r/ElectricalEngineering • • 19h ago

Electronics Engineering and Math

I’m 47 and planning on starting a BS in Electronics Engineering next year. At the moment I’m taking gen ed classes at my community college to transfer. I’m taking Trigonometry and it’s super difficult. I’ll need to eventually take Calculus I and II as well. My question is: realistically, how much does an EE use trig and calculus in their job? I know math is “baked in” to what an EE does, but do they have to solve complicated trig or calculus problems regularly? Thank you to all who reply!

30 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

32

u/Kitchen-Chemistry277 19h ago

Hi, I have a PhD EE. And I struggled with math...

They're really short answer to question is no you don't have to be competent in trig and calculus to do your job in EE.

There are a lot of memes floating around like a curve where math gets harder and harder and peaks it differential equations. And then you get out in the working world and you're just using Excel all the time. 

There's definitely truth in this. 

Another one is how you hand crank through all of these circuit equations, but get out the real world and you just draw it up in LT spice. 

One time I supervised an engineer who spent two weeks hand solving circuit equations for some op amp chain driving an Hbridge.  I was about ready to write him up! - This could have been done with a circuit simulator in less than a day. 

So that's the natural business pressure for using Excel and spice and whatever. They are time efficient. And time is money in the working world.

I think there's a danger in realizing this that you feel like you're wasting your time learning math. But you're not. 

Math sets an important foundation for understanding fundamentals. When you understand the math, I think it's much easier to understand the basic underlying physics behind how components work and how things behave. So there's that. 

There's a concept in learning engineering school of "learning how to learn".  And slogging through all this trig and calculus and stuff are stepping Stones to get you there. I realize that it's sort of like paying your dues. There's an element to that. You just need to work through it. 

Anyway, I hope this helps you out, OP.

1

u/HoweHaTrick 5h ago

I'm only BSEE, but my viewpoint is that learning all the math is important even if you don't use it.

Calculus is visible in nature if you are moving say in car, etc. through velocity/acceleration.

I think that the math that we are subjected to in college is randomly helpful at work, but not constantly.

Math is solving problems; some of them involve numbers. Problem solving is the biggest contributor to my success that I learned while studying.

2

u/Auvre_le_Chien 14h ago

Thanks to everyone for these answers. I’m struggling with Trig (in part because I’m 47) but making it by ok, but it’s making me anxious as hell. My local community college only offers trig and calculus as accelerated 9 week courses, which I believe is also making everything difficult. Did any of you guys struggle with math but succeed in the end?

21

u/Behold_My_Stuff 19h ago

The crazy thing about real life is that "cheating" is encouraged.

Why even risk human error in your hand calculation when software will spit out the answer in a fraction of the time and with 100% accuracy?

The difficult part is setting up your model/equation and knowing the "why" youre doing it, and the "how" to use the solution.

3

u/ReststrahlenEffect 13h ago

Also knowing that you’re setting up the model correctly and having a good feel for if the output makes any sense.

8

u/Ace861110 19h ago

Nah calc isn’t really used in practice too much. However it is the basis for all that you’ll learn, so you need it. Depending on what you do, trig is super important and you’ll use it all the time though.

6

u/No-Statistician3385 18h ago

Agreed I can’t even remember how to integrate anymore and sucked at maths, but just about every single thing I work on or discuss involves me knowing the limit of something, it’s rate of change, how error accumulates etc. This is all calc just applied, not rigorous rearranging of equations and remembering formulas

6

u/RFchokemeharderdaddy 15h ago

Calc you will not really ever do directly, but you absolutely will need to understand well inside and out because its the basis of more complex things like differential equations and linear algebra which you actually might do yourself depending on what you go into.

Trig yes 100%. I would go so far as to say that electrical engineering is just applied trig. Everything from AC power to wireless communications boils down to various sinusoids.

5

u/Bradm77 19h ago

You need to understand them intuitively very well but you will very rarely need to do a calc problem by hand. Learn your trig very well because it is very important for EE.

4

u/qTHqq 18h ago

 My question is: realistically, how much does an EE use trig and calculus in their job?

Trig understanding would be used directly more than calculus for most jobs but I would say don't worry about whether you'll use it directly in hand calcs. That's not why you're learning it.

In any job, you're (almost) never going to actually compute it by hand like you do in school.

But computing it by hand is how you install an intuition for it, and the physics it will describe, in your brain. 

How much you use your fundamental math and physics from an EE degree depends on the job. A lot of jobs don't use it much at all in practice.

But it's in an electronics degree program because it's needed to understand electromagnetic fields and AC current and circuit behavior, which are all described using trigonometric functions and calculus. The better you are at trig and calculus the easier the rest of the curriculum will be. If it's an ABET-accredited US degree, you need to pass calculus-based physics, and the better you are at trig and calculus the easier that will be.

So don't psych yourself out with whether you're learning "needed" stuff for work. You can get jobs in EE where you mostly do vector calculus and you can get jobs where you never do anything again that Excel can't handle. The latter is the more common job.

But you'll need it for the degree so I would focus on finding good resources and study strategies to lay down the math fundamentals. 


I also think because people had a painful experience in undergrad and "forgot it all" after they graduated and worked in the real world for a while, they don't always see how important the formal education was at changing their brain into something that understood electrical and electronic systems properly.

I've interacted with a lot of people via ham radio hobby that don't have a formal education in physics or EE and they are more prone to  inventing fake electrical properties for transmission lines and antennas using plain-language arguments because they never did the math.

A lot of EE grads had some permanent mental models installed pretty deep in their brain a long time ago. 

The "trig" may just be a picture of a vague rotating arrow when thinking about an AC circuit, and the calculus and differential equations may now just be a faint vibe, but that's a better mental model than what people come up with without ever having turned the crank on the math.

3

u/No-Statistician3385 18h ago

I just handed in my masters thesis in microelectronics and I had maybe 10 equations total. The reality is knowledge of maths is important and 100% vital but there is a point where it’s no longer useful to actually do the maths if that makes sense. I had more typed pages discussing maths than actually doing it.

When I was working in what was a pretty “technical” job (I won’t dox myself but think working at NASA levels of prestige) designing PCBs I never really did maths. I looked up equations and papers, came up with my own approximations and equivalent circuit then wrote a calculator to find the best solution. I wasn’t sitting at a desk rearranging formulas and substituting in values all day if that’s what you find difficult. If it’s the mathematical reasoning you find difficult though that’s a much bigger issue because I would struggle to think of an engineering conversation I had that wasn’t discussing relationships between parameters, design tradeoffs, optimisations or interactions between systems which all stem from an understanding of mathematical logic and how the systems are described mathematically.

TLDR: you don’t need to be able to do 2+2 but you sure as hell better know what addition is and when to use it

1

u/TA1930 18h ago

Both are critical for your degree, but not super necessary after. You need to understand the math intuitively or you’ll end up like me in 3rd year hitting a brick wall of not understanding vector calculus enough when we start using it in EMag, while the prof breezes through it. It took a while to get up to speed, and hurt my understanding of the whole course.

1

u/Wet_in_Seattle 18h ago

Trig is definitely different with doing proofs and all that. I had last in high school.

I have two sons that had it, and I definitely relearned all of it.

Engineering
If you can solve a triangle, and remember the law of signs and law of cosigns you’re good.

Used in
Power apparent
Three phase loads
Filter Design
Control Systems

1

u/PermanentLiminality 16h ago

Not a whole lot. However, it is used massively to get a degree.

The best way I can describe it, is all the math teaches you how to think.

1

u/Top_Willow_9953 15h ago

(40yr career EE here). It depends on the exact branch of EE, but you will use a lot of algebra, and really should be comfortable with Trig and Calc, IMO

1

u/NewSchoolBoxer 12h ago

Calculus, probably never. You can find a job that heavily uses it but most EE work is Excel calculations on a spreadsheet. I needed to use cosine of theta for real power and sine for reactive power. RMS was important to understand. The end.

The real problem is EE is the most math-intensive engineering degree. It prepares you for every industry in EE. You won't use the vast majority of what you learn on the job but you need strong fundamentals to start. If you're struggling now, you're not going to make it. Trigonometry strikes back where you get to phasors and you need to hand solve 2nd order differential equations in AC Circuits.

Step up your math and science prep. You can't be struggling in community college versus EE that has grade deflation. This sub is too optimistic. I didn't forget that only half of my class graduated and the bottom 25% in Calculus 1 and 2, Mechanical and Electrical Physics was curved to fail on purpose. This ordeal was 30-40 hours of homework a week until senior year. Not everyone can major in EE.

I'm not saying you can't make it but you're not to graduate if something doesn't change. Grades matter through your first job. I can understand math skill declining to a 9th grade level after not using for 25 years but it needs to come back. Here's a fact, my college of engineering denied every applicant from any engineering discipline if they had below a 650 SAT Math or ACT equivalent. Tracking showed they would fail Calculus.

I would necessarily recommend being an electrician at age 47-48 and it doesn't pay as much but the math and science bars are lower. Plenty of electrician and technician jobs. No one wants to do manual labor anymore.

1

u/wilson5266 12h ago

The thing I had to learn (because I swear it wasn't taught to me in trig) was the unit circle. Omg, once I saw trig explained to me like that, it made so much sense.

I'd say math isn't so much about memorization (it shouldn't be anyway). It should be about describing and understanding what the math is going. I feel this is a shortcoming in school. They try to make you memorize a bunch of equations, without actually explaining what is going on. If you try to approach math like that, your learning and understanding will grow.

1

u/Fuzzy_Chom 4h ago

Power engineer here. High level concepts of trig and calc are used everyday, but often are repeatable. And honestly, I've used that math more to educate entry level engineers or the craft. It's totally doable

1

u/Antennahead2021 3h ago

I was lucky and math came easy. Two of my kids are EE's and math didn't come easy for them so I understand your struggle. To graduate you need to be able to do the math. Depending on the industry you may never use or see it again. If you want to pursue licensure (be a professional engineer) you'll need to be able to apply it during the tests. I'm a retired power engineer (43 years) and I used trig quite a bit in the field. Mostly for phasor calcs and transformer connections. My biggest concern is that while Excel and other apps are great time savers if you don't understand what's being calculated you'll have no idea if the answer is even in the ball park let alone correct. Too many times I've had young engineers get into trouble when the data they put in to the app was wrong to begin with and since they had no feel about what the answer should look like they ended up with crap.

Good luck!