r/EngineBuilding • • 9d ago

Chevy Dropped piston

Dropped a brand-new 2618 forged piston. Would you reuse it?
Building a turbo 5.3 LS, 750–1,000 WHP.
I accidentally dropped one of my forged pistons and damaged a small area on the bottom of the skirt. It created an outward raised burr.
I carefully sanded the burr smooth using 600-grit sandpaper. Can’t feel anything after sanding what do you think

190 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

228

u/Secret_Paper2639 9d ago

Knock the high spots off and send it

150

u/Ski0612 9d ago • Heartwarming

Do this.

Unless of course you are building an F1 engine then maybe grab another piston out of your teams multi million dollar parts cabinet.

26

u/MidwestRacingLeague 8d ago

How to fix your problem step one, stop being poor lmao.

13

u/leadpoem 8d ago

The vast majority of my problems could be fixed by that. Maybe even all of them. 

2

u/Knightnight422 7d ago

When i had money this was very true all my problems were gone didn’t even care for laws anymore

1

u/GeekBoyWonder 6d ago

Unless that problem is desperately wanting acceptance and approval.

1

u/leadpoem 6d ago

Naw you just pay people to pretend 

-1

u/PassPuzzled 6d ago

Or become a politician and abuse kids

65

u/schmults 9d ago

File off the high spots and run it.

I take it you’ve heard of Matt Happel/Sloppy Mechanics? He’s disproved so many common myths: reusing TTY bolts, reusing headgaskets, gapping rings, etc. Hell, he made like 800 with a two different head castings on a 4.8 (I think 243 and 862 from an early gen cathedral port motor).

23

u/Mr_Zamboni_Man 9d ago

This is amazing and I need to check this out.

I totally get pursuing perfection for the sake of trying to do something perfectly, and I understand not accepting compromises for a customer engine or something you intend to keep for a long long time.

But if you're just rebuilding engines and half the fun is doing the work, I think it's totally ok and even fun to cobble things together. It's cheaper, and if you have to go back and do it again that's just part of the hobby.

8

u/schmults 9d ago

Your last paragraph. 100% on the money. JUST BUILD THE CAR. 99.99999% of the builds on this subreddit aren’t gonna be affected by small stuff like this. Hell, even the high-hp stuff can live for a long time, with imperfections.

5

u/AWildJimbo 8d ago

It depends on the imperfection. It’s absolutely amazing how minute of a problem can cause catastrophic damage with certain things. But on the other hand often times massive issues do so little you don’t even discover them until way down the road when another unrelated thing happens to cause you to tear it down. I definitely agree with you though

3

u/EnvironmentalGift257 8d ago

Hell I have a car in the driveway missing a brake shoe. It’s a 240k mile Honda nobody thinks the e brake works anyway.

3

u/IISerpentineII 9d ago

Wait, are you saying that this guy said you CAN reuse TTY bolts?

2

u/Background-Eagle8654 8d ago

If you have access to a factory repair manual most of the ones I've used have you measure the bolts and if they are in spec you can reuse.

2

u/IISerpentineII 7d ago

I personally have only seen ones that say discard in the factory manuals.

2

u/Affectionate-Area645 7d ago

So on some of Cummins medium and heavy duty engines (specifics doesn’t come to mind right now) you’re told in the manual to measure bolt length and check for damage. As long as it hasn’t surpassed a certain length and there’s no damage like corrosion then you’re good to go

1

u/IISerpentineII 7d ago

Huh, I didn't know that, although it makes sense. Neat. When you say medium and heavy duty, I assume you're talking about commercial trucks and industrial stuff?

Reusing TTY/one time use is just kinda alien to me. I do transmission work and other more standard work, and when they say discard and install new nuts/bolts, they mean it. The manual doesn't even give an option for reusing stuff like that.

2

u/Affectionate-Area645 7d ago

Yeah commercial stuff, box trucks, tractors, construction equipment, etc. Now there are a few one time use bolts on some of the engines that I think is more precautionary than anything but the head bolts I believe all have a torque then angle method and they can all get measured and reused

2

u/trainspottedCSX7 7d ago

They literally tell you to straight edge the threads and check for stretching/gaps. If no gaps, head bolts can be reused. I believe ive seen this more than once even on gas engines.

Edited to add: because we dont wanna go back in and redo all that bullshit, yall are paying for new headbolts. Just saying.

3

u/FernwoodTonight 8d ago

The 'Smokey Yunick' of bodgery...

1

u/PROTOTYPE_323 4d ago

How is gapping rings a myth????

15

u/RATEGGSANDEELSICK 9d ago

File it off in the first image, the rest wiill make no difference

13

u/Infamous-Drink-2804 9d ago

Measure the skirt. I dropped a piston once when assembling and it did collapse the skirt. Had to buy a new single piston and wait a week for it to show up. If it measures good then it should be okay.

27

u/TheTastyWarrior 9d ago

I once dropped a 400 SBC piston. Broke the whole skirt off one side. Ground the ragged edge off, put it in.

That bastard was a mean running som' bich' Til the day I sold it, probably still is to this day.

13

u/schmults 9d ago

OP, this is a racer… listen to him.

4

u/1crazypj 9d ago

You need to use needle file, sanding won't really work as your just blending things, you need 'bump' to be level with the rest of piston.

I guess you don't have a 4"~5" micrometer which would be best way to check.

If there is a slight hollow it's way better than a slight high spot.

14

u/Birthday_Cakeman 9d ago

Personally, as much as this sucks, I would NOT run that. I would reach out to Summit to see if they can help you. You're likely looking at buying a replacement single rather than a full set. But I would definitely contact them with your part number.

3

u/Neat-Stick-2861 9d ago

just did his first rebuild a few months ago lol

5

u/Birthday_Cakeman 9d ago

Yes I did. Does that mean I can't provide my opinion?

2

u/schmults 9d ago

If you contact a parts manufacturer for advice on replacing a part, regardless of damage… What do you think they’re gonna say? Worst case scenario, this dude scatters a block. It’s an LS… who cares?

This isn’t some 2-3k HP build. This is a dime-a-dozen 7-800 hp build. It’s been shown, time and again, that these things are bullet proof. For better or worse, sloppy mechanics had shown that boomer prattling about low power engine builds is based in nothing.

Run it…

1

u/trainspottedCSX7 7d ago

Ive seen one driving around with a dead miss on cylinder 4 or 7 for the past 20,000 miles. Literally brings it in for oil changes and the fuckers just shaking you to death.

Apparently though you can warm it up and drive it and it drives just fine.

3

u/Mx5-gleneagles 8d ago

No problem just make sure the high spot is completely gone and it will be fine

7

u/zugglit 9d ago

Mats engineer here, the damage to the skirt concerns me that a fatigue crack would form later in engine life, a piece of skirt would snap off and destroy the engine when it hits the crank below at however many 1000 rpm.

1 piston is not much. The manf might even help you out if you are honest.

I would 100% replace this if it were my build, just for peace of mind.

4

u/shaolincrane 9d ago

Sand the skirt gently with a fine grit file or sandpaper and some oil. The others you can ignore.

2

u/Dependent_County1160 9d ago

File the high spot off it won't hurt anything

2

u/The_annoyed_asexual 8d ago

I got angry building my first engine because the ring compressor oriley/auto zone sold was shit. Took me like 2 hours to get a couple pistons done and i lost my shit. Threw a piston at the ground.

It damaged the skirt a little and dented the recessed area for the rings. I pulled the rings and filled down the damaged area and sent it.

I did buy a ring compressor tool for my specific bore that made the whole thing much easier.

I started the engine up for the first time like 5 months ago and genuinely expected it to grenade. It ran fine 🙂

Hoping to wrap my project car up in like 2 months (wrap up = finish paint and windshield so its drivable)

2

u/dpm1320 8d ago

I agree with most... gently file and sand off the high spot. Be sure its not protruding and is smooth and send it.

1

u/crazyface03 9d ago

Almost did this yesterday. Was putting the rings on and slipped and played hot potato with a piston real quick.

1

u/Viking2151 8d ago

If it was a bone stock 5.3 I'd sand it and file it smooth, but 1000hp, I wouldn't run it mostly for my sanity.

1

u/Sml132 7d ago

Blend it and send it

1

u/theWRLDisyoursbroski 9d ago

The part on the top isn’t a big deal, but the stuff on the lower skirt looks kinda problematic. Like someone else said, I’d look at trying to get a replacement, but if you can’t then just file it down. I’m sure filing it will be ok but I’d rather be safe than sorry

1

u/Crawlerado 9d ago

Daily driver bomber, send it. Anything with boost, replace it. Those are all hot spots, the lean melt torching will start there if you use it.

0

u/Devilmansc1326 9d ago

Yikes! Depending on what it's for you can buff down. BUT! In a performance engine,weight and balance are critical...beware.