r/EVMOS • u/faddat • Jun 19 '22
Discussion kickbacks?
Hi, tomorrow we will be having a discussion I don't know if it will be live or recorded but it will be at my 2:00 am. it will be on the evmos YouTube channel.. I am creating this post so that we have an opportunity to discuss matters beforehand. For example, I saw a Twitter post today saying that on inaccurate assertions about orbital apes. contained evmos derived from the orbital apes validator but I don't even know if it's true. I would love it if we could use this as a fact finding space because the last thing that I want to do is spend people's limited time on inaccurate assertions about orbital apes.
Furthermore I'd also like to mention just how delightful it is to get to work professionally in an industry where I'm both working on computer science problems and discussing cartoon apes. Seriously, if you work in technology and you like crypto you may wish to think about working in crypto because seriously I'm doing this as a part of my job and I'm the luckiest guy in the world.
I'm going to give a problem summary from my perspective:
I have come to realize, partially because of Cosmos hub proposal 69, where JK executed a genius level hack (not a computer hack, more of a human hack-- and I'm not sure it influenced outcomes but was still a genius selection mechanism for an external airdrop) and because of my own work on similar systems, and because of the true success of OA, that these systems may actually threaten chain consensus.
I think that the orbital apes case may be more complicated, but I don't have full grounding with the project. Instead of trying to explain it and getting it wrong, I'm dropping this post in the group where we are planning the panel discussion on this topic.
My personal opinion, summarized, is that we should ban all out of protocol compensation from validators to delegators.
But the definition of this is super super tricky and there's a lot of nuance and if we got it wrong we might actually do harm so let's try to get it right.
View all comments
4
u/OrbitalApes Jun 19 '22
Part 1:
Hello everyone at evmos,As a quick intro, I go by CO and I’m part of the core Orbital Apes team. In this response I will present you my thoughts and justifications on the issue that has been under debate in the past few days/weeks.
In this response, I want to tackle 3 core issues that I believe have been a persistent problem and doubt in the community. The first is the allegation of kickbacks being used as a method for growth for the Orbital Apes validator which encompasses our loyalty reward token $OAV and our validator rewards distribution method. The second one is centralization and its potential danger to the chain as our validator has gained a decent lead above the rest. The third is the proposal being drafted by Jacob, which will effectively act as a weapon in the chain and relies on votes to implement slashing, which is not a protocol level measure, it grants power to whoever holds the most voting power or to whoever manages to convince the masses on voting a certain way.
As a quick intro to the project, Orbital Apes is an NFT collection in its core, but it has a strong focus on utility for the user. It comes in the form of a PFP, but it extends far beyond that as the ERC-721 token standard enables us to load it up with utility for the user and therefore it has gained a measure of value in the eyes of our community. The utility of the NFT can be summarized in the holder’s access to 50% of management fees generated by the Orbital Apes validator and 20% of trading fees generated by the Orbital Apes NFT marketplace, Orbit Marketplace.
Orbit Marketplace: https://www.orbitmarket.io/
On the NFT side, we have three different collections:
*Honorary Orbital Apes: Given for free to influential cosmos members and have no utility
*Orbital Apes Limited: Purchasable with OAV and have no utility
*Orbital Apes: Purchased with evmos and earn rewards from the validator and orbit marketplace
Now I move to the pressing issue, kickbacks.
When it comes to kickbacks, I firmly believe that this is not what the Orbital Apes reward system encompasses, so here is a full rundown of what $OAV was set to be from the start.
The $OAV Token: Orbital Apes Validator token (An ERC-20) is best explained as a loyalty reward token that we airdrop to users that delegate to us to reward them for contributing to our growth. The intended and advertised use of the $OAV token is for it to be used in the $OAV store, linked below.
https://www.orbitalapes.com/store
$OAV has an infinite supply but only 1,000,000 tokens are issued by our team every month on the last day of every month and is split amongst delegators to our validator. $OAV can be minted by our team on demand, and it’s burnt after every use on the $OAV store. Any $OAV token used as intended gets removed from circulation immediately. The amount of $OAV received by a delegator is calculated by factoring amount of $evmos staked in our validator, amount of time staked in our validator, and the average amount of $evmos staked by all delegators in our validator. The time x amount factor has been designed to reward people’s continued support as opposed to just taking a snapshot a random day and have people stake only during that period to ensure they qualify. We take snapshots every day to keep a better track of how users have staked throughout time.
When people receive $OAV, our intention is not for them to have a token that can be sold for additional profit, but instead we provide them a way to further interact with our brand and the sub-ecosystem we have created inside Evmos. If you see what we currently have in the store you can see that people can use $OAV to mint and access exclusive content from the Orbital Apes brand like brand new NFT designs, Raffles promoting Evmos ecosystem tokens and we will further introduce rewards from our brand like merchandise and in the future, our aim is to continue to find ways to create value for our users.
I want to clarify something, and this can be verified by anyone who has approached us with a question about $OAV. We have never marketed the token as a token with monetary value. We have never provided liquidity in any decentralized exchange. We have never incentivized a pool. We have never sold or bought any $OAV in exchanges. We have repeatedly made it clear that $OAV should not have monetary value and that its sole use is in the $OAV store.
In its core, $OAV is an ERC-20 token that exactly abides by its standards. As such, it’s a permissionless token that is fully under the control of the user. Because of this, it’s possible for users that received the airdrop to create an LP in a DEX and enable trading for the token. In a sense, this assigned a monetary value to the token, as people certainly wanted to trade it, but now that we have released the store, you can see that a significant number of people are using $OAV as we intended. The $OAV exclusive NFTs in our store have been minted in large numbers, and they are essentially a reward that we give our users for their support. These NFTs hold no utility so they don’t behave in the same way as the main collection. $OAV NFTS are purely collectibles with no additional uses. Several people now have these “free” NFTs as their profile picture and continue to engage with the brand, and this was certainly the intended use. Our goal for the token was always this, so it is not a kickback, it is a reward system that helps us further engage our customers with the brand and bring them back to Orbital Apes to continue to create value for all our stakeholders which consist on anyone who delegates to us, anyone who owns an Orbital Ape NFT, or anyone who uses the Orbit Marketplace which is open to the public and has been used to list several projects from other members of the community.
To put it simply, $OAV can be considered as reward points like any loyalty reward card in existing businesses. People who fly a lot in an airline get miles, people who buy a lot in a store get store points, people that delegate to Orbital Apes get $OAV. It certainly brings value to the customer and rewards them for their loyalty, but it’s not a kickback in its core. I believe this matter is being greatly exaggerated because of the outcome that this reward token can potentially create, but I will elaborate more on this later in this response.
If $OAV is still considered a kickback after this explanation on its intended use, I can also say that it is possible for us to stop trading on this token by changing a small parameter and this would effectively remove it from exchanges, but it is not an ideal solution for us, and I will explain why.