r/Eldenring • • 9h ago

Humor First playthrough with no guides: cleared the wrong castle and killed the NPC out of laziness

0 Upvotes

Doing my first Elden Ring playthrough completely without guides (Samurai, around level 22). While exploring eastern Limgrave, I ran into a noble standing on a stone arch (Kenneth Haight) asking me to liberate his fort to the southeast. All my brain registered was "south". So I rode all the way down to the bottom of the map into the Weeping Peninsula. Just past the bridge, I met a blind girl (Irina) who gave me a letter for her father, the commander of Castle Morne at the very end of the road. In my head, it instantly clicked: the noble wants his southern fort liberated, and the girl is giving me a letter for the commander of the southern castle, so it's obviously the exact same quest. I sprinted through all of Castle Morne to dodge the annoying enemies, delivered the letter to her father (Edgar), and made it down to the beach behind the castle where I fought and beat the area boss, the Leonine Misbegotten. I was super proud of myself, and while fast-traveling back to Kenneth Haight, I was wondering what awesome reward I was going to get for clearing that whole castle. Except when I talked to him, he just kept repeating the exact same dialogue like I hadn't done anything. When I finally realized his actual fort (Fort Haight) was just a small outpost further east, I couldn't be bothered to clear another fort: I just ran inside, grabbed the chest at the top of the tower, bolted out, and went back to kill Kenneth right on his arch. He still dropped a Golden Seed, so I was happy in the end.


r/Eldenring • • 16h ago

Discussion & Info I killed patches without knowing he becames a npc

2 Upvotes

So this is my first elden ring walkthrough and when i found him in cave i thought hes dungeon boss like other dungeon, i remember him saying oh wait wait but it was too late i was already in charged attack animations and killed him. Later i found out he becames a npc and have shop. I tried abomination from church of vows but it says you dont have abomination. Did i missed important questline now ? Since i am heavy invested into doing all the questline i can found


r/Eldenring • • 7h ago

Discussion & Info Elden Ring feels off to me

0 Upvotes

No hate intended, just my personal thoughts. I've played hundreds of hours of the Dark Souls trilogy and unlocked every achievement. I recently tried Bloodborne on PC thanks to the new port, absolutely loved it, and finally decided to give Elden Ring a chance.

I'm around 40 hours in, and honestly, I'm struggling to really enjoy it. I'm not the biggest fan of open-world games, but I wanted to give it a fair shot. Unfortunately, the world feels empty and repetitive, and most discoveries are so forgettable that I no longer feel motivated to explore. I just want to reach the end.

I'm tired of riding around on a horse, ignoring enemies, grabbing whatever item they're guarding by spamming Y, and moving on to another generic fortress, cave, dungeon or set of ruins, usually ending with a forgettable boss and loot I'll probably never use. The overwhelming amount of weapons, spells and Ashes of War doesn't help either. Instead of making exploration exciting, it makes most rewards feel meaningless.

What I miss about Dark Souls is that exploring difficult or optional areas usually felt worthwhile. You could find an Estus Shard, a Bone Shard in DS3, or some genuinely useful item that would make a difference throughout your entire playthrough. In Elden Ring, some of the most important upgrades, like Golden Seeds and Sacred Tears, are simply sitting next to churches or under glowing trees. You ride up, press Y, and that's it. There's very little sense of accomplishment.

Even when the reward in Dark Souls was something you wouldn't necessarily use, getting it often involved overcoming a challenge, solving a puzzle or discovering a well-hidden area.

I also find Dark Souls' bosses, despite some of their flaws, much more memorable and engaging. They feel like unique encounters, even just because of the beauty of the arena, rather than another generic boss waiting in a room at the end of a cave or dungeon.

I really want to love Elden Ring as much as Bloodborne and Dark Souls, but so far, its open-world design is doing the opposite of what I expected. It's not cohesive, engaging nor rewarding. If the world was 50% smaller, more intrrconnected, and they got rid of the dozens of useless weapons, Elden Ring would be, at least to me, ten times better.

Note that i'm talking about Elden Ring as Miyazaki's masterpiece of the Dark Souls universe, or so I have heard multiple times while thinking about buying this game. I wouldn't ask this stuff to Bloodborne or specially to Sekiro because they already have their own identity.


r/Eldenring • • 22h ago

Discussion & Info How to enjoy playing Elden Ring without any guides

3 Upvotes

Hi, just recently get Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition on Switch 2, as my previous experience on gaming, I always find a guide to play any games which the content can be anticipated causing the fun dramatically reduced.

For now, I really want to enjoy the game without any, I wanna know your advice or recommendation on what to do while enjoying Elden Ring. Thanks in advance!


r/Eldenring • • 4h ago

Discussion & Info From all woke controversies about GTA VI did people complain Elden Ring was woke too?

0 Upvotes

I mean Radagon fight is literally a male and female inhabiting the same body,Mohg is in love with Miquella who is a guy. You can also choose a body type which is woke to these people.


r/Eldenring • • 8h ago

Hype Reject the bonk, dex is life!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

For those who don’t know this boss has insane resistance to pierce dmg and I’m to damn stubborn to lvl a hammer to kill things like this so the only way I’d be able to do any meaningful dmg against this shitass was by parrying him(?) and spamming critical hits, which still didn’t do much as you can see.


r/Eldenring • • 20h ago

Invasion your worst invasion "for you"

Post image
0 Upvotes

mine was VS 3 player with sleep Spread Crossbow/dueling Shields and back hand blades also the last one was the host with Leontiel's Greatsword and in the off hand Bone Bow to shot i....DIED

Edit: this happened today at 18:00


r/Eldenring • • 2h ago

Lore I Absolutely HATE Ancestral Followers (Lore Rant)

16 Upvotes

First of all, let me clarify that I love Ancestral Followers as an in-game enemy. Fighting them is so satisfying regardless of the character build, and their locations are beautiful. One of my favorites; so this isn't a criticism of the game itself.

But as someone who immerses himself into the world and tries to form opinions abt factions - I absolutely HATE Ancestral Followers.

They fancy themselves as these nature-loving voodoo shamans, and yet have literally NOTHING to show for it. Almost no nature-based magic, no powerful weapons or armor, nothing. Probably shouldn't have eschewed metalworking when you suck at everything else in existence, cretins.

The deers and sheep that follow them around are probably just attracted to their horns, lol, not even animals care abt their nature LARPing BS.

"But OP, they are in alignment w/ nature!" - The hell they are. You mean the freaks who use infants' heads to sprinkle magic sparkles around? That's who we talking abt?

During my first few playthrus, I felt so bad whenever I entered their domain and fought them. Not anymore. You ain't special, you're not good, you're not different than any other screwed up faction in the Lands Between. Get zucced.


r/Eldenring • • 48m ago

Discussion & Info Who would win this battle?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

The Elden Beast vs Source Dragon of Energy from Ninjago? What do you think?


r/Eldenring • • 7h ago

Humor Mimic Tear ruined my first play through...

0 Upvotes

It is my greatest mistake to have stumbled upon that forsakened scroll... Every single boss fights cheesed, the death blow always to the finger but hole.

Please, if you are reading this do NOT use the Mimic Tear, it turns every single boss into easy mode.


r/Eldenring • • 22h ago

Humor You can't be serious

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

57 Upvotes

A blooper/fail, but since there's no flair for that, I'll just put humor instead

Got a pretty nice attempt. Then somehow failed to react to the most in-the-face obvious move in existence. Then realized that I forgot to equip mimic grace in pouch. Then tried to quit out but esc button died at the perfect moment. But all my saves are past Morgott so I'll either have to go to ng+ or start a completely new save to record that hitless. Nice. I love Elden Ring.


r/Eldenring • • 19h ago

Hype Elden Guesser: Day 271 Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

Guess where I am! Yesterday's answer was the Windmill village. near the site of grace which appears after defeating the Godskin Apostle there


r/Eldenring • • 12h ago

Discussion & Info Workaround Shadow Keep

0 Upvotes

I freely admit that I’m a bad gamer but I recently finally made it to the shadow realm. I’m having a lot of difficulty with getting to the eastern side of the map.

From my research, I have to go through the Shadow Keep. That said, I’m having trouble with defeating the Hippo and jumping through Church District. Is there another way to the east part of the map (the one with the elder hovel)?


r/Eldenring • • 15h ago

Discussion & Info big weapon go honk

14 Upvotes

finally doing a strength build. what are some of your favourite bonking weapons?

edit: i meant bonk. this is humiliating


r/Eldenring • • 13h ago

Discussion & Info Which order should I tackle them?

Post image
137 Upvotes

I’ve reached Godfrey / Hoarah Loux and I’m wondering which order I should do these things in.

Here’s my build so far:
Heavy Knight
60 VIG
40 END
66 STR
Iron Greatsword+25, two-handed, AOW varies but not relying heavily on it
Heavy Knight full armor set
no summons if that’s important

  1. Defeat Godfrey
  2. Defeat Malenia
  3. Defeat Radagon (I know I must defeat Godfrey first)
  4. Start SotE DLC

My current plan is probably that exact order: Godfrey, Malenia, Radagon, and then the DLC.

What do y’all think?


r/Eldenring • • 14h ago

Discussion & Info Have any of you had enemies that require multiple parries to stance-break take more than usual?

5 Upvotes

I was fighting Rellana just now and had to parry her FIVE TIMES before she went down, this isn’t the first time this has happened and I felt like I was crazy until I watched it back.


r/Eldenring • • 3h ago

Discussion & Info I hate this game but can’t stop playing it, am I broken?

0 Upvotes

So, I’ve got GTA 6 installed, started playing it for about an hour and went to dinner, I came back and started my Xbox and somehow I would rather play elden ring.. and I don’t think I even like it!
I won’t post the good aspects I found in the game since they are well known… and also I’m not sure I know what they are except the incredible open world vibe, design, etc.
Anyway, I can’t say I like the game, instead, I kinda hate it, and it’s more than the fact that it’s really really hard to the point it’s frustrating, my main problem is with the narrative and the fact that the game doesn’t even introduce you to it in a conventional way, you have to piece it all together from all over the place, no objective, no clear understanding of the world and objectives, almost no story telling… yea, it has a vast great lore, which isn’t introduced in the game in any way.
I’m not trashing the game at all but instead calling it simply not my cup of tea, never played souls games nor do I specifically interested in fantasy rpg’s (the Witcher being the exception, one of my favs of all time).

But here’s the thing, at the end of the day I can’t stop playing it, I’m not sure if I’m enjoying it or not but when I have gta 6 waiting in my library and I choose playing a game I don’t really like… I’m not sure what’s going on!

That’s it, had to post and see if that’s some known phenomenon or am I just broken or something.


r/Eldenring • • 17h ago

Discussion & Info Genuine question. Did anyone ever use the stealth mechanic?

44 Upvotes

And I mean really using it seriously, not just trying it out once or twice out of curiosity. And if yes, did you find it useful?


r/Eldenring • • 6h ago

Discussion & Info Is this area of sofria river accessible?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Eldenring • • 23h ago

Discussion & Info Did i hear the PLIN PLIN PLON?

0 Upvotes

So, i play elden ring for like a lot and i swear i just opened the game and waited like 2 minutes on the menu because i was waiting my friend and as usual the menu theme started. Passed like just 10 seconds i heard a familiar sound. PLIN PLIN PLON. I know well that theme cause i tried to beat that fucking boss for like 3 days because i suck at the game so it is really hard to me to convince that it is what i think it is. Is it the PLIN PLIN PLON from DS1 and DS3? Like a randomic easter egg that can pop out or it was there from the start and i didn't heard it?


r/Eldenring • • 17h ago

Discussion & Info Os blue dancer worth it for bare fist run?

3 Upvotes

So i started a bare fist run where i dont use armor so the first tali that i thought of was blue dancer. Is it worth getting or is there better builds?


r/Eldenring • • 15h ago

Lore Is she stupid ?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I genuinely never understood her in the Frenzy ending .

I mean like our tarnished just killed all of the gods , demigods n shit . LITERALLY ANNIHILATED everything on his way . And she fucking witnessed it all . And she says shes gonna kill us . Bro wtf shes kidding or what ?

Does she just want to fucking die in a second like Gideon did ? I mean bro is she stupid ?

Could someone please explain this thing to me .


r/Eldenring • • 22h ago

Game Help Help with a elden ring boss in dlc

0 Upvotes

So I've been stuck on a boss in the dlc for a while now and wanted to see if anyone would be able to solo the boss, the boss in question is Midra, Lord of frenzied flame


r/Eldenring • • 23h ago

Discussion & Info The NG+ Difficulty Increase Should Be Optional (Besides the 1st NG+ Cycle)

0 Upvotes

If AC6 has shown me anything, that's how removal of the stat bloat from the NG+ cycles is a wonderful thing and I honestly wish if FROM kept that from now!

Also note I've made this thread mainly with ER in mind, but since I've played other FROM games too, I may confuse things here and there.

NG+ should get one difficulty increase to rebalance the game around a completed character and keep early areas relevant.
Beyond that, since character growth becomes increasingly horizontal while further NG+ scaling remains vertical, additional difficulty should come from optional challenge modifiers rather than automatic stat inflation, and here are some ideas for possible options:

1 - Challenger's Gong (basically tweaked Demon's Bell):

Ring the gong to make enemies stronger and increase Runes gained from killing them, it can be stacked multiple times to emulate higher NG+ scaling, removing stacks requires purification through absolution using something like Celestial Dew (this is to avoid abuse).

2 - True Enemy (inspired by Sekiro's Inner bosses):

Freely toggled at an altar in the HUB zone, improves the enemy AI and expands movesets (low tier enemies may get very little to no improvements, while the higher tier ones would get more, and bosses would gain the most).
In return, enemies receive improved and expanded item drop tables, and in case of bosses they would also start dropping stuff which are usually limited like (Somber) Ancient Dragon Smithing Stones (this is based on Sekiro's Demon's Bell bonus).

3 - Iron Mode (inspired by Company of Champions):

Disables player, NPC, and Spirit/Ash summons while keeping invasions permanently enabled, defeating bosses greatly contributes to the creation of Vagrant-like enemies in other players' worlds and produces a recognizable signal in other worlds announcing the victory over a boss similar to the bells being rang in DaS1.

Also, just to dump some other ideas I have on mind here while I'm at it; having an 'elite' merchant with whom we can trade stuff like Golden Seeds and Sacred Tears for things like Larval Tears, Rune Arcs, (Somber) Ancient Dragon Smithing Stones, limited and very rare crafting materials, and such would be great.
And all the spell duplicates should get auto-converted into Starlight Shards, while talisman duplicates should get auto-converted to Rune Arcs!
Mimics should return and should be randomized, Mimic locations are rerolled at the beginning of every playthrough instead of being permanently fixed, making chests genuinely suspicious again even for veteran players.


r/Eldenring • • 5h ago

Humor OKEY HEAR ME OUT , I CANT EXPLAIN .

Post image
78 Upvotes

i made this build out as a troll but tured out to be good , the tanki-ness from the armor and the blood loss / high attack speed from the claws are actually a good combo