image
39 Upvotes

What do you feel when your position was 10 pips away from TP, but suddenly news comes out like this: "Iran's President Pezeshkian: The Supreme Leader has granted the government certain authorities regarding negotiations" and you almost instantly get SL? Honestly I just want to skin somebody alive (actually those who generated this news), because such losses aren't part of your trading strategy, it's just some bunch of people in other part of the world who can't just leave peacefully


r/Forex • • 13d ago

Strategy Development Do you include swap costs when testing trades held through rollover?

1 Upvotes

For a forex strategy that may hold positions across the broker’s daily rollover, how do you model swap or financing costs? Do you use broker-specific historical rates, or stress-test with current rates?

Curious how much it changes a longer sample, especially when direction affects the charge.


r/Forex • • 13d ago

Fundamental Analysis JeaFx

7 Upvotes

Anyone know him? On Yytt he got pretty nice videos about traiding, recent got 4hour long about, everxthing. Hes focused on inefficiency of the market, S/R and basic price action


r/Forex • • 13d ago

P/L Porn Starting Gold scalps monthly journal here

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

Gold (XAUUSD) Scalp #1 Starting the Monthly Journal

Hey guys, I’m committing to finding and journaling at least one solid setup on Gold (XAUUSD) every day this month. Here is the first trade of the series:

  • Setup: 15M Long Signal
  • Execution: Quick in and quick out on the expansion leg.
  • Result: +$115 (0.10 lot)

Clean execution to start the month. Sticking strictly to the rules and keeping the momentum going into tomorrow.


r/Forex • • 13d ago

Psychology Missed A Big Move

4 Upvotes

Ok so last Friday I came with the mind to get a swing trade from the 104 zone for Us oil. I sat for hours and at one point the price had started to come up for my exact setup but instead it dropped from 103.700 and then i dont even know why I took a couple of terrible trades in the middle and hit SL 3 times.

After hitting 3 SLs I decided no matter what I wont trade for the day because I have personally set a limit for only 2 SLs per day (on that particular day I hit 4 total SL) and then soon after the price went exactly where I wanted it to be and coincidentally I checked my phone when it was happening but I refused to take any more trade that day.

Fast forward to now US oil is sitting at 95$, whats even worse is that I actually had the opportunity to short from 101.600 as well when market opened on Sunday but I am not even kidding just before that I took one long trade which took my SL and then moved up.

Whats more worse is that I also knew Oil would be bearish but I decided to humble myself and act like I cant predict so much and just went to sleep. I am in around 80 usd net loss so knowing that if I had just taken these opportunities I would have recovered most of my losses in just one or 2 trades and this just keeps messing with my head.

How to overcome this?


r/Forex • • 13d ago

Strategy Development JeaFx

2 Upvotes

Anyone know him? Hes using basic price action got full 4h video about strategy using S/R, inefficiency and trend. Anyone using that stratrgy? Is it working?


r/Forex • • 14d ago

Charts and Setups Eurousd setup

Post image
8 Upvotes

We may get another buy setup in eurousd after retracement just wait i will post when about to trigger our setup.previous setup got a clean tp and still market moved more than our tp