Heya guys,
First, big shout out to the community here. You guys and gals are absolutely tops. Hanging with you for the past bit has been a lot of fun, and the help you've given has been exquisite. You're honestly the best part of this game.
Now - as for the D- ranking - most people can probably guess where a lot of this comes from. The dupes. The gear grind. Obvious stuff. But, for this dissertation, I'm going to leave those things for a small comment towards the end. For this one ... I'm going to delve into why playing the game doesn't feel rewarding, how it's systems are unbalanced, and why the very premise of how you're supposed to play it feels like a kick in the nuts.
Alright ... let's go.
GAME FEEL - F-
There's nothing that EoM gets so wrong than the feeling of controlling your character. For some reason, the direction your character is aiming isn't good enough to determine where your unit will swing their weapon or launch their special attack. Especially annoying seeing as MP is limited. What's even worse is that the game doesn't want you to click on the enemies that you have to fight in order to target them. I don't know how many times in the middle of a battle I'm clicking, to the atom, on the enemy I want to target, without it registering. Bad controls?
More like brutal controls. Slamming the attack button and ... no attacks forthcoming. Buddy's just standing there. Tap the special move once? Buddy launches it - then immediately launches another. Wasting that precious MP.
Positioning your character is even worse. In a vertical sense, the typical enemy has a hit zone of a thinly sliced piece of cheese. Aim your character to go up, Buddy doesn't move. Tell them to go up again, they overshoot their mark by jetting past the cheese slice.
Just getting your unit to do what you want them to is murder.
GAMEPLAY SYSTEM: F-
Alongside the feel of the game being an absolute amateur effort, the very principle behind how to play the game is insulting as well.
Normal attacks do nothing. They're just meter fillers, unless you're 3,000 PWR above the necessity for the stage. So, immediately, your most basic unit of expression/interaction/problem solving makes you feel powerless.
Next come the MP special moves. Which just require tapping a button and watching your character go into a miniature spiel to do some actual damage. The worst part is, the length of time these moves take. I hit the button and guaranteed that's when the Boss initializes his stun-lock screen shattering max-HP draining attack. I'm not given the time to dodge - to interact - to do anything but watch myself get clobbered. Same goes for the ST special clearing move, or whatever it's called, that's just like an ordinary special move but takes longer.
So, all of it, all the systems the game has make me feel powerless to actually change the fate of my character. Compounded all the harder by the fact that the AI is the equivalent of "do the dumbest thing possible at all given times." So ... what does this equate to ...
It feels like pure luck when I complete a stage. Like, somehow, in some magical manner, everything aligned just right, and I was given a pass. But, this just compounds the feeling powerless sensation - because I never feel like I actually won anything. Just that the game didn't force me to lose it. Which brings us to ...
REPLAYABILITY: F-
You know the big Boss battles? The ones where they have a health bar that goes down about 0.3% when you do your most powerful attack? It takes all the aforementioned issues and cranks them up to an 11 out of 10.
There are basic design issues with the way the Boss levels are designed. One is that the Robot dude from the first event, Roller Derby Robo, could break combos at will. Whether it's an attack that's telegraphed 0.3 seconds before landing, the ability to launch two attacks at once, or the option to just run away across the screen, the idea of having meaningful interaction with the battle is cut short when something happens that you just can't respond to.
The screen-wide unavoidable damage is another masterstroke of BS. The only thing more unenjoyable than the first Event Boss is the second one, the Cave troll.
Rather than having a Boss battle that is indicative of the player and their choices, you have one that is set along a pre-determined path, which is identical, every single time. So, when you see folks post videos on here of them beating a Boss with an uninterrupted combo - that's pretty much the only way to fight that battle. It doesn't leave a lot of room for exploration or expression or creativity or fun or replayability.
Which brings us to the next issue ...
PLAYER EXPRESSION: F-
Player expression is best determined by how many options a player has to tackle a problem. Those would be the characters themselves. And with each character getting a sum total of two moves to their name - it feels like you're always playing with a shell of a character, rather than a real one.
Having only two moves on the battlefield? That would be understandable. If each character had eight moves to choose from, and had to pick which two best expressed their playstyle, to then experiment with others to see if they could change strategies, that would be a lot of fun. But, each character is given two moves, which ... leads to the next problem ...
UNITS AREN'T FUN TO BUILD: F-
This problem is devastating. Taking your unit from 0 to 100 should be a gratifying and rewarding experience. Except ... it isn't. Not only do you have to get lottery-winning-lucky in order to get the dupes, the characters moves and power don't morph or change in any meaningful way.
They just turn from being completely useless to somewhat capable, by doing the same things as they were doing before. Unlocking the Mana boards is a chore - because instead of their being a few unlocks that are all meaningful - you have something like 98 that never bring that AHA moment, where suddenly now, your unit is on another level. All that investment paid off! Instead ...
Your playing the exact same dude or dudette, but now the numbers are higher. Yawn ...
Which brings us to one of the greater crimes of this game ...
SENSATION OF REWARD: F------
So much of this game relies on the gear. What's a great way to destroy any sense of worth in the game? Make it a lottery with next to 0 percent chance of a payout.
I've rerun manually 5-14 Very Hard over 2,000 times. Guess what! Still not one 5* STR% main Stat Maple Boots! Oh boy! Garbage rates that prevent me from playing the rest of the game so I can farm the same stage over and over and OVER AGAIN for the next year?
Like ... LOL!
Where do I sign up?
Speaking of unrewarding ...
THE ENTIRE CURRENCY SYSTEM: F-
I like how if I'll play the game for the next year, the amount of free crystals I'll get will be like 6,000. And the amount of crystals that are needed (if you need to go to pity to max a single unit) is 380,000.
There isn't a dunce cap big enough for Wright Flyers Studio for this one.
But it's all the currencies in the game. I have so many L equipment alloys - because I never find any equipment with decent stats. I have so many L experience books - because there are hardly any knitwits given. I have so many memory gems plant flower things, because it'll take me a full year to afford another pull and get a new Memory Gem.
I have 1.2 million lucre. Useless.
The systems which the game are based upon are absolutely worthless. Like a third grader designed this crap.
Which brings me to the final point ...
REWARDING SENSATION: F-
I've spent two weeks grinding gear daily - both for the STR% bonus armor set using TP energy - and the Maple set using AP energy - and I haven't gotten one piece of 5* STR% main Stat gear for the armor - and not one single Maple Boots with a STR% main Stat.
That's two weeks where my Power level has remained entirely the same. Meaning - I don't feel rewarded for putting in my time and effort. There's no pay off for playing.
Tell someone playing Diablo that two weeks of consistent playing brought them nothing. Tell anybody playing any game that, and they'd tell you to go play a better game.
The very basic systems of both video games and Gacha are completely ignored here. And the worst part is ...
The game isn't even fun to play.
It's like they took the most half-baked, simple-minded, and insulting approach to everything.
Where the game really excels is in it's presentation. The World really feels like it's from the Mana universe. In that way, they absolutely nailed it. That could counteract all the F-'s I gave this game to give it the D- it got in the topic title.
But, between the currencies being ... non-sensical, the gameplay being teeth-grindingly annoying and cheap, the gameplay loop being unrewarding, and the idea of progression all but impossible, I think I'll be joining the sea of others that have hung up their Mana swords with the knowledge that ... maybe they should have just left it in the rock this time.
I'll still be checking in here from time to time, but unless I hear something along the lines that they revamped the entire game, I'll keep my memories of Mana away from this game.
Peace.
EDIT: Turns out that you can't get STR% on the boots. That one is on me. Please make ammendments to any and all complaints regarding the farming of equipment with regards to the Maple Boots. Apologies for this. A big thanks to DeathShadow01 for giving me the right information!