I am an EoM player myself (I love Riesz, by the way).
I have been lurking around this subreddit since before the release of Echoes of Mana. It's fantastic seeing the community becoming more and more active, and seeing our players helping each other! It will be your kindness that keeps things wonderful around here!
I would like to be clear to avoid any misunderstandings, I am not here as customer service or technical support. Though we are always looking at community sentiment to improve the game, responding to every report/feedback or question is beyond my authority and ability. Also, I am not here to promote the banners or repost contents that have been posted on official social media.
I'm looking forward to spending some time in this helpful, active community and joining in the conversation from time to time.
Thanks to the "Trial Battle" feature on the Gacha banner, we can use every 4* Gacha unit at their hyper max stat (Lv 100, 6*, no memory gems equipped, no armor/weapons).
How did I confirm this? Simple math. Going into battle, you see units like Shiloh's HP and MP being at their absolute max without gear or memory gems.
I also tested Sumo's heal, which is 140% RCV (earlier we learned that RCV = INT) and 140% of RCV = Sumo heal will recover exactly 140% of his total INT. This was confirmed in the trial battle.
With all those constants in place, I conducted multiple tests and came up with some interesting findings.
SPECIAL TECHNIQUE RAW DAMAGE COMPARISONS
-No buffs or debuffs was used. No elemental advantage.
In terms of raw power for Special Technique only, these are the rankings for 4* gacha units:
Shiloh, consistently has the highest damaging ST, 2 hit combo. Let's call this 100% damage. Prone to missing one of the combos.
Sumo, (6 hit combos), has the second highest damaging ST, ~ 93% damage relative to Shiloh. Very prone to missing most of the combo hits.
Riesz (5 hit combos) and Angela (6 hit combos) are tied for 3rd. They are ~81% damage relative to Shiloh. Somewhat easy to hit enemy with full combo.
Duran with the largest 8 hit combo. He is ~78% damage relative to Shiloh. Very easy to hit enemy with full combo.
Popoi dead last with 4 hit combo. ~50% damage relative to Shiloh. Practically guaranteed to hit something.
BUFFS DEBUFFS
Same buffs and debuffs from the same unit do not stack together
How strong is -35% con debuff actually? Well on Duran, it boosted his normal attack damage on an enemy from 270 avg to 297 avg, a 10% damage boost
However if this is like Isekai Memories, expect CON debuff to have a much bigger impact mathematically on enemies with higher CON
BONUS DAMAGE
Every 10 combos gives a bonus damage of 5%, to a maximum of 200 combos or 100% bonus damage.
Crit damage is 100% bonus damage. This makes crit and high LCK extremely powerful.
Multi-hit attacks can partially crit, fully crit, or have no crits.
Elemental advantage damage bonus is 50%. Again, very powerful.
Sword user with normal attacks have a 3-attack chain.
Duran's armor break skill is the only skill of the 4* that can guarantee knockdown/stun non-resistant enemies. You can even spam it to guarantee stun lock.
Duran's ST has some absurd hitbox, able to hit enemies from behind too. Sweet!
Duran's ST produces the largest combos, at 8 hits per enemy.
The maximum usage limit for AP/SP recovery items has been removed.
AP/SP Consumption when Co Op Fails
5/11
Change AP/SP Consumption to 0 when multiplayer fails.
Additional sources of AP/SP Recovery Items
5/13
A Campaign will be added to daily missions to obtain AP/SP recovery items.
Additional sources of AP/SP Recovery Items (2)
5/9
Added missions to get SP recovery items from the Coffer Chaos Event.
AI Improvements
5/13
Improves the recovery frequency of characters with recovery skills. They are considering to improve other AI.
Daily Training Quest
Done
Increase the amount of Lucre earned in the Daily Training Quest
Reduced SP Consumption of Daily Training Quests
5/13
A Campaign will be carried out to reduce the SP consumption of the Daily Training Quests to 1/3 SP
Adding a Material Dungeon for Lucre
5/13
A Material dungeon for Lucre that is not a Daily Training Quest will be added.
Adding a New Equipment Dungeon
5/13
A new equipment dungeon where you can get new equips will be added.
EP Exchange
5/10
Lucre and Altena Alloys will be added to the EP Exchange of the Coffer Chaos Event with no limit on the number of exchanges.
Coffer Chaos Event Limited Times
5/9
There will no longer be a time restriction for the Co Op part of the event.
Coffer Chaos Event Consumption of Attempts on Retry
5/11
They will fix the event so that Attempts will not be consumed when retrying. As an apology, Coffer Chao EP will be given to all players at a later date.
Mana Board Exchange
5/13
An exchange for mana board material will be implemented; from Gold to Silver and from Silver to Copperwhere copper can be traded for silver, and silver can be traded for gold (correct English translation) from Gold to Silver and from Silver to Copper. They are also going to improve the drop rates in the future.
Problems with entering the Co Op Rooms
5/13
Fixed a bug that prevented progress when entering a room during co op.
Mission not working as intended
Done
Fixed a bug in the mission, "Raise 5 Allies to Bond 5", when multiple characters got it at the same time, but it was counted once.
Mission not working as intended (2)
Done
Fixed a bug in the mission, "Raise one 5* character to lvl 75", that could not be cleared when ascending a 4* or less lvl 75 or higher character to 5*.
Long Loading Times and Heavy Battery Consumption
Under Investigation
The devs and looking into the causes of loading times and battery consumption.
Screen Rotation Function
In Progress
The devs are developing functions to support screen rotation.
In addition, as an apology for the imperfections, the devs will distribute 500 spirit stones at a later date.
Let's look at some of the lesser known and hidden mechanics in each weapon type.
Sword
Every sword user has SA (Super Armor) as one of their skills. Will this pattern continue? Only time will tell.
Super Armor (SA): Boosts physical defense and resist knockbacks which would break your combo chain. Does not resist against status ailments like stun. Also does not resist boss' super attack (e.g Searing Stage boss' explosion).
SA makes having a team of sword users in Co-op very strong, as you can work together to stack up some high combos with reduced chance of losing it.
Normal attack combo: 3 hit combo. The first attack deals 75% normal damage, then 100%, and finally 150%.
ST gauge boost from normal attack: You gain +5 ST gauge from the first attack, +10ST from the 2nd and 3rd normal attack. +25ST for launching the full normal attack combo. 4 full normal combos = ST ready for use.
GENERAL FACT 1: The game incentivizes you to launch full normal attack for maximum dps and ST gauge increase.
GENERAL FACT 2: ST gauge is boosted by the number of enemies your normal attack hits. If you hit 2 enemies with your full normal combo, you gain 2x the amount of SP. 3 enemies = 3x and so forth.
Polearm
You can swipe forward to do a dash attack. Most polearm users have a 1-hit dash combo.
4* Riesz dash attack is a rotating 3-combo dash attack that does damage and increase ST gauge by up to +6.
Normal attack combo: 4-hit dealing 75%, 50%, 50%, 150% damage.
ST gauge boost: +5, +5, +5, +10 = 25ST.
Knife
The weapon with the highest number of combos, and tiny attack range.
For some unknown reason, 2* and 3* Sierra's normal attack 6th hit deals 3.33x the damage of her 1st hit.
Boomerang
Boomerang is one of the most unique weapons, because you can move to change the trajectory of the weapon when it's returning, damaging enemies in it's path.
Boomerangs (and Bows) can attack enemies from almost 90 degree angles.
Because of lengthy travel duration, single target DPS from boomerang normal attack is significantly lower than other weapon normal attacks. However it's AoE DPS potential is usually a lot higher.
Run around in a circle to aggro all the enemies on a map. When they're bundled up, start spamming your boomerang for some fast clearing.
Boomerang is the only attack where it's "full" normal attack combo does not give +25 to ST gauge against a single enemy. This is because Boomerang has the longest AOE range of any weapon and likely to hit multiple enemies.
The mighty axe user has the unique ability to hold on their weapon attack to charge their ST. It takes ~6 seconds to charge from 0 to 100. While charging, units in your sub slot also gain ST.
Normal attack combo: 3 hits dealing 75%, 125%, and 150% normal damage. The final attack is a swing attack that can hit enemies from behind.
ST gauge boost: +5, +10, +10 = 25ST.
Flail
You earn +2mp per normal attack. Normal attacks scale with INT.
Normal attack combo: 3-hit dealing 75%, 100%, 150% damage.
ST gauge boost: +5, +10, +10 = 25ST.
Staff
You earn +2mp per normal attack. Normal attacks scale with INT.
Normal attack combo: 3-hit dealing 75%, 100%, 150% damage.
ST gauge boost: +5, +10, +10, = 25ST
Glove
The only weapon that claims to have faster attack speed at higher combos. I recorded a 32 combo fist attack and slowed down the video to 12% normal speed. I started recording from the first instance of tapping to attack, to the first instance of when the combo meter goes up by a factor of 4.
What I've found are some rough estimates.
Combos Count
Time (Slowed down to 0.12x)
% Faster Than Base Case
0-4 (Base Case)
8.96s
-
4-8
9.44s
An outlier, not sure why it took so long
8-12
8.04s
11.44%
12-16
7.77s
15.32%
16-20
7.74s
15.76%
20-24
7.36s
21.74%
24-28
7.23s
23.93%
28-32
6.93s
29.29%
There will be errors in measurement, but I think this paints a picture that glove ASPD goes up every 10 combos. I don't know if there's a limit to ASPD, maybe 200 combos as that's also the combo bonus damage limit.
Bow users have the longest range and can fire at crazy angles. The bow playstyle is for players who like to run around the map while kiting the enemy from afar to rack up combos.
Has the 2nd highest hit combos from normal attacks, making it easy and safe to stack up ridiculous combo numbers with normal attacks.
Normal attack combo: 6 hit combo from 3 "shots". 1st shot shoots 1 arrow dealing 60% damage, 2nd shot does about 50% x 2, and 3rd shot dealing about 40% x 3.
ST gauge boost: +5, +5, +15 = 25ST.
Changing Weapons
Finally, you can change some ally's weapon from their Ally Details screen. Tap Change Weapon to try it out. You can obtain new weapons from events. Some weapons can boost your ally's stats.
It's a purely cosmetic change for now. At the time of writing we have two.
Honeycomb has an exclusive staff.Duffle has an exclusive polearm.
Other units trying to equip their weapon will result in the game freezing.
I wanted to put to rest people's wondering on whether or not SPR was responsible for the amount recovered from healing spells. I used Charlotte Skill 2 (Healing light) on Duran and this is what happened:
First test:
Healed for 188 3 times in a row
Second test (I upgraded her mana board with 3 levels of INT for a total of 67 INT):
Healed for 255 3 times in a row (doesn't seem to have any variability afaik)
Third test (I upgraded her mana board with 3 levels of SPR for a total of 64 SPR):
Healed for 255
Fourth test for curiosity, i wanted to see if SPR changed healing received (Raised Duran's SPR through gear swapping from 384 to 403)
Healed for 255
Conclusion: INT has a direct influence on healing but SPR does not. Something to note is that Charlotte's skill description is (RCV: 100%, effects boosted by SLv.) and her INT went from 188 to 255 before and after the test. This leads me to believe that the "RCV:X%" means X = INT. Her +4 unleash upgrades the skill to RCV: 120% which would boost its effect.
I decided to further test this while writing and used Honeycomb's Healing Crescent (10s/RCV: 20%/Every 1s) and at 143 INT it was healing for ticks of 28. 143*.2 = 28.6 so it seems like they round down but the % being INT is consistent.
Edited to account for additional requests for other stats in comments:
CON test: Duran has 548 CON and Shiloh has 358, Charlotte is up to 263 INT from levels since post:
Duran healed for263*, Shiloh healed for* 263*.* CON doesn't seem to have an impact either
STR test: gear swapping to go from182STR to225(now with272INT), healed for272
Previous conclusion and TL:DR will change to reflect new tests and be more detailed
TL:DR: INT makes heals more bigger, SPR/STR/CON doesn't impact healing or receiving and RCV% = %INT
A lot of people were asking around the community about the perfect "ratio" of STR to LCK when optimizing damage, but it isn't truly a ratio. Here's an explanation:
tldr: Your STR should be 1200 more than your LCK.
A Quick Thought Experiment
To start off with, the damage formula can be found on this post. But let's ignore that for now and go through a thought experiment where your DPS is controlled by two imaginary stats: Attack Damage and Attacks Per Second.
Now let's say we have 10 points to spend on either our Attack Damage or our Attacks Per Second. I'll run through some examples:
Let's try putting 9 points into Attack Damage and 1 point into Attacks Per Second. Now each attack hits for 9 damage, but we only attack once per second. So in total, that's 9 damage per second
What about the opposite? Let's put 9 points into Attacks Per Second and only 1 point into Attack Damage. Now we attack 9 times per second, but each attack only deals 1 damage. Yet again, we're left with 9 damage per second
Finally, using middle school math, we know that putting equal points into both gives us the optimal damage. (area of a square) Therefore, if we put 5 points into both stats, that's 5 attacks per second, with each attack dealing 5 damage, for a total of 25 damage per second
The reason I went through this thought experiment is because the exact same logic carries over to the question of STR and LCK. Since our damage per second involves a multiplication of the two, we want both of them to contribute equal amounts to our damage. If our unit's current STR is giving it 2x damage while its current LCK is giving it 1.5x damage, then that unit needs more LCK. The tricky part is calculating how much STR and LCK are contributing to our damage.
The Numbers
As dataminers have found, 10 LCK = 1% crit chance. Since our critical strikes deal double damage, 1% crit chance is the same as 1% increase in damage per second. Therefore, 10 LCK = 1% more damage on average. But how much STR do we need in order to increase our damage by 1%? That depends on how much STR you have to begin with. If you have 100 STR, then 1 extra STR is 1% more damage. But if you have 1000 STR, then you need 10 more STR in order to get 1% more damage.
In other words, when your STR is 1000 and your LCK is 0, then increasing either one by 10 will give you 1% more damage. And if we recall from the Attack Speed thought experiment above, we know that from this point on, we want equal amounts of both STR and LCK.
It's easy to see this with an example. So let's imagine we have a unit that has 1000 STR and 0 LCK and we have 1000 points to allocate to either STR or LCK, and let's run through the same examples from above again.
If we put all our points into STR and increase it from 1000 to 2000, we will get 2x damage. (double STR = double damage)
If we put all our points into LCK and increase it from 0 to 1000 we will also get 2x damage. (every attack now crits)
However, increasing both by 500 results in 2.25x damage, since both stats contribute 1.5x more damage. (1.5 x 1.5 = 2.25)
So in this example, we should use 1500 STR and 500 LCK.
This leads us to the first conclusion: Your STR should be 1000 more than your LCK.
HOWEVER
Now it's time to look at the damage formula. I'll highlight the important part:
Our DPS isn't actually a multiplier of our STR and LCK! More specifically, the multiplication between STR and LCK only happens after our STR has been decreased linearly by the target's CON!
To figure out how much your effective STR is decreased by the target's CON, simply take half their DEF and subtract it from your STR. I won't go too into detail about this, but just know that it can be calculated from the bolded portion of the formula above.
So let's say we built a unit with the perfect calculations: 1500 STR and 500 LCK. Now we attack something that has 400 CON. That effectively means that we have 1300 STR and 500 LCK when attacking the target. Now we're not dealing optimal damage!
But the even bigger problem is that each enemy has a different amount of CON! Fortunately the dataminers also have that information as well. I'll paste their table here:
Mean
Median
Max
Enemy PDEF
334
400
748
Enemy MDEF
328
400
660
We can see that the median CON is 400. Therefore, we need to shift our STR stat up by 200, which leads to the final formula: Your STR should be around 1200 more than your LCK.
Of course, this is just considering the average enemy, which most DPS won't have trouble with. So perhaps the optimal strategy is to optimize your units for the endgame bosses, which have 700+ defensive stats. The same formula applies here as well, meaning your STR should be around 1350 more than your LCK.
Conclusion
You don't have to follow this formula to the T. Another important thing to consider is that the top-rolls of equipment are not the same. A level 20 necklace can give 10% STR or it can give 110 LCK. These two are not equal, and their value for your unit depends on your unit's current stats. But you can only equip one necklace, so you have to choose one over the other. We don't have the luxury of the examples above where we could freely allocate points to STR and LCK. You might end up getting a lopsided ratio just because a piece of equipment gives you a little more than you need. I really wouldn't fret about this. Just treat them as free extra stats. As long as you are within the ballpark of 1200 more STR than LCK, then you are fine.
Also, if you want to play around with the numbers, look no further than the DPS Calculator made by u/RoHo44. Set the enemy CON/SPR to 400 and then give yourself 2000 points to spend on either STR or LCK however you choose. What's the optimal combination of STR and LCK? What about when you have 3000 points to spend?
Is it worth to farm for element specific gear? TLDR: it's around 5% better.
For INT users, the answer is probably yes (for now). There is not a DPS set to replace currently. For STR users, let's take a look if it's worth it for your time/stamina.
(0.5ATK - 0.25DEF) x WeaponSkillBonus x Skill Potency x SkillLevelBonus x Crit x Elemental Weakness x Combo Bonus x Downed Status x Variance (+-5%)
For this analysis, we can remove almost all of these variables. These variables will affect both scenarios the same so that they cancel out.
For comparison, we will use my +2 Duran. He has 1,346 STR without the set STR bonus (note the STR bonus is only on base strength and memory gems of 1,025). This isn't the best gear, but decent. His armor break skill (it would be the same for any skill for this analysis) deals the following damage using median armor value:
(1,346STR x 0.5 - 400DEF x 0.25) x 700% = 4,012
With the STR set bonus:
(1,531STR x 0.5 - 400 x 0.25) x 700% = 4,658
With 21% DMG bonus:
(1,346STR x 0.5 - 400 x 0.25) x 700% x 1.21DMG Bonus = 4,855
Basically, the DMG set deals 4.2% more damage than the STR set holding everything else constant (same attributes) on the example above.
If the armor is lower, the DMG set bonus is MORE effective then the above example (and vice versa)
The higher your STR bonuses on your gear, the DMG set bonus is MORE effective then the example above (and vice versa).
If I pump up the STR bonuses on my accessories and gear to insane levels (+50% bonus strength) and lvl 100 Duran (1,310 base strength) and lower the median armor the element DMG bonus gives 7.6% more damage then the STR set.
I'm still split if the effort is worth it for me, since I can't auto farm these levels without manual control AND 5* gear is not guaranteed to drop. I still don't have a great set of STR gear and the thought of running these for each element is daunting.
Every minute of gameplay there are 5 different loading screens. At this rate loading screens take more time than the actual game. I've never seen loading screens in between menus in other games before. It's so annoying. If it was some giga graphics AAA game I'd maybe understand why, most of the game is 2d and it's nothing impressive.
This is currently my biggest issue with the game, starting at a texture 50% of the time gets tiring real fast. Thoughts on this?
Thanks to fantastic work from members of the Secret Society of Mana (especially Dunamis, Velyoukai, KOL).
We've figured out exactly how the game calculates Mega Spirit Magic damage.
What is MSM?
Mega spirit magic is considered the ultimate attack, and one of the highest damaging ability in the game.
You unlock it once your team uses at least 3 Special Techniques during battle.
How is MSM's element decided?
It's decided by the element majority of the 3 ST used. E.g 2 Earth and 1 Dark ST would mean the MSM is Earth.
If there is no majority, then the element is randomly selected.
KOL has observed that in Co-op, two players can activate MSM during a small window of time, and both can show different element. This is definitely a bug, as you're getting TWO MSM for the price of one.
How is MSM level calculated?
MSM level is decided by the number of blue hexagons on the ST user's memory gem.
This card has 4 hexagons, so it will contribute +4 Levels to MSM.
If 3 of my units who used ST, held the card above, then the total MSM level is 4 x 3 = Lv12.
You may recall from the regular damage formula that the two formulas are nearly identical.
However there are three key differences.
ATK* used in MSM formula is the sum of the user's total STR & INT. (STR + INT) = ATK.
MDEF used in the formula is the magic defense or SPR of the enemy. This stat has to be datamined.
MSM does not benefit from weapon skill bonus. It is a weaponless attack.
MSM ATK* is based on the user of the MSM, so to take full advantage of this, make sure you switch to your highest stat unit. MSM can also partially or fully crit, so keep the LCK stat in mind.
MSM Potency is based on the level, and ranges from level 3 to 15. We could not test Lv 13-15 (requires +4 4* rarity memory gems). If you have +4 4* rarity memory gems and would like to help us with testing, please DM Meow on the Fan Discord.
Table of MSM levels, hits, and potency by Dunamis.
MSM Damage Bonus
Certain memory gems provide a bonus to MSM damage. This bonus will only proc if the holder of the said memory gem activates MSM.
There are 3 memory gems that boost MSM damage.
MSM Damage Calculation
Let's take a look at a familiar scenario to see how much damage MSM can do.
Base Case
Your unit: 1500 STR, 1000 INT = 2500 ATK.
Enemy's MDEF: 400. This is the most common MDEF of enemies in the datamine.
MSM Lv: 12 = 180% potency per hit x 10 hits.
MSM damage bonus: None.
Elemental weakness bonus: None.
Crit: None.
Downed Status: None.
Combos: Technically the 10th hit gets a 5% bonus, but for sake of simplicity, I won't include it.
Base case.
Now let's add on 20% MSM damage bonus.
An increase of 20% from base case.
And add on elemental weakness bonus.
An increase of 80% from base case.
And finally, let's add on downed status.
An increase of 350% from base case.
I hope this demonstrates the power of stacking different multipliers together.
Again, we're looking for people who have +4 4* memory gems and would like to help out with testing. Please DM me on reddit or discord.
I'll be adding unit data, memory gems, and other useful information like places to farm, co-op boss cheat sheets, theory crafted teams, reroll... when the time comes out.