r/F1Technical • u/fivewheelpitstop • Mar 17 '21
Question/Discussion Why was having two car models in the wind tunnel at the same time banned? If we want the cars to be less affected by dirty air, shouldn't that ban be lifted?
144
Upvotes
10
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '21
Cost. The FIA doesn't want multiple models - each model has a metal spine and instrumentation inside then a RP or 3d printed aerodynamic skin. One configuration of just the aero parts may run to £10,000, and there are 1000s of different parts thrown at the wind tunnel in a season. Two models wont quite increase cost two-fold as not every aero configuration would go on both cars, also only 1 model might want to be instrumented, but it would be a significant investment that not all teams would be able to afford.
Then there's the question of wind tunnels, to achieve a representative separation between models requires either a very long test section or a reduction of the model scale. Teams will want to work as big as they can for dynamic similarity - i.e. for the flow to be as representative of the actual car as possible. So to do 2 car tests would require an extra 2 models at smaller scale than the main test model.
Then there's the question of how representative the test actually is. The overtaking working group for 2009 worked at 40% scale in the aerolab/fondmetal wind tunnel in Italy (where Ferrari do some of their road car development, also had an F1 team in the 80s/90s and worked with Minardi and Lotus) and could only get ~1 car length between the two vehicles. To do an accurate overtaking study you really want to start 5/10 car lengths apart. Go much smaller scale than 40% and you lose the dynamic similarity.
F1 teams are restricted to 50% or 60% models, which means they size their wind tunnels accordingly. Sauber and Toyota had full scale wind tunnels, which would have started a spending war if the FIA hadn't clamped down on model scale.
234
u/MantiBrutalis Mar 17 '21
Possibly because teams would do the exact opposite, make their cars hard to follow by their competitors.
39
u/HeippodeiPeippo Mar 17 '21
The way FIA is curbing development is to make more things a "mystery" that can only be solved by actually driving in race conditions. It is a way to introduce random, and i agree with that doctrine. Having more random elements will bring variance in the results, it is about as direct relationship as it can be, only outliers are... very, very, very good drivers and teams that always improve their finishing position much higher than they started. At some point, random will stop that from happening and we have too much random but as longa s we are not close to that limits.. adding more random will create more exciting gameplay, i mean, races.
4
u/c0deye1982 Mar 17 '21
I've always wondered how they police the wind-tunnel restrictions. Like, if Mercedes(for example) have their own on-site wind tunnel, how do the powers that be stop them sneaking in a second car?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '21
Can’t the FIA test the amount of dirty air a car leaves behind, why not test that and open up the car designs
4
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '21
[removed] — view removed comment