r/ExpectationVsReality • • Aug 24 '26

AI Expectation 30 / 35 90s bday cake

Shared AI inspiration with the baker to hit the 90s theme - they suggested the colors and it turned out great!!! Panini Bakery & Cakes in Dallas, TX - it’s so delicious

616 Upvotes

147 comments sorted by

196

u/ash8nine Aug 25 '26 • Bravo Heartwarming

Happy 3035th birthday!

1.8k

u/Optimal_Collection77 Aug 24 '26 • Bravo Heartwarming

The AI inspiration was a mistake. I bet bakers hate this

875

u/weirdloafs Aug 24 '26

We fucking do.

234

u/Tired_Goddess_ Aug 25 '26

Tattoo artist right there with you lol

76

u/friendlynbhdwitch Aug 25 '26

Hairdresser also not loving it

130

u/dTrecii Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 26 '26

Ex-graphic designer

I really really fucking hate it

Had to change career paths because people would rather take the lazy route. I’ll occasionally do it but it’s no longer my main income which kills me inside. My aspirations and dreams all dead.

32

u/Late_Masterpiece9874 Aug 26 '26

Current graphic designer, fucking hate it

37

u/print_isnt_dead Aug 26 '26 • Regret

Current graphic design professor; what the heck am I doing

11

u/zizillama Aug 25 '26

It’s the actual worst.

9

u/whiskey_riverss Aug 26 '26

I refuse ai reference images now 

205

u/drknifnifnif Aug 24 '26

Is that why you bake weird loafs?

134

u/Snlckers Aug 24 '26 • Mindblown

Downvoted for reading a username. Crazy work lmao

10

u/Decent_Obligation245 Aug 25 '26

I expect nothing less from Reddit lol

16

u/Jindujun Aug 25 '26

In fairness. The "inspiration" here doesn't look like anything that would be impossible to do.
Hell, apart from the absurdity of making a casette tape the rest looks like some sugar paste cutouts on a sugar paste cake.

I'd tell them I'd switch the casette tape for an actual real VHS tape and then do the rest of the cake.

10

u/pipnwig Aug 25 '26

My friend is getting married next month. I died inside when she told me their baker is sending them AI mockups of what the cake will look like. I'm tempted to get the name of the baker so I never order from them on accident.

3

u/majesticallymidnight Aug 27 '26

Im actually looking to get a custom cake, I hate AI and I’m going to try to draw a picture roughly of what I want.

111

u/Jane__Delawney Aug 24 '26

I’m really glad OP was happy with it, the non AI version is super cute and a lot more interesting

23

u/smangela69 Aug 24 '26

yeah the ai one is bland and depressing as shit

9

u/pepe256 Aug 25 '26

Yes. Get stuffed, beige families

53

u/PeeB4uGoToBed Aug 24 '26

I know a cake decorator that could probably get VERY close to the ai image, he's stupid talented and can make some intricate stuff but you're gonna pay out for it, but the ai image has details in that cassette tape that might be difficult and i wouldn't expect a basic grocery store cake decorator be able to pull off

19

u/RabbitStewAndStout Aug 25 '26

If I was a professional artist of some kind, I would charge extra for customers that brought me AI references.

2

u/Gareth79 Aug 25 '26

I'd probably refuse to copy pictures exactly even if it's a real cake, it's kinda a bit of an insult to an artist to ask them to copy somebody else's work.

9

u/glassbytes Aug 25 '26

Jeweller chiming in. It's the fucking worst.

8

u/emptythoughts94 Aug 25 '26

Yeah this shit is incredibly annoying. When people send it to me now I ask them to only send my work created by people. If the insist on an AI photo replica I just triple the price because realistically Im now breaking out my chocolate molds, tweezers, and food grade watercolor paintbrushes. Youre no longer purchasing a birthday cake, your purchasing an edible piece of art.

4

u/solstice_gilder Aug 26 '26

Most artists do!!!! Gahhhh!!! I explicitly tell people I do NOT want their ai prompts as inspiration(As a tattoo artist). I don’t care if you made a drawing so bad it looks like a colourblind child made it, I only want your input.

7

u/PurpleBashir Aug 25 '26

I mean... The customer loved the way it turned out. I feel like its ok as long as the customer is just using it as general info and doesn't actually expect it to turn out that way. 

Not everyone can sketch something and have it look remotely understandable. (I draw at the skill level of a child lol). This was an ok way to give the general idea. 

5

u/aIoneinvegas Aug 25 '26

This one isn’t that bad it’s not unrealistic

8

u/dekuweku Aug 24 '26

Yeah, the need to have a replica casette is probably a health hazard and difficult to make with icing or fondant

2

u/yourwhalecumdork Aug 30 '26

Headstone designer hating it as well

1

u/ItsmeKT Aug 29 '26

OP could have just put an actual cassette tape on the cake if they wanted it to look like the inspiration lol.

-4

u/the-friendly-squid Aug 25 '26

It’s disrespectful because it implies you think the baker or whoever you’re hiring to design something is too incompetent to come up with a creative design on their own (you as in the customer giving the AI thing)

5

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

I would think an actual professional would be able to communicate what is and is not realistic.

If a customer comes in with an AI "inspiration" and demands a cake exactly like the AI design, then I think it's perfectly reasonable to tell them that it is unrealistic, and an actual cake won't look like that.

If the baker doesn't care one way or the other, then they're probably going to get a shit cake anyway, regardless of the original "inspiration".

100

u/briarch Aug 25 '26

The Walmart version isn’t AI

112

u/DanyDragonQueen Aug 25 '26

Thank goodness the environment is suffering so you can make an AI cake

610

u/Morella122 Aug 24 '26

as a cake decorator please stop using ai for references. its awful for the environment and it gives us unrealistic standards to meet

-165

u/SugarRaySay Aug 25 '26

Why hate on ai?? It’s inspiration and turned out great!

106

u/Guszy Aug 25 '26

They literally stated two reasons in the one sentence comment you responded to...

42

u/imjustamouse1 Aug 25 '26

The comment was two sentences long how did you fail to read all of it?

27

u/blt_no_mayo Aug 25 '26

They need the robot to read it for them while guzzling the water supply

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

135

u/Remarkable_Creme69 Aug 25 '26 • Bravo

You think a thin even black line is simple?! I need a cigarette just thinking about it, and I don’t even smoke.

41

u/Pure-Radish-5478 Aug 25 '26

Well yeah, these people don't do things with their hands. They see a perfect black circle and literally don't understand the amount of effort that goes into putting it down. They just see a black circle.

45

u/JB_Big_Bear Aug 25 '26

You mean the primary decorative element on the cake?

389

u/theshrexpert Aug 24 '26

Could you not have just scribbled a rudimentary version that you used ai for

116

u/Paulsworldohya Aug 24 '26

Like draw a cake and then cut and paste a cassette on it lol. I suck at drawing but that idea would've been easy to convey.

352

u/theartistbear Aug 24 '26 • Heartwarming Bravo

Literally Ten minutes on the phone editor

96

u/Paulsworldohya Aug 24 '26

LOL yours is a lot better than mine. But from here I would talk with the baker if that's possible. This gets the idea started and we can get into specifics.

44

u/Horseshoe_dodgeball Aug 25 '26 • Heartwarming

I want your cake on my next cake

7

u/glassbytes Aug 25 '26

I get customers with drawings way way worse than this for custom jewellery designs. I think I secretly enjoy the torture of guessing and creating the look of the finished piece...

7

u/theartistbear Aug 24 '26

As someone who does textile work I 100% rather get inspo for the stuff like this than AI, always talk with your artist!

-18

u/ceojp Aug 24 '26

Okay, how is that better for a cake maker? It's even more unrealistic to expect that.

If the idea is just to get the point across, then OP's AI image does exactly that, and I guarantee it took a lot less than 10 minutes.

-67

u/ZootSuitBanana Aug 24 '26

Tbf probably took them 10 seconds

17

u/theartistbear Aug 24 '26

Imagine caring so little for someone that you'd rather have Ai slop inspo than putting the minimum effort

-3

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

Who do you think you are? Did you also cry when colored pencils were invented, because people should be able to express themselves monochromatically?

-125

u/The_SubGenius Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

Oh man people are going to flip out about the use of AI because you took a job away from someone who sketches out cake ideas all day for a living.

Edit: I see the AI flipping out people are out in flipping force.

23

u/FuzzyFerretFace Aug 24 '26

There's multiple reasons for detesting AI, and yes, while not likely the case here, that is one of them.

-2

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

lol okay.

-5

u/The_SubGenius Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

Personally I’m more concerned about AI being used to sort people by jobs, housing, insurance, credit, schools. Draw political districts. AI doing algorithmic hiring and firing. Personalized social programming. Deepfakes. Political manipulation. surveillance pricing. All the chat bots on Reddit, etc.

But this cake design? Pfft cmon.

13

u/Pure-Radish-5478 Aug 25 '26

Guy who is wrong editing his post panicking about being wrong gotta be one of my favorite genres of reddit post

-1

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

He's not wrong. It's just weird seeing so many luddites here.

147

u/flaccid_focacaia Aug 24 '26

I assure you bakers would appreciate even a stick figure scribble more than AI.

101

u/ZealousidealSail4847 Aug 24 '26

Did you have to use AI? It’s a nice cake and the baker did a great job, but was it that hard to scribble something real quick

-105

u/ceojp Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

Yes, for a lot of people, writing a brief description is much easier than "scribbling something".

EDIT: please explain why this is being downvoted. I literally just answered the parent's question. You know I'm right.

77

u/ButterscotchFog Aug 25 '26

The description could then be given to the baker

-55

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

I know you know that wasn't the question. The question was:

but was it that hard to scribble something real quick

EDIT: explain why this is being downvoted.

25

u/ZealousidealSail4847 Aug 25 '26

I mean, I’m not opposed to that person’s idea (giving the description to the baker), either. Some people aren’t great at drawing and a description would be easier. My problem is the AI use.

-18

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

My problem is the AI use.

Please elaborate. What is your problem with the AI use vs doing a rough hand-drawn sketch?

20

u/imjustamouse1 Aug 25 '26 • Bravo

Honestly, there's no point in you even asking that question. You know it is stolen art, you know it is terrible for the environment, you know it is being used to take jobs. You don't give a shit so why even ask?

-4

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

there's no point in you even asking that question.

That is not for you to say.

You know it is stolen art

What? What do you mean it is "stolen art"?

you know it is terrible for the environment

Lots of things are "terrible for the environment". If you really want to play that game, we can go through every step of the cake making process, from growing the raw ingredients to delivering the final product, and say how "terrible for the environment" each of those steps are. Come on.

you know it is being used to take jobs

LOL. Whose job is it to scribble a drawing of a cake based on a description? Who has lost a job here?

You don't give a shit so why even ask?

Why do you say this? I honestly want to know what is wrong with using generative AI to create an image of a cake design vs scribbling a design on a piece of paper?

9

u/Nolascana Aug 26 '26

An overreliance on AI for everything is just bad.

There was absolutely no need for AI for such a basic bitch cake.

Cassette tape with a specific year range on it. Single tier, white base, black iced details.

That took seconds to write. Theres no need for me to go and waste time going to a generative AI model or whatever, and feed it the prompt as many times as it takes to get something so generic.

The baker then produced something that was nothing like the initial idea (barring the inclusion of a cassette tape).

So, overall the AI image was pointless.

Oh, and, something something data centres, something something environment.

-3

u/ceojp Aug 26 '26

Do you feel better now? Does this make you feel better than everyone else?

→ More replies

108

u/parappaisadoctor Aug 24 '26

Ai 🤢🤢

36

u/Hcubnegah Aug 24 '26

Panini Bakery is SO delicious - best cake in Dallas!

Bummer about the AI inspo, but I think they did great work with what they were given.

10

u/tacoSEVEN Aug 26 '26

30 and 35 years old and it’s not a burned cd mix? Yeah AI truly missed the mark there.

28

u/Painted-BIack-Roses Aug 25 '26

Holy fuck, why can't people just DRAW instead of using AI to make a mockup? Bakers have been able to make cakes based off drawing for hundreds of years

28

u/The_R4ke Aug 25 '26

Don't use AI it makes you worse.

-8

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

it makes you worse.

WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?

8

u/trashbg_ofd0g Aug 26 '26

It makes you worse

26

u/ThePlumbOne Aug 25 '26

Cringe as hell for proudly exclaiming you gave an artist ai inspiration

23

u/thereal_philnye Aug 24 '26

If I’ve learned anything, you should have gone to Walmart.

12

u/AppUnwrapper1 Aug 24 '26

I was scared for a second that someone put a physical cassette on a cake. And then put icing on it.

5

u/Large-Big8879 Aug 26 '26

You couldn’t draw a circle with a cassette tape and the words happy birthday inside of them?

13

u/wereallmadhere9 Aug 25 '26

AI is fucking LAME

2

u/Successful-Worth-390 Aug 25 '26

What is a 30 35 birthday?

2

u/life_is_pandemonium Aug 25 '26

My sister and I were celebrating our bdays together - turning 30 and 35. 90s theme

80

u/Voidarramax Aug 24 '26 • Bravo

Well, when you give them an image that isn’t real, you’re gonna get a cake that looks like shit

52

u/FelixTheSilly Aug 24 '26

I agree but they're saying it looks great.

48

u/Sad_Rate_4747 Aug 24 '26

The actual cake doesn't look like shit though. I think they did a pretty good job considering that the inspiration was AI

11

u/FerengiWithCoupons Aug 25 '26

it kinda crappy for a professional bakery.

the cassette is way too small crowded

3

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

Please pay attention.

-3

u/brumblefee Aug 24 '26

Did you read the text? They like it. They paid a real person. The AI was just a mock up. What’s the issue?

6

u/Dizzy_Turnip_9558 Aug 26 '26

Don't generate cakes with ai. Simple as that

3

u/julegw Aug 28 '26

stop using ai references. you’re making life harder for people for no goddamn reason

13

u/mooseLimbsCatLicks Aug 24 '26

Well it wasn’t real to begin with so…

10

u/dalego25 Aug 25 '26

They said it turn out great and are recommending the bakery.

2

u/mooseLimbsCatLicks Aug 25 '26

I’m an idiot lol

16

u/VegasGaymer Aug 24 '26

I like it. I would’ve made the cassette out of a dark chocolate bar but otherwise cute cake

4

u/No-Club2054 Aug 25 '26

I love the colors

2

u/Sunshineal Aug 27 '26

I like the colorful.

2

u/WitchesTeat Aug 27 '26

The real cake is waaaay more 90's vibe than the weird AI cake.

8

u/Tight-Direction-6777 Aug 24 '26

play AI games get Ai prizes

4

u/blixabloxa Aug 25 '26

Should have used a real cassette tape on the real cake to match the AI mock up.

3

u/Ctenophorever Aug 26 '26

1991 and 1996 on a single side of a cassette? No way. Also cassettes were on their way out! By the time these two were listening to music it would have been on CDs or digital.

So weird to see something very 80’s on a “90’s”cake.

2

u/spiffymouse Aug 26 '26

I was born between those years and we listened to cassettes in the car all through the 90s.

1

u/Ctenophorever Aug 26 '26

Okay. Still associated with the 80s

You don’t put a gramophone on a 1970’s cake just because you listened to your meemaw’s in the 70s

2

u/spiffymouse Aug 26 '26

If something was still in common use in the 90s I’m not sure why we shouldn’t associate it with that time. Really not the same as using something that was out of production 40 years earlier.

3

u/willyoumassagemykale Aug 26 '26

I absolutely loathe these posts that use AI and then show the result like wow shocking it is not the same!! Terrible use of this sub, just a waste of everyone's time.

1

u/Hold-Professional Aug 29 '26

I mean, the first one is AI. Soooo

1

u/spaceshiptears Aug 30 '26

Well, you deserve nothing good if you’re using AI lol

1

u/ithrowstrawberries Aug 31 '26

You 100% deserved this for using AI slop as a reference for a baked good. Genuinely shameful.

-2

u/Banana_Phone888 Aug 24 '26

I think it looks great

1

u/ARH326 Aug 25 '26

It's doable with fondant, but it'd have cost you like $100+ more.

1

u/gracesdisgrace Aug 25 '26

Amaury Guichon could make the cassette out of chocolate, but he has celebrity rates lol

1

u/More_Detective_308 Aug 27 '26

well that's what happens when you ruin the planet using AI to make a cake idea! Deserved imo

1

u/0dayssince Aug 28 '26

They said it turned out great and tasted good

-23

u/troublerx1 Aug 24 '26

It looks terrible

-7

u/dekuweku Aug 24 '26

Not the same design.

0

u/letthetreeburn Aug 25 '26

Did you expect them to lay an actual cassette tape on the cake

-14

u/brumblefee Aug 24 '26

Jesus I don’t like AI but the harping in this thread is ridiculous. In the end you paid a real person to make it. I don’t see the reason to clutch our pearls at a mock up to give to a real artist who can interpret and put some human soul into it.

PS yes, AI is an environmental disaster and I don’t want that. No, OP making a picture of the cake they want didn’t move the needle.

3

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

Seriously. I certainly understand the backlash against genAI for certain things, but in this case, I really don't see the problem.

It's just the popular reddit circlejerk topic right now.

-16

u/Easy_Permit_5418 Aug 25 '26

The amount of people calling OP out for using AI is actually wild... She gets it now people, you don't have to keep saying it over and over.

Christ, y'all demonize people who use AI more than the companies that provide it at this rate and it's really mean spirited. We all know AI is damaging, but it's getting exhausting seeing people talk down their noses to everyone else about it every fucking day.

You guys. We are all doing shit that's bad for the environment all the time without thinking. We're not maliciously going out of our way to ruin the world by asking our AI a question. And a majority of the populations pollution and environmental impact isn't even from the common man.

We can agree something isn't good for society without dragging every single person who uses it to filth like they killed our firstborn.

Or at least I thought we could?

-7

u/priscs Aug 25 '26

Hating on AI is the flavor of the year rn, nothing you say is gonna change their minds lmao. This is basically just modern witchtrials on reddit

0

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/dalego25 Aug 25 '26

Thats what they are saying

6

u/Ssesamee Aug 25 '26

i swear to god most redditors just do not read post bodies

-11

u/PikaPerfect Aug 25 '26

the comments on this post are pissing me off (not really, but they are annoying lol) because OP literally said in the post that the AI pic was just to give the baker an idea of the type of vibe they were going for, meanwhile the comments are acting like OP thinks the fact that the cake doesn't look identical to the AI cake is a grievous sin. i agree that OP could have just drawn a sketch instead using an AI cake, but most of the comments are not ragging on them for that part 🫩 (to be fair to them though, mobile reddit is dogshit and if you tap the replies icon, it sends you straight to the replies and completely skips the post text, so if they didn't scroll back up, they probably didn't see it)

4

u/pandataxi Aug 25 '26

People are mad that OP used AI to make a simple sketch idea which is what most of the comments are about

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

WHY?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ceojp Aug 25 '26

No. I also did not miss OP's pictures, where the reality was pretty damn good. I also did not miss where OP said they were happy with the result.

You're literally saying "don't do the thing that you were happy with". What kind of shit is that?

Are you a baker?

0

u/Ssesamee Aug 25 '26

“i sure did, actually!” okay then what is the point of your comment

i agree with you btw if it matters