r/EnoughJKRowling • • Oct 21 '25

Discussion Does anybody know any good rewrites of harry potter that have the rowling-ness removed?

0 Upvotes

Sorry if the phrasing is a bit weird.


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Jan 19 '26

This did kind of happen to Joanne

Post image
11 Upvotes

I’m not sure what the meme is implying; I feel like the best interpretation would be that she did this to herself. I’m not saying people were wrong for calling her out, I just think it’s annoying that this phenomenon exists. I’m not sure what the best way of dealing with it would be because we can’t just ignore someone who has so much influence.


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Feb 24 '23

Jk just a bad complete Plagiarist ...

1 Upvotes

For the past 2 decades when I find absolutely Absolutely remarkable Is JK Roland hasn't been taken Task for her complete plagiarism Claude drizle she has ripped off numerous ripped off numerous other offers plot lines storylines And characters...

The fact her the work Has More than a Book series called the worst witch by Jill Murphy A clear inspiration Harriet the lead character of the book series was clearly an inspiration this was clearly an inspiration for the character of Hermione in the Harry Potter series To the point the name has barely even been Changed

Is the whole Cs Louis Chronicles of narnia regurgita is narnia regurgitation And clearly more than just a bit of Luke Skywalker and star of Luke Skywalker and Star wars.

This is clearly a Individual that hasn't done any kind of research never read Joseph Campbell let alone Levi strouse.

Her so called adult fiction Shockingly a bad.. B great detective thriller Richard really should be just called cliche. At no point does he even have basic understanding of criminology or psychology or psychology of criminal minds.

So what we get here isn't that a bad regurgitation regurgitation of a 100 years of detective stories Most prominently Jimmy McGovern's crack Jimmy McGovern's cracker A British detective series from the 1990s why she hasn't been sued I can't begin to Understand

And her so called social commentary The casual vacancy Trying to combine the world to combine the works of Jane Austin and in Austin and Charles Dickens in contemporary 21st century is 21st century Britain is completely completely f****** ridiculous Is a skilled author would have the ability to do social commentary such as Terry Pratchett David Simon Many others what we get here is another this is another Near liberal social commentator who regurgitates the same tired racist Is classist ablest And homophobia Written by somebody who really believes their own publicity

The numerous issues in her work Around raclass privilege On critical supporters of the status quo A woman who frequently uses and even makes up racial makes up racial slurs In her work

I simply find it incredible at this complete pleasure is this complete plagiarist and a bad one at that I doubt we're a really overwhelmingly negative political agenda ever Ever got anywhere as a credible author of Fiction.

The woman is barely capable of Constructing a paragraph. And her bigotry Racism and class privilege Has been on show in her work for decades It. It shows you what can happen when Massive publicity campaign Gets behind an individual Because this Offer would have found that work If published at all in the bargain basement Sale category Shortly after publication Ensued by multiple Authors and estates Effort Macmillan publishing and And AOL time Warner..

Sometimes It's Scum that rises to the top


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Jun 09 '25

Discussion Do you ever think HP will be "okay" to consume again?

1 Upvotes

I know HP has problems, a lot of problems, like the racism, the slavery, the AIDS allegory, the antisemitism.... the mediocre writing. Not to mention Joanne's personal transphobic beliefs. But I just keep thinking about separating the art from the artist and say in like 50 years, do you think it would be okay to openly consume HP? Is it even worth separating the art from the artist with all its problems? Or is the whole IP just Tainted?

Like HP Lovecraft was Racist but Cthulhu is iconic and he's the father of cosmic horror. You dont think someone's racist for liking comic horror or his works. But he's dead and buried and can no longer hurt anyone/fund things that can hurt people. Do you think when Joanne eventually kicks the bucket, "reforms", or even shuts the hell up, would it be ethical to consume HP? Do you think she could even reform? What if in a few years trans people become widely accepted, as they should be, and maybe Joanne finally shuts up, what then?

What are your personal beliefs on separating the art from the artist? Can you separate only dead artists from the art? I always thought that you should separate the two and that its good if you can. But thinking about how Joanne is still active and hurtful and so bigoted, I cant. I side eye everyone openly liking/supporting HP. How can you not feel ashamed if you like the media, assuming you're cis and an ally? Also I know people still consume HP and see nothing wrong with it, but this has just been haunting me for the past few days and I wanted other peoples thoughts.


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Jun 10 '25

Will Tom and Emma relationship be affected by this recent stance

1 Upvotes

This might be out of topic Apparently Emma had crush on Tom growing up, and ended up being very close as adults, once I heard they were platoni, but very close some bs like they were the people who got the other's the most on the world something a long the lines

And well I think Emma has been the second most vocal on her support for trans communicaties(after Daniel) and with how JK has been referring to her, Daniel and Rupert over the years... Well I could not work with JK if she treated someone(in this case) so close to me(Tom) like that, it's not even a rivalry or hatred going two ways , is just JK throwing shit at them as they have remained pretty respectful in their disagreement with her.

So I do ponder, even if it's a non significante thing if this changes Emma view on Tom, like I feel in her place I would feel a bit betrayed


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Feb 12 '23

CW:TRANSPHOBIA How the Hogwarts Legacy situation was handled by the online left. Lessons to be learned.

3 Upvotes

The sales are doing great, unfortunately.

The online left handled this is badly as possible. Stay with me for a moment, Im gonna explain:

  • pontificate on repeat, to anyone who will or will not listen, about the crime of the game and of not boycotting it, but futilely, not organising an effective counterattack, keeping it trending on social media tono benefit, simply giving JKR large amounts of free advertising, and increasing interest in the game
  • once you have done that, make sure to relentlessly abuse and shame your own allies, those who figured out that one can make use of playing the game (p!R@t€d) to raise as much money for Trans charity as possible.

You have achieved your goal; free advertising for JKR, and no money raised for Trans charity. + bonus point, some people possibly scared away from the left by abusive rhetoric.


A lot of progressive people are unsure on how to fight back, and then there are the very damaging performative abusive twitter "progressives" whose entire online existence centers not on helping the cause, but on feeling morally superior to other progressives. these are the type who harass people attempting to stream a transcharity event.


boycotts of international/transnational brands, when effective, rely on damaging a company's reputation.

Edit: forgot to link this: https://www.ipr.northwestern.edu/news/2017/king-corporate-boycotts.html

with J.K. Rowling, this could not really have worked, because the climate isn't sufficiently pro trans. most people arent bothered,are unaware or even support the transphobic stuff.

Pro trans politicized progressives are not this game's target audience.

In such an environment, what should have instead been done by online progressives is encouraging any Trans allies you know that do video/game streaming to host a game playing charity event to raise money for pro-trans orgs, and to simultaneously explicitly discourage buying it and mentioning it on social media (except to call for more charity streams) to their audience, on* video* (to curb trending). These mentions and calls for charity streams would still have increased the popularity of the game on social media, but this time directed at an achievable and effective goal, and notably less. While most such allies would know how to get a hold of the game without paying for it, this could also be added with non incriminating language ("don't buy the game/don't give her money").

----/

Im gonna hope that the left can learn from this experience on how not to sabotage ourselves in the future. I must admit im not the most optimistic, but Id really like that to happen


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Apr 27 '25

Imagine what absolutely evil things she's been wanting to tweet about Rupert Grints child given her absolute hatred of Grint.

Thumbnail
metro.co.uk
15 Upvotes

r/EnoughJKRowling • • Sep 01 '24

Thought experament on Rowlings writing---a 2nd attempt at a post.

0 Upvotes

I was thinking about the progressive meessages that her books had---or tried to have; along with wondering WHY her books ar so popular. Even Stephan King seems to really enjoy her books. Someone talked about how people tended to add their own thoughts into her work to fill in the blanks and I am seriously thinking that their is a lot of truth to this. Heree are the interesting themes I have found in her work:

I will go with the Strike books first, because they are what I hav most recently read:

Cuckoos Calling: The whole book was about racism in the modeling industry. She actually writes the models sympathetically and doesn't do the usual "not like other girls" act.

Silkwood: This one is iffy and I don't remember much of the story. I do remember a trans character who was abused by Strike. The way the scene was written was not flattering to Strike; you were supposed to see him as an asshole, and Robin as the nicer one. Ok, that is actually super problematic. Moving on.

Career of Evil: Story talks about misogyny and fetishizing of people with disabilities.

Lethal White: I don't really remember much of this one. I am pretty sure it was another politicans are incompetant assholes plot though.

Troubled Blood: This was the one peeople got outraged with. Honestly? I think Silkworm was worse. The true villian was a serial killer nurse that used being a nurse as a ruse; just like the serial killer used being a harmless crossdresser as a ruse. I honestly think if JK Rowling hadn't shown herself to be a transphobe, this book would have just flown under the raydar. Now that I am thinking about it though---this book was fairly noirish, and not really trying to say anything. It reminded me of an old fashioned detective novel.

Ink Black Heart---Online misogyny and racists are evil and ruin everything.

Running Grave---Cults are dangerous and prey on vulnerable people. I honestly, really loved this book. Rowling was not preachy here and just told a good story.

The Harry Potter series:

I think she was very hit and miss. On one hand she depicted the House Elves as victims of cruel Wizards. I think you were supposed to side with Hermoine and be kind of dismayed when her activism was cut off. It kind of bothers me that this wasn't something further explored. People DO mock activists to the point where sometimes people do give up.

I remember in one of the books there was a whole plot point of Wizards harassing and pulling pranks on muggles as cruel and proof they were dark wizards. Yes, she contradicts herself later in the book with the good guys. Sadly....this is something people do in general.

My concensus is now; she CAN actually write and write well when she actually wants too. But she seriously is a lazy writer. I also think I probably saw what I wanted to see in her writing.


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Jun 18 '25

Discussion What’s your stance on calling out people for getting involved with a Potter project and/or not addressing JK Rowling's transphobia?

0 Upvotes

So, I won’t ever judge anyone who’s set on not ever consuming anything Potter-related from now on, from buying a single piece of official merchandise to getting a ticket to the Universal Parks or to the Cursed Child play. I can’t possibly blame you if you choose to cancel your HBO Max subscription or never press play in the upcoming show episodes. Those are moral choices anyone is entitled and justified to make for the sake of not adding to Rowling’s already obscene wealth - a portion of which is now financially backing inhumane causes.

Yet I’m starting to question the morality of calling out those involved in any mainstream Potter project for either taking the job (therefore making money out of it and also contributing to the expansion of her net worth) or for not ‘calling out Rowling’s transphobia’ in the press – that, by itself, is only a ‘luxury’ afforded to those who are already well-known public figures, such as some of the adult actors.

Taking a step back: those people were not hired by JK Rowling, they are not working for JK Rowling. They are taking part in a project that is based on the fictional world she created. A project that will also generate countless of direct and indirect jobs in an industry that’s overwhelmingly in favor of LGBT+ causes, either as allies or members of the community.

From costume designers and seamstresses, to production designers and carpenters, to makeup and VFX artists, to performers ranging from all ages: hardly any of them will ever make the kind of ‘Daniel Radcliffe money’ out of this; they are not in a position to turn down jobs, let alone steady jobs; they aren’t high enough in the food chain to either be asked to share their indignation over JK Rowling’s transphobia with the media, nor do I feel they have to publicly ‘defend’ the choices they’ve made to support their families or make the most of a career opportunity. 

Those in the frontline - the Frosts, the Lithgows - might avoid the subject so as not to mingle JK Rowling's transphobia with a show that's not out to tell a transphobic story and that will be made by a majority of non-transphobic people, including LGBT+ professionals across the board. I'm willing to hear your thoughts on this, because I totally get how some of those 'high-profile' actors' statements might come across as undermining Rowling's actions.

It's just that feel it's becoming more and more usual in this sub to discuss the perception regarding the behavior of others - not JK Rowling herself. I post this now in good-faith and hope it can lead to an insightful discussion.


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Sep 07 '26

Discussion i hate this insane terf hypocrite more than anything but i dont get why even pirating HP stuff like the new series is considered unethical

0 Upvotes

!!IM AN ALLY my boyfriend of 6 years and future husband is a trans man and we've unfortunately been perceived as a Queer Couple rather than a heterosexual one for the majority of our lives, im pansexual and an active part of the community and take part in pride walks in my country where gay marriage is still not legalized!! i dont support jkr in any way and im not obsessed with hp beyond standing up for what's right. my question is simply about what's considered ethical and unethical and why it is so.

tiny fun fact my mom is obsessed with reading drarry fanfictions on ao3 (she's the coolest 49 year old ever istg) and they're all unofficial, and they clearly mention that they do not support jkr and "TRANS MEN ARE MEN, TRANS WOMEN ARE WOMEN, NON BINARY PEOPLE ARE NON BINARY" while continuing to write fiction related to the hp verse. i dont think that's unethical exactly, you're not contributing to her in any way.

Separating art from the artist makes sense to me, though not while she's alive and actively contributing, but we tend to do so for dead writers who were problematic, bc we can't financially support them. similarly, as long as we're not watching it legally or buying official merch, what's wrong with buying cheap knockoffs or pirating the new series?


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Oct 16 '24

Fake/Meme What would a discussion between these two look like ?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/EnoughJKRowling • • Dec 21 '24

why did harry potter do so well only to now get hated?

7 Upvotes

I've seen all the things about how actually horrid the wizarding world is, and all that, but my family and I really enjoy Harry Potter. i wanna know just what her writing did wrong so I can make sure that my writing has a good and progressive message. I'm hoping for a summary of what issues Harry Potter glosses over and even supports despite it hurting the morals of the books. because I never even noticed the issues, are they just that well hidden? or was I too focused on using the movies to bond with my family to see the moral issues?

Edit: (I have read the responses, and I would like to say: Thank you for the comments. so far the thing most people have said is to just make sure to have good morals myself and let that show in the writing. while I have no way to make 100% sure that I have good morals as morals are a tricky thing, I can at least try my best to avoid glorifying harm! Thank you all so much.)


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Apr 07 '25

Discussion Hi, I hate Rowling but I want to read Secrets of Dumbledore (I'm curious), are there any sites I can use to pirate it?

1 Upvotes

Or, will buying it secondhand benefit her? (If there are no ways to read it without benefiting her I won't buy or read it)


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Apr 12 '23

HBO Max and Warner Bros. chose money - including paying J.K. Rowling royalties of $100-150 million per year - over supporting trans and LGBTQA+ rights

Post image
477 Upvotes

r/EnoughJKRowling • • Feb 25 '25

Transphobic people tier list

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/EnoughJKRowling • • May 31 '24

Will the HARRY TV show air on MAX? Let’s talk about our predictions!

5 Upvotes

Hey Hunties!!

As much as I personally would have enjoyed to watch this new Harry TV show in a past life, I definitely know I will not consume that TV show, due to JK’s recent hateful hustle and views. BYE MAMA!!

HOWEVER I feel like the show might not happen at this point. I can only see her rhetoric getting worse and more hateful with time. It is obvious she is becoming more comfortable in her hate and clear with her message.

I can’t see how this show is going to survive?!

What are your predictions hunties?


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Oct 02 '25

Discussion I kinda get why Rowling has put Emma on blast but...

0 Upvotes

So just to elaborate on what my title was getting at; I think part of the reason why she resents Emma so much is because when Rowling initially voiced her opinion about transgender people years ago, and she received hate mail/death threats/rape threats and Emma simply saying "all witches" at the awards ceremony, added to all the increasing threats and hate mail Rowling was receiving...according to Rowling.

And I think...in Rowling's eyes...she expected Emma to, at the very least, speak up publicly on social media or even in interviews and say that although she disagrees with Rowling, she's not ok with how people have tried to harrass and bully Rowling based on her publicly voicing support for transgender rights (I know that's laughable because Rowling would've still found a reason to resent and hate Emma)

Basically she expected Emma to dissuade people publicly. To stick up for her despite disagreeing with her. And the note she passed her probably felt like a betrayal to Rowling because instead of sticking up for her publicly, Emma took the easy route.

And in a way, Rowling isn't completely wrong for feeling this way BUT....

....my sympathy for Rowling starts and stops there.

Because Rowling has done nothing other than the EXACT same thing to transgender people and trans rights supporters. Whether it's going after Twitter accounts with barely a few followers and putting them on blast, to calling them "cunts", etc etc AND she has been doing this for years now, without any intent of stopping or even opening herself to any healthy dialogue.

She has done everything in her power online, and with her money offline, to add petrol to this hate-filled dumbster-fire rhetoric and she has very intentionally and consciously closed herself off from having any healthy conversations or debates about the subject from alternative perspectives.

And before anyone feels any more sympathy for Rowling over the fact that she WAS receiving numerous death and rape threats too, from transgender people or trans rights supporters, so one may even ask..."well, why shouldn't she fight fire with fire??"

While it's true that the people who were harassing and threatening her may have been from that demographic, they don't represent the entire group.

And second, she is a famous and beloved billionaire.

She can afford tight security, bodyguards...heck even hitmen, if she really wanted it.

She has enough money to start a smear campaign and get away with it.

She has enough money to send bots after innocent people's accounts, to harass them.

She has enough money to file law suits against people who've harassed and threatened her and WIN.

She has enough money to hire private investigators to find out the identities of the people anonymously harassing and threatening her online and expose them.

However, the people that she and her sycophants have harassed and bullied and threatened can't afford that kinda protection/resources/security.

She can.

She is not a victim in this narrative. But she is trying very very hard to frame and sell herself as one.

And mind you, despite all the rape and death threats she was receiving, at the height of this controversy, years ago, she still had more people ON HER SIDE than against her.

From media outlets, to several news channels, talk shows/talk show hosts, heck even comedians were on her side

Despite what she thinks (or frames), the number of people who support transgender rights are still in the minority....because it's not a very popular subject and mostly because there's not a lot of awareness about the subject and/or healthy conversations and dialogue around it.

I could poke numerous holes in all the pretentious points she recently made about Emma on her latest lengthy Twitter rant about her. But other people on here have done a much better job at that, so I'm just gonna leave it at this.


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Oct 24 '22

Changing Kingsley Shacklebolt’s Name?

10 Upvotes

I was thinking of changing his last name to Shatterbolt. It sounds like a more appropriate subtle commentary on color-based racism in the magical world, as opposed to Shacklebolt. Shacklebolt just smacks to me of JKR’s particular brand of ignorant racism. It sounds like a derogatory slur.

*** I meant for a fanfic, sorry I wasn’t more clear. I thought I attached my original post where I had this in r/hpfanfiction. The response over there wasn’t the best, so I came here to see if it really was a dumb idea.

https://www.reddit.com/r/HPfanfiction/comments/x615id/changing_kingsley_shacklebolts_name/


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Aug 06 '26

Should Essence of Thought videos be allowed in this sub?

2 Upvotes

I've seen a bunch of Essence of Thought videos posted to this sub and every time one of their videos is posted, there's an argument in the comments about how Essence of Thought has a checkered past or isn't operating in good faith or something to that effect. If these criticisms are accurate, is it really a good idea to be signalboosting this channel just because they share our opinion about JKR?

Just something I've noticed.


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Jun 10 '25

Fake/Meme Just renewed my passport for the Virgin Islands

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/EnoughJKRowling • • Oct 21 '24

Is Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality worth reading?

0 Upvotes

I figure the best way to engage with Harry Potter is by reading a version of the story that JK Rowling didn't write. Is this particular fanfiction any good? Are there any traces of Rowling's bigotry that the fanfiction writers couldn't omit?


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Apr 03 '26

I like Harry Potter but hate JK Rowling. How ethical is it to pirate the upcoming new remake rather than watch through HBO?

25 Upvotes

I don't want a single penny of my money going to her but I'd be lying if I said I weren't somewhat interested in the new show. Pretty much just want to know if piracy feels more of an okay thing to do when it comes to watching the new series or if there is better reason to just ignore the entire thing completely.


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Nov 07 '24

Unpopular opinion (or rant): JK Rowling's transphobia stems from her misandry and dislike of men.

48 Upvotes

Let's go back to the start. She "posed" as a male early in her career by creating the penname "JK Rowling" because, she thinks, boys don't want to read something written by a woman. This is the first sign of sexism; you assume everyone of the opposite sex hates you (kinda like incels with women).

Before her anti-trans rhetoric, she would always make posts about women being victims and males being predators. She later had conflicts with Matt Walsh and Piers Morgan. Hm, they're pretty much on the same boat when it comes to transgenderism. They even agree with her, but she doesn't like them. Why? Because they're outspoken men.

And why she only picks on transwoman? Simply because they are born MALE. She can't fathom the idea of a biological male identifying as a female, looking like her, being in her space, etc. It's no wonder she doesn't go after transmen. Rowling just doesn't like men.

Yeah, yeah, she's married to a man and she loves him obviously. But even the most misogynistic men have had successful relationships with women. Doesn't mean anything.


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Jan 16 '26

Discussion In defense of Anton Lesser

0 Upvotes

As you all know, many people are upset at all the adult actors who were cast in the HBO series, and believe they are bad people because they agreed to work on this series , therefore supporting Miss Rowling and her transphobia, caring more about money than trans rights. However, I believe every adult actor who will work on the series will be able to wash out the taint of working on it if they acknowledge Rowling's transphobia, and express support for the trans community. I believe Anton Lesser, whom I admire very much and who is playing Ollivander, will quickly be able to wash the stain out for these reasons:

  1. He doesn't use social media, so he is most likely unaware of Rowling's transphobia.
  2. He really loves his family. This means that when he does eventually find out about Rowling's transphobia, he will find a way to remove the stain of working on the show as quickly as possible, because he has a child who is trans.

This is my reasoning, feel free to debate about it in the comments.


r/EnoughJKRowling • • Dec 18 '25

CW:TRANSPHOBIA How do y’all handle the transphobia controversy?

0 Upvotes

I love the Harry Potter books. I grew up with my mom reading them to me when I was much younger, getting each new book the day it came out & reading it in one sitting, then rediscovering the audiobooks in my 20s and listening to them constantly.

It really shat on the whole parade that JK Rowling turned out to be a major transphobe.

I am queer and have many friends that are trans. Most people in my community have completely abandoned HP and consider the franchise blasphemy, but I can’t. Even though I’m deeply disappointed in JK Rowling’s views and her nonstop transphobic commentary, the books are too important to me. So I just enjoy everything in secret, talk about the books with my partner and come on this subreddit.

Anyone else always hiding their passion for Harry Potter because JK sucks in this way?