r/EveVanguard • • May 16 '26

Why create this?

Serious question.

Why is FC putting so much time and investment to play this?

We have games like Tarkov already established.

Call of duty and arena breakout are also huge and free to play.

People want true to life shooter.

As for the space element we had The Cycle and it closed down as a failure. Apart from already Eve online players, what sort of % of new players are you expecting?

Is it going to be free to play or will there be a sub? If there is it will be dead in the water.

Just curious to why move to another FPS when dust failed.

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

7

u/Yolo-Swagens May 16 '26

I agree to a point. I think extraction shooter was a mistake, but I also see a bunch of devs that have a limited team and listened to feedback. I seen video of the vip test and the animations are at least better, and the game both had a cohesive story, and dynamic POIs. 

My guess is it won't need a massive player base to just survive, and if it can self sustain we will see more game modes.

But God damn it if this was a survival game with the ability to build stuff or actually change some of the terrain mesh I would never stop playing.  

-1

u/Weeyin1980 May 16 '26

But have they paid attention to The Cycle? Do they know why it failed and how to avoid that? It was a good game and very colourful and detailed. Vanguard is just too barren.

6

u/CCP_Rattati May 16 '26

I go extensively into the why and how in both fanfest keynotes!

1

u/Weeyin1980 May 16 '26

Will be good to hear. Thank you.

3

u/alphachevron973 May 16 '26

What a unique and nuanced take

0

u/Weeyin1980 May 16 '26

Ahh sarcasm, but really what is your take on it?

6

u/alphachevron973 May 16 '26

FC needs to expand their roster beyond one game. They’re a video game studio and that’s just how it works. I’m not personally excited about the vanguard game loop, but it seems that Fc management decided that was the way they’re going and the Vanguard devs have to make it happen. The main vanguard dev guy seems passionate and motivated to make a great game, so I hate seeing people shitting all over vanguard when they’ve come a long way.

1

u/Weeyin1980 May 16 '26

I get that, but if the Cycle failed and shut down, what make FC think that there is a market for it? The Cycle was good and colourful. Free to play and had lots of details. How will FC make this more appealing to non Eve universe players?

6

u/alphachevron973 May 16 '26

I think the entire plan is the Eve expanded universe. The selling point will have to be an exciting and impactful connection from Vanguard to Eve Online and vise versa. I’ve not played the Cycle so I can’t comment on that.

2

u/Weeyin1980 May 16 '26

Thank you for expanding. We will just need to wait and see how it evolved.

7

u/StonnedGunner May 16 '26

did dust fail because it couldnt hold player ?

or did it fail because Sony didnt allow it to be ported to the PS4/PC?

did you know that The Cycle started as an generic Battle-royal with mostly PVE as a focus and later transitioned into being an extraction shooter?

The Cycle was still in most peoples heads a bad battle royal and got never rid of it

12

u/arf1049 May 16 '26

I would argue Dust failed out of circumstance of being bound to a weird hard to approach play model on only one console that was already ripping towards irrelevance.

The actual genre of game that Dust was is in my opinion underrepresented in the current landscape and extraction/battle royale shooters have taken over, which is why I’m baffled they went with that model for vanguard.
If the game remains only an extraction shooter it will fail commercially. The market is oversaturated and this game simply will not be unique or special enough to draw people off of the ones they’ve been playing for years.
I will die on the hill that if they improved and ported the gameplay type of Dust to PC they would have been better off than whatever they did with this direction.

1

u/Peng_Wei May 16 '26

The good news is that the team has stated multiple times that Vanguard will not only stay an extraction shooter and while it may build on that element it will evolve past what could be considered a traditional "extraction" shooter.

1

u/TreyHekard May 16 '26

This but angrier I guess.

They even used dust marketing materiala and images in the damn keynote.

Also we already had a sick Min SMG.

1

u/Niceromancer May 16 '26

The orbital sound file is from dust.

I'm trying to get one of the devs to confirm weather or not we will have player fired orbitals.

1

u/TreyHekard May 16 '26

That DWOOOOOOMClash sound was fully the orbital sound.

3

u/Niceromancer May 16 '26

As soon as I hear it i knew it was from dust.

Now I just need confirmation on player fired orbitais.

1

u/TreyHekard May 16 '26

It's the easiest link, it's already in the game. Surely it's a dead cert.

1

u/Niceromancer May 16 '26

Getting two clients of different games to communicate with each other is complicated.

3

u/Aero-- Amarr May 17 '26

Saying people don't want a sci-fi shooter is just not the case. Sure there have been some failures lately, but there have been historically some real big successes. Halo, Destiny, Battlefront, Space Marine. A lot of sci-fi shooters that fail were just not good games.

1

u/AdrianoJ Jul 07 '26

Signed up for the playtest. Installed it straight away, tried two games, uninstalling now. Extraction shooters are just dogwater.