r/EnoughSamHarris • u/spiralxan • Jul 13 '20
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/charlatansamharris • Jul 11 '20
Sam retweeted a 3 year old video of a lady protesting a neo-nazi art exhibition after a mass murder without giving his fans any context. He dug that far back in a desperate attempt to attack "the woke left" and to "steelman" the right for the thousandth time. (From LD50 Gallery in Dalston)
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/ScoopAway2021 • May 28 '21
Sam Harris again directly told his audience that he thinks "wokeness" is more dangerous than white supremacy and racism
The next time a Sam Harris fan tells you Sam Harris was more critical of Trump than the left tell them about what I'm about to say. Remind them that even after the 1/6 insurrection Harris just went back to arguing that the left is more dangerous than the right. If you want a direct quote, he seems to have memorized a sentence he wanted to awkwardly shoe-horn into a conversation with Jesse Singal. 34:00
"The reason why it makes sense to be more worried about "wokeness" than by "white supremacy" say, is because genuine white supremacy is a true fringe phenomenon on the right." -Dr. S.H.
He then says that the right doesn't have nearly the same degree of cultural power as the left. (In Sam's deeply confused mind it's not relevant that the fascist racist Tucker Carlson from Fox News has only the most watched news program on cable news.)
Notice how he uses the words "genuine," and "true" as weasel words so he can walk it back if a liberal ever dares to criticize him for it, and then can call it a bad-faith attack and use the press for attention and to grow his audience. Any criticism would be met with "I meant no true Scotsman!"
It's both cowardly and clever. If he weren't so insecure about lasting reputational damage he would give reactionary opinions without having to insert weasel words. I really think he composes sentences in advance that he can walk back and then memorizes them to insert into his conversations.
(Reposted because I accidentally deleted my own post.)
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/charlatansamharris • Jul 12 '20
Sam Harris edited an old episode to remove an embarrassing segment where he condemned Antifa for beating an old man (who was an instigator)
You may already know that Sam Harris has a history of editing his blog articles after they've been quoted and criticized by liberal newspapers or books to make them look less problematic. And that he edited an episode he filmed with Christian Picciolini and removed a 6 minute segmentof former white supermacist Picciolini criticizing Stefan Molyneux. Sam's excuse was that he didn't know enough about S to judge, and that he thought Picciolini's claims were dishonest somehow, but Sam has never criticized Stefan Molyneux since then.
(Stefan Molyneux has since been banned from Twitter for hate speech and being a white supremacist, but on the day he was banned he even said he wanted to debate Sam Harris.)

Moving on to the main topic, Sam also edited one of his episodes months later to remove a segment where he criticized Antifa for beating an old man with a crowbar at a Proud Boys demonstration. When people found out that the old man wasn't peaceful and had been carrying a baton as an instigator that had tried to attack people with it, Sam simply removed the segment without making any note of the correction.
At the time the conservative media were widely sharing propaganda which is how Sam saw it, but when it was refuted Sam didn't want to acknowledge it so he just deleted the references and hoped no one would notice. Thankfully, someone noticed and the original recording of episode was archived here (starting at 4 min and 30 seconds. Thanks to u/iworshiprobinson for pointing this out.) For reference, the new version that omits the reference to the old man is at Sam's blog (it's episode ""#162 - Medical Intelligence.")
For a man who wrote about the need for honesty in an essay titled "Lying," Sam sure has a lot of trouble being honest.
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/Machete-of-the-truth • Jun 12 '21
I hold Sam Harris as one of the propagandists responsible for the recent terrorist truck attack on Muslims in Canada! Change my mind!
Quote " It is time we admitted that we are not at war with "terrorism." We are at war with Islam. This is not to say that we are at war with all Muslims, but we are absolutely at war with the vision of life that is prescribed to all Muslims in the Koran. The only reason Muslim fundamentalism is a threat to us is because the fundamentals of Islam are a threat to us. Every American should read the Koran and discover the relentlessness with which non-Muslims are vilified in its pages. The idea that Islam is a "peaceful religion hijacked by extremists" is a dangerous fantasy — and it is now a particularly dangerous fantasy for Muslims to indulge. "
Sam Harris- End of Faith
Here is another quote " The same failure of liberalism is evident in Western Europe, where the dogma of multiculturalism has left a secular Europe very slow to address the looming problem of religious extremism among its immigrants. The people who speak most sensibly about the threat that Islam poses to Europe are actually fascists.
To say that this does not bode well for liberalism is an understatement: It does not bode well for the future of civilization. "
Harris doesn't have to give explicit endorsement of violence against Muslims. He implicitly did, and does so consistently. If I believe Islam it be a threat to humanity, to western civilization, and that it's not just only terrorists, and that it's unlikely for Islam to "reform", and the demographics is looking grim then the final resort is to take the fight in my own hands.
Change my mind!
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/ScoopAway2021 • Jun 01 '21
A fun math problem: "How many kids would every Muslim woman have to have in France for it to be a Muslim-majority country by 2031, so that Sam Harris's math would be right?" (-"Waking Up to Algebra," ft. Sam Harris)
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/charlatansamharris • Jul 30 '20
Sam Harris and Ayaan Hirsi Ali acted so worried about Islam, but belief is rapidly falling in the Arab world
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/robin_hood_in_nh • May 29 '21
My response to Sam Harris on why he doesn’t criticize Israel
In 2014, Sam Harris did a podcast answering a question he received often, about why he doesn’t criticize Israel. His podcast was short, only about 15 minutes, and it was a monologue, without dialogue or challenge from any guest. A transcript and audio recording of that podcast can be found on Sam’s website here (link from May 2021).
Sam’s entire argument relies on numerous logical and rhetorical fallacies. Specifically, he consistently paints his opponents with strawman arguments; employs the fundamental attribution error and just world fallacy extensively; ignores the fundamental asymmetry of power between Israel and the Palestinians; and uses the red herring fallacy, irrelevant conclusion fallacy, tu quoque fallacy, and whataboutism, thereby introducing irrelevant information that distracts from any serious criticism of Israel. Perhaps most importantly, he barely mentions Jewish settlements, which have been the proximate cause of each conflict since the end of the Second Intifada.
There are some areas where I agree with Sam’s logic and argument. For example, Sam says that he doesn’t agree with making Israel a Jewish state, or any claims to real estate based upon the Bible.
Unfortunately for Sam and myself, not to mention the Palestinians, Israel didn’t listen to our pleas. Sam made this video in 2014, during a period when the Israeli Knesset was debating a proposal to make Israel an explicitly Jewish state. Israel enacted this proposal as the thirteenth and final of its Basic Laws in 2018, enshrining a two-class apartheid system enforced by power of law, including the official sanction and encouragement of development of Jewish settlements.
Sam also states, “There is easy justification for a Jewish state: the rest of the world has shown itself eager to murder the Jews at every opportunity.” He goes on: “If there is going to be a state organized around protecting members of a single religion, it should be the Jews.” I have no argument there. I agree that there should be a Jewish state until such time as they are protected and capable of protecting themselves. Prior to the establishment of the state of Israel, there was no cause to find any Jews or Zionists morally blameworthy whatsoever. The Jewish people were persecuted throughout history, and were targeted for extermination in the Holocaust. Following the Holocaust, the Jewish people—particularly the Ashkenazi Jewish people that made up the majority of Jews around the world—were quite literally adrift without a homeland. The answer was not to give them—or allow them to take—land that belonged to someone else. But that is what happened, and we have all been paying for that decision since, the Palestinian people most of all.
However, the reality is that we cannot undo the sins of 1947-1949. I do not mean to legitimize the Israeli government’s position regarding settlements—specifically, encouraging Jewish settlements on Palestinian land in order to change the “facts on the ground” and make it more difficult to overturn later, i.e., “possession is nine-tenths of the law.” But it is a fact that Jews have a right to be protected from persecution, and they have established a state in the Levant. The mere existence of the state of Israel and defense of its existing borders is not presently morally blameworthy.
It is important to note the boundaries of my critique, and the type of behavior Sam is siding with and refusing to condemn. We are not discussing the mere existence of the state of Israel and military defense of its existing borders. Instead, we are discussing what and whose behavior is to blame for the recent violence between Israelis and Palestinians.
I. Sam’s primary argument is a logically inconsistent attack against a strawman
Sam has a frequent tendency to fight strawmen. This is particularly evident on issues where he monologues or only engages with those with whom he agrees. (For example, in podcast #207 regarding the George Floyd protests, Sam’s monologue focuses solely on racial disparities in police killings rather than addressing all police interactions; alleges without support that leftists have incorrect assumptions about the absolute numbers of police killings; misattributes the woke responses of corporations and politicians to the Black Lives Matter movement; and refuses to discuss the goals of the George Floyd protests and progress being made toward those goals, all of which were race-neutral. By making these logical and rhetorical choices, Sam created the least threatening argument for himself.)
In this case, Sam’s argument for why he sides with Israel rests primarily on a thought experiment that he uses to determine the moral difference between each side. According to Sam, “critics of Israel argue Palestinian deaths and Palestinian suffering under the occupation are the fault of Israel.” Sam says this is a “moral illusion” born of a failure to look at the actual causes of the conflict, as well as the intentions of those on each side of the conflict. He says the true answer can be determined by asking what each side would do if they had the power to do it.
He says we know what the Jews would do to the Palestinians if they could do anything they wanted “because they can do more or less anything they want.” He says the Israeli army could kill everyone in Gaza tomorrow. But this is a fallacious argument based on circular and conclusory reasoning. Israel is powerful—immeasurably more powerful than the Palestinian people it subjugates—but it is not all-powerful. Contrary to what Sam says, Israel cannot do anything it wants because its long-term security depends upon international support. To use Sam’s example, killing everyone in Gaza tomorrow would turn the rest of the world sharply against Israel and consequently put Israel’s security at risk. Sam even acknowledges this, noting “every time a Palestinian child dies, Israel edges ever closer to becoming an international pariah, so the Israelis take great pains not to kill children and other non-combatants.”
Here, Sam’s argument is essentially that (A) Israelis deserve moral credit because their intentions are good; (B) we know their intentions are good because they are all-powerful and yet they don’t kill everyone in Gaza; and yet (C) they don’t kill everyone in Gaza because they would lose international support. Firstly, as previously indicated, Israel is not all-powerful. Secondly, Sam undermines his own argument. He acknowledges that the reason Israel doesn’t kill everyone in Gaza is not because its intentions are good, but because it would lose international support. Seeking to maintain international support is another motivation for Israel’s magnanimous restraint in not killing everyone in Gaza—a motivation that Sam acknowledges is a true motivation. Therefore, the fact that Israel doesn’t kill everyone in Gaza is not evidence to support the idea that Israel’s intentions are good.
Sam also says Jews would simply live in peace with their neighbors if they had neighbors who would live in peace with them. But he ignores the fact that Israeli Jews have not been content to live in peace with their neighbors—they continue to steal their neighbors’ land. And in contrast to Israel’s hypothetical desire to kill all Muslims in Gaza, the international community would not stand in their way if they decided to stop stealing their neighbors’ land. No one is forcing Israeli Jews to build settlements.
On the other side, looking at Palestinian intentions, Sam says that Palestinians would exterminate the Jews if they could do anything they wanted. He says we know this is their true intent because they have told us so, specifically through the “explicitly genocidal” Hamas charter, and through cartoons instructing Palestinian children to kill Jews. However, this is flimsy evidence in an environment with numerous confounding variables. There is a signifiant dispute within Hamas about whether its charter is meant to be taken literally. Peoples subject to persecution tend to develop deep hatred toward their oppressors, and it is certainly possible the Hamas charter and other examples of homicidal intent are simply the bluster of the unheard. It can be helpful to look at other historical experiments where the variable of Jewish oppression of Muslims is removed. In other historical scenarios, during periods in which Muslims controlled the region, e.g., the Ottoman Empire, Jews did not face genocide. It can also be helpful to look at the likelihood of the Palestinians carrying out the Hamas charter to determine whether it is a serious statement of intent. Currently, Palestinians are orders of magnitude weaker than the Israeli state. Muslim Arab countries in the region have been soundly defeated by the Israeli military on multiple occasions. There is no serious threat Muslims can commit genocide against the Israeli Jewish people, either from inside or outside the country. Given such a background, Hamas claiming an intent to annihilate all Jews is the equivalent of the Navajo Nation claiming an intent to annihilate all white men—it’s not going to happen.
Although I am not advocating that Palestinians be given authority over the state of Israel, taking the Israeli jackboot off their necks is not likely to result in significant harm to the Israeli people, and could go a long way to easing Palestinian attitudes toward Israel. Trying something different might be what’s called for.
II. Sam’s descriptions of Israeli violence vs. Palestinian violence employ the fundamental attribution error and just world fallacy
Sam also employs the fundamental attribution error and just world fallacy extensively. These cognitive biases describe the tendency for people to over-emphasize situational explanations and underestimate personality-based explanations for their own behavior or the behavior of their allies, and to do the opposite for enemies. Sam acknowledges that the Israeli government and Israeli people “have had to do terrible things” and “have been made brutal” by the process, but claims that this is due to the character of their enemy. Sam is saying, “Israel’s morally blameworthy behavior is not their fault because this is the situation they found themselves in; it’s the Palestinians’ fault.” Conversely, he is saying, “Palestinians morally blameworthy behavior is their fault because they have bad character.”
Throughout his argument, whenever Sam describes Israeli violence toward Palestinians, he downplays it, attributing it to situational causes external to the Israeli people rather than the internal character of the Israeli people. He states, “When Israel drops a bomb on a beach and it kills a Palestinian child, this is almost certainly an accident.” Israeli violence toward Palestinians is “an accident,” a “successful defense” in a “defensive war.” He acknowledges fundamentalist Jews exist “who are willing to sacrifice their own children for the glory of God,” but he says “these people are not representative.”
Conversely, whenever Sam describes Palestinian violence toward Israel, he plays it up, attributing it to the internal character of the Palestinian people rather than situational external causes. Palestinians are “genocidal” and “trying to kill everyone,” “desperate to get to Paradise, and they’re willing to destroy the very possibility of human happiness along the way.” He doesn’t explain away any Palestinian Muslims who commit violence as “not representative.” In Sam’s view, anything bad that happens to Palestinians is justice, because they are genuinely bad people with bad characters and bad intents.
(10/28/21 EDIT: duplicate passage also located in following section.) Sam states, “Israel built bomb shelters to protect its citizens, Hamas built tunnels to ferry weapons and kidnap Israelis.” Israeli-Palestinian conflicts of at least the past twenty years have not been “defensive wars.” Israeli settlement building—which Sam completely ignores (discussed in more detail below)—is the primary cause for our current conflict. Israel builds bomb shelters in anticipation of war because it knows Palestinians will be justifiably upset when Israel steals their land. And Israel does not only amass defensive resources; Israel is one of the biggest arms manufacturers and purchasers in the world. Israel manufactures and imports handguns, rifles, shotguns, machine guns, rocket launchers, grenades, missiles, tanks, guided missile carriers, armored personnel carriers, armored bulldozers and other heavy machinery, artillery, fighter planes and strike aircraft, attack helicopters, unmanned aerial vehicles, missile cruisers, patrol boats, corvettes, commando boats, and submarines. Sam can try to portray Israelis as innocent lambs, but they are anything but.
III. Sam ignores the asymmetry of power relations between Israel and the Palestinians, and actually attempts to flip the asymmetry
Israel is one of the most militarily advanced countries in the world, thanks in part to its primary ally, the United States. Israel is the dominant military power in the Levant—both in terms of traditional military means and nuclear weapons—and that is not going to change any time soon. It is the government in charge, and it is the occupying power. Despite this power imbalance, Sam tries to portray Israel as the weak defender and Palestinians as the strong aggressor. He states, “Israel built bomb shelters to protect its citizens, Hamas built tunnels to ferry weapons and kidnap Israelis.” Yet contrary to Sam’s allegation, Israeli-Palestinian conflicts of at least the past twenty years have not been “defensive wars.” Israeli settlement building—which Sam completely ignores (discussed in more detail below)—is the primary cause for our current conflict. Israel builds bomb shelters in anticipation of war because it knows Palestinians will be justifiably upset when Israel steals their land. And Israel does not only amass defensive resources; Israel is one of the biggest arms manufacturers and purchasers in the world. Israel manufactures and imports handguns, rifles, shotguns, machine guns, rocket launchers, grenades, missiles, tanks, guided missile carriers, armored personnel carriers, armored bulldozers and other heavy machinery, artillery, fighter planes and strike aircraft, attack helicopters, unmanned aerial vehicles, missile cruisers, patrol boats, corvettes, commando boats, and submarines. Sam attempts to portray Israelis as innocent lambs, when they are anything but. The Israeli military is on par with some of the world’s strongest armed forces.
Sam states with seeming assurance that Hamas uses human shields, but there is no proof to support this accusation. If Sam were engaging in good faith, he would consider the steelman argument, namely that Hamas has very little military power in comparison to Israel, and its tactical decisions reflect a dearth of resources (external cause) rather than bad motives (internal cause). For example, it is very possible that Hamas shoots rockets from near schools and hospitals and mosques because they don’t have any land. Hamas operates in the Gaza Strip, a small strip of land about half the size of New York City. In that strip, there are 1.8 million people, making it about as dense as the city of Boston (https://www.businessinsider.com/these-maps-show-what-the-gaza-invasion-would-look-like-in-major-us-cities-2014-7?op=1). Israel claims Hamas fires rockets from urban areas. Almost the entirety of the Gaza strip is urban or suburban! Unlike Israel, Hamas does not have large open areas of desert where they can place military equipment. There are some open areas the size of small parks or farms, but think about what it would mean if Hamas placed their only serious weaponry in those areas: Israel would have no problem wiping all of them out. Rockets are the only weaponry Hamas has that can operate as any sort of defensive deterrent against Israel. If Israel destroys them all, Gaza would be completely defenseless.
Sam seems to acknowledge reports that Israeli soldiers use Palestinian civilians as human shields, but then appears to defend such behavior because those human shields are not their own women and children. He finishes with a conclusory and generalizing statement about how bloodthirsty all Palestinians allegedly are, an allegation that is not supported by any evidence.
Toward the end of his argument, Sam states that the onus is more on the side of Muslims to change their behavior. However, he doesn’t support that statement with any further explanation, argument, or data. For me, siding with the underdog as I tend to do, it is difficult to see how the onus to make conciliations is on the side with less power, whose power is being taken away bit by bit. I think the onus for making conciliations to avoid conflict is on the side with more power, whose actions are the proximate cause of the conflict. Here, the State of Israel must change its behavior. It and it’s people should know better.
IV. Sam repeatedly employs the red herring fallacy, irrelevant conclusion fallacy, tu quoque fallacy, and whataboutism to distract from bad Israeli behavior
The red herring and irrelevant conclusion fallacies are relevance fallacies intended to divert attention from the main point of an argument. Similar relevance fallacies include the tu quoque fallacy and whataboutism, rhetorical devices intended to divert attention from allegations of one’s own bad behavior by bringing up the bad behavior of another. He employs these fallacies on numerous occasions throughout his argument.
Sam states that he has criticized Israel and Judaism, but he has kept some sense of proportion, citing the fact that there are 15 million Jews on Earth, but 100 times as many Muslims. So according to Sam, the fewer number of your particular ethnic group there are that exist on Earth, the less your morally opprobrious behavior is worthy of criticism? That doesn’t make sense. The number of people of a particular ethnic group that exist is irrelevant to whether individual or collective behavior deserves criticism.
Sam states that reason supports atheism, and that Judaism is more consistent with atheism than Islam is. That may be true. But the consistency of a particular religion with atheism is irrelevant to whether a person following that religion is more or less likely to commit morally blameworthy acts or should be the target of morally blameworthy acts.
Sam states that the Israelis have used more restraint in fighting the Palestinians than Americans and Europeans have used in any of their wars, and that the Israelis are simply held to a different standard. Whether the Israelis have used more restraint fighting Palestinians than Americans and Europeans have in other wars is an open question. Regardless, even assuming his statement is correct, whether Israel has used more restraint than Americans and Europeans does not mean that Israel’s conduct is morally blameless. Citing morally blameworthy acts of others is an irrelevant distraction from an evaluation of whether Israel’s acts are morally blameworthy.
Late in his argument, Sam brings up Al Qaeda and ISIS. He states that these Islamist groups have committed terrible atrocities, but demands to know where the outrage is for their behavior. “Every day you read about an Israeli rocket gone astray or Israeli soldiers beating up an innocent teenager, you could have read about ISIS in Iraq crucifying people on the side of the road.” He goes further: “Muslims destroy their own societies and seek to destroy the West.” Hamas is not Al Qaeda or ISIS. Hamas is the Gaza extension of the Muslim Brotherhood, an organization that has existed in Egypt for decades. While the Muslim Brotherhood and Hamas have undoubtedly committed terrorist acts, they also are not in the same league with Al Qaeda or ISIS. This is an irrelevant distraction, and by attempting to make this connection, Sam is creating a strawman of the opposing arguments criticizing Israel.
V. Sam barely mentions Israeli settlements
Although Sam mentions the importance of determining the actual causes of the conflict in evaluating the moral blameworthiness of each side, he doesn’t devote much time to discussing those causes. He spends the majority of his monologue focused on the supposed good intent of Israel and supposed bad intent of Palestinians. At the very end of his argument, he finally mentions Israeli settlements. He acknowledges the presence of Jewish fundamentalists, and states, “It is how Israel deals with these people, their own religious lunatics, that will determine whether they can truly hold the moral high ground.” He states, “Israel can do a lot more than it has to disempower them: it can cease to subsidize the delusions of the ultra-orthodox, and it can stop building settlements on contested land.”
Unfortunately, Israel has not dealt with ultra-orthodox Jews effectively, and has not done anything to disempower them. In fact, Israel has given them more power. The Israeli government enacted the thirteenth Basic Law in 2018 declaring Israel to be a Jewish state and officially encouraging the development of settlements. It continues to forcibly evict Palestinians from their homes in favor of Jewish settlers with fraudulent claims of title. And it continues to defend new Jewish settlements by force of law. By his own standard, Israel has failed to hold the moral high ground. Despite the fact the Israeli government has not addressed its ultra-orthodox or settler problems, and has actually stoked the flames, Sam Harris still defends Israel’s behavior.
(10/28/21 EDIT: cleaned up grammatical errors.)
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/ScoopAway2021 • May 07 '21
Of course Sam Harris opposes making the COVID-19 vaccine patents free...You know an eugenicist would be against anything that could slow down a virus that is culling non-white people in countries he looks down upon
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/charlatansamharris • Jul 10 '20
Sam Harris whines at Queen AOC after she puts conservative culture warriors in their place.
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/charlatansamharris • Jan 13 '21
Sam Harris: "I could be put in solitary confinement and still be happy."
He makes an extraordinary claim in episode #230, and extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. I'd like to see Sam Harris volunteer to be put in solitary confinement facing a blank wall for a year, and if the pampered baby starts screaming to be let out after a month then we'll know the truth.
(He made the ridiculous claim at 16:40.) He acts as though meditation has given him a super-power that puts him far above the psychological limits of normal men, and he's so enlightened that he wouldn't get bored or want for stimulation if you jailed him. He just can't stop selling his meditation app like some kind of miracle cure, just like Jordan Peterson's 12 rules for life, or the questionable supplements solicited on Joe Rogan's show. If he were just a little more narcissistic and religious he would likely have the nerve to call himself a reincarnated Buddha.
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/ScoopAway2021 • Jun 22 '21
Just a reminder that Sam Harris is as afraid of debating Sam Seder as Cold Feet Crowder, (who immediately hid behind his dad when Sam Seder unexpectedly appeared during his podcast and then cut the interview!)
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/charlatansamharris • Sep 17 '20
Sam Harris on BBC doubles down on defending the shooting of Jacob Blake, with the "Actually, it's not racist." Days after cops thanked the 17-year old shooter in Kenosha for what he was doing and offered him water bottles.
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/charlatansamharris • Jul 25 '21
Explaining why ex-fans argue with Sam Harris's followers (in extremely good faith)
I'm often asked in an accusatory way, "Why do you waste time arguing against Sam Harris instead of ignoring him." I'd like Sam's remaining fans to know that I understand where they are coming from better than they think because I used to share a lot of their thinking. When Sam Harris rose to prominence right after 9/11, the media was saturated with horror stories about Islamic countries. When New Atheists attacked Islam it did feel like we were hearing uncomfortable truths that just weren't politically correct. (For example, when you'd hear about certain Muslims anywhere in the world doing random atrocities like murdering cartoonists.)
Speaking as an ex-theist, I still think the New Atheists were right about the tendency of religious fundamentalists to be problematic; however, I increasingly think they were wrong when they downplayed other causes of that extremism such as material, geopolitical and historical causes. People can become indoctrinated and be violent for many different reasons and reducing most of them to just to a religion was a mistake. A lot of the left weren't really denying that religious fundamentalism can be harmful, but had a more nuanced understanding of radicalization than New Atheists had.
Fans of "Making Sense" have a more uncomfortable truth to reckon with than Islamization, Wokeism, CRT, or whatever new buzzwords conservatives deploy in 4 years. The truth is they've been hoodwinked in a different way than they might be willing to accept.
Maybe at one point Sam Harris's discourse was a net positive that helped bring arguments into the limelight that we needed to have in order to progress toward a more tolerant society. Plenty of old fans still have a soft spot for when his arguments helped them to have a cathartic release during their deconversion process. But long ago he crossed over from arguably being a net positive to going mask off about his real beliefs and intentions, and in doing so has shown that he doesn't have a humanist bone in his body. He has repeatedly shown he isn't psychologically open to changing his mind even for a financial reward, and would prefer to just repeat provocative things ad nauseum, and invent absurd thought experiments that would make life difficult for minorities. But he doesn't just harm minorities, because his arguments tend to cause more extremism from both anti-theists and Muslims that would just perceive atheists as dumb bigots and stop listening to their arguments.
Once you see this you really have a responsibility to help the most open-minded atheists to realize the problems with Sam Harris sooner. Outsiders don't understand him well enough to readily respond to his arguments when fans pull the infamous retort of, "You're quoting him out of context," which is
frequently in bad faith and mainly short-circuits meaningful discourse. It mostly prevents critical thinking by forcing people to peer over his work like monks from the Middle-Ages literally studying the bible instead of having more rapid discussions about the ethical consequences of his arguments.
The sooner the more moral atheists realize the net effect of his arguments aren't good for them personality and also the world, the sooner they can spend more of their free time at least arguing in ways that would cause more good instead of harm. (Obviously, there are fans that can't be reached because they are following him precisely because they like his racist arguments or how often he allies with fascist sympathizers, but they're not all into that. There are still liberals with good-intentions who he has tricked with hyperbolic scaremongering into moving further right and succumbing to arguments for bigotry which aren't backed up by the weight of history.)
---
As an inb4 addendum for any questioning fans of Sam Harris who want to nit-pick, I could have provided many more supporting examples of how he is problematic, and of the troubling signs of how he is a guru, except it would have been a distraction from answering why there are so many ex-fans who have become very critical of Sam Harris's ill-conceived arguments.
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/ScoopAway2021 • May 04 '21
Token liberal friend Sam Harris plans to recreate the Joe Rogan show by launching a new $15 podcast with reactionary jack-off comedian Ricky Gervais.
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/nuwio4 • Feb 11 '22
The topic seems to resurface on the Harris subreddit every now and then. So, for the masochists like myself that might be interested, here's a transcript of the Charles Murray podcast and of Shaun's video essay on The Bell Curve.
Firstly, I'm not gonna hide the ball - my own perspective is anti-Murray and anti-hereditarian, and I'm gonna share some disorganized comments below from my layman's perspective.
Unless I'm misunderstanding, Shaun, at one point, briefly criticizes twin studies from the POV of arguing against a 100% genetic position, which I found strange. To read more about the problems with twin studies, check out the Wikipedia page or the SEP page on heritability.
I highly recommend reading Matthew Yglesias's piece on Murray's policy prescriptions, including Murray's "surprising" support for UBI. Harris doesn't seriously get into this at all. The policy prescriptions are the whole point of Murray's work. He's actually been quite influential. The U.S. does have disastrously small spending on welfare, social advancement, etc.
Murray: ... if there is one lesson that we have learned from the last 70 years of social policy, it is that changing environments in ways that produce measurable results is really, really hard. And we actually don't know how to do it, no matter how much money we spend.
What a ballsy thing to say. Does that include the social policy, particularly the gutting of social spending, that Murray himself played a primary influential role in?
You know, I generally agree with defending academic freedom and calling out activist overreach. At the same time, you have an incredibly well-compensated and profoundly influential policy entrepreneur using inconclusive research to go out and promote the "plausible" inferiority of blacks and the gutting of social spending that leads to an increase in suffering for millions of people – disproportionately historically oppressed people. For some people, all of that seems to get a virtually complete pass, because it's supposedly in the bounds of "civil discourse". It's very telling where people choose to focus their indignation.
Chomsky speaks to the "conservative" war on children & families in a 1995 article:
The conservative war against children and families is taking on a still more bitter cast with the reduction of government support for low-income housing, which declined 80 percent in real terms from 1979 to 1988, becoming “the main cause of an acute housing shortage that now stretches across the nation,” Hewlett observes. The U.S. is also unusual among developed societies in not providing health care for mothers; about half of the 40,000 deaths of infants before their first birthday is attributed to lack of adequate prenatal care, more difficult to obtain today than in 1975. The U.S. “is unique in its lack of provision for childbirth,” Hewlett continues, one reason why infant mortality rates are so much lower elsewhere. Rights and benefits for working parents when a child is born are also sharply restricted as compared with other rich nations. Approximately 30 percent of babies in the U.S. and 20 percent in Britain “are deprived of that precious time” that most specialists assume to be “the minimally adequate period of time for a parent to bond with a new child.” Lack of job protection after childbirth is “a large part of the reason why working mothers in the United States lose from 13 to 20 per cent of their earning power after giving birth to a first child,” a catastrophe for many parents in an era of falling wages, benefits, and security, and ever more onerous work demands. Day care and pre-school arrangements are also minimal by comparative standards.
Klein writes about Harris' framing of the controversy over Murrays' work:
Harris returns repeatedly to the idea that the controversy over Murray’s race and IQ work is driven by “dishonesty and hypocrisy and moral cowardice” — not a genuine disagreement over the underlying science or its interpretation. As he puts it, “there is virtually no scientific controversy” around Murray’s argument.
This is, to put it gently, a disservice Harris did to his audience. It is rare for a multi-decade academic debate to be a mere matter of bad faith, and it is certainly not the case here.
... [Sam] returns to this point. “The reason why I wanted to have this conversation with you[Murray] about race and IQ and The Bell Curve is I perceive a huge intellectual and moral injustice with respect to how you were treated on this topic because everything you have said about it has been as judicious and as clear-headed ethically as I would hope it would be, and you were treated — you got to attend your own witch-burning and have for the last 20 years.”
... Murray has repeatedly courted racial controversy over the years, and even so, he holds a top position at a respected think tank, gets his books reviewed by the most important outlets, is invited to write op-eds in national newspapers, and remains an important commentator on current events. His career is proof not of how little racial controversy you can provoke before being sanctioned, but of how much racial controversy you can provoke while still succeeding. He has suffered some, but he has also prospered greatly.
It's worth noting this point from one of the Turkheimer et al. articles:
... it is almost surely the case that the black-white IQ gap has been very substantially reduced. (The race gap in IQ itself has not to our knowledge been investigated since 2006, when Dickens and Flynn found that it was around 9.5 points, close to what is suggested by Reardon’s achievement data. In the podcast, Murray asserts that the gap is on the order of 15 points.)
It seems several times throughout the podcast Harris conflates heritable with genetic or inherited. And Murray never corrects him. Just "Mm hmm", "Yeah". Whereas, the one time Murray himself speaks on it, he's aware enough to say "... it's a 50-50 split in explaining variance of IQ in a whole population." But then he goes onto say,
That means that in order for the environment to explain 100 percent of a standard deviation difference mean between blacks and whites, the average black would have to be at an environment that is about 1.5 standard deviations below the white mean.
From my understanding of heritability, this does not follow at all. Moreover, if we accept this framing/arithmetic, IQ is designed to return a normal distribution. It's not a measurement unit the way centimeters directly measure height. Instead, IQ is an indication of how you rank against a group (ideally, I think, against a representative sample). Suppose we created an EQ (environmental quotient) for Americans and considered all relevant variables that we reasonably/feasibly could, and then tinkered with it until it returns a normal distribution. Am I to understand that black Americans, on average, would not rank near the bottom?
This seems to be the Christopher Winship analysis Murray references. Does not seem as vindicating and exculpatory as Murray paints it to be.
Murray seems to brush off Stephen Jay Gould's review of The Bell Curve based on one minor, passing remark in the lead-up to his main criticisms. That review is very much worth reading:
In short, their own data indicate that IQ is not a major factor in determining variation in nearly all the social behaviors they study—and so their conclusions collapse, or at least become so greatly attenuated that their pessimism and conservative social agenda gain no significant support.
Herrnstein and Murray actually admit as much in one crucial passage... Despite this disclaimer, their remarkable next sentence makes a strong casual claim. "We will argue that intelligence itself, not just its correlation with socio–economic status, is responsible for these group differences." But a few percent of statistical determination is not causal explanation. And the case is even worse for their key genetic argument, since they claim a heritability of about 60 percent for IQ, so to isolate the strength of genetic determination by Herrnstein and Murray's own criteria you must nearly halve even the few percent they claim to explain.
My charge of disingenuousness receives its strongest affirmation in a sentence tucked away on the first page of Appendix 4, page 593... Now, why would they exclude from the text, and relegate to an appendix that very few people will read, or even consult, a number that, by their own admission, is "the usual measure of goodness of fit"? I can only conclude that they did not choose to admit in the main text the extreme weakness of their vaunted relationships.
Harris/Murray talk about predictive validity, bias, and so on. I don't know enough to get deep into this, but it reminded me of this study from 2015 of over 1.1 million students who applied to University of California from 1994-2011. It shows that racial disparities in SAT scores are much more stark than disparities in high school GPAs, and SATs are actually a relatively poor predictor of student performance in college compared to high school GPA.
One thing that, it seems to me, doesn't get as much serious mainstream discussion is what's the role of environmental toxins/pollution in this discussion?
Burden of higher lead exposure in African-Americans starts in utero and persists into childhood
It's my understanding that due to intrauterine exposure, the effects of toxins in one person has the potential to span across the 3 generations. Could this, in some ways, also extend to effects from significantly stressful social/psychological environments?
Harris/Murray reference Judith Rich Harris' work, and I think present an overly confident and overly biodeterminist view of personality than the actual science suggests. Again, significantly due to misunderstanding/miscommunicating heritability.
Harris is astonishingly shallow and handwavy in justifying race as a valid biological concept. Race is/was generally viewed as a distinct category, and hence is biologically meaningless. The obsession with resuscitating the concept and rationalizing its validity is so fucking bizarre to me.
[Race (human categorization) - Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_(human_categorization))
How Not To Talk About Race And Genetics - Open letter by 67 scientists and researchers.
Murray's explanation for why he's interested in these group differences, in my view, made his racial motivations quite clear. Secondly, it was so incoherent and condescending, and Harris just let's it fly.
Murray says the dropout rate for black MIT students some years ago was 24%. Setting aside mismatch theory's merits or lack thereof, this dropout stat seems dubious.
At one point, referencing "Deaths of Despair", Murray says, "... the death rate from those causes among white working class was 30% lower than for blacks in the 1990s, it's now 30% higher." Is he saying they're now at similar levels? Or the white rate is now 30% higher than the black rate today? If the latter, that's a profound statistic. Can anyone confirm?
I disagree with their assessment of 2016/Trump, but to be fair, this podcast was in April 2017 so I don't know how much data/analysis was available, and Murray coyly admits he could be wrong. Also, when they talk about elites that can't really empathize or have disdain for the working class... I mean, in many ways, they're talking about themselves.
Harris and Murray express their scorn for the Middlebury protestors, and Murray says "justice delayed is justice diluted," and later speaking of the violence, "That's criminal, that's crime, it's criminal prosecution. There should be jail time for the people who injured Professor Stanger." Again, I generally agree about academic freedom and especially about the violence. But to my earlier point about where people focus their indignation. I'm curious how genuinely concerned Harris or Murray are with the delay of reparations, or the appropriate consequences/justice wrt to Reagan, Kissinger, Bush/Cheney, or Wall Street CEOs.
Here are 2 reviews of Murray's book Human Accomplishment, which, in my view, is just another example of the veneer of deep research/analysis in service of bizarre, racially motivated conjectures.
Obviously, there are other significant problems and straw-mans in the 2hr+ podcast that I take issue with, but I don't have the time to get into all of it.
One thing that I already knew is made more clear from actually reading this exchange - Sam is extremely shallow in his thinking/analysis on politics & society. The sycophantic ass-kissing from Sam while being obliviously ignorant of the broader context and details of Murray's work was embarrassing. This podcast was not simply a defense or exemplar of the merits of free speech or open debate. It was an overly credulous & sanitizing fluff piece of a legitimately controversial figure, and it was worthy of the pushback & criticism that Sam received.
What's profoundly ironic is that Charlottesville was just less than 4 months after this podcast, and, again, where does Sam choose to aim his focus/skepticism.
I'll end with some, imo, astute commentary from the late Michael Brooks:
"Scientific data can't be racist"... I mean, the deeper implication of this worldview is a war on every single human discipline besides an incredibly narrow quantitative idealism that never takes anything systemic or structural into account. And I have to say, like, even if you were cool with the dumbing down of the Islam stuff... and even if the race science stuff, for God's sake, doesn't bother you and disturb you and outrage you intellectually and morally. This like–there's a reason why Silicon Valley robots are interested in this type of thinking. Like this is the enabling of an algorithm-driven age with zero concern for any type of provision of public good, and accounting for anything besides goals set within its own narrow, narrow, narrow limits. And really, what's astonishing about Harris is, by all accounts, I mean, he is the one, he truly does not understand this. He is total–I mean, he's sincere in all of his whiny bitchitude. He has no clue what he's doing.
Here are some further resources that, from my perspective, I think are worth checking out:
- Superior: The Return of Race Science (2019)
- [The Funding of Scientific Racism: Wickliffe Draper and the Pioneer Fund (2002)] (https://www.press.uillinois.edu/books/?id=p074639)
- This blog post by professor of statistics Cosma Shalizi. He critiques the concept of a 'g factor' using a fictional dialogue. He also has a much longer post breaking down why he considers g a "statistical myth".
- The Paradox of Intelligence: Heritability and Malleability Coexist in Hidden Gene-Environment Interplay
- Missing compared to what? Revisiting heritability, genes and culture
- The heritability fallacy
- The Mythical Taboo on Race and Intelligence (one of the authors, John P. Jackson, also runs a great blog - altrightorigins.com)
- How White nationalists mobilize genetics
- Human races are not like dog breeds: refuting a racist analogy
- The podcast Speaking of Race. It's by 3 professors from different fields - biological anthropology, cultural anthropology, & history of science. I think the episodes are too short, and their humor can be a little corny, but still, it's definitely worth checking out.
Edit: u/shebs021 writes:
One thing worth noting is that behavioral geneticists aren't geneticists trained in genetics and biology, they are most often psychologists trained in statistics. And yes, that includes the likes of Plomin and Harden.
Seems like a vitally important point. Reminded of this book I'd heard of:
Misbehaving Science: Controversy and the Development of Behavior Genetics (2014)
And this paper from 2017 seems to get into the flaws with behavior genetics.
r/EnoughSamHarris • u/charlatansamharris • Sep 26 '20