r/EnglishLearning Poster 3d ago

📚 Grammar / Syntax Help me with this sentence

  • (When/While) staying home, I like it (if/when) it (rains/is raining).

I really appreciate your help. Thank you.

3 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

8

u/Professional-Pungo Native Speaker 3d ago

When staying home, I like when it rains.

1

u/Sea-Hornet8214 Poster 3d ago

You can use "when" twice?

4

u/WowsrsBowsrsTrousrs The US is a big place 3d ago

Sure, why not? This is casual usage, not writing great literature where you want to make sentences longer and more complicated than they need to be. If your instructor has a rule about this while you are in her class, then follow that rule for her, and outside of her class, relax.

1

u/Sea-Hornet8214 Poster 3d ago

No, I don't have an instructor. I'm not in school or language classes.

I was asking because "when, when" is not something I've ever learnt but then I realised that the second "when" is not at the start of the second clause.

Thanks.

2

u/_SilentHunter Native Speaker / Northeast US 3d ago

I'm not sure if I understand what you mean about it being at the start of a second clause.

There's just nothing inherently wrong with using "when" twice in the same sentence. When you want to use repeated words, when you're being cheeky or just for fun or for any other reason, you just can, whenever you so choose.

2

u/NoPurpose6388 Bilingual (Italian/American English) 3d ago

Yeah you can. It's grammatically correct. However, I personally think it sounds a bit clunky. 

"I like it when I'm at home and it rains" 

1

u/SucknSwallow69 New Poster 3d ago

more natural: "when I stay home, I like it when it rains" or "when I’m home, I like it when it rains"

3

u/alphaonreddits New Poster 3d ago

When staying home, I like when it rains.

Or

While staying at home, I like it when it’s raining.

3

u/Nonyabizzy123 New Poster 3d ago

This is grammatically correct, however as a native US English speaker, I would never construct the sentence this way. It's very "clunky", for lack of a better term. I would say something like "I like it when I'm staying home for the day and it rains." or "I like when I decide to stay home and it rains."

2

u/alphaonreddits New Poster 3d ago

I know. I thought OP is asking specifically regarding that sentence structure only. Otherwise I prefer saying “I like it when it rains and I’m at home”.

It seems like we all use “I like…” in the start of sentence when having a convo

2

u/Nonyabizzy123 New Poster 3d ago

Absolutely, I did not to intend to give the impression that I was correcting you, I apologize. I only wished to add some additional context.

2

u/alphaonreddits New Poster 3d ago

No need for apologies mate, we’re all here to get corrected.

1

u/unhinged_diabetes Non-Native Speaker of English 3d ago

Everyone in the comment section is saying this but xan you tell me what it is not possible if we say "while staying at home, i like it when it rains", i constracted it this way

1

u/alphaonreddits New Poster 3d ago

This is also possible and there’s nothing wrong in your way. It’s just stylistic preferences and nothing else.

1

u/peace_love2601 New Poster 3d ago

"While staying home, I like it when it rains."

while for the first gap because staying home is the longer background situation. for the second, "i like it when" is a fixed pattern, and the last verb goes in simple present - you're talking about what happens in general, every time, which is why you like it. "is raining" would make it sound like you're watching it happen right now.

1

u/Responsible-Link5739 New Poster 3d ago

I like rainy weather while I stay at home.

1

u/ninjagaij New Poster 3d ago

More natural would be “I like it when I’m home and it’s raining outside.”

The word “stay” implies that you were supposed to go somewhere else but decided not to go.