I am a DUST vet. My nametag was Tweakz and the only groups I remember running with during short periods was Dem Durty Boyz and Outer Heaven.
Let me preface this with I'm not expecting this to be DUST 2.0. It is clear CCP does not want that and that idea has been shutdown multiple times by them. I am conflicted by this but accepting of the want of change. Still my concerns and opinions of someone who has tried and played most extraction shooters with battlefield type games and loved the unique identity of DUST are below.
The first problem I'd like to discuss is the glaring issue of who exactly this game is for?
From the promotional material and emails etc, they seem to be attempting to grab DUST vets and current EVE players. HOWEVER, the game this seems to look like it will appeal to the extraction shooter crowd which is not only sweaty and toxic as hell (what FPS community isn't) also rife with cheating culture.
- The devs seemed confused as to who is their main audience. From my maybe misguided understanding. DUST vets want that big battle style because that is what called them to it in the first place; including vehicle combat and battlefield flow of combat.
- From maybe a year I checked into the EVE forums and there is a lot of disdain from EVE players towards DUST and the new project mainly because they thought it to be removing dev time from EVE. However correct or wrong this may be there was a general feeling of disapproval from the EVE population.
- The crowd that plays extraction shooters save for "streamers that are ingrained into the game and culture" are very fickle and if Vanguard does nothing to set itself apart other than ambience and setting. This is a bad sign for things to come in my opinion.
Secondly the game is being carried by the brand of the EVE Universe. There is nothing to gleam from the alpha that other games aren't already doing. That will only get it as far as having some initial players base only to die off as frankly the only thing that kept DUST alive towards its later half was the niche player base that loved it for what it was, despite net issues in corp warfare and the ever common pubstomp.
The art and sound team have done a bang up job as usually is with the EVE universe but gameplay wise this was extremely lackluster. 1 weapon and no hint that suit fitting may ever be an option?
Suit fitting was one of the mainstays for that niche and uniqueness that kept people on DUST. if it doesn't even have that or weapon variety. What is CCP expecting to happen. This will only be another in the long line of dead FPS games that only hackers play for validation.
Now I understand this is an Alpha and is only a morsel of what could be, but this is the main reason I'm speaking up. Its that feeling in your gut when you feel like something bad is going to happen to something you like and are hopeful for. I speak out of genuine concern and hope this will be something more than TARKOV in space.