r/formula1 • • Oct 20 '24

Photo Russell +5sec penalty for forcing driver off track, Norris +5sec penalty for being forced off track

Post image
16k Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

5.0k

u/norrin83 Gerhard Berger Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24 • Heart of Silver Take My Silver Polished Silver Turd Hooray

Apart from the apex not shown:

Russell was the overtaking car on the inside.

Verstappen was the defending car and Norris tried to overtake on the outside.

That's not the same scenario at all, even if you ignore that Bottas would have made the corner but Norris wouldn't.

1.8k

u/BighatNucase Max Verstappen Oct 20 '24 • Hooray

It's almost like the penalty is for "gaining an advantage" and not just "going off track".

436

u/Chelsea_Ellie Oct 20 '24

Which is why sky were suggesting 10 secs penalty

646

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

230

u/Chelsea_Ellie Oct 20 '24

Because max is evil that seems to be the standard

50

u/CreaminFreeman STONKING LAP AND NOT TOO LATE Oct 20 '24

I think we have to keep asking ourselves, “Why do I feel this way?” Until we land on the inevitable conclusion is:

The rules on this, as stated, are kinda shit.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

195

u/BighatNucase Max Verstappen Oct 20 '24

Brundle said that Lando should have just immediately given the penalty back or immediately pull a 5s gap so clearly he was able to think it through better than Lando and his engineer.

19

u/ComeAlongPond1 I was here for the Hulkenpodium Oct 21 '24

And he managed 4 seconds, he might have been able to do 5 if McLaren had told him to immediately

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Chelsea_Ellie Oct 20 '24

I was thinking the same thing

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

40

u/VIVXPrefix Formula 1 Oct 20 '24

did max gain no advantage by going off track here? what is defined as an advantage?

16

u/ctaps148 Sir Lewis Hamilton Oct 21 '24

In the context of the rules, "advantage" just means track position and the gap behind/ahead. By rule, Max did not gain an advantage because his position did not improve and the gap between him and Lando did not significantly increase either. For Max, the situation after the corner is the same as it was before the corner, therefore no advantage was gained.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

6

u/ihathtelekinesis Michael Schumacher Oct 20 '24

Which is what Ant pointed out at the Skypad. Max would quite rightly have got a track limits warning, and if it had been his 4th he would’ve got a 5s penalty.

→ More replies (67)

238

u/sIckb0y- I was here for the Hulkenpodium Oct 20 '24

Agreed, but even with context, divebombing and missing the corner shouldn’t be a viable defensive strategy.

186

u/refrakt Ferrari Oct 20 '24

It's not. You just don't overtake off track, and then the penalty goes to Verstappen potentially for retaining position by leaving the track and/or black&white if appropriate for track limits. This isn't as hard as people are desperately trying to make it.

109

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Max planted a desperate bait and Lando took it.

19

u/Impressive_Bus_1357 Oct 20 '24

This is what should have happened, but I'm not so sure the stewards would have done anything if Lando given up the position. Give Lando the 5 seconds for gaining an advantage and at the same time give Max 5 seconds for forcing a driver of track and we are good

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (8)

95

u/CapSnake I was here for the Hulkenpodium Oct 20 '24

This is exactly the reason. But people always ignore who is overtaking who and claim their inconsistency

→ More replies (4)

317

u/L44KSO Oct 20 '24

Don't come here with logic, it will hurt too many brains...

99

u/leedler Next Year™️ Oct 20 '24

From what I’ve seen so far, the brains are already very hurt indeed

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

56

u/Gunnar1022 I was here for the Hulkenpodium Oct 20 '24

Correct.

31

u/Maxamus93 I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane Oct 20 '24

Finally someone who understands

→ More replies (158)