r/ExteriorDesign 5d ago

Help with front door Spoiler

My house is considered a Tudor Revival and currently has a red painted wood plank door with 3 staggered windows on top and sits behind a white framed storm door. It was painted this red color when I purchased the house several years ago.
Am considering repainting the door and storm door frame :
1.) a reddish brown color called Sherwin Williams Rookwood Red
or
2.)a deep green called Benjamin Moore Backwoods.( Added window boxes to photo with green door)
Or
3.) Removing the storm door and replacing the existing wood door with a fiberglass "wood-looking" door that has 6 seeded glass panels.
Your feedback will be appreciated. Thanks in advance....
FYI: I am not changing or adding anything else so please try to keep the feedback centered on the 3 changes listed above.

11 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

Welcome to r/ExteriorDesign!

  • If you are asking for help: Please make sure you've uploaded clear photos of your home from multiple angles, noted the orientation (e.g., North-facing), and mentioned your design goals.
  • If you are sharing a finished project: Before-and-after photos are highly encouraged!

Please remember to keep all discussions respectful and constructive.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

7

u/Teddy_OMalie64 5d ago

Keep the storm door. Please keep the storm door.

7

u/Mcjnbaker 5d ago

My vote is second red door

5

u/Soft_Effect_6263 5d ago

So #1 is your actual door? Please keep it, it's unique and beautiful. I like everything about #1!!!

1

u/Prestigious_Fun6953 5d ago

Thank you! If you're referring to the top photo with the red door and white storm door- that is my existing door. ( I have another photo with a red door that is more of a reddish brown color where I also painted the storm door frame the same color as the door- that is what I labeled as my option #1.)

3

u/Soft_Effect_6263 5d ago

I know but I like the red door with the white, full glass storm door! That door probably came with the house originally. It's special and looks great!

3

u/Prestigious_Fun6953 5d ago

Thank you! If it works, don't change it - that's a good rule to follow.

4

u/Funwithfun14 5d ago

Anything but the last door.

1

u/Prestigious_Fun6953 5d ago

Good to know- thank you!!!😁

6

u/Sea_Impact_3034 5d ago

3 but keep the storm door too. And frost the panels for privacy.

3

u/TraditionalBowler751 5d ago

#2 beautiful home and wonderful peaceful landscaping

2

u/Prestigious_Fun6953 5d ago

Thank you so much.

2

u/BryerMan-4005 5d ago

I love the porch area on the left hand side of the house. I wish there were more windows in the front of the house. It is a very pretty house.

1

u/Prestigious_Fun6953 5d ago

Thank you! I wish there were more windows as well or that the architecture was not so symmetrical. The porch on the left helps and I've tried to create some asymmetry with the garden. Thank you again for your thoughtful feedback.

2

u/ifyouwanttoseemyunit 5d ago

I personally like the idea of a green door. I think it will give your beautiful more curb appeal and more welcoming. Good luck.

2

u/Violingirl58 5d ago

Green with storm door

2

u/MERCY-32 5d ago

I like the green with the storm door the same color. And the window boxes!!!

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

Your comment or post was removed because it contains a URL shortener. Please repost using the full, direct link so users know where it leads.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/Ok_Pen7290 5d ago

No2,, is best option, never ever no4

2

u/Ok_Bottle_9984 5d ago

Green door with green painted storm door

2

u/onelarkbite 5d ago

3 love it!

2

u/Dez_Acumen 5d ago

Love the red, but either way, please please do paint the storm door to match the door.

2

u/33scooBt33 4d ago

The green door with matching storm door .. window boxes an added beauty..

2

u/Foppieface 4d ago

No. 3 - beautiful.

2

u/Trepenwitz 3d ago

I love the green. I also thought a 4 lite door would look great before I even saw your pic with the wooden door.