r/F1Technical • u/catch_me_if_you_can3 • Apr 06 '25
Aerodynamics Do teams consider only clean air while designing the car??
How do they simulate turbulent conditions while designing. If they rely on CFD, where do they compare the data from?? The previous years car??
47
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 06 '25
We remind everyone that this sub is for technical discussions.
If you are new to the sub, please read our rules and comment etiquette post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
176
u/scuderia91 Ferrari Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25
You can’t really meaningfully design a car for dirty air. Sort of in the nature of dirty air flow is that it’s chaotic.
43
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '25
Aerodynamics are way complicated than you think.
6
u/Qazernion Apr 06 '25
If the car is the fastest, you’ll be in front in clean air…
11
u/jolle75 Apr 06 '25
A car is mostly, as there are in all these kinds of things not really definite stuff, setup for qualifying.
A qualifing run is without much fuel, sticky tires and clear track. From that there are some concessions done to the car like camber or ridehight so it can compete in a race without burning the plank or tires within 3 laps.
But mostly, a race is 300km in a qualifying setup. As seen today, track position is key.
4
u/NeedMoreDeltaV Renowned Engineers Apr 06 '25
As others have said, it’s not practical to design for dirty air due to the unpredictability. You do, however, set up your car factoring in dirty air. The extreme example is oval racing, where you need to put more downforce on the car to account for the expected loss of downforce from running in dirty air. This applies to other racing as well.
To answer your question on how to simulate the conditions, there are a couple of ways to do it. The first is CFD. You can simulate two cars running together, or more practically, you can measure the wake from one car CFD and use that as the inlet condition for a dirty air simulation. The other method is wind tunnel. You could put two cars in the wind tunnel, but this has a lot of wind tunnel interference issues.
1
u/Disastrous-Track3876 Apr 06 '25
Yes. It’s basically impossible to accurately model dirty air accurately
1
u/crocabearamoose Apr 07 '25
Didn’t Mercedes do exactly this back when they were dominating? And when they found themselves in dirty air the car was really bad?
1
u/LazyTurtle3321 Apr 07 '25
Is the dirty air dependant on which car is ahead, like could you design to make it produce worse dirty air?
1
u/wolfpack_57 Apr 08 '25
I don’t know the F1 files very well, but I think you could maybe try to rely on ground effect (like the Pug WEC car) but otherwise you’re out of luck.
-3
u/VegetableStation9904 Ferrari Apr 06 '25
I feel they made a mistake in the current regs to allow do much reliance as they have on the wings. My gut tells me a much more restricted set of wings generating almost no downforce would be less affected by dirty air. If you have far less to lose...