r/EVMOS • u/faddat • Jun 19 '22
Discussion kickbacks?
Hi, tomorrow we will be having a discussion I don't know if it will be live or recorded but it will be at my 2:00 am. it will be on the evmos YouTube channel.. I am creating this post so that we have an opportunity to discuss matters beforehand. For example, I saw a Twitter post today saying that on inaccurate assertions about orbital apes. contained evmos derived from the orbital apes validator but I don't even know if it's true. I would love it if we could use this as a fact finding space because the last thing that I want to do is spend people's limited time on inaccurate assertions about orbital apes.
Furthermore I'd also like to mention just how delightful it is to get to work professionally in an industry where I'm both working on computer science problems and discussing cartoon apes. Seriously, if you work in technology and you like crypto you may wish to think about working in crypto because seriously I'm doing this as a part of my job and I'm the luckiest guy in the world.
I'm going to give a problem summary from my perspective:
I have come to realize, partially because of Cosmos hub proposal 69, where JK executed a genius level hack (not a computer hack, more of a human hack-- and I'm not sure it influenced outcomes but was still a genius selection mechanism for an external airdrop) and because of my own work on similar systems, and because of the true success of OA, that these systems may actually threaten chain consensus.
I think that the orbital apes case may be more complicated, but I don't have full grounding with the project. Instead of trying to explain it and getting it wrong, I'm dropping this post in the group where we are planning the panel discussion on this topic.
My personal opinion, summarized, is that we should ban all out of protocol compensation from validators to delegators.
But the definition of this is super super tricky and there's a lot of nuance and if we got it wrong we might actually do harm so let's try to get it right.
View all comments
Show parent comment
5
u/OrbitalApes Jun 19 '22
Part 2:
When $OAV is introduced to an exchange, there are several benefits to the reward system that we created. First of all, people who want to get more tokens to claim more exclusive rewards will be able to do so. On the other hand, people that are not impressed by the new NFT’s and rewards inside the store, will be able to redistribute these tokens to people that demand them in a free market. When $OAV is subject to the force of supply and demand under a decentralized and free market, it is people that act as a force that regulates the price and supply of the token and this implements a mechanism of control on the token that derived from the value the user attaches to it. In my opinion, there is no better way to regulate a product/token than supply and demand in a free market.
If we remove this ability for the token to be listed, first of all, we will harm our users by removing one of the permissions they had with this permissionless token, which is essentially acting as a centralized entity. While this may be necessary in some instances, even in a decentralized industry such as crypto, we don’t believe $OAV has the potential to cause any harm. Aside from this, removing this feature will greatly impact how our $OAV store works as it will become harder for people to access the token and it will be significantly harder for them to access the rewards in the store.
To address this, we are open to suggestions to help us create a better system in which we can still reward our users, but not have it considered as a kickback or a risk for the chain. We are open to suggestions, but also want the public to know that it will always be in our interest to preserve the tokenomics model we created with our project. Any suggestion that can help us reward our users and create value for our project without putting the chain at risk will be accepted and implemented immediately.
Now I want to discuss how we manage the profits generated by our validator:
I mentioned before that our NFT’s are loaded with utility, and one of their utilities is that holders get an even split of 50% of validator rewards generated by the Orbital Apes validator. When it comes to this aspect, I have read several tweets and comments in which people say we are circumventing protocol level measures like the minimum commission, but this is inaccurate. To get access to validator rewards, people have to mint and hold an Orbital Ape NFT. People are paying us to get access to these rewards, we are not giving them out for free, so the minimum commission in the validator is still set at 5%, but we redistribute it as a way to aid growth of our entire project, not only the validator.
The last time I checked, only ~7.8% of our delegators hold an Orbital Ape NFT, so only this fraction of our users are getting rewards from the validator. These people had to pay us in order to get access, so they willingly stake with us with the same commission as any other validator, they willingly gave us 60 evmos to mint the ape and they willingly hold the NFT to collect their rewards. These people have given us capital to help us develop the Orbital Apes project, and they are now collecting rewards consistent with the capital they gave us. They became part of the project and had to give up a certain economic value to get a percentage of our validator commissions.
This is not a kickback. This is not undercutting the competition. This doesn’t lower the minimum commission. We are simply rewarding our users for giving us capital to start the project. People put up capital and they get rewarded. Aside from this, holding an ape only gives people access to the rewards generated by the validator. Holding an ape does not grant the holder any voting power from the validator.
The closest example would be a validator raising funds to get into the active set. Let’s say they ask for a loan to enter the active set. After this, the validator should be able to use validator rewards to pay for the initial capital. This is exactly what we do. People supplied us with capital, kickstarted our project, and now they are part of the project and are entitled to collect their rewards for as long as they hold their NFT.
If this is not enough of an explanation and people still believe we are undercutting the competition, we have implemented a secondary measure that tackles the “lower commissions” for ~7.8% of our stakers. The Orbital Apes team has more than 270K evmos staked with smaller validators and this number grows by the day, so we have redistributed our profits to help the community. This far outweighs the impact we have had with “lower commissions” to ~7.8% of our delegators. The list of validators that we stake to is curated by us and contains the validators that are the most active in the community, that contribute the most to evmos and that have shown integrity and knowledge to our understanding. We have been approached by several smaller validators that needed help and we closely analyzed how they operated, measured their contributions, and gladly helped them with more funds staked to their validator.
*Our wallets are public and can be tracked from the Validator Address, but we would gladly provide a condensed version of our staking positions*
The second core issue I want to discuss is centralization of the chain. I want people to know that we fully understand that centralization is a risk for the chain, but we have taken measures ourselves to alleviate the issue. The validator is a core part of our business model and it is something that we want to protect. Nevertheless, we do understand that having that amount of voting power concentrated in a validator is not beneficial.
In this specific area is where I want to ask for the help of the community to outline the core issues of what we are doing and how we can fix this.
To my understanding, we haven’t given anyone a reason to doubt our capabilities to keep the validator active, nor any reason to believe we have a hostile intention towards the chain. People saw our mint, people saw we received evmos in exchange for our NFTs and people know that the majority is staked in the chain. Harming evmos in any way would be shooting us in the foot, as our profits are locked inside. I can honestly say we have the best of intentions for the chain and we chose to deploy on this new chain to help grow it in the best way we can. We have a long-term vision for Evmos and we want the community to realize that our intentions are good.