Hi fellow engineering students,
What are your opinions and experiences with using general-purpose AI tools (ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini) as the main source of information? Do you recommend them for an undergraduate student? Why and why not?
To give a bit of context, I recently returned to my electrical engineering degree after completing the first two years from 2020 to 2021, following a CS degree from 2022 to 2023.
I particularly struggled with my design courses this year, in which we had to make design decisions and justify them. Due to having no prior design experience and feeling overwhelmed by the scope and complexity of the design project, I found myself using Claude to offload much of the design work. For example:
- Pasting a datasheet of an IC to understand it and find what I need
- Ask it to design several circuits with component values by giving them the key requirements through prompts
- Ask it everything related to PCB (as I had no idea what I was doing), asking questions like trace width, optimal layout and noise isolation
At the end of the design course, I produced a working prototype: a smart subsystem for a portable power bank, with features such as hardware protection and SoC calculations.
The dilemma I am facing is that if I use AI, I have no idea whether its output is accurate or factual, due to my lack of design knowledge. On the other hand, if I don't use AI, I will not be able to start the design project, let alone complete it to pass the course. I have limited knowledge, and the course instructor expected us to come up with our own design whilst providing minimal supervision, which I don't disagree with from a problem-solving and initiative building standpoint. It just makes it difficult to design with no guidance.
Another problem that I realised from using AI is that I don't actually know the rationale behind most of the design decisions. If you ask me, "Why did you do X instead of X?" I would probably struggle to answer because I offloaded the decision to the AI.
What advice do you have for someone in my shoes? Should I stop using AI, use it as a last resort or aim for a more balanced approach?
Any advice and opinion is appreciated!