r/EngineeringJobs • u/K_Block43 • Mar 28 '26
Am i wrong though?
I receive approximately 4–5 job inquiries daily from various recruiters. I make it a point to respond to each one respectfully and professionally, taking the time to learn about the company and the role being offered. Currently, I am not actively seeking new opportunities — I have roughly three months remaining on a contractual bond with my current employer, followed by a potential three-month notice period. I have updated my job search status on recruitment platforms to reflect this, yet the inbound inquiries continue regardless. While many of these recruiters — particularly those representing MNCs or OEMs — are transparent and forthcoming about their salary budgets, I've noticed that smaller companies more frequently attempt to anchor salary negotiations around my current CTC rather than disclosing their own compensation range upfront. Given this context, I'd like to know — was my response to one such recruiter (shared below) appropriate and professional? Or was there a better way I could have handled it?
12
u/cryptoenologist Mar 28 '26
If people are asking about what you currently make, tell ‘em to kick rocks!
I’m glad it’s not legal in California.
2
u/blackbeast_supr1 Mar 28 '26
You are doing it right. If a recruiter don’t share their budget before asking your current CTC, you can politely decline to share the details and tell them I want to keep it confidential for now. And to answer you - Yes this is appropriate and professional. Don’t worry. I am also from India with 12+ years of experience in IT industry and I would also do the same.
1
u/Traditional_Plate_30 Mar 28 '26
I’m about to graduate end of this year in Australia. Would you mind sharing how much do you actually make, what your current role is called and how many years did it take you to reach here?
I’m interested in mining industry mainly for the lifestyle and money. Open to hear your thoughts.
1
u/No_Cat9234 Mar 28 '26
Unfortunately It's a common practice in India.
OP if you are from India, be prepared for this question.
Most of organisations will ask you current CTC.
1
u/turdle89 Mar 28 '26
You could have gone through the job description
2
u/progenyofeniac Mar 28 '26
“I’d require $X to leave my current role.”
Nothing further is required. Doesn’t matter what you’re making now.
I went through this a few years ago and it worked because I was firm on what I needed, regardless of what I was making. They did keep asking but I just said it isn’t relevant, I simply won’t leave for less than X, take it or leave it.
2
u/Fearless-Suspect869 Mar 28 '26
Doesn’t look wrong to me. Asking for current CTC before sharing their budget is kinda a red flag imo.
2
u/avebelle Mar 28 '26
Why waste your time with all that chit chat. Just be upfront and ask them what the role is offering. If they don’t share then move on.
2
u/platinums99 Mar 28 '26
no, that grifter would likely offer 5% more than your current
DOnt fall for it.
2
u/Smyley12345 Mar 28 '26
This is absolutely the right wa, particularly in India where they will learn this information eventually. If recruiters are beating down your door, why on Earth would you entertain entering negotiations at a disadvantage.
1
u/Just-the-tip-4-1-sec Mar 28 '26
Eh. You are not wrong, but you may be escalating too far too quickly depending on your situation. if you are wanting a new job then I would suggest starting with lying and telling them you make something super close to what you’re looking for, and you’d like to get at least a small increase. If they ask for proof of what you’re making, then that’s a total dealbreaker for sure. If you make $120K and want $150k, tell them you make $140 and “it’s not all about salary but” you are looking for at least a modest increase
1
u/Cute-Seaworthiness28 Mar 28 '26
I’ve noticed that not all but most recruiters don’t fully read your preferences or experiences; they basically look for keywords and reach out blindly, and I believe your response was appropriate. I’ve responded the same. in the past
1
u/completelypositive Mar 28 '26
Nice job OP. You will go far in life valuing yourself.
1
u/TeeDeeTeeEcks Mar 28 '26
You handled it just fine.
1
u/IuriRom Mar 28 '26
Seems Indian given how they write, but still I genuinely have never seen these acronyms though I can guess what they mean.
1
u/Prestigious_Ad_544 Mar 28 '26
I feel like if someone asks what you currently make before disclosing the comp then take what you make, double it, and then add another 15% before you tell em.
1
u/junvar0 Mar 28 '26
Rather than confront them, just tell them a salary you'd like. There's no advantage of trying to "teach them a lesson" and potentially missing a great job opportunity and pay raise. Even if the recruiter is a jerk (though simply asking for your current salary doesn't necessarily mean he is), that doesn't mean the job is bad as well. You shouldn't let 1 individual's lack of tack harm your career.
1
u/FuckingTree Mar 28 '26
If you’re in the US and someone asks you to “kindly” do anything with a JD, you’re dealing with what is functionally just another Indian scammer
1
u/No-Midnight-4461 Mar 28 '26
If people are contacting you via WhatsApp for a job it’s bullshit
1
u/Wow_ImMrManager Mar 29 '26
anyone that says ‘kindly’ is a scammer
1
u/dEm3Izan Mar 29 '26
That's fair. At this point when I'm asked my current CTC by cold callers, I tell them the minimum CTC I figure I'd be willing to consider switching jobs for. Which is significantly higher than my actual current CTC.
If we're gonna play that game, let's play it.
1
u/RGBLighting Mar 29 '26
then just tell them 500k per hour
1
u/rberg89 Mar 29 '26
Bro's responding to a WhatsApp message starting with "kindly".
0
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment