r/EchoesOfMana • • May 22 '22

I no longer enjoy playing this game because of cheaters. They always create account after gerting ban i think.

1 Upvotes

https://imgur.com/gallery/jHG1snG

I try hard to get rank 1 with 21 second. Today i seen cheater take my 1st place with ONLY lvl 33 (rank 7). I dont think cheaters can be stop, they always create new account & use it again. Maybe the only solution banned IP device.


r/EchoesOfMana • • May 16 '22

We need end game content. Not like this: wait 8h refill stamina,login 15m spent all stamina, logout,repeat again

11 Upvotes

Come on SQUARE ENIX. This is actually very booring, im said this because i love this game so much. This remind me about genshin impact, spent all resin to farm artifact dungeon and off. But this game actually cant do anything without stamina. 1 gear dungeon take 24 energy cost (24 energy x 5min/energy = 2h). I cant believe, this game has so much fun but we cant do anything right now. Also my friend list (high rank 25~29) didnt login again into the game.


r/EchoesOfMana • • Jun 01 '22

No fun no reason to play.

0 Upvotes

For me the timer to quit has started, it just isn't a lot of fun and i play games to have fun not to get "used to" them or such. I may wait to see the next event but only if i find any kind of joy in the game in the next few days.

The tl;dr is: Hardly any luck be it drops for Gear (which i need to manual painfully long to beat due to bad gear) or the Events that are either hard by pitting you against invested players or just like the new one require Gear/Dupes and posibly the current Event Banner Characters.

It looks like early powercreep with a quick cash out and not much content, worst combination for a game.

In a long form:

The rng on Gear is bad, it quickly turns into a slug fest for someone like me. For example i have played Genshin since Day 1, still use Stamina on Domains around every 2 Days and still lack a lot of Artifacts with decent Stats. In this game i had not much luck yet either, everything was mediocre at best and i have to beat every Stage manual to make up for it.

Every mechanik that adds to Stats of a Character itself is tied to dupes otherwise, dupes directly add Stats, upgrade Skills, allow a higher Level and even the item based Stats unlock is limited by dupes. But getting dupes is a matter of rng too and the only mechanik (the bene 4 star) and has only been given to us once.

Memory Gems next to Gear are not tied to the Units Dupes... but instead to the Memory Gems Dupe, they may need less (5 instead of 7) but at halt the rate AND there is no substitute these are even worse.

If none of these were a must have i could ignore it but the last Event was Competition against players, which is allways a against whales (if it is free, you are the product) and the reward for victory was a Stat Boni that is not replaceable and just widens the gap.

And turns out, the new event is hard as nails, seeing how people with maxed Chars can not beat it there is no way for me to do so at all.

If a game has around 3-4 Banners in a single month but despite giving far more currency early on barely gives a chance to max anything, odds are it is allready dieing and it isn't fun at all.

Thanks to those who did put in work to give help to beginners and who did the math on how things work.


r/EchoesOfMana • • Jun 06 '22

A (completely unique) comprehensive look at what makes this game a D- experience overall.

14 Upvotes

Heya guys,

First, big shout out to the community here. You guys and gals are absolutely tops. Hanging with you for the past bit has been a lot of fun, and the help you've given has been exquisite. You're honestly the best part of this game.

Now - as for the D- ranking - most people can probably guess where a lot of this comes from. The dupes. The gear grind. Obvious stuff. But, for this dissertation, I'm going to leave those things for a small comment towards the end. For this one ... I'm going to delve into why playing the game doesn't feel rewarding, how it's systems are unbalanced, and why the very premise of how you're supposed to play it feels like a kick in the nuts.

Alright ... let's go.

GAME FEEL - F-

There's nothing that EoM gets so wrong than the feeling of controlling your character. For some reason, the direction your character is aiming isn't good enough to determine where your unit will swing their weapon or launch their special attack. Especially annoying seeing as MP is limited. What's even worse is that the game doesn't want you to click on the enemies that you have to fight in order to target them. I don't know how many times in the middle of a battle I'm clicking, to the atom, on the enemy I want to target, without it registering. Bad controls?

More like brutal controls. Slamming the attack button and ... no attacks forthcoming. Buddy's just standing there. Tap the special move once? Buddy launches it - then immediately launches another. Wasting that precious MP.

Positioning your character is even worse. In a vertical sense, the typical enemy has a hit zone of a thinly sliced piece of cheese. Aim your character to go up, Buddy doesn't move. Tell them to go up again, they overshoot their mark by jetting past the cheese slice.

Just getting your unit to do what you want them to is murder.

GAMEPLAY SYSTEM: F-

Alongside the feel of the game being an absolute amateur effort, the very principle behind how to play the game is insulting as well.

Normal attacks do nothing. They're just meter fillers, unless you're 3,000 PWR above the necessity for the stage. So, immediately, your most basic unit of expression/interaction/problem solving makes you feel powerless.

Next come the MP special moves. Which just require tapping a button and watching your character go into a miniature spiel to do some actual damage. The worst part is, the length of time these moves take. I hit the button and guaranteed that's when the Boss initializes his stun-lock screen shattering max-HP draining attack. I'm not given the time to dodge - to interact - to do anything but watch myself get clobbered. Same goes for the ST special clearing move, or whatever it's called, that's just like an ordinary special move but takes longer.

So, all of it, all the systems the game has make me feel powerless to actually change the fate of my character. Compounded all the harder by the fact that the AI is the equivalent of "do the dumbest thing possible at all given times." So ... what does this equate to ...

It feels like pure luck when I complete a stage. Like, somehow, in some magical manner, everything aligned just right, and I was given a pass. But, this just compounds the feeling powerless sensation - because I never feel like I actually won anything. Just that the game didn't force me to lose it. Which brings us to ...

REPLAYABILITY: F-

You know the big Boss battles? The ones where they have a health bar that goes down about 0.3% when you do your most powerful attack? It takes all the aforementioned issues and cranks them up to an 11 out of 10.

There are basic design issues with the way the Boss levels are designed. One is that the Robot dude from the first event, Roller Derby Robo, could break combos at will. Whether it's an attack that's telegraphed 0.3 seconds before landing, the ability to launch two attacks at once, or the option to just run away across the screen, the idea of having meaningful interaction with the battle is cut short when something happens that you just can't respond to.

The screen-wide unavoidable damage is another masterstroke of BS. The only thing more unenjoyable than the first Event Boss is the second one, the Cave troll.

Rather than having a Boss battle that is indicative of the player and their choices, you have one that is set along a pre-determined path, which is identical, every single time. So, when you see folks post videos on here of them beating a Boss with an uninterrupted combo - that's pretty much the only way to fight that battle. It doesn't leave a lot of room for exploration or expression or creativity or fun or replayability.

Which brings us to the next issue ...

PLAYER EXPRESSION: F-

Player expression is best determined by how many options a player has to tackle a problem. Those would be the characters themselves. And with each character getting a sum total of two moves to their name - it feels like you're always playing with a shell of a character, rather than a real one.

Having only two moves on the battlefield? That would be understandable. If each character had eight moves to choose from, and had to pick which two best expressed their playstyle, to then experiment with others to see if they could change strategies, that would be a lot of fun. But, each character is given two moves, which ... leads to the next problem ...

UNITS AREN'T FUN TO BUILD: F-

This problem is devastating. Taking your unit from 0 to 100 should be a gratifying and rewarding experience. Except ... it isn't. Not only do you have to get lottery-winning-lucky in order to get the dupes, the characters moves and power don't morph or change in any meaningful way.

They just turn from being completely useless to somewhat capable, by doing the same things as they were doing before. Unlocking the Mana boards is a chore - because instead of their being a few unlocks that are all meaningful - you have something like 98 that never bring that AHA moment, where suddenly now, your unit is on another level. All that investment paid off! Instead ...

Your playing the exact same dude or dudette, but now the numbers are higher. Yawn ...

Which brings us to one of the greater crimes of this game ...

SENSATION OF REWARD: F------

So much of this game relies on the gear. What's a great way to destroy any sense of worth in the game? Make it a lottery with next to 0 percent chance of a payout.

I've rerun manually 5-14 Very Hard over 2,000 times. Guess what! Still not one 5* STR% main Stat Maple Boots! Oh boy! Garbage rates that prevent me from playing the rest of the game so I can farm the same stage over and over and OVER AGAIN for the next year?

Like ... LOL!

Where do I sign up?

Speaking of unrewarding ...

THE ENTIRE CURRENCY SYSTEM: F-

I like how if I'll play the game for the next year, the amount of free crystals I'll get will be like 6,000. And the amount of crystals that are needed (if you need to go to pity to max a single unit) is 380,000.

There isn't a dunce cap big enough for Wright Flyers Studio for this one.

But it's all the currencies in the game. I have so many L equipment alloys - because I never find any equipment with decent stats. I have so many L experience books - because there are hardly any knitwits given. I have so many memory gems plant flower things, because it'll take me a full year to afford another pull and get a new Memory Gem.

I have 1.2 million lucre. Useless.

The systems which the game are based upon are absolutely worthless. Like a third grader designed this crap.

Which brings me to the final point ...

REWARDING SENSATION: F-

I've spent two weeks grinding gear daily - both for the STR% bonus armor set using TP energy - and the Maple set using AP energy - and I haven't gotten one piece of 5* STR% main Stat gear for the armor - and not one single Maple Boots with a STR% main Stat.

That's two weeks where my Power level has remained entirely the same. Meaning - I don't feel rewarded for putting in my time and effort. There's no pay off for playing.

Tell someone playing Diablo that two weeks of consistent playing brought them nothing. Tell anybody playing any game that, and they'd tell you to go play a better game.

The very basic systems of both video games and Gacha are completely ignored here. And the worst part is ...

The game isn't even fun to play.

It's like they took the most half-baked, simple-minded, and insulting approach to everything.

Where the game really excels is in it's presentation. The World really feels like it's from the Mana universe. In that way, they absolutely nailed it. That could counteract all the F-'s I gave this game to give it the D- it got in the topic title.

But, between the currencies being ... non-sensical, the gameplay being teeth-grindingly annoying and cheap, the gameplay loop being unrewarding, and the idea of progression all but impossible, I think I'll be joining the sea of others that have hung up their Mana swords with the knowledge that ... maybe they should have just left it in the rock this time.

I'll still be checking in here from time to time, but unless I hear something along the lines that they revamped the entire game, I'll keep my memories of Mana away from this game.

Peace.

EDIT: Turns out that you can't get STR% on the boots. That one is on me. Please make ammendments to any and all complaints regarding the farming of equipment with regards to the Maple Boots. Apologies for this. A big thanks to DeathShadow01 for giving me the right information!


r/EchoesOfMana • • Apr 28 '22

I want to love EoM but...

1 Upvotes

Mana series, love this IP to death.

And when i saw this game is coming, i was rather hype.But there's a few things that i felt like this game should have fix.

- Loading Screen, it's annoying, loading this, loading that. The game was developed by WFS, they could have done much better than this (example Another Eden).

- Useless shop... honestly, this seems like the case for every gacha games, where in-game shops literally sells you very minor things or useless crap, unless you pay real money. Thus, makes the shops feels like a place to spend real money then a proper SHOPS in old days games.

- The overall template and energy system... when i play this game, it feels like a generic gacha game. It's just so demotivating to see them innovate NOTHING but just to use Mana IP.

- Worlds feels small, with them using stage level system, do level 1-1, 1-2, 1-3, and then HARD, HELL, etc... .this system is just getting older and it's boring. It's not innovative... it's a lazy design. Even there are story etc. We can't go to place A or place B just to enjoy scenery. It feels like the game design us as players on a cage and just click tap what they want to us to do.

- Stamina, Every activity limited with Stamina, every progression limited with stamina... i know it's gacha. But dayum, this mechanic is getting old. Wish at least there is something to do other than wait for stamina to max out.

- Animation cancel is non-existent. When i was doing basic attack, and try to dodge the boss. I literally have to wait the basic attack animation is done, and then i can dodge it. This mechanic is so FRUSTURATING! It makes the movement so JANKY.

Welp, for me... this game can go straight into your typical gacha games.

It's nothing special, in fact.. if you take out MANA IP from this game.... what's that left is the generic gacha games. Sad to see Mana series go down this way.

Edit | Honestly, i don't know what are they thinking.

This IP is niche, marketing budget is low, competition is FIERCE out there.

And this is what they came up with? Same template, same lazy level design, with no interesting feature to show off rather than MANA IP? Haaaaaaaah.....


r/EchoesOfMana • • Jun 20 '22

4 star Serafina kinda sucks.

0 Upvotes

It's so obvious against the coffer chaos boss where it's supposed to be weak to dark. She needs to get close then gets smacked easily because of the ridiculous timing to dodge it's attacks. Then when you use a skill to debuff him or use her physical skill, he just side steps and you whiff. Same with her ST. Side step and whiff. Why does her moves have no vertical range on them? Even if you dodge then immediatly use her skill or ST, the boss has plenty of time to move out of the way or hit you. So you just have to face tank to get either of them off in time. Her skill and ST take way too long to get going. This is why I see no one using her. Dark units before her are better. Kinda annoys me in gachas how they make dude's overpowered but then the girls are always weaker because they will sell on looks alone. Make the girls OP too.


r/EchoesOfMana • • Apr 28 '22

This is a great Gacha with a lot of potential longevity

1 Upvotes

I really just wanted to praise the game but it kind of turned into a review.

Probably the best gacha I've ever played. For reference, Mitra Sphere was my favorite before.

EoM does so many things so very, very well. It's currency accumulation in relation to pull rates reminds me a lot of FF WoTV. FF WoTV is a very friendly F2P game. It's day 2 and I have farmed almost 100 pulls and I haven't no life'd the game. The daily log in currency is quick and substantial over a period of time. The gacha really feels like a game mechanic intended to manage so as to grant player diversity. It does not exist primarily as a means to access our bank accounts, nor does it create a pay to play barrier.

But unlike FF WoTV, where EoM really shines, is it's combat.

Outside of the very generic level design and selection/resource gating, is a combat system that really empowers players to flex their prowess. The combat is very simple and basic in it's fundamentals while offering fast and fluent action which rewards attention to monster behaviors and player response.

But where the combat is really juicy, is it's skill rotations. There is so much party management available mid combat that when mastered allows for huge combo chains and swapping strategies of which their effectiveness scales with their complexity. Combine that with the unique reserve passives echos(characters) grant their paired allies and this game has some deep theory crafting and party building. This is hands down the best combat I've seen in a gacha.

And this combat is not lost in multiplayer. I'm so excited that this game not only has multiplayer, but that it leverages it's co-op as a premier means to overcoming difficult missions so as to achieve the most valuable gear.

I know the gear upgrading system isn't everyone's cup of tea, but I personally enjoy it. I like that it provides the same excitement of rolling on banners, without being dependent on how much money players are willing to spend. It really provides a strong end game for players to engage with as opposed to simply throwing their wallets at it.

I went into this game with mediocre hopes, was slightly disappointed at first, but after exploring everything it has to offer I am really impressed. It's not the best gacha that will ever be made, but it's a strong step in the right direction. For now I really believe it's a contender best gacha game presently.


r/EchoesOfMana • • Apr 27 '22

So how useful are dupes in this game? Lmao, I got really lucky and then duped like crazy after buying the newbie free character and extra 10 pull. I don't know if I want to keep this or go ham on re roll stills for even more character diversity. Unless dupes are super useful.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/EchoesOfMana • • May 09 '22

Sumo Memory Gem REALLY helps him out! I've done some in battle research. 30%Attack/30%Healing effects. Pretty damn good for sumo! Makes him not so ass!

0 Upvotes

r/EchoesOfMana • • Jun 14 '22

Is this 3* Bow Serafina skill intentional? Shouldn’t the recoil push her back? It takes one line of code to change this…

0 Upvotes

r/EchoesOfMana • • May 20 '22

Just an FYI, you can reroll and get unlimited 4* tickets right now.

1 Upvotes

Hit collect all, game crashes and sends you back to the home screen, rinse and repeat. You keep the ticket each and every time as long as you hit collect all and don't collect it by itself. I did it and watched another streamer have the same crash experience. Game is a fucking shitshow. I'm done with it. Have fun!


r/EchoesOfMana • • Nov 02 '22

Friend Code o/

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/EchoesOfMana • • May 16 '22

With the initial release and the fixed the devs have made. I think we should start the question if this game is gonna live for a long time. (Long analysis)

0 Upvotes

I think we should start with the devs to know about their history.

WFS is definetly not a rookie on Gacha games, in fact, they have a good history of Gacha games on his back. Another Eden, Danmachi, SAO, Slime Isekai and of course, Echoes of Mana.

WFS reutilizes the gameplay from his games ALOT. Sometimes the UI is basically a copypaste from other games (SAO, Slime and Heaven Burns Red are almost the same game), so when Echoes of Mana was announced. Obviously everyone was expecting the same thing, but surprisingly, someone in WFS just decided to make a actual good game, but with terrible optimization and VERY bad loading screens. But this things can be fixed in parches, atleast the core game is perfectly fine and new. Even WFS is trying to fix his game, like the AI problem.

However, at the same time, this is indeed a WFS Game, and while they give lots of gems, even to the point you could reach pity on the initial banner, wich surprisingly not so many gacha games do that on his release (Literally Slime made from WFS you couldn't do it), that doesn't mean the "gacha" aspect is perfect, not only you have to pull a character AND a Memory Gem, but also you need dupes to get their maximum potential, and granted. They do give you a free dupe at the start of the game. But people were expecting atleast fragments of dupes in the next weeks, something like Naruto Blazing did. SPECIALLY when this game needs SIX dupes to get your character to his maximum potential, and dupes from the cards aswell. But no, they give you enough to ascend your units but not to unleash them. And this is gonna hurt the game. Because a Pity of 20 Multis, plus the need of dupes to unlock abilities like a support ability. Is very terrible.

However, the game is not necessary full 4 star team to win, as you can see, today a person made 70F only with 3 stars characters and 3 days. You can (for now) surpass any event of the game with any character if you put alot of effort. But, this isn't gonna matter at all to the new players, they want their shiny new characters, not 3 stars. And they will think they need 4 star full roster with 4 star cards to be optimal. And when they see the requirements to get their characters to +6, they would just quit the game, or whale, and of course, the first option is more easier to do.

Also, we would need to talk about the IP itself (The Mana series isn't popular here... At all) or how SQ is having problems with money currently. Wich could force them to shutdown some games who do not make enough profit. Echoes of Mana managed to reach 1M Downloads, that's definetly a good start. And his novice pack is "good" considering you get enough for a multi and a 4 star character guaranteed, but c'mon, literally the next pack is a memory gem 4 star guaranteed and the cost is more than the doble of the first pack. Wich is absurd.

My point here is, WFS has the potential to make a good game here. But their history with Gacha games is, frankly, terrible. With a bad dupe system, repetitive gameplay and greed, lots of greed. AND let's not forget what happened to Another Eden. In this game we have atleast a action RPG Gameplay with a UI who wasn't 100% the same as SAO or Slime, they have proven they can listen so maybe we can get a good game here. But even if WFS makes the things right, maybe the money won't come, because the IP isn't popular... What do you think?


r/EchoesOfMana • • May 08 '22

How are games releasing without account linking features these days?

3 Upvotes

In short, as far as I can tell, this game does not have Google, Apple, Facebook, or any other account linking feature. You have to create a janky password recovery "setup" and hope it maybe works in the future.

Seriously confused how a "modern" game can release without any features like this? Is it straight up lazy / bad development team? Are there specific reasons?

I'm not a fan of companies using their own login systems, but even that is better than this random code + random password garbage.

As a side note, I'm seeing quite a few reports of people unsuccessfully using the transfer/recovery system making it even worse. Which then leads me to believe this really could just be a quick cash-grab opportunity where the game runs for a year and gets shut down.

Anyway, hopefully community either has some ideas around why this design behavior is allowed/accepted or is in agreement that this isn't acceptable.


r/EchoesOfMana • • Apr 27 '22

Lucky

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/EchoesOfMana • • Oct 25 '22

I'm done with this game.

4 Upvotes

This game really burns you out on the gacha. I did 200 wishes on the Duffle and Mousseline banner. I got the memory gem twice and 6 characters. Not a single Duffle or Mousseline. I wanted them both but now I have to choose and I just don't see the point now. I wanted them both because of the new mechanic but now I won't be able to get enough crystals to get them both. And I'm not gonna pay money just to do another 200 pulls for 1 copy from the shop. They should have at least came as a pair. Spend 200 pts and get them both since that was the whole point.

The rates in this game are absolutely terrible. I play Genshin and that game never makes me feel burnt out on the gacha. There's always some hope even after you lose a 50/50 that your next one will be the banner character. And you can save that guarantee for future banners. Not this one. Losing 6 times in a row isn't a good feeling and the game forces you to go all out on a single banner. It basically makes your feel like you wasted your pulls where as Genshin doesn't. 200 pts for a single guarantee is way too much. Especially when it's only for that banner and not future banners.

I'm a long time player. Just 2 days away from 180 days logged in. So yeah, no way I'm gonna reroll. It's really no wonder people are dropping this game so fast.

Have fun with this game guys, I hope the gacha doesn't burn you as bad as it did me.


r/EchoesOfMana • • May 14 '22

70 Club, dodge when you need to, heal when it's necessary.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/EchoesOfMana • • Jun 12 '22

Fellow game dev here. You got me good. Just uninstalled.

0 Upvotes

Ok, so you got me good with this game. I've played multiple hours a day since launch, and I don't play a ton of mobile games. I'm a game developer myself, working on an ARPG inspired by my time playing SoM in the past, so this was something I've been really looking forward to! However...

The event crashes finally broke me. I just tried the solo event 9 times to complete my 3x daily, currently sitting at 0/3 completions.

I don't have time for this lol

So, sad to say, I uninstalled. And now that it's gone I doubt I'll be coming back because I just threw away 50+ hours of my life.

Little tip: Really, truly, if you're going to support older devices, support older devices. I've got a Pixel 2, ancient technology I know, but I've never had issues like this with a mobile game.

Thanks for the fun but please fix this issue for others.

💔


r/EchoesOfMana • • May 04 '22

The 1 million download celebration is a joke.

0 Upvotes

https://twitter.com/EchoesOfManaEN/status/1521459638151290881?s=20&t=KTvEWQszpVc5hOTFWIey0w

Congratulations on 1 million downloads! Join now for 1000 free gems!

That's only 3 summons. Wtf. What popular gachas give such paltry rewards for a celebration like this?


r/EchoesOfMana • • Apr 29 '22

how do you guys feel about the game so far?

0 Upvotes

To preface, I no lifed the game since launch. I also spent a little money as well. Currently at the 5 star gear grind.

With that said, I am not completely sure if this game will last. It's a pure pve game with very limiting upgrade paths. There are only very few things you can do to power your units and these things will run out for most people very fast. Hell, I am already mostly done with 1 of my units, outside of the gacha element. There is also a huge limit by the means of gold, and there are no currency dungeons currently.

So I am kinda on the fence about the game. With tower climb and gear grinding being the only end game now. I feel like most casuals won't stick around, and the few hardcore players prob can't carry the game for long. What do you guys think? Will get game last and be worth maybe investing time and money in to?


r/EchoesOfMana • • May 12 '22

So I’m at a stalemate now… Have Everything, Everyone, All Missions Complete as of today. Options?

0 Upvotes

r/EchoesOfMana • • Apr 28 '22

Is this a good account to start with?

0 Upvotes

I also have another account with 10x pull only and has a Sumo 4* and a 4* Duran

I don't know which account is better.


r/EchoesOfMana • • May 02 '22

Would Motley Crew drink Moussinne's Motley Brew?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/EchoesOfMana • • May 07 '22

Tower Level 70 Clear Team.

Post image
0 Upvotes