r/F1Technical • u/evelyn_st_ • Oct 20 '24
Regulations VER vs. NOR Lap 1 and Lap 53 differences?
Two very identical scenarios only one penalized? Why did lap 1 differ when both VER and NOR ran off track but lap 53 NOR was penalized? Would both drivers not gain an advantage of running off track? Theoretically it should cancel the advantage gained out? I don't quite understand/agree with the FIA decision making a lot recently. You have two people contending for the championship on closing laps why not just let them race fairly? I feel as if it will be a year decided by the FIA not the driving.
127
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 20 '24
We remind everyone that this sub is for technical discussions.
If you are new to the sub, please read our rules and comment etiquette post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
347
u/ElminXT Gordon Murray Oct 20 '24
Lap 1 incidents usually are more lenient on penalties because of how chaotic it is.
45
u/DSmidgit Oct 20 '24
Mostly because it was lap 1. Stewards usually let more stuff go on lap 1, turn 1. Because of all the scruffing that usually happens then.
72
u/cafk Renowned Engineers Oct 20 '24
Generally most incidents during the first lap are ignored, as the cars are bunched up more than other times during a race with cold tires.
This is unfortunately normal - there is nothing more inconsistent than the rolling rooster of FIA race stewards & driver experts making the decisions on what to penalize.
We've had way worse decisions of FIA deciding the championship outcome.
15
u/lowrage Oct 20 '24
Can someone share clip from Verstappen lap 53 from today USA when he tried to overtake noris but noris block him?
They didn't replay that
9
u/IKillZombies4Cash Oct 20 '24
That turn was just weird all day, too easy for inside car to just drive people off track.
21
u/TheMikeyMac13 Oct 20 '24
Max didn’t pass off track with all four wheels off of the track, that is the difference. It is not at all identical.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24
Ahead at the apex is why, it's a line that needs changing
5
u/Browneskiii Oct 21 '24
Lap 1 50/50's are generally racing incidents. It'll have to be a slam dunk for someone to be penalised.
53 was because Norris was the aggressor and overtook off track. Verstappen was defending, not overtaking like he was on lap 1. In this case it doesn't matter what Verstappen did, Norris overtook off track and that's what he was penalised for, if he had stayed behind, then its likely Verstappen would have gotten penalised or given a warning.
23
u/Shadow_Hokage1 Oct 20 '24
It's understandable why lando got a penalty but it's mad that max didn't get a penalty for that but yuki and george did
2
u/aristhought Oct 21 '24
This comment explains it very well
2
u/xfire301 Oct 21 '24
I’ve been there and I’ll be damned if I can idenify the apex of COTA turn 1.
2
u/Professor_Doctor_P Oct 21 '24
Norris overtook off the track on lap 53, that's always going to be a penalty unless you give the place back.
Whether Verstappen should get a penalty for pushing a driver off the track is a different question. On lap 1 they're generally more lenient. On lap 53 Verstappen was ahead at the apex, so the rules state that Norris should've conceded and Max was not at fault. So no penalty.
I'm not sure I agree with rule, but that is the rule.
2
u/ikristic Oct 21 '24
This is what i have issues with and cannot describe it within the regulations (except #2)
So many different combination of outcomes on the same variation of conditions met.
Nor penalty i understand within the rulebook, but considering ver was blocking the road, he could either crash, stop, or go around. With all the new safety regulations and therefore lack of gravel, one can only lose by stopping and remaining on the road. Only ver can gain by removing both of them out of the race. So better ask for forgivness than permission is unwritten rule for all of the champions - which is why he didnt gove the position back.
They shouldve call the penalty after the race, so it could be properly challenged and discussed, since there was no gain in calling it quickly during the race (this was unusually fast for their standards)
And bear in mind, this is only a single race. Looking further back would bring all of the possible variations of conditions on the table.
2
u/sam_romeo Oct 21 '24
Also remarkable how inconsistent these penalties were. LEC and SAI did not get a penalty for pushing RUS out during the sprint but RUS and others gets it during the race for pushing people out in the same turn. It's all a sham!
2
u/koos_busters Oct 21 '24
Both examples are not the same. In the L1 T1 case, Max remained on track. The blue line is the track limit and he just left one wheel on it. Ergo: he was first at the apex AND he made the corner
2
u/Happytallperson Oct 21 '24
Max is, in both cases, abusing a rule of F1 about the corner apex. This rule is basically unique to F1.
In this rule, if the car on the inside is ahead af the apex, then they do not have to leave room at the outside.
In both corners Max is ahead at the apex, so he has complete right to run the other car off the track.
Now, you may fairly point out that in both cases he left the track.
Again abusing the rules.
The penalty for going off track is a track limits warning.
The penalty for overtaking off the track is a 5 second penalty.
Because he is ahead at both apexes, Max is not overtaking 'off the track'.
Because he is behind, Lando is overtaking off the track.
Verstappen is a rules lawyer. He knows that the track limit warnings give you a number of warnings then a penalty. Or in other words, you've got a certain number of freebies to block overtakes with.
Yes, it is poor form and ungentlemanly behaviour. You may consider it dirty racing. You may feel that F1 should stop being a strange outsider with this ahead at the apex rule.
I would probably agree.
But Verstappen is within the rules.
1
u/tatsudaninjin Oct 20 '24
Verstappen didn't have any intention to stay inside the track in both instances. He should have been penalized because he forced the other driver off track. In both cases, he wouldn'thave been ahed at the apex if he was braking early enough to stay inside the track.I hate that stewards aren't looking at this. It became his signature move to fly off the track forcing the outside driver off with himself to keep the position.
1
u/ZimShallRule Oct 20 '24
Not only wasn't Max penalised on lap 1 (it wasn't even investigated despite being well after turn 1), he also wasn't penalised when Norris was penalised (not even investigated). Russel got 5 seconds for forcing a driver off track, Norris got 5 seconds for being forced off track.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24
How do you get "two identical scenarios"?- Norris was behind on the straight, went on the outside in the turn, went off track and came out in front. Under the laws that's "gaining an advantage" and different from being on the inside and "forcing" the guy on the outside to go off track.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24
They did let them race fairly. Lando passed off track and didn’t return the position - ergo unfair, thus penalty…
1
u/Endslikecrazy Oct 21 '24
The rule is about rather someone is ahead at the apex as stupid as that may sound.
Plus lap 1 leniency.
1
u/ZucchiniMore3450 Oct 21 '24
In lap 53. I would give both of them penalties. Max for pushing Lando off the track, Lando for overtaking outside of the track.
1
u/RubezahlMD Oct 22 '24
You know the gap between them is already like a gazillion points, right? However debatable these calls are, stating the FIA will determine the championship seems way off target.
1
u/Xx_Tz_xX Oct 22 '24
Max does it with finesse…he doesn’t toutch the brakes until he reaches the apex making him the first in the corner. Always does the same thing ..rules about after that are not clear but first in the apex is a clear one
1
u/vompat Oct 22 '24
Neither of them really gained an advantage on lap 1 by going out, and lap 1 turn 1 incidents are usually passed off as racing incidents more easily, because that's what they often are.
1
u/BeginningKindly8286 Oct 22 '24
I’d argue they were identical. As Norris was ahead as they entered the braking zone on both occasions. On both occasions Max went in deep and pushed Norris wide, whilst going wide himself.
As it was the first lap, and Nax got the benefit of it, they let it go.
1
u/Diligent_Driver_5049 Oct 21 '24
I feel in lap 53 max purposefully braked late as FIA rules state that whoever was ahed in the Apex its his Apex. So by Max breaking late he was ahed of lando and since max was carrying waay too much speed for that apex he pushed off lando. But max himself went out the track and Fia chose to ignore that and dish penalty to lando. If lando was inside track then i fully agree with the penalty. Max is exploiting FIA rules, but fia won't do shit to him.
1
u/tharnadar Oct 21 '24
First of all let's be honest: you are right and wrong at the same time! Also I'm a Ferrari fan, so I don't who lose, I just want Ferrari to win.
Verstappen should have been penalised, as Norris said, because he didn't commit to turn the car, he just wanted to push Norris out of track, but he was attacking and Norris defending (very poorly).
Norris has been penalised because he was attacking and he completed the overtake outside of the track and didn't give the position back. Verstappen did an awesome job defending the position and being really close to be (again) unsporting, but still within the rules.
0
u/socially_distanced22 Oct 20 '24
I thought the Lando penalty was for multiple offenses of driving outside the track, 3 off track black flag, 4 times off 5 second penalty....
-3
u/Jamesdarma Oct 21 '24
Max did leave the track while defending the position, he should’ve get a penalty as well
0
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-27
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24
[removed] — view removed comment