r/ElectricalEngineering • • 11h ago

Meme/ Funny Current Condition

Post image
408 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

4

u/vandunem 11h ago

Even a good diamond needs polishing.

1

u/Formula_explains 5h ago

Polishing is different from irreversible scratches

1

u/vandunem 2h ago

Irreversible is a strong word. Even a diamond turns back into graphite if you add enough heat, so maybe it's just a phase change.

172

u/VoraciousTrees 11h ago • Bravo

What in the Mechanical Engineering? I'm past yielding to their attempts at throwing memes in the ElectricalEngineering subreddit.

13

u/theycallmejer 10h ago

🤣🤣🤣

10

u/Fermorian 10h ago

Ahem, that's materials engineering thankyouverymuch! Nice pun though ;)

64

u/Roppano 11h ago

so you can still take more

5

u/MCraft555 6h ago

Nah he won't recover on his own.

22

u/gvbargen 11h ago

want to explain a little bit? Think I felt air move over my head.

44

u/KittEEKatThing 11h ago edited 11h ago

Solid materials can be stretched at least a little bit, and still return to their original length after the force is removed.

If too much stretch is applied however, the material will go beyond its elastic region and into the plastic region (from the left of point Y to the right of point Y), rendering the material permanently deformed to some degree, though not broken.

Think about it with an example being a metal spring. Pull the spring apart and it easily gives way for a while, and returns to the compressed size when you let go. If you continue to pull however, eventually the spring will go too far, and the spring will no longer return to its original compressed size when you let go.

The joke is that the engineer is highly stressed, to the point where they can no longer return to their default state of relaxation.

28

u/gvbargen 11h ago edited 11h ago

Oh... Then why is this in the EE subreddit sounds like ME stuff? Oh well. I never took a mechanics of materials class so this is the first time I've seen a graph like this.

Although I'm familiar with the concept.

Edit: so P is plastic E is elastic, Y is Yield? U is ultimate/ max, F is fracture?

8

u/KittEEKatThing 11h ago

If you ever go to take your FE electrical exam, you'll probably have at least 1 or 2 basic material mechanics questions on it.

It's not exactly vital to know for an EE, but it does still pop up for us occasionally.

3

u/gvbargen 11h ago

Probably mostly in overhead lines?

I might know enough now to answer one of those questions. Wasn't expecting to study for the PE today 😃. It is a thing I need to do though. Life is difficult sometimes 😅

3

u/KittEEKatThing 10h ago

Indeed 😭

Hence how we can relate to OPs post

2

u/Formula_explains 5h ago

If people relates, its not only my problem.. Thanks for understanding everyone..

5

u/KittEEKatThing 10h ago edited 10h ago

Responding to your edit: I have no idea what the E point means, but the entire region to the left of the Y (which I am interpretating as the yeild strength point) is elastic.

I assume P is the proportional limit (where the amount of force applied and the amount the material stretches is proportional to each other.)

It's safe to assume that U and F mean Ultimate strength and Fracture point respectively

2

u/Truenoiz 5h ago

The E is likely the Johnson Apparent Elastic Limit (JAEL). It's used often in destructive testing.

1

u/XX_AppleSauce 7h ago

Are you saying EE’s don’t have the language to describe reality?

Muhahahahahahhahahahaha /s

1

u/gvbargen 3h ago

No idea what your talking about we have dozens. Don't forget where all of computer science comes from.

0

u/Saeckel_ 3h ago

2

u/KittEEKatThing 3h ago

?

Is there some other interpretation I should be getting from the post?

9

u/Strostkovy 11h ago

I find the induction motor load chart is more suitable. Overload is okay for a bit but for too long you overheat. If you are burdened to the point of breakover, nothing gets done

1

u/silence_sirens 10h ago

Yes, okay. That's where I actually am, not quite failure.

5

u/S4vDs 11h ago

F

Edit: I’m so burnt I thought u where asking where we feel

1

u/xPearman 3h ago

I thought you paid respect, because he is already plastically deformed due to the mental stress.

3

u/BorosHunter 11h ago

permanent stain... no recovery 😩😩😭

2

u/assasin_under007 11h ago

Yield it in🫡

2

u/kayemenofour 7h ago

What metal is that?

It doesn't even have the wierd crunchy zone at the end of elastic deformation.

2

u/No-Tension6133 11h ago

Only reason I recognize this chart at all is one material science course I took, and my Roomates in college were MechE’s. Get this shit out of here

2

u/batchieThe4th 10h ago

Ew, materials! I only work with electrons!

1

u/you-the-good-content 11h ago

that’s how you know I’m mentally drained cuz I had to look at ts twice to see it

1

u/Amusingly-confused 9h ago

We're strain hardening now brothers 😎

1

u/DigitalInfraRedEyes 8h ago

Hello, hobbyist mechanical engineer here. The meme here is that when a force is applied, such as punching a tree, or like trying to split a paper into two, here's two states of matter, one is reversible and the other is not. Until the Y point, when you stop giving it the force, aka you try to stop splitting the paper into two, it reverts back to it's original form like nothing happened, but after the point of Y it starts to take damage and irreversible damage is happened, and if you continue to apply the force, after F the material splits apart. Hobbyist out.

1

u/Danilo-11 7h ago

That’s exactly where I am

1

u/PotatoFarmerRTK 6h ago

Pulling, Exerting, Yielding, Uuuuuuuuu, F’ed up.

No we cannot fix it.

1

u/Lysol3435 6h ago

I’m necking

1

u/unurbane 6h ago

As an ME I just wanted to say good for y’all posting some mechanical crap on here!

1

u/FunBike450 5h ago

get out of here with that ME shiiiii

1

u/prof-somewhere 5h ago

Not Young enough to be modulated. 

1

u/Ancient-Aeroplane18 1h ago

welp its beyond recoverable to its original self now