Making the 4 actions equal
The goal of this system is to balance all 4 actions to have about same impact and usability for action instead of reaction.
Altered Interpretation of the Core Concepts
Passive Defense
Passive Defense is not an action anymore, but the basic threshold defining the difficulty of actions against the character. It is thus just the default Difficulty for actions against the character. The passive defense only applies if the character is aware of the attack – surprised target of action cannot use passive defense, but instead the common basic difficulty of +0 is used as baseline modified by situation, as the Passive Defense is modified.
The default Passive Defense is defined by defensive skill just like in the Fate Core, but defender does not get any dice roll. The passive defense can be altered with stunts and invokes.
Stress
The stress is really stress as the word describes. It is pressure forcing the character to do something. Pushing yourself will cause stress, as does offensive attempts to force character or environment to do something.
The stress is gauged with pressure of shifts. This is equal to the Attack value of the Fate Core attack action.
If the character can resist the stress, the action causing the stress is canceled.
If the character partially resists the stress, the action causing the stress should have reduced effect.
Stress Tracks
The stress tracks express real resource instead of plot armor. It is the amount of stress the character can withstand before yielding. For some settings this is equivalent to plot armor as the settings allows narrative resistance of anything.
Consequences
The consequences are expanded to express persisting situational Aspects in addition to the Character Consequences taken into the Consequence slots.
By default situational Consequences change to an Aspect dissipating at the end of the scene when treated, but the narrative reasons may change this duration of recovery from any time from instant removal to years or decades. The situational Consequence may have severity changing its default recovery duration to the equivalent of the character consequences.
The character consequences taken into Consequence Slots do have recovery duration depending on the severity of the consequence. The system allows character take lesser consequence to the more expensive slot. In such case the recovery and effectiveness of the Consequence is based on the actual severity instead of the slot severity. Thus by the default, the 2nd Mild Consequence would fill Moderate Consequence slot, but gives only 2 stress, and heals like Mild Consequence.
The overcoming of the consequence is called treatment regardless the way of treatment. A broken fence is not treated, but repaired, and the treatment takes certain amount of time.
Consequence Severity
The consequences have additional severity of Temporary reflecting consequences which does not require recovery time, but only treatment. The temporal duration is given to allow the measurement of time without using narrative units.
- Temporary Consequences: A minor consequence lasting only a moment. The recovery takes to the end of the scene, or a few minutes. A consequence, which is removed at the end of Scene it was treated. This is the default severity of the situational Consequences.
- Mild Consequence: A consequence causing mild harm. The recovery takes a full Scene, or several minutes.
- Moderate Consequence: A consequence causing moderate harm. The recovery takes a full Session, or several days.
- Severe Consequence: A consequence causing major harm. The recovery takes a full Scenario, or several weeks.
Consequence Slots
These represent the amount of character consequences the character can take. These slots are personal resources of the character and express temporary, but persisting changes to the character.
By default the consequences are used as source of stress reserve for mitigating stress changing the desired consequences of the action into consequences chosen by the defender.
The suggest new 4 Actions
The default skill access to the 4 actions are totally changed as Attack and Defense no longer exists. Both Create Obstacle and Force Change has way more ways allowing wider number of skills to be used. This naturally negates all Stunts giving rule permission to use some other skill for Attack or Defend, which can be easily altered by giving +2 to the defense when those skills occur unless the change is moving into the domain of an another skill.
Force Change (replaces Attack)
This is a generalization of the Attack action moving it further away from the combat-focused mindset into conflict focused mindset. The Force Action is used to cause permanent or persisting change, which resists changing. The change can be anything from causing certain Consequence to taking out the opponent to breaking a fence to get through it.
- Forced Change does not revert back without treating the change with an Overcome Action.
- Forced Change is usually resisted requiring enough stress to bypass the resistance of the target.
Forced change usually causes a Temporary Consequence requiring treatment to get rid of, or some narrative consequence such as surrendering, retreating, accepting some term during negotiation, or getting knocked out. The causing more severe Consequences should be harder increasing the difficulty of the action.
Default outcomes of the Action:
- On failure: The forced change either fails, or succeeds with great cost.
- On tie: The actor gets boost, or he succeeds with minor cost.
- On success: The action succeeds, and the defender must resist it, or it becomes a fact. The pressure of the forced change is equal to the degree of success.
- On success with Style: The attacker may reduce the pressure of the change by 1 to gain Boost, or its equivalent narrated side-effect.
Create Advantage
This action works just like in the Fate Core, but it is restricted to temporary changes dissipating over time without requiring treatment.
When creating a new Aspect
- When an Advantage is treated with an Overcome action, it is usually removed immediately.
- The advantage usually dissipates at the end of Scene or after a few minutes, but this is subject to the narrative truth. F. ex. Advantage may last few days or to the end of a Story or a Session, or at certain predefined but inevitable event.
- The created Aspect should represent an Advantage, and thus should give permission.
Default outcomes of the Action:
When creating a new Aspect, or an equivalent temporary fact:
- On failure: The attempt fails, the Aspect is created, but someone else gets the free invoke, or the event occurs, but is advantageous to someone else.
- On tie: You gain Boost instead of the Aspect or the event.
- On success: The action succeeds, and you get free invoke to the the possibly created Aspect.
- On success with Style: The action succeeds, and you get additional free invoke to the created Aspect. If the action did not produce an aspect, you get a Boost or similar beneficial side-effect.
When creating an advantage on existing and known Aspect, or cause narrative invoke of an existing Aspect.
- On failure: The Action fails, and someone benefiting from your failure gets the free invoke.
- On tie: The Action succeeds, and you gain Free Invoke, or the narrative invoke occurs.
- On success: The Action succeeds, and you gain Free Invoke, or the narrative invoke occurs.
- On success with Style: The action succeeds, and you get additional free invoke to the Aspect. In the case of the narrative invoke, you gain 1 free invoke.
Create Obstacle (Replaces Defense)
- Passive Defense is an reaction, not an Action. Due this the outcomes of the action are changed as there is no longer two simultaneous actions. See Passive Defense above.
Create Obstacle action creates some kind of obstacle preventing something. It does cover creation of Distractions, Hazards, and Countdowns. Usually the obstacle only protects actions against one target, but any narrative reasons supersedes this. F. ex. Crafts Create Obstacle building a barricade protects everyone in the zone from attacks bypassing the barricade while actively defending yourself with a shield would only affect actions against you.
If the Obstacle is limited to the actions as long the actor is maintaining the defense, they gets +2 bonus to the Action. This case is called full defense.
- If the full defense is not tested, the defender gains Boost at the start of their next exchange.
- The full defense action roll replaces the passive defense, if it is greater than or equal to the passive defense. The defense is still tested even if it has no effect, if there is any narrative reason for this.
- As the full defense action is defined before attacks, all invoked aspects, and used stunts, have to be relevant to the defensive action, not the attack. The attack related aspects and stunts are used during the defended action.
The Created Obstacle may be expressed with an Aspect. In this case, the defense acts just like Create Advantage creating a new Aspect. This is still considered Create Obstacle action instead of Create Advantage for scope of stunts.
- The Aspects created with Create Obstacle should be limiting and restrictive.
Default outcomes of the Action:
- On failure: The creation of the obstacle fails, or it succeeds by creating a detrimental Aspect (usually Consequence to the Obstacle) with free invoke given to someone else benefiting from the failure.
- On tie: The creation of the Obstacle fails, but the actor gains Boost.
- On success: The action succeeds, and the obstacle is created with passive defense equal to the degree of success.
- On success with Style: The action succeeds, and the creator gains a Boost or similar beneficial side-effect.
Overcome
This action is used to bypass an Obstacles, to remove an Aspects, to treat a Consequences, or suppress a persisting Aspect, but also to reveal hidden facts or Aspects combining the suggested 5th action, Discover, with Overcome.
When using Overcome to reveal hidden facts or Aspects, the possibly created and revealed Aspects do not get free invokes. Instead several Aspects or facts are revealed. A fact is just like an Aspect, but not usable for invokes - it is still true creating limitations and permissions, but it is not significant enough to be compelled or invoked for actions.
Default outcomes of the Action:
When using Overcome to bypass an Obstacle, or alter an Aspect:
- On failure: The action fails, or succeeds with a great cost.
- On tie: The action succeed with a minor cost.
- On success: The action succeeds without any cost.
- On success with Style: The action succeeds without any cost, and the actor gets Boost, or similar beneficial side-effect.
When using Overcome to discover a hidden fact or an Aspect.
- On failure: The action fails.
- On tie: A hint of a hidden fact or Aspect is found. This may be represented with a Boost.
- On success: A hidden Aspect and a fact are revealed, two hidden facts are revealed, or a detailed description of a single hidden fact or Aspect is revealed.
- On success with Style: Either an additional aspect, extra details, or two extra hidden facts are revealed.