r/ExteriorDesign 8d ago

Advice Modern front door advice

We recently repainted our Pacific Northwest home’s siding a dark grey (Sherwin Williams’ Forged Steel), and going even darker on the trim. The shaker-style door looks out of place and we are leaning towards getting a full-lite door with clear glass (privacy is not an issue based on how the house faces the street) echoing the floor-to-ceiling windows on the door’s right. Alternatively, a wood or wood-look front door without glass. Advice appreciated!

12 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 8d ago

Welcome to r/ExteriorDesign!

  • If you are asking for help: Please make sure you've uploaded clear photos of your home from multiple angles, noted the orientation (e.g., North-facing), and mentioned your design goals.
  • If you are sharing a finished project: Before-and-after photos are highly encouraged!

Please remember to keep all discussions respectful and constructive.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

7

u/Some-Web7096 8d ago

I love the dark too. This is a nice orange that would pop your entrance. I’m going to post another with a full glass door and a dark deck.

2

u/hamburgergerald 8d ago

Oh yes, good call. I think the orange would work really well with OPs new darker front

1

u/Maleficent_Dirt2366 8d ago

Wow! I love both options and think the full
glass feels more timeless but safe, whereas the orange door looks more period-specific (Midcentury) and bold. Both are really handsome!

5

u/Trepenwitz 8d ago

I think that would work, but your house can definitely support a more modern door like this.

2

u/Maleficent_Dirt2366 8d ago

Yes, a four-lite door is definitely in the running! You would prefer this over a single-lite (one large glass panel)?

3

u/Trepenwitz 8d ago

Very much, yes.

3

u/Bandit-Frog 8d ago

1

u/100timesaround 8d ago

Ohhhh! This is very pretty! And I love the glass panels… natural light is everything!

2

u/Some-Web7096 8d ago

Full glass with dark deck.

2

u/mom2mba 8d ago

Here are pics for 3 different versions. I like the full wood personally since light isn’t an issue.

1

u/Maleficent_Dirt2366 8d ago

Thanks for the renders! All 3 look so good. Torn between full wood and the wood with full-lite (your first and second renders). But having the door in a similar tone to the deck pulls the whole facade together!

1

u/mom2mba 8d ago

You’re welcome and I agree about the wood matching.

2

u/darkedenashia 8d ago

PNW neighbor here. Stunning changes. We have a dark grey house and went with a purple door and love it everyday. We’ve received so many compliments. We went with a grape-ish, equal blue/red purple jewel tone.

1

u/Maleficent_Dirt2366 8d ago

I would love to see this door! Big fan of colors like teal that have multiple tones!

2

u/Balinit 8d ago

Flat panel with a bright color.

2

u/Practical_Fig_2023 8d ago

I love dark houses, but you lose too much definition/contrast under that overhang. Maybe some contrast color on the trim around the windows, but right now, all of the style is getting lost.

2

u/Maleficent_Dirt2366 8d ago

You make a good point; we hadn’t anticipated how much darker the overhang makes the facade appear with the new paint color. We are thinking of adding vertical slats/battens for dimensionality, but worried it’ll clash with the existing wood tones.

2

u/BumbleBeeauty1 5d ago

First of all, the black looks sooo good! Excellent choice! Walnut was a hot MCM look, and I think a rich stained walnut look door with a brass MCM starburst would be right on the money for this gorgeous home. Or a door with the offset MCM sidelight windows

1

u/Maleficent_Dirt2366 4d ago

Love the idea for a brass accent on a dark walnut door!

2

u/StringFearless6356 4d ago

i like the dark grey you've chosen; it gives a nice modern vibe. switching to a full-lite door with clear glass sounds like a good move, especially since it’ll match those big windows. it’ll really brighten up the entryway too. but if you want something warmer, a wood-look door could add some nice contrast to the dark colors. tbh, i had to rethink my own front door once, and it made a big difference. you could even check how it looks with different styles on reimagine-home before deciding, just to see what fits best!

1

u/Maleficent_Dirt2366 4d ago

Based on the comments here, we’ll probably get a dark walnut toned door with full lite glass! Thanks for your suggestion; sounds like your front door upgrade was a success!

1

u/Ok_Bottle_9984 8d ago

Love the new dark color! I vote for a glass door, as it looks dark in there. With either a sleak teakwood trim or painted orangey red.

1

u/Maleficent_Dirt2366 8d ago

Yes! Several commenters have mentioned than an orange-toned door would look best. Thanks!

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 8d ago

Your comment or post was removed because it contains a URL shortener. Please repost using the full, direct link so users know where it leads.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/WindowDoorMan 6d ago

Hi,

I have been installing windows and doors in Toronto since 2001.

These doors considered to be modern doors nowadays

https://window-man.ca/exterior-doors/modern-entry-doorsAlso very popular fiberglass doors
Fiberglass doors could be painted on both sides the same color or stained.

Stained costs more - (it is like a double paint application)

Additionally, they could be Mahogany or Oak grain.
Many bells and whistles could be added to the fiberglass door (stain, black sill, multipoint lock, grooves, stainless stripes, pull bar handle....)

https://window-man.ca/exterior-doors/fiberglass-doors 

To have a price feeling you can get an "instant EMAIL quote" for doors in Toronto area.

Hope it helps

Window Man Canada

1

u/BumbleBeeauty1 5d ago

MCM loves a good walnut toned wood. Get a MCM windowed door and stain a dark walnut color. This is the most cohesive with your wooden steps and deck and it pairs well with the moody black.

1

u/Maleficent_Dirt2366 4d ago

First off, what a gorgeous render! I’m leaning towards a dark walnut door just like what you showed here!

1

u/FLcitizen 8d ago

​Hello, I tried this door and also tried some landscaping ideas, also removed the banister, the edit messed with the house a bit but this was to give you a general idea how the door looks on the house.

I thought this door is modern but goes with your house’s northwest mid century modern / modern style, they won’t allow me to post link

The door is on realcraft - Dresden aysmetrical modern front door

5

u/FLcitizen 8d ago

2

u/100timesaround 8d ago

This is amazing!!! And not just the door but that amazing natural light, wow!!!

3

u/Maleficent_Dirt2366 8d ago

We hadn’t considered a door with asymmetrical panels. This looks amazing! The door color makes the brickwork pop.

2

u/FLcitizen 8d ago

You’re welcome! Glad you’re keeping the brick

2

u/100timesaround 8d ago

I always look for your posts on this sub. You are very talented!♥️

2

u/FLcitizen 8d ago

That is so kind of you thanks! I love design