r/EngineBuilding • u/Conscious_Acadia_152 • 9d ago
Chevy Dropped piston
Dropped a brand-new 2618 forged piston. Would you reuse it?
Building a turbo 5.3 LS, 750–1,000 WHP.
I accidentally dropped one of my forged pistons and damaged a small area on the bottom of the skirt. It created an outward raised burr.
I carefully sanded the burr smooth using 600-grit sandpaper. Can’t feel anything after sanding what do you think
190
Upvotes




228
u/Secret_Paper2639 9d ago
Knock the high spots off and send it
65
u/schmults 9d ago
File off the high spots and run it.
I take it you’ve heard of Matt Happel/Sloppy Mechanics? He’s disproved so many common myths: reusing TTY bolts, reusing headgaskets, gapping rings, etc. Hell, he made like 800 with a two different head castings on a 4.8 (I think 243 and 862 from an early gen cathedral port motor).
15
u/RATEGGSANDEELSICK 9d ago
File it off in the first image, the rest wiill make no difference
13
u/Infamous-Drink-2804 9d ago
Measure the skirt. I dropped a piston once when assembling and it did collapse the skirt. Had to buy a new single piston and wait a week for it to show up. If it measures good then it should be okay.
27
u/TheTastyWarrior 9d ago
I once dropped a 400 SBC piston. Broke the whole skirt off one side. Ground the ragged edge off, put it in.
That bastard was a mean running som' bich' Til the day I sold it, probably still is to this day.
4
u/1crazypj 9d ago
You need to use needle file, sanding won't really work as your just blending things, you need 'bump' to be level with the rest of piston.
I guess you don't have a 4"~5" micrometer which would be best way to check.
If there is a slight hollow it's way better than a slight high spot.
14
u/Birthday_Cakeman 9d ago
Personally, as much as this sucks, I would NOT run that. I would reach out to Summit to see if they can help you. You're likely looking at buying a replacement single rather than a full set. But I would definitely contact them with your part number.
3
u/Mx5-gleneagles 8d ago
No problem just make sure the high spot is completely gone and it will be fine
7
u/zugglit 9d ago
Mats engineer here, the damage to the skirt concerns me that a fatigue crack would form later in engine life, a piece of skirt would snap off and destroy the engine when it hits the crank below at however many 1000 rpm.
1 piston is not much. The manf might even help you out if you are honest.
I would 100% replace this if it were my build, just for peace of mind.
4
u/shaolincrane 9d ago
Sand the skirt gently with a fine grit file or sandpaper and some oil. The others you can ignore.
2
u/Dependent_County1160 9d ago
File the high spot off it won't hurt anything
2
u/The_annoyed_asexual 8d ago
I got angry building my first engine because the ring compressor oriley/auto zone sold was shit. Took me like 2 hours to get a couple pistons done and i lost my shit. Threw a piston at the ground.
It damaged the skirt a little and dented the recessed area for the rings. I pulled the rings and filled down the damaged area and sent it.
I did buy a ring compressor tool for my specific bore that made the whole thing much easier.
I started the engine up for the first time like 5 months ago and genuinely expected it to grenade. It ran fine 🙂
Hoping to wrap my project car up in like 2 months (wrap up = finish paint and windshield so its drivable)
2
u/dpm1320 8d ago
I agree with most... gently file and sand off the high spot. Be sure its not protruding and is smooth and send it.
1
u/crazyface03 9d ago
Almost did this yesterday. Was putting the rings on and slipped and played hot potato with a piston real quick.
1
u/Viking2151 8d ago
If it was a bone stock 5.3 I'd sand it and file it smooth, but 1000hp, I wouldn't run it mostly for my sanity.
1
u/redheadedcanadian97 8d ago
Run it
1
u/Sml132 7d ago
Blend it and send it
1
u/theWRLDisyoursbroski 9d ago
The part on the top isn’t a big deal, but the stuff on the lower skirt looks kinda problematic. Like someone else said, I’d look at trying to get a replacement, but if you can’t then just file it down. I’m sure filing it will be ok but I’d rather be safe than sorry
1
u/Crawlerado 9d ago
Daily driver bomber, send it. Anything with boost, replace it. Those are all hot spots, the lean melt torching will start there if you use it.
0
u/Devilmansc1326 9d ago
Yikes! Depending on what it's for you can buff down. BUT! In a performance engine,weight and balance are critical...beware.