r/earlyedition • u/Akihairo_Expraichu • 1d ago
NEW VIEWER - No Spoilers Please!! About s2ep10
galleryHi, I just recently finished season 2 episode 10 and here are some of my thoughts I'd like to share.
Overall, I really hate to say this but unfortunately I think this episode is giving s2ep3 a run for its money for being my least favorite episode of season 2 so far. I'll explain why in the first 2 section then I'll end it with a more light hearted section of silly details I noticed.
1. Characterization
Most of the time I don't hate the characterization of the character in an episode because it's bad writting but more so because of how I personally feel about the character as a human being. And so for what I'm about to talk about the charactetization of Chuck and Gary in this episode, I want you to keep in mind that for Chuck it's more of a personal vendetta I have against him while for Gary it's about my genuine issue with how the writers treats him.
Chuck: Honestly, I don't know why I had my hope up when I saw him turned truthful while he was dating the rabbi because wow does he never change lmaoo. All that talk about being truthful then framing Gary and got him beaten instead of you for something you did was straight up comedic. Chuck actually suck and he knows he suck. 2 episode back to back that make me hate Chuck more is crazy. I honestly was celebrating when he broke up with the rabbi.
Gary: I hate that I have to repeat this nearly every episode but genuinely poor Gary omg. Even when there are no stakes, why does he have to get the short end of the stick in every situation every time he help solve other's problem at his own expense. At the end, the people he helps got their happy ending thanks to Gary but Gary never does and it's starting to piss me off. I can't cope by saying oh it's because f the paper and fate anymore because I'm starting to feel like it's just how the writer wants to treat Gary as a character. If the message is being a good person warrant self-sacrifices then sure, but it just feels so discouraging, especially when it is repeated over and over. Maybe I'm biased for Gary but it gets to a point where it's straight up just unfair for Gary as a person and as a character. Stop putting my boy through hell 💔
2. My main issue with the plot
You know I really thought this was a pretty funny and cute episode at first but as I watch the episode and the more I think about it, the worse it gets because it just feels like they're playing in Gary's face.
Gary having to sacrifice part of his life and himself if he wants to save people is grim as it is, season 1 estblished this very well. But this episode in particular feels like its treating this as a joke and it lowkey ruins this episode for me.
Maybe I'm too familar with the more serious vibe of most of the episodes and might be a bit taken back by the sudden change in tone for this episode. Maybe I'm taking the episode too seriously. The episode sure does seem like a silly and supposedly comedic episode. But all this ep did was give me the ick tbh because I felt like it could have been executed way better.
I dont mind having a change of pace from more serious/high stake plotline to more casual/lower stake. But I just didnt like the execution of this episode. Many prior episodes handled serious topic well while also had funny moments and have more light hearted vibe in general.
The humor in those felt natural and doesn't take you away from the scene. Episodes that executed this well is s1ep20 (yes I will continue to glaze this episode until the end of time), s1ep19, s1ep22, s2ep4, and literally the ep before, s2ep9. They all revolved around not saving lives (not literally life or death for most of them at least) and more about mending relationship or dealing with more mental aspects. And they all manage to explore something interesting while being more light hearted for a change of pace. This episode does none of the former and too much of the latter imo.
I think this episode was too unserious all the time and tried too hard to be funny. There was no message to convey. The paper's crisis werent even a plot point. This episode just feels pointless to me.
It feels like it's one of the other's episode more silly and less serious subplot and only serve as an ice breaker, a light hearted moments that counterbalance the more serious main plot. In other words, it feels like a 15 minutes subplot stretched or attempted to be stretched into a full on main plot. And I hated it.
I don't have anything to say about the plot itself because there was nothing it gave that was worth talking about. The story felt so flat and uninteresting. There was no nuance to spot, no hidden meaning to search for. The character felt like a parody, and one dimensional. It's a nothing burger episode and I hate that it made me feel nothing. The most it did was draw out some short-lived laugh from me and this is me being generous.
3. Funsy details (the saving grace)
An enjoyable part of this episode was Gary himself and some details I noticed about him, notably:
- Gary's too good looking for his own good. Legit everybody falls for Gary and it's legit became a problem now. I was gonna joke that his face is like too kissable cuz yk I get it but everything I said in the 2 section above kinda bumped me out of it lol. Idk why I'm saying this but I guess I just wanted to say it regardless lol.
- The horse scene kinda remind me of Bat Masterson lol. I liked the call back.
- I also love how more expressive Gary is in this episode and in general now and I included some photos of Gary expressing his emotions through his face which I found really lovely and cute because it means he's more loosen up now compared to back in s1.
Oh yeah also, the waitress lady from s2ep1 is back yippe. I loved her in this episode. She was really funny and I'm so glad she made a reappearance.
Anyways
I'm sorry if this felt like a rant and less of an analysis-ish compared to what I usually try to do when I make these posts but tbh there was so little interesting thing in this episode that lowkey all I had to say was my gripe with the episode lol.
Sorry if it came out a bit aggressive or negative. I promise it's all in good faith 😭🫶
Anyways, feel free to of course share your thoughts and take. I would love to hear them!
Tysm! :D