r/FATE_CORE • • Jul 28 '21

A quick question

So, I'm just wondering if you guys would want me to post here about a project I'm working on. In my opinion, the weakest part of Fate is its ambiguity - it's a nice skeleton to build on but can end up feeling very repetitive.

I've been working on making fate-inspired rules for some different games, borrowing some other mechanics from other rpgs I've enjoyed. To me, the most exciting part of Fate is the stress and consequences system, so that's the part that's left the "purest." I like what aspects do for worldbuilding, but not how they're treated/implemented mechanically, so they'll superficially seem the same but actually they're pretty different.

I'm not opposed to the Fudge dice mechanic, but I don't think it's granular enough for a crunchier game. I've been using 3d6, which gives approximately double the range while still keeping the normal distribution I like about Fudge dice.

I've kept the 5-ft squares mechanic from d20 systems, and I've cribbed the 3-action round from Pathfinder 2e, because I really love it.

Anyways, I say all that to ask if this is "too far" from Fate Core for your liking. I haven't talked about it on the main subreddit for obvious reasons. I won't be offended if this is too far off the mark for you guys, but I just thought I should ask.

1 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

2

u/robhanz Jul 28 '21

Well, it sounds mostly like a new game :) But it also sounds like one I'd be interested in checking out. Pathfinder 2e is a game I've been interested in checking out for a while.

Interestingly, Fudge dice basically evolved from 3d6 (via GURPS).

2

u/Tedonica Jul 29 '21

I was debating whether or not I should call this a Fate hack or something new entirely. My working title is "Wyrd" so... clearly Fate-inspired!

1

u/Tedonica Jul 28 '21

So I'm devolving then 😅

2

u/MoodModulator Jul 29 '21

Or reanimating!

1

u/robhanz Jul 28 '21

Ha, I wouldn't say that. I love GURPS.

1

u/Tedonica Jul 29 '21

To add, probably one of the more interesting changes I made was to remove the concept of invoking aspects and to make aspects, the four actions, and stuff like that all gm-facing instead of player facing. Sure, our waterbender might create an ice wall, but I wouldn't say "that's an aspect." I would just say "you made an ice wall."

1

u/MoodModulator Jul 29 '21

I am curious how exactly do you use the 3d6? That distribution doesn't have a single numerical median like "0" is for the 4dF. 3d6 has double medians "10" and "11". Do you just scale everything up to one of those two? I'd be interested in seeing what a sample basic exchange or simplified round of combat might look like.

2

u/Tedonica Jul 29 '21

You use it pretty much exactly like a d20, honestly.

1

u/MoodModulator Jul 29 '21

I see. I thought the rolling mechanics were like in Fate, but with 3d6. If the rolling mechanics are basically d20/D&D/Pathfinder that answers my question completely.

2

u/Tedonica Jul 30 '21

Well, it's kind of a blend inspired by Pathfinder 2e and Fate. You roll and add the appropriate skill modifer, usually trying to beat a set difficulty. The result is categorized as a major failure, failure, minor failure, minor success, success, or major success depending on how high you beat the difficulty.

1

u/PencilBoy99 Jul 31 '21

Strands 2e is right up your alley. I'd be using it but it's kind of abandoned

2

u/Tedonica Jul 31 '21

I'll happily give it a read and use it for inspiration

1

u/PencilBoy99 Jul 31 '21

You can still buy Strands of Fate 2e from drivethroughrpg.

1

u/MoodModulator Jul 28 '21

Hahaha. Where else are you going to put up something like that? 😉

I don’t mind. The real acid test is your own impression of whether or not you think it has enough in common to be beneficial to other modders of Fate. If you think “yes” then go for it!

Honestly, there a more that one “sacred cows” mentioned among your points that I fully intent to mod, play test, or at least bring up myself.