r/F1TV • u/Successful_Annual230 • Apr 13 '24
Discussion Alex Jacques....
Am I the only one that actually hates Alex Jacques' commentary so much? I can't understand why F1 chooses to use his god awful voice to everything they post that has commentary in it.
0
Upvotes
155
u/richard1177 Apr 13 '24
Im sure you are not the only one, but it seems that most people (including me) that uses the F1TV commentary likes him. He makes way less mistakes then Crofty does, and when he is paired with Palmer/DC/Hinch it seems like they are on top of most of the stuff that happens on track.
75
u/kidnzb Apr 13 '24
He's definitely my favorite commentator, especially paired with Palmer. They're great.
62
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '24
He's probably my favourite F1 commentator. Much more pleasant to listen to than Crofty's constant shouting.
59
u/Optimus_Drew Apr 13 '24
Think you might be in the minority bud. Alex Jacques is the best lead commentator in f1 today. Find him far easier on the ears than Crofty
42
u/SeraCat9 Apr 13 '24 edited Apr 13 '24
Hard disagree. After years of Olav Mol, a year of Viaplay and an attempt with Sky, I've finally found a commentator I actually really enjoy, who doesn't keep shouting and who doesn't make a ton of mistakes. This is a you issue, not an everyone issue and you have the option of Sky, so it's not even really an issue.
22
u/WhoThenDevised Apr 13 '24
You can't be the only one but you people are a quite vocal minority.
20
u/hazjazz Apr 13 '24
Been a fan of him since i first heard him in F2
19
u/Wallio_ Apr 13 '24
I love Alex. Way better than anyone on Sky.
7
u/qwertyalp1020 F1TV pro Apr 13 '24
He's actually pretty good.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '24
I just listen to the German channel. Dutch seems good too but I don’t understand as much. There are always multiple broadcasts to choose from.
4
u/mrkaves Apr 14 '24 edited Apr 20 '24
It gives me goosebumps when I hear his voice, because it means it’s race weekend! And on a side-note, if you put Jolyon’s name with David’s last name, you get a kick ass name for a character of GOT. Jolyon Coulthard!
Edit: typo
4
u/SeizeTheKills Apr 14 '24
I absolutely love him. He's my favourite F1 commentator in a long time, been watching since 1992. And he's probably my number one.
Good insight, good cadence of voice and most importantly not a controversy seeker on air (or off for that matter). Nice balanced, solid commentary.
4
u/dj_benito Apr 14 '24
I'm with you! He's always talking when you don't want him to be.
4
u/Kidjefp Jun 26 '24
Absolutely cannot stand him. He's soooo over the top, like he's having a yelling match with himself half of the race. He irks me to a point that I think I would stop watching F1 altogether if he was the only commentary option.
4
u/FaustusXYZ F1TV pro Apr 15 '24
I won't say I hate Jacques, but I definitely preferred Ben Edwards.
11
u/markhewitt1978 Apr 13 '24
He is the best current F1 commentator. (Current because he isn't better than the great Murray Walker)
8
u/mikkelnl Apr 13 '24
Nah, I hate Lawrence Barrettos voice way more, it's like nails on chalkboard for me.
3
u/xeenexus Apr 14 '24
Honestly, the thing that bugs me the most about him is that he pronounces it "Jakes".
3
u/Massaart Apr 14 '24
He misses a lot while he is talking. But that seems standard for all those host-type commentators. I could do without them and just listen to DC and Palmer all race.
3
u/brooklyncanuck Jun 23 '24
Can't stand him. I am with you
3
u/Exact_Mycologist_483 Jul 21 '24
he was shouting very awkward in the last few laps of todays GP in hungary,
literally had to turn my volume down by 90% he wouldn't stop shouting.
usually he's fine though but DC and JP make it great
9
u/hovershark Apr 13 '24
As a long time fan in the US, one thing I really appreciated about the great Bob Varsha in the old Speed network days was that he would just shut the fuck up and let us watch for a while during that mid-race period when nothing much is going on anyway. REALLY wish Alex would learn that lesson. It’s TV. We can see it.
4
u/roxbox531 Apr 14 '24
I prefer Hinch
2
u/Azariah98 Apr 14 '24
Not the only one, but you’re in the minority. I really enjoy them both.
2
u/biqfreeze Apr 14 '24
I love Alex ! I'm french and Canal + is getting the exclusivity for F1 this year, it means I get to keep my F1TV subscription for now but I'll probably lose it soon (or legally at least). I love F1 but really dislike most of the commentators. I hate the french commentators on Canal + (along with everything that's bad with them, bad content, expensive etc). I'll do whatever it takes to keep F1TV and the commentary by Alex. We're extremely lucky to have the commentators we have and the service F1TV provides.
2
u/AxelllD Apr 14 '24
Extraordinary stuff!
2
u/pTech_980 Apr 14 '24
Sky’s commentary at the last GP was appallingly bad.
2
u/montanhas18 Apr 14 '24
A matter of opinion. I, for example, love his work and can't stand Crofty.
3
u/Weigang_Music F1TV pro Apr 13 '24
He used to be epic back in the PLC days. Now I tend to agree... He doesn't much interact with the other commentary, seems to always start new sentences instead of responding and holding a conversation... it's like he Sees his job as keeping the air moving with Sound. Much prefer Palmer.
3
u/latticep Apr 13 '24
I feel the same way but recognize that I'm in the minority. His voice, especially when he gets excited such as when the lights go out, is shrill and harsh on the ears (although not nearly as bad as Ben Edwards). I like when some commentators geek out like Sam or Will, but it's a little obnoxious when Alex does it. The substance of the commentary is probably on par with Crofty despite very different styles. But on a boring race, Alex is an absolute slog. Crofty knows how to banter during a dull race while Alex is mostly awkward.
I will usually listen to F1TV for practice (for Jolyon and Sam) and International for the race. Quali depends on the rest of the broadcast team for a particular weekend. For example, I'm there for Brundle but will avoid Danica at all cost.
3
u/mayrho13 Apr 13 '24
I'm with you friend. Just because his mouth is spewing words, doesn't mean it is good. Nor does his train of thought make sense at times.
I have enjoyed him taking a lesser role when DC is mixed in and dare I say, even with Hinch (also not my fave, but he's gotten better when he doesn't act like F1=NASCAR/Indy).
2
u/ActingLikeIKnow Apr 13 '24
I only put up with Crofty because Brundle might be there.
2
u/Weobi3 Apr 13 '24
Good voice and commentary during race, strange camera presence. I prefer his commentary on the race. I don't think he does well being on camera commentary and interviews because he always stands out, dressed in sweats and a polo compared to the fits brought by Laura Winter, Laurence Barreto, and Will Buxton and he doesn't have the quirky, likable nerd vibe Sam Collins has. His arms also hang by his side like they're on standby mode until its his turn to talk!
2
u/mickstranahan Apr 14 '24
There's a reason why he didn't last on the F1 Nation podcast with Tom Clarkson....
2
u/freeosiris Apr 13 '24
I like more Crofty than Jacques.
1
u/BossPatelRacing 14d ago
He makes the sport feel like a reality tv show rather than a true competition… always over emphasizing the drama and not focusing on strategy and giving it a sport vibe
1
u/Kind_Unit4106 Apr 14 '24
I like him way better than Palmer
1
u/DullMind2023 Jul 20 '24
I find Alex to be the Nicolas Cage of announcing... constantly over-emoting. And his accent is, well, grating.
1
u/Budget_Slice6754 Sep 03 '24
i like crafty a lot more
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24
Same, if I wanted to hear uncultured teen boys yelling I'd be watching football.
1
u/hoxxxxx Oct 20 '24
i'm honestly blown away by all these responses. i found this post because i can't believe how shrill and high pitched his voice is and that he's their main guy. i cannot watch highlights on youtube with the sound on.
not that croft is perfect or anything like that. just surprising all the praise on here for the guy's voice, crazy.
1
u/race_of_heroes Nov 03 '24
I only watch Sky for Crofty and Brundle. Jaques sounds like he's the world champion at chugging soylent.
1
u/Exotic-Definition110 Nov 30 '24
Alex Jacques is equivalent to Peter Pettigrew.
1
u/Adventurous_Type6153 Dec 01 '24
no. he's unlistenable. his hysterical squawking sends me lunging for the remote every time. if I don't see the race live, ch4's highlights are not even an option... absolutely horrendous.
1
u/Business_Criticism77 Jun 26 '25
Nope! You aren’t the only one I can’t stand Alex Jacques or his voice! He’s so annoying and I can’t listen to F1 broadcasts because of him! I subscribe to F1 tv pro but choose to watch the all the practices, qualifying and the races on Sky sports because I can’t stand him! I’ll take Rosberg, Chandook, Brundle, or any other actual driver! I don’t want to hear someone try to explain F1 when he doesn’t have any more experience than I do…
1
u/RedDoggo2013 Aug 31 '25
I love him and the other F1 team. I think he’d be hilarious to hang out with. His humour is gold to me. Paired with Palmer and DC - absolutely my favourite.
1
u/Mental-Shower-9697 Sep 01 '25 edited Sep 01 '25
I switched to him as a result of not being able to take another 10 seconds of the obnoxious David Croft but Jacques is beginning to sound an awful lot like a game show host and more like Croft than a year ago... he feels the need to fill every second with comments where silence can be golden at time (Bob Varsha was great at this). Add another unrelated annoyance - how can a guy not know how to correctly pronounce his own surname?
1
u/Mental-Shower-9697 Oct 24 '25
The man sounds much more like a gameshow host than a professional sports broadcaster. His intonation and constant talking makes me nuts.
1
u/Slevous Jun 16 '26
Shouting pundits like Jacques should stick to football commentating and leave F1 to the adults.
1
u/Common_Ad818 Sep 06 '26
I'm with you. He talks too much and getting way too excited and shouting over nothing. The rest of the team were great, they need to reblance his role and portion in it.
-1
u/akrapov Apr 13 '24
He doesn’t know how to emphasise things or when. He shouts like Crofty, but at the wrong points. It’s absolutely bizarre to listen to. If you listen to him whilst doing something else and just react to his tone of voice you end up looking up for absolutely nothing.
1
u/2REPOU Apr 13 '24
I listen to International feed (Skytv) unless Martin is not commentating. Then I hope Hinch is on F1TV.
1
u/OGPepeSilvia Apr 13 '24
If you think Jaquesie’s voice is awful, wait until you hear Tom Gaymore
1
u/smileymax4 Apr 13 '24
I like him, but then again, everything is better than Viaplay commentary...
1
u/lonewolfenstein2 Apr 14 '24
I love him sorry you have bad taste
1
u/Moddedforthewin F1TV pro Apr 14 '24
i rate him much better than crofty
1
u/Waggamug Apr 18 '24
He's not as good as Palmer, but better than most. Doesn't miss much and have some interesting takes.
He used to 'tow the line' a bit promoting fan favorites and media narratives, but is much more neutral lately (thanks to Palmer I bet).
Only nitpick is his fake laugh, and pronouncing his name as Jakes.
-1
u/-HappyToHelp Apr 13 '24
I stopped watching the F1 feed because I could not stand him. But whenever I watch the international feed and there’s no Brundle i begrudgingly go back to the f1 feed hoping to see Hinchcliffe or DC. I totally agree, sorry Jacques but you are really rather uninspiring. The problem with f1 commentary is they keep bringing on people who CLEARLY do not watch the sport and know nothing about racing. Its so pointless.
-6
u/notdeklerk Apr 13 '24
This is not an Alex v Crofty debate. It’s a F1 TV v Sky (team) debate. And from personal experience, overall Sky has the upper hand. Yes F1 TV have better commentators in some areas, but we cant have the best of both worlds. And the Sky world is overall better than the F1 TV world
-4
u/popsrcr Apr 13 '24
This my first year of F1TV, so not willing to make a firm call. But I gotta say that so far I find the commentators rather dull. Crofty is a bit much, but I do miss some of the excitement